Black Swan Event Under Way

New Zealand is functionally covid free yet the restaurants are open and deserted.

It will take a little time, but if we get another fortnight of zero cases, people will start to go out again.

The only industry truly screwed in NZ is tourism, and even that won't disappear completely, with lots of Kiwis wanting to take a break within the country and not have to compete with squillions of tourists.
 
It will take a little time, but if we get another fortnight of zero cases, people will start to go out again.

The only industry truly screwed in NZ is tourism, and even that won't disappear completely, with lots of Kiwis wanting to take a break within the country and not have to compete with squillions of tourists.


I heard someone (Peter Dutton?) about a week ago saying the Australian Immigration Department officials are looking into easing travel restrictions, or lat least NZ first.
 
To be fair, typical investors also hold on to things, including stocks, long after they ought to realize that they are overvalued.

Eugene Fama got the economics Nobel prize for research quantifying that tendency.

A truly rational and well informed investor would recognize when economic or business conditions have changed, resulting in a company's real value changing, and they would sell shares until the price dropped to the new, more realistic, value that reflected current economic conditions. However, that doesn't happen. People tend to overvalue things that they already own. When applied to stocks, that means people tend to stick with a stock that they already own, even when it ought to be apparent that the true value of the company has dropped, which ought to make the stock price drop.

The result is that when something bad happens to a company, or in the current case to a whole lot of companies simultaneously, there tends to be a delay between the bad thing happening and the drop in stock price that the bad thing causes.

ETA: That still doesn't mean that I know whether current stock prices are overvalued. For companies that do not go bankrupt, many will recover, so their current really bad year shouldn't mean that their stock prices ought to reflect this year's awful performance.


Were you replying to me, because you shouldn't have. I wasn't talking about typical investors.
 
Were you replying to me, because you shouldn't have. I wasn't talking about typical investors.

I know.

You were saying what calm and rational investors do. I was saying that typical investors also do the same thing. The difference is that a calm and rational investor will look at the inherent value of the company, and will not panic and sell when the price goes down. A typical investor will hold onto a stock when the price goes down, waiting for it to come back up, even if the fundamentals of the stock strongly suggest that it will never come back up, or at the very least, will take so long to come back that there are other, better, investments that could be made.

In other words, and this was the primary result of Fama's research, people tend to overvalue stocks that they already own. They tend not to look at their stocks rationally. So, people who "buy and hold", might be calm, rational investors who know that a given stock is currently undervalued, and they should hold onto it, but they also might be typical investors who overvalue what they have in their possession, and hold onto their stocks, ignoring the signs that the company is not as valuable as it once was, or that it once was believed to be.
 
I heard someone (Peter Dutton?) about a week ago saying the Australian Immigration Department officials are looking into easing travel restrictions, or lat least NZ first.

Yep, a potential trans-Tasman bubble is in play - both Cindy & Morrison are pretty keen.

As are all the skifield owners & operators, with only a month until opening day.
 
The Atheist, and there's Queensland and Victoria fighting over Virgin Airlines' home state, plus Qantas hanging on and putting on more flights last week from the UK.

Meadmaker, that's good. I was alluding to Warren Buffet and contrarian investing.
 
Yep, a potential trans-Tasman bubble is in play - both Cindy & Morrison are pretty keen.

As are all the skifield owners & operators, with only a month until opening day.

Agreed. Once there are direct flights all the Australians that want to do an overseas holiday will visit New Zealand. The only competition would be a domestic holiday. Not sure this will compensate for the loss of American and European tourists. Also I think tourists will not want to visit in winter so in spring New Zealand will start to get heaps of tourists from Australia.

Australia's tourist industry will not earn much international currency. The operators will be ok as they will get a lot of domestic tourists, but hardly any international ones.
 
The Atheist, and there's Queensland and Victoria fighting over Virgin Airlines' home state, plus Qantas hanging on and putting on more flights last week from the UK.

There's a sensible plan - almost like having had very few domestic cases, it's time to import some.

Also I think tourists will not want to visit in winter so in spring New Zealand will start to get heaps of tourists from Australia..

I really don't know, but I suspect the travel bug might mean a fair few do. Obviously, skiers will flock in, but that's not going to be any increase on a normal winter. I think the top half of North Island, where there's plenty for tourists to do and it's not that cold, might work out ok.
 
There's a sensible plan - almost like having had very few domestic cases, it's time to import some.

There's a 2 week quarantine period, at least.

I've seen that on other international flights into other countries from other countries.
 
I think I already mentioned on this thread that I started saving £300 a month in a stocks and shares ISA three years ago. I considered cashing it in in February when the likely extent of the "black swan event" became apparent but I'm unlikely to need the money for quite a few years, and interest rates on cash savings are currently negligable, so I decided to continue investing and hope that losses in the short term will be made up in the long term.

I record a snapshot of the values of the 12 funds I'm invested in when I log in once a month to invest another £300 and I thought it might be interesting to record how the ISA is doing here at the same time, and see if that turns out to be the wrong decision. The portfolio is mostly trackers, plus a couple of riskier funds.

I use the percentage difference between the amount I've invested and the total current value to monitor the health of the ISA, so I've tabulated the quarterly values of that from the first anniversary up to February, and the monthly values since. I'll add a new line to the table each month.

Date | % +/-
5.18|1.3
8.18|3.4
11.18|-3.1
2.19|-0.8
5.19|1.9
8.19|7.4
11.19|6.6
2.20|10.3
3.20|3.7
4.20|-4.9
5.20|0.3

As you can see the value has been up and down quite a bit in the three years I've been investing, but it was doing reasonably well when the black swan flew in (that 10.3% increase in February was the highest it's ever been). It plunged over the next few weeks but has since recovered a bit and at the last update was slightly more than the amount I invested. The next update will be around the 10th, so tune in next week for the next exciting installment. Alternatively tell me you're not the slightest bit interested in my little ISA and I'll shut up. :)
 
A bit odd, what are you invested in anyway? March was an awful month for equities and yet you had a 3% gain so you must have been in something else that was hedged against that decline.

Odd now that the stock market is almost back to pre-corona levels now (S&P 3,193.93 now vs S&P 3,386.15 at the peak). It only has to climb around 5% to regain all lost ground.

Weird given the situation with the rest of the economy.
 
Odd now that the stock market is almost back to pre-corona levels now (S&P 3,193.93 now vs S&P 3,386.15 at the peak). It only has to climb around 5% to regain all lost ground.

Odd or just the result of $5T thrown at the economy?

The fundamentals were weak at the start of the crash, and with a recession firmly under way, earnings & profits will decrease, so it's even more over-valued now.
 
A bit odd, what are you invested in anyway?
These are the 12 funds I've invested in:

Baring Europe Select Class I
Blackrock Balanced Growth Portfolio
Blackrock Emerging Markets
iShares Emerging Markets Equity Index
Legal & General All Stocks Gilt Index
Legal & General European Index Class C
Legal & General Global Inflation Lnk Bond
Legal & General International Index
Schroder Managed Balanced (Class I)
Threadneedle European Select
Threadneedle UK Equity Income
TM CRUX European Special Situations

I've got £300 invested in one and about £1200 in three, the rest about £900. [I say about because of course charges nibble away at my £300, so some months I only have £290 to invest]. I stopped at 12 funds as I thought that gave me a sufficiently diversified portfolio. I might add some more as time goes on.

March was an awful month for equities and yet you had a 3% gain so you must have been in something else that was hedged against that decline.
They certainly vary a lot, a couple are currently over 10% up whilst another couple are 15% down. In total I've paid in £11100 so far and the value on 10th May was £11129. So as of that moment I would certainly have done better to just leave those £300s in my bank account, which is currently paying 1% pa on balances of up to £20000 (though that's about to go down to 0.6%).
 
Looks like a whole bunch of bond/equity funds, which I suppose do offset each other a bit. Are these actively managed ones? You might end up paying some pretty hefty fees just to have your money in them. Overall though 300 a month though is a good amount to put in, letting compound interest do its thing.

Odd or just the result of $5T thrown at the economy?
I suppose the money printer going brrrrr does have something to do with it as well.

Totally relevant music video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GI7sBsBHdCk
 
Looks like a whole bunch of bond/equity funds, which I suppose do offset each other a bit. Are these actively managed ones?
About 50:50 managed and trackers.

You might end up paying some pretty hefty fees just to have your money in them.
I avoid funds which charge more than 1% fees. Hargreaves Lansdown (whose ISA this is) have often negotiated discounted management fees.

Overall though 300 a month though is a good amount to put in, letting compound interest do its thing.
That's the idea. The plan is to continue investing until I'm about 70, and then gradually start to convert to cash.
 
Thanks for typing that up, Pixel42. I found it interesting, and would like updates.

Were you tracking dividends too?

I'm not sure how old you are, but is it a rather conservative portfolio?
 
Thanks for typing that up, Pixel42. I found it interesting, and would like updates.
It's all in a spreadsheet so there was more cutting & pasting than typing. :)

Were you tracking dividends too?
I'm investing for growth rather than income, so I don't pay any attention to dividends. I'm not really sure how they work, to be honest. I should make it clear I'm a rank amateur at all this.

I'm not sure how old you are, but is it a rather conservative portfolio?
I'm 66 and yes, I think it's pretty conservative. As I said it's mostly trackers, with only a few riskier funds. If I was 30 years younger it would probably be the other way round.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom