Black Swan Event Under Way

The eventuality of a pandemic was predictable and plans were in place in many areas. Not the US, but this only means the US failed to plan for a predictable event.

Even in the US, and arguably, especially well in the US. The administration was given an entire day of pandemic response scenarios in January 2016. They simply decided not to follow the recommendations for political reasons. Even Senator Turtle had to back down on the lie that they were left with no planning. It was publicly published and shared by all state governments, so too hard to deny outright I guess.

But to your point, yes, pandemics are one of those things that's predictable to the point of being treated as inevitable by most governments, and impact estimates for different scenarios are updated annually.


We couldn’t predict and plan for something like airliners being used to crash into big buildings. You may say; “Sure we could have! It was obvious in hindsight.” Yes, precisely. It’s that kind of Monday morning quarterbacking that is a part of the aftermath of BSEs.

In the case of 9/11 it was a popular fiction device to have an airliner hijacked and flown into the WTC. To the point where I think Bin Laden got the idea from TV shows containing this plotline.

One that comes to mind - because it was filmed here in Vancouver - was The Lone Gunmen, pilot episode... where terrorists hijack an airliner to smash it into the WTC.

 
Last edited:
So QE is 'artificial'. Got it.

An unstable economy caused by unfettered capitalism is 'natural', so any attempt to stabilize it is 'artificial'?

Maybe I didn't explain it well enough, having done so a page back.

QE was fine when it was QE without an ever-increasing number beside it. Money needed to be tipped into the system, but it also needed to stop.

All the continuations of QE have done is artificially inflate real estate and share prices. Ask yourself - has the average American got better off since 2009, or has the money just gone into the hands of those who already had more than enough?

US GDP increased by an average of 2.2% pa after 2009.
During that same period, billionaires increased their wealth by 80%.

Or, you could just take a look at US debt growth since 2010: https://www.statista.com/statistics/187867/public-debt-of-the-united-states-since-1990/
 
Maybe I didn't explain it well enough, having done so a page back.

QE was fine when it was QE without an ever-increasing number beside it. Money needed to be tipped into the system, but it also needed to stop.

What? How can that be? More money is always better!

And lower taxes!

You just don't understand economics.
 
This is bigger than a Financial black swan event.

Is there even a term for a global event of this scale?
 
Global depression ?

I asked earlier, and my algorithms let me receive.

:)


"The Great Reset."

From the likes of The World Economic Forum, Davos, Forbes.



""The Great Reset” is a commitment to jointly and urgently build the foundations of our economic and social system for a more fair, sustainable and resilient future.

"It requires a new social contract centred on human dignity, social justice and where societal progress does not fall behind economic development."



https://www.weforum.org/great-reset

https://www.forbes.com/sites/danpontefract/2020/06/13/this-moment-calls-for-the-great-reset/


(Probably far more positive than any of you were thinking, but what else would you expect from me? :))
 
""The Great Reset” is a commitment to jointly and urgently build the foundations of our economic and social system for a more fair, sustainable and resilient future.

"It requires a new social contract centred on human dignity, social justice and where societal progress does not fall behind economic development."


(Probably far more positive than any of you were thinking, but what else would you expect from me? :))

:dl:

You're funny! You and stanky/quarky should get together some time - he's on the same bandwagon.

I entertained a momentary hope that Covid and its fallout would lead to lasting change, but the light-speed of NZ's return to the same ugly habits as it had in February stopped after a couple of milliseconds.

(I take it USA wasn't a signatory to that statement?)
 
All the continuations of QE have done is artificially inflate real estate and share prices. Ask yourself - has the average American got better off since 2009, or has the money just gone into the hands of those who already had more than enough?

US GDP increased by an average of 2.2% pa after 2009.
During that same period, billionaires increased their wealth by 80%.
Just one problem with that theory - the wealth gap started long before QE. It may be contributing, but only like everything else in our economy is.

Capitalism produces inequality by its very nature, and anything that supports Capitalism must contribute. To reduce that inequality you have to limit the accumulation of wealth and share it more equally. But this is socialism - which we will never accept. The real reason for wealth inequality is our desire for it.
 

Attachments

  • us wealth inequality.jpg
    us wealth inequality.jpg
    38 KB · Views: 1
Just one problem with that theory - the wealth gap started long before QE. It may be contributing, but only like everything else in our economy is.

You can definitely see the gap widen considerably in that time.

Capitalism produces inequality by its very nature, and anything that supports Capitalism must contribute. To reduce that inequality you have to limit the accumulation of wealth and share it more equally. But this is socialism - which we will never accept. The real reason for wealth inequality is our desire for it.

Spot on.

Other countries are slowly catching on, but I have little hope USA will change.

The trouble is, it's not capitalism so much as a worldwide Ponzi scheme, based on ever-increasing asset prices driven by migration to cities. Humans being finite, it will fall over at some stage. Not anytime soon, though.
 
:dl:

You're funny! You and stanky/quarky should get together some time - he's on the same bandwagon.

I entertained a momentary hope that Covid and its fallout would lead to lasting change, but the light-speed of NZ's return to the same ugly habits as it had in February stopped after a couple of milliseconds.

(I take it USA wasn't a signatory to that statement?)

Haha, good old quark. Say hi for me.

I must say, I was unimpressed with Jacinda Ardern's mere 10% paycut and announcement.

The USA? We'll be sending in the WHO and World Food Program there soon.
 
I'll repeat what I've already said:

1 - the scope of this is far greater than any pandemic since 1918. Given that we've had quite a few pandemics since then, I think the scope of this one was completely unexpected, which is why it took lots of corpses to make people sit up and take note.

It certainly didn't take the experts by surprise. Something like this or worse was expected to occur, though the timeline is obviously uncertain. And if the expected rate is once per 100 years, that's definitely something we should have been planning for.
 
It certainly didn't take the experts by surprise. Something like this or worse was expected to occur, though the timeline is obviously uncertain. And if the expected rate is once per 100 years, that's definitely something we should have been planning for.

Of course. The other thing others seem to have missed is that, since the 1930s anyway, many pandemics were ameliorated by antibiotics and vaccines. Yet they still happened. We have yearly flu pandemics controlled by imperfect but still wonderful vaccines.

So pandemics are no surprise at all. The impact of a Covid-19 is major and tragic. But a Black Swan it ain’t.
 
It certainly didn't take the experts by surprise. Something like this or worse was expected to occur, though the timeline is obviously uncertain. And if the expected rate is once per 100 years, that's definitely something we should have been planning for.

I've already noted pandemics are highly predictable.

The scale and scope of devastation this one is causing certainly is, especially when taken in light of previous coronavirus outbreaks.
 
I've already noted pandemics are highly predictable.

The scale and scope of devastation this one is causing certainly is, especially when taken in light of previous coronavirus outbreaks.

Well, the rest is probably just semantics anyway. I'm aware that you were one of the few people on here who understood what was going on early on.

My point really is just that governments had enough information that they really should have been much more prepared for this. We're experiencing a relatively rare event whose exact time of occurrence couldn't be predicted, but who rate of occurrence is actually pretty well understood, and high enough that any reasonable cost-benefit analysis would suggest much more investment in preparation for it, as well as prevention.

I think you probably feel the same way, though, so yeah, any disagreement here is probably just semantic.
 
Well, the rest is probably just semantics anyway. I'm aware that you were one of the few people on here who understood what was going on early on.

My point really is just that governments had enough information that they really should have been much more prepared for this. We're experiencing a relatively rare event whose exact time of occurrence couldn't be predicted, but who rate of occurrence is actually pretty well understood, and high enough that any reasonable cost-benefit analysis would suggest much more investment in preparation for it, as well as prevention.

I think you probably feel the same way, though, so yeah, any disagreement here is probably just semantic.

Sounds right to me!

I do think governments had been led into a false sense of security by SARS, MERS and the Mexican 'Flu, none of which turned out to be that severe.

Being fully prepared for a pandemic of this scale would have been prohibitive for most budgets. Given countries' inability to put money aside for a genuine planetary threat in global warming, the likelihood of the entire world spending hundreds of billions on pandemic preparedness was always zero.

A bigger question would be, having seen the abject failure of response to Covid, what the hell do they do to prepare for the next one? My advice is to hope it's not ebola or a hantavirus.
 
Being fully prepared for a pandemic of this scale would have been prohibitive for most budgets.
Yet we spent trillions on trying to stop non-existent terrorism and propping up the stock market. It's only 'prohibitive' when other goals take priority.

A bigger question would be, having seen the abject failure of response to Covid, what the hell do they do to prepare for the next one? My advice is to hope it's not ebola or a hantavirus.
My advice would be - stop building walls to keep Mexicans out, and start building walls to keep viruses out. Stop spending billions on useless military 'defense', and start building up the medical and social defenses we need to respond to pandemics. Stop giving out tax cuts to the rich, and start saving for the next nationwide lockdown. Stop worrying about 'the economy' and start looking after people.

Covid-19 is a game changer - the question is will we change our game to be prepared for next time? If we don't learn enough from Covid-19 to deal with the next worse one, then we deserve to perish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom