Black Swan Event Under Way

I'm going to have to argue against the idea of this being a "Black Swan Event." Yes, it's a major event with severe impacts that will be felt for a long time. But a BSE is a very specific thing, which reading the book will elucidate. As Taleb and Mark Spitznagel write in a Medium.com piece:

Furthermore, some people claim that the pandemic is a “Black Swan”, hence something unexpected so not planning for it is excusable. The book they commonly cite is The Black Swan (by one of us). Had they read that book, they would have known that such a global pandemic is explicitly presented there as a white swan: something that would eventually take place with great certainty. Such acute pandemic is unavoidable, the result of the structure of the modern world; and its economic consequences would be compounded because of the increased connectivity and overoptimization. As a matter of fact, the government of Singapore, whom we advised in the past, was prepared for such an eventuality with a precise plan since as early as 2010.

This was predictable and planable. The fact that we lived our lives as normal and acted all surprised after it happened doesn't change that. I suggest you request a title change to "White Swan Event Underway."

ETA: Perhaps alternatively: A Gray Rhino event.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to have to argue against the idea of this being a "Black Swan Event."

I'll repeat what I've already said:

1 - the scope of this is far greater than any pandemic since 1918. Given that we've had quite a few pandemics since then, I think the scope of this one was completely unexpected, which is why it took lots of corpses to make people sit up and take note.

2 - Taleb might have popularised the term in a book, but black swans have been a metaphor for rare events for centuries. Accordingly, Taleb isn't the sole arbiter of what constitutes one.

3 - However, since Taleb is your go-to guy, his own description states:

rare events that are beyond the realm of normal expectations in history

This is clearly way beyond normal expectations. No other pandemic has caused the kind of worldwide carnage this has, and we've had several infuenza pandemics since 1918. On top of that, we have had SARS 1.0 & MERS.

If a Black Swan isn't a 1 in 100-year event, then the term may as well not be used at all.

But I'm going to continue using it & the thread title stays.

If you ask me, Taleb's just sore because he didn't call it first. It looks to me that if a UFL landed in front of UN HQ he wouldn't think it was a Black Swan because Sci-Fi writers have already done it.
 
One of my stop orders hit today. My brief experience as a Planet Fitness stockholder is over, at least for now. I made a 20% gain.

I'd think most of the sellers right now are the smart money - people who know the economy is deeply in the crap, and have taken advantage of an artificially high market.
 
I'm going to have to argue against the idea of this being a "Black Swan Event." Yes, it's a major event with severe impacts that will be felt for a long time. But a BSE is a very specific thing, which reading the book will elucidate. As Taleb and Mark Spitznagel write in a Medium.com piece:



This was predictable and planable. The fact that we lived our lives as normal and acted all surprised after it happened doesn't change that. I suggest you request a title change to "White Swan Event Underway."

ETA: Perhaps alternatively: A Gray Rhino event.

Thank you. Someone who has read the book and understands the term.
 
This was predictable and planable.
So only an event that is not predictable and not plannable counts as a 'black swan'?

Well nobody predicted the behavior and appearance of this virus, but does that means it was unpredictable?

Definition of unpredictable

a : not able to be known or declared in advance
// unpredictable weather​

We say the weather is unpredictable because we never know exactly what it is going to do. Sure there will be cloud or rain or sunshine sometime. But we can't say when or how much. Similarly with viruses - we know new ones will appear from time to time, but not when or how severe. So Covid-19 meets the normal definition of 'unpredictable'.

To be predictable, Covid-19 would need to have appeared within some expected time frame, and have a behavior and impact similar to others. A time frame of 'sometime in the future' is not good enough. A perplexing behavior radically different from others is not good enough. An impact vastly greater than others is not good enough. The last time we had an epidemic as disruptive as this one (or perhaps not - it ain't over yet!) was just over 100 years ago. That doesn't mean you can just 'predict' that a sort-of similar event will occur every 100 years and then call it 'predictable'.

But was it plannable?

We plan for all kinds of things all the time, but not this particular one - which is one reason the plans we did have were inadequate. There comes a point when you have to ask, how many plans do you have to make before saying that something is 'unplannable'? Well I have a plan that covers everything - it's called 'do nothing and just let the event take its course' (yes, that's the 'plan' some people came up with for Covid-19!).

We are still learning about this virus and its peculiar behavior. Nobody saw it coming, nor were we expected to. You could argue that even unpredictable events can be planned for, but a 'plan' that doesn't account for the characteristics of that particular event is not a plan for it.

But hey, Taleb and Spitznagel can make up their own definition of 'black swan' if they like. Only problem is it's so restrictive that nothing qualifies.
 
Last edited:
But hey, Taleb and Spitznagel can make up their own definition of 'black swan' if they like. Only problem is it's so restrictive that nothing qualifies.

Well Taleb took an obscure saying, exposed it to the world, explained it to the world, turned it into a theory and wrote a best seller about it.

I can’t think of a better person on earth to define the term. I certainly take it over yours and The Athiest’s “it’s not a Black Swan because I say so” definition.
 
So Covid-19 meets the normal definition of 'unpredictable'.

And we're having that emphasised by the chronic illnesses it's causing that nobody has any clue about.

In what way is it 'artificial'?

Thanks to the trillions pumped into the economy by consecutive QEs.

Well Taleb took an obscure saying, exposed it to the world, explained it to the world, turned it into a theory and wrote a best seller about it.

It was only obscure outside of financial markets, where the term has been used for decades. 1987 had lots of discussion about being a Black Swan event*, 20 years before his book.

You should read your sig some time.

*Spoiler alert: it wasn't.
 
So only an event that is not predictable and not plannable counts as a 'black swan'?

Well nobody predicted the behavior and appearance of this virus, but does that means it was unpredictable?

Definition of unpredictable

a : not able to be known or declared in advance
// unpredictable weather​

We say the weather is unpredictable because we never know exactly what it is going to do. Sure there will be cloud or rain or sunshine sometime. But we can't say when or how much. Similarly with viruses - we know new ones will appear from time to time, but not when or how severe. So Covid-19 meets the normal definition of 'unpredictable'.

To be predictable, Covid-19 would need to have appeared within some expected time frame, and have a behavior and impact similar to others. A time frame of 'sometime in the future' is not good enough. A perplexing behavior radically different from others is not good enough. An impact vastly greater than others is not good enough. The last time we had an epidemic as disruptive as this one (or perhaps not - it ain't over yet!) was just over 100 years ago. That doesn't mean you can just 'predict' that a sort-of similar event will occur every 100 years and then call it 'predictable'.

But was it plannable?

We plan for all kinds of things all the time, but not this particular one - which is one reason the plans we did have were inadequate. There comes a point when you have to ask, how many plans do you have to make before saying that something is 'unplannable'? Well I have a plan that covers everything - it's called 'do nothing and just let the event take its course' (yes, that's the 'plan' some people came up with for Covid-19!).

We are still learning about this virus and its peculiar behavior. Nobody saw it coming, nor were we expected to. You could argue that even unpredictable events can be planned for, but a 'plan' that doesn't account for the characteristics of that particular event is not a plan for it.

But hey, Taleb and Spitznagel can make up their own definition of 'black swan' if they like. Only problem is it's so restrictive that nothing qualifies.


The eventuality of a pandemic was predictable and plans were in place in many areas. Not the US, but this only means the US failed to plan for a predictable event.

We couldn’t predict and plan for something like airliners being used to crash into big buildings. You may say; “Sure we could have! It was obvious in hindsight.” Yes, precisely. It’s that kind of Monday morning quarterbacking that is a part of the aftermath of BSEs.
 
We couldn’t predict and plan for something like airliners being used to crash into big buildings. You may say; “Sure we could have! It was obvious in hindsight.” Yes, precisely. It’s that kind of Monday morning quarterbacking that is a part of the aftermath of BSEs.
Absolute nonsense. You think 9/11 was the first time a large airplane crashed into a skyscraper, or the first time an airplane was deliberately crashed into a building by terrorists? Not only was it predictable, it was planned for. The World Trade Center buildings were designed to withstand airliners crashing into them.

Twin Towers Engineered To Withstand Jet Collision
Feb 27, 1993
"We looked at every possible thing we could think of that could happen to the buildings, even to the extent of an airplane hitting the side," said John Skilling, head structural engineer...

Skilling, based in Seattle, is among the world's top structural engineers. He is responsible for much of Seattle's downtown skyline and for several of the world's tallest structures, including the Trade Center.

Concerned because of a case where an airplane hit the Empire State Building, Skilling's people did an analysis that showed the towers would withstand the impact of a Boeing 707.

"Our analysis indicated the biggest problem would be the fact that all the fuel (from the airplane) would dump into the building. There would be a horrendous fire. A lot of people would be killed," he said. "The building structure would still be there."

So you call 9/11 a 'black swan' event even though we knew terrorists were determined to strike on US soil, they had tried using a smaller airplane before, hijackings were commonplace, and domestic security was lax. The truth is, it was only a matter time before someone attempted it (which is why many of us were not surprised when it happened). The only thing 'unpredictable' about 9/11 was the collapse of the twin towers, which was simply a failure of the engineers to correctly analyze the damage that could occur.

In what way is that different from a pandemic? Pandemics are inherently unpredictable because they are caused by random mutations, which rarely result in a 'novel' virus with unusual characteristics that make it especially difficult to control. This is much less predictable than the damage caused by a known airliner design crashing into a building (whether deliberately or by accident).

If you think a large aircraft crashing into a building was a black swan event after it had already occurred and engineers were designing buildings to withstand it, then a novel virus pandemic should qualify even more.
 
Last edited:
Absolute nonsense. You think 9/11 was the first time a large airplane crashed into a skyscraper, or the first time an airplane was deliberately crashed into a building by terrorists? Not only was it predictable, it was planned for. The World Trade Center buildings were designed to withstand airliners crashing into them.

Twin Towers Engineered To Withstand Jet Collision

So you call 9/11 a 'black swan' event even though we knew terrorists were determined to strike on US soil, they had tried using a smaller airplane before, hijackings were commonplace, and domestic security was lax. The truth is, it was only a matter time before someone attempted it (which is why many of us were not surprised when it happened). The only thing 'unpredictable' about 9/11 was the collapse of the twin towers, which was simply a failure of the engineers to correctly analyze the damage that could occur.

In what way is that different from a pandemic? Pandemics are inherently unpredictable because they are caused by random mutations, which rarely result in a 'novel' virus with unusual characteristics that make it especially difficult to control. This is much less predictable than the damage caused by a known airliner design crashing into a building (whether deliberately or by accident).

If you think a large aircraft crashing into a building was a black swan event after it had already occurred and engineers were designing buildings to withstand it, then a novel virus pandemic should qualify even more.

You are all over the place with your (poor) logic.

You are saying that 9/11 was predictable but it’s consequences were momentous by any measure. Isn’t that exactly what you and the Atheist saying about Covid-19 - “sure the pandemic was predictable, but not the consequences”? You can’t have it both ways.

Also pandemics are often very predictable. The flu pandemic (defined as a global epidemic) with mutated viruses, occurs almost every year.

Nothing in your post supports the contention that Covid-19 is a Black Swan.
 
Thanks to the trillions pumped into the economy by consecutive QEs.
So QE is 'artificial'. Got it.

An unstable economy caused by unfettered capitalism is 'natural', so any attempt to stabilize it is 'artificial'? Well I say the concept of capitalism itself is artificial. Capital doesn't exist in nature, it is an artificial construct that only humans value. Not to say that it isn't useful, but the so-called 'free market' is no more 'natural' than any of the other technologies we have developed to thwart Nature.
 
You are all over the place with your (poor) logic.

You are saying that 9/11 was predictable but it’s consequences were momentous by any measure.
No, I am saying that being 'predictable' doesn't doesn't disqualify something from being a 'black swan'. We knew terrorists would strike sooner or later, and we knew there were a variety of targets and methods they could have chosen. We just didn't know when, which, and how. We planned for it too, as best we could given the opportunity costs (financial, political etc.) of doing so.

The consequences of 9/11 were not that momentous. It's primary result was providing the very predictable excuse for Bush to attack Iraq, which probably would have happened anyway. In comparison to Covid-19 the impact was far less, and would have been minimal if we hadn't (predictably) overreacted.

Yet 9/11 is held up as an example of a 'black swan', even though it appears to fail Taleb's test. So I am not 'all over the place', I am very consistent. I say that if 9/11 is sufficiently 'unpredictable' to be a black swan then so is Covid-19.

Isn’t that exactly what you and the Atheist saying about Covid-19 - “sure the pandemic was predictable, but not the consequences”? You can’t have it both ways.
I am not the one trying to have it both ways. I didn't argue that 9/11 wasn't predictable, but Covid-19 was. I didn't define 'unpredictable' so narrowly as to be impossible (because anything is 'predictable' if you don't have to specify the time frame and details of the event).

Also pandemics are often very predictable. The flu pandemic (defined as a global epidemic) with mutated viruses, occurs almost every year.
Sure, but that doesn't describe Covid-19, does it? It's not your usual pandemic.

I get what Taleb and Spitznagel are saying - that every now and then something happens 'out of the blue' that the markets aren't ready for because nobody expected it. But they don't get to pick and chose which events qualify by inventing impossible criteria and then relaxing them for their own picks.

6 months ago, nobody was considering the global economic and social effects of a pandemic like this one, let alone predicting that it would hit us now. We had pandemics in the past and shrugged them off, so we thought we could do the same again. But it quickly became apparent that this time was different. And it's not over yet. We still don't know what the eventual outcome will be. Until it's all over we can't dismiss it as 'just another pandemic'.
 
No, I am saying that being 'predictable' doesn't doesn't disqualify something from being a 'black swan'. We knew terrorists would strike sooner or later, and we knew there were a variety of targets and methods they could have chosen. We just didn't know when, which, and how. We planned for it too, as best we could given the opportunity costs (financial, political etc.) of doing so.

The consequences of 9/11 were not that momentous. It's primary result was providing the very predictable excuse for Bush to attack Iraq, which probably would have happened anyway. In comparison to Covid-19 the impact was far less, and would have been minimal if we hadn't (predictably) overreacted.

Yet 9/11 is held up as an example of a 'black swan', even though it appears to fail Taleb's test. So I am not 'all over the place', I am very consistent. I say that if 9/11 is sufficiently 'unpredictable' to be a black swan then so is Covid-19.

I am not the one trying to have it both ways. I didn't argue that 9/11 wasn't predictable, but Covid-19 was. I didn't define 'unpredictable' so narrowly as to be impossible (because anything is 'predictable' if you don't have to specify the time frame and details of the event).

Sure, but that doesn't describe Covid-19, does it? It's not your usual pandemic.

I get what Taleb and Spitznagel are saying - that every now and then something happens 'out of the blue' that the markets aren't ready for because nobody expected it. But they don't get to pick and chose which events qualify by inventing impossible criteria and then relaxing them for their own picks.

6 months ago, nobody was considering the global economic and social effects of a pandemic like this one, let alone predicting that it would hit us now. We had pandemics in the past and shrugged them off, so we thought we could do the same again. But it quickly became apparent that this time was different. And it's not over yet. We still don't know what the eventual outcome will be. Until it's all over we can't dismiss it as 'just another pandemic'.

I’m sorry. That is breathtaking nonsense.
 
I’m sorry. That is breathtaking nonsense.
I think Roger Ramjets has made a great deal of sense in that post.
With Beijing in lockdown right now it is sensible to not throw caution to the winds.
 
I think Roger Ramjets has made a great deal of sense in that post.
With Beijing in lockdown right now it is sensible to not throw caution to the winds.

What the **** does this to do with Beijing?

Have you read this thread? Have you wondered why this is in the economics section?
 
What the **** does this to do with Beijing?

Have you read this thread? Have you wondered why this is in the economics section?
Yes and posted frequently.
The outbreak in Beijing is an unexpected event.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom