So only an event that is
not predictable and not plannable counts as a 'black swan'?
Well nobody predicted the behavior and appearance of
this virus, but does that means it was
unpredictable?
Definition of
unpredictable
a : not able to be known or declared in advance
// unpredictable weather
We say the weather is unpredictable because we never know exactly what it is going to do. Sure there will be cloud or rain or sunshine
sometime. But we can't say when or how much. Similarly with viruses - we know new ones will appear from time to time, but not when or how severe. So Covid-19 meets the normal definition of 'unpredictable'.
To be predictable, Covid-19 would need to have appeared within some expected time frame, and have a behavior and impact similar to others. A time frame of 'sometime in the future' is not good enough. A perplexing behavior radically different from others is not good enough. An impact vastly greater than others is not good enough. The last time we had an epidemic as disruptive as this one (or perhaps not - it ain't over yet!) was just over 100 years ago. That doesn't mean you can just 'predict' that a sort-of similar event will occur every 100 years and then call it 'predictable'.
But was it
plannable?
We plan for all kinds of things all the time, but not this particular one - which is one reason the plans we
did have were inadequate. There comes a point when you have to ask, how many plans do you have to make before saying that something is 'unplannable'? Well I have a plan that covers
everything - it's called 'do nothing and just let the event take its course' (yes, that's the 'plan' some people came up with for Covid-19!).
We are still learning about this virus and its peculiar behavior. Nobody saw it coming, nor were we expected to. You could argue that even unpredictable events can be planned for, but a 'plan' that doesn't account for the characteristics of that particular event is not a plan for
it.
But hey, Taleb and Spitznagel can make up their own definition of 'black swan' if they like. Only problem is it's so restrictive that
nothing qualifies.