Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
At that time we were at the data collection/hypothesis forming stage rather than any further. The first test was to see if there was any effect at all, and the second was to see (inter alia) if any such effect also lasted after time and EMF exposure. The second Harmoniser results were not very strong, and I hope this message came over in our findings. As I have said elsewhere, that we advertise this product at all is marginal to us, and of no impact on our activities.

It seemed to me that the reason for introducing the Harmoniser work was simply to brand me as a fraud, rather than as a researcher. Then later to criticise its methodology as typical of our published work. The taske ohome message is that we do not reject anything simply because it seems counterintuitive, but giv these devices a fair trial in a scientific scenario where no one else is prepared to do so for fear of being branded a nutcase. We have no axe to grind either way re the Harmoniser or any other of the devices which pop up from time to time.

I heard a rumour that goldfish are supposed to have a memory that only lasts for 7 seconds. I don't know if that is true of goldfish, but I certainly suspect it applies in some other cases! :)

Don't worry Rog, I'll remind you. This thread STARTED with discussion of the harmonizer and similar "devices". Now, whilst you have made numerous efforts to hijack it to something else, that remains the first and foremost issue in the minds of many, it was not something "introduced".

Regardless of whether its methodology is typical of your published work it goes a long way to telling us about your methodology in general. Your astounding error rate, your ignorance of basic scientific procedures, and above all, your committment to truth and/or ethical behavior. If you believe that your harmonizer work is even remotely credible, that tells us just about all we need to know about how credible ANY of your work is.

It is of course good that you are prepared to give "counterintuitive devices" a fair trial. Except that you don't. Your "scientific scenario" is anything but scientific. You don't show the negatives. And by your own admission, you are concerned about maintaining a "commercial advantage" as well, and you don't actually care whether the thing "works" or not, or if the public are deceived. So there is no fairness here, and we are knee deep by now in your "axe grindings"!
 
Why not gas heating? Amazing what you can do with it. Just be sure you have a large reservoir of water and a little gravity, since water pumps are usually electrical too.
 
Don't worry Rog, I'll remind you. This thread STARTED with discussion of the harmonizer and similar "devices". Now, whilst you have made numerous efforts to hijack it to something else, that remains the first and foremost issue in the minds of many, it was not something "introduced".

ER , didn't I start this thread with the idea of discussing bioelectromagnetics ? Sorry, but Bix Beiderbecker calls.
 
cogreslab said:
Why not gas heating? Amazing what you can do with it. Just be sure you have a large reservoir of water and a little gravity, since water pumps are usually electrical too.

So do you or don't you use a water bath ? You said not, but now you are suggesting you do. If your water bath is gas heated then perhaps you could let me know the manufacterer, i'll suggest their use to our purchasing dept.
 
cogreslab said:
ER , didn't I start this thread with the idea of discussing bioelectromagnetics ? Sorry, but Bix Beiderbecker calls.

I am sorry but it's Bix Beiderbecke. I have always suspected that this Jazz Club in Pontypool is actually a tea room for the elders( who goes to a jazz club at 18:30?) but now my suspicion is confirmed. Why you go there? To sell magnets? :)
 
cogreslab said:
Damn! And I paid a small fortune for my panomec! (OK I know its ivermectin), but not much less for the piperazines, around ten quid a syringe if I remember, having now sold my three Welsh cobs.

So you don't actually USE the crap that you sell! If magnets are so good then why are you paying such exorbitant amounts for redundant medicines?
 
Prester John said:


So do you or don't you use a water bath ? You said not, but now you are suggesting you do. If your water bath is gas heated then perhaps you could let me know the manufacterer, i'll suggest their use to our purchasing dept.

PJ: He probably uses ambient hot air - he's got plenty of that! :)
 
cogreslab said:
ER , didn't I start this thread with the idea of discussing bioelectromagnetics ? Sorry, but Bix Beiderbecker calls.

Didn't Cleopatra start her thread with the idea of discussing woo woo EMF "protection devices"?

Didn't you redirect all that to THIS thread?

"Beiderbecker" huh? That amnesia problem is quite severe Rog.

If I had Bill's talent for animated GIF's I'd be flipping you an amnesiac goldfish right about now! :)
 
cogreslab said:
The issue of single sampling in pilot cellular studies.

In published studies of effects on cells it is customary to present data with the average of three values +/- SDs. yada, yada, yada, yada, yada.

Roger, the purpose of comparing samples stastistically is to try and find out if they belong to the same population or not. If you only have one sample, you cannot know the range of that sample, and therefore you cannot know if another sample, wich has been exposed differently belong to the same population or not. Remember my cat example? You weigh a cat; it weighs 2.5 kg. What does this tell you of the weight range of cats? Nothing, except that 2.5 kg is within the range. Now you weigh another cat. It weighs 6 kg. Is this within the range for all cats or is it peculiar to this type of cat? You do not know.

You made five samples, exposed them differently and found different cell counts for them. Is this within the normal range of such samples or is it a product of the different exposures? You cannot know. Now, if you made 15 samples, exposed three in each way, and they were grouped according to exposure, THEN you could begin to talk about a correlation. Whether it was siginificant or not would depend on the figures.

Do you understand now? If not you never will.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
A blood test on a patient to determine an illness/condition is HUGELY different to a series of experimental protocols to test an hypothesis. It is obvious you do not see this, but I cannot fathom that you do not know this as a "scientist".

At that time we were at the data collection/hypothesis forming stage rather than any further. The first test was to see if there was any effect at all, and the second was to see (inter alia) if any such effect also lasted after time and EMF exposure. The second Harmoniser results were not very strong, and I hope this message came over in our findings. As I have said elsewhere, that we advertise this product at all is marginal to us, and of no impact on our activities.

It seemed to me that the reason for introducing the Harmoniser work was simply to brand me as a fraud, rather than as a researcher. Then later to criticise its methodology as typical of our published work. The taske ohome message is that we do not reject anything simply because it seems counterintuitive, but giv these devices a fair trial in a scientific scenario where no one else is prepared to do so for fear of being branded a nutcase. We have no axe to grind either way re the Harmoniser or any other of the devices which pop up from time to time.
Back-pedalling so fast you risk a speeding ticket :p. I can understand you want to put as much space between yourself and the harmonizer as you can, but it won't work; you have advertized the thing on your website under products, and offered it for sale. You advertize it with this text:

Promotes that feeling of wellbeing and gain personal protection most RF radiations with this pendant device. Also available in Silver and Gold.
The Harmoniser protects against ambient radiation of all frequencies using the technique of implosion. IMPLOSION is a word derived from the research of Schauberger, a Scandinavian water engineer, and its protective effects have spiral tube for wear around the neck. For all around protection at most RF/MW frequencies.
A clear and unreserved claim that it protects the user from radiation by a specific mode of action. Yet you admit elsewhere that you do not know if it works in vivo. You also admit right here that you have little idea of how it could work.

I know what the term for such a ting is in my dictionary. Do you use a different dictionary, Roger?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
It has been troubling me that one poster was unable to afford to go sailing.
So here are Coghill's rules of how to afford/go sailing:

1. Never go sailing. In case you get smitten with the bug to repeat the experience (more likely you will puke more mightily than Bouncer's bird) get someone take a picture of yourself whilst puking up. (any handy skeptic will love to do that for you).

Yeah, I've had that kind of crew.

2. Never own your own boat. If you want to experience boat owenership, simply stand in a shower and tear up ten pound notes. Coghill's rule of boat ownership: the denomination of the note in this exercise equals 1.4 times the square root of the boat's length at the waterline.

I used to own a boat, and I know all about those people who show up and want a free ride. When the bottom is to be overhauled, somehow they are NEVER around.

3. Learn how to be a foredeck hand and practice knots and astronavigation (you can do this by doing astrological charts for your neighbours and friends: it doesn't mean much, but the spherical geometry of astro is astrology in reverse).

Personally, I've never been desparate enough to rely on a foredeck hand for navigation, but I suppose there are skippers and skippers.

4. When invited, bring copious amounts of Gin and Tonic, and leave plenty behind after the trip.

Yeah, I know the kind of tourists that bring a sixpack and leave two behind assuming thay have contributes mightily to the expenses of running a boat :rolleyes:

5. Learn Morse code jargon: Alpha, Bravo and especially Whisky etc.

?? If they acted impressed by THAT, they were just trying to be polite.

6. Bring a sharp knife and a bottle opener gadget. You will certainly need the latter, and probably also the former to cut yourself out of the rigging after a B2 knockdown.

Trust a tourist to get entangled in SOMETHING during a spinacker broach.

7. Do not make passes at the skipper's wife.


8. Borrow a pair of yellow wellies from your local affluent vet (aka BVM).

Armed with these rules you should have a costless and longterm sailing experience. Off now to the jazz club in my R Reg. Good weekend to all. [/B]
Urf! Good thing you're were never near MY boat.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
The issue of single sampling in pilot cellular studies.

In published studies of effects on cells it is customary to present data with the average of three values +/- SDs. This is particularly important where the SD is large or the assay not frequently published. In cases where the assay is well known however, .... [yadda, yadda]
Sorry, I just read this four times, unable to believe that Roger was saying what he obviously is saying, and now I may need professional help to re-hinge my jaw. This is his answer to criticism of his n=1 study?

:dl:

Roger says that when an assay has rather poor precision, then it is good practice to do the measurements in triplicate and present the result as a mean, but when the precision is known to be good, then singleton assays are acceptable.

Yes. So what?

First, when n=1 is criticised, Roger says, "but I measured that sample 10 times, so that counts as 10 data points." That is justifiably shot down in flames, and Roger says, "but it's OK just to measure each sample once."

I can't believe that this constant confusion between repeated measurements of a single sample, and having multiple samples in a group, is genuine. If Roger is really so confused, he's even stupider and more ignorant than I thought he was - but then if he isn't, how does he think that making this confusion will in any way fool anyone here?

Or to go back to Hans' analogy, first Roger says that he weighed each of the two cats ten times each, which gives him sufficient statistical power to declare that tabbies are significantly heavier than black-and-whites. Then when we criticise him for only having one cat of each colour, he says that if your scales are reliable enough, it's OK just to weigh each cat once as that will give you a sufficiently accurate measurement of its weight.

Duh? :wink8:

The Blessed Virgin Mary.

By the way, I don't have yellow wellies, and you'll only be able to borrow my wellies of you take a size 4 anyway.
 
Rolfe said:
Sorry, I just read this four times, unable to believe that Roger was saying what he obviously is saying, and now I may need professional help to re-hinge my jaw. This is his answer to criticism of his n=1 study?

:dl:

Roger says that when an assay has rather poor precision, then it is good practice to do the measurements in triplicate and present the result as a mean, but when the precision is known to be good, then singleton assays are acceptable.

Yes. So what?

First, when n=1 is criticised, Roger says, "but I measured that sample 10 times, so that counts as 10 data points." That is justifiably shot down in flames, and Roger says, "but it's OK just to measure each sample once."

I can't believe that this constant confusion between repeated measurements of a single sample, and having multiple samples in a group, is genuine. If Roger is really so confused, he's even stupider and more ignorant than I thought he was - but then if he isn't, how does he think that making this confusion will in any way fool anyone here?

Or to go back to Hans' analogy, first Roger says that he weighed each of the two cats ten times each, which gives him sufficient statistical power to declare that tabbies are significantly heavier than black-and-whites. Then when we criticise him for only having one cat of each colour, he says that if your scales are reliable enough, it's OK just to weigh each cat once as that will give you a sufficiently accurate measurement of its weight.

Duh? :wink8:

The Blessed Virgin Mary.

By the way, I don't have yellow wellies, and you'll only be able to borrow my wellies of you take a size 4 anyway.

It is abundantly clear to me that either :
o Roger has no lab, and
o Roger runs no lab, or,
o If the first two conclusions are wrong, he most assuredly has no business running a lab, and that
o Any and all papers authored by him and actually published in peer-reviewed journals ought to be summarily withdrawn by the editors unless it can be demonstrated Roger was compus mentis when they were submitted, and has since become non compus mentis.

What is my justification for these comments? The argument over counts and proper lab protocols may seem both arcane and incomprehensible to many readers here, but it is absolutley essential in science. The Baylor College of Medicine Laboratory procedure link I provided many posts ago gives the clue:

" A total of 300 - 400 cells should be counted, since the counting error is approximated by the square root of the total count. "

Counting errors (or any random errors for that matter) are critical in data interpretation. Let's translate that into something with which nearly everybody is familiar: opinion polls We have two candidates, Dewey and Cheatam. The morning paper reports 50% of likely voters pick Dewey and 50% pick Cheatam. We don't need to know about errors to know that's a dead heat. The next week, the morning paper reports 48% of likely voters pick Dewey and 52% Cheatam. Is Cheatam pulling ahead? We need to know the margin of error to say that with any certainty.

Fortunately, the paper is more informative than the average tabloid and further reports the margin of error is +/- 4%. That means that Dewey's figures actually lie somewhere between 44 and 52% and Cheatam's between 48 and 54%. The measurements overlap! It is still a dead heat.

Leaving out the technical details for the moment, any research paper that wants to "prove" something typically needs to distinguish between two population samples, much like the poll example above. It also needs to report the margin of error (so to speak) so that it can draw a proper conclusion from its experiment.

Roger here can draw no such conclusion because he doesn't even know enough to know the base counting error! He can't calculate it because he doesn't even understand it. He offers singleton cell counts where he should be using 300-400 cells! His error rates represent an unbelievable proportion of his raw counts.

This would be like the morning paper reporting the poll results as Dewey 48%, Cheatam 52%, with a 36% margin of error. Now obviously no poll would report such results. The poll documents would be shredded, some counter heads would roll and they'd start over. Likewise, no peer reviewed journal would publish a paper showing population A count 257 and population B count 195, +/- 112.

But roger would have us believe that he, someone who somehow lacks this fundamental understanding, has made these kinds of measurements with this kind of sloppiness and ignorance. He's so wet, one has to wonder if his boat-owning friend doesn't hang him upside-down from the bowsprit all weekend long so he doesn't have to listen to roger's drivel.
 
Hooray! At last a glimmer of sense among all the crap!

"Leaving out the technical details for the moment, any research paper that wants to "prove" something typically needs to distinguish between two population samples, much like the poll example above. It also needs to report the margin of error (so to speak) so that it can draw a proper conclusion from its experiment".

The total population is the entire culture of millions of cells in this case. From this we take samples and expose them (or not) so we have several sample populations each still with thousands of cells. Each cell in this case a "cat", because they will either be blue or white (ginger or black/white) after the trypan dye is added.

If we confine each of these sample populations to the area under the ruled area of hemacytometer, that would be 20 squares, buit applying the non-adjacent rule we actually count only ten non-adjacent squares to arrive at a viability percent based on say 400 or so cats. Then we wash the hemacytometer (actually we use two to speed things up) and start the count of the next (and differently exposed) sample. Another 400 or so "cats", any one of which might be blue or white; and we thereby get another viability percent. We also get numerical data capable of analysis to see its SDs, means etc. The question is, is the difference betweennthese two viability percentages significant in statistical terms? To find out, we apply the test for inference on proportions (see Colton, Statistics in Medicine, Little Brown and Co., page 151 et seq.). This is what we did. There is nothing wrong with that approach, although it would have been nice to repeat the exercise three times.
 
cogreslab said:
Another 400 or so "cats", any one of which might be blue or white; and we thereby get another viability percent. We also get numerical data capable of analysis to see its SDs, means etc.
Dodger,

This is absolute gibberish. It constitutes try number what for you to explain your methods. Each one different enough to indicate you are not familiar with the basics. Case in point is the selected section of your last post. One doesn't do the counts and "also get numerical data capable of analysis" yabber yabber yabber, you fool. One does sufficient basic counts so that the collection of counts is sufficient to calculate reasonable means and standard deviations.

Where in bloody hades do you think those 'also data" come from. Your nether regions? In the future, please assume you are speaking with and to people capable of seeing through the blizzards you attempt to blow here. Or just stop posting here, you insufferable fool.
 
Sorry, of course there are only 18 not 20 squares in the hemacytometers, of which we count ten (five from each of the two wells)
 
Wading past your immaculate rhetoric Bouncer, I cannot see for the life of me what you are driving at:

you say:

"One does sufficient basic counts so that the collection of counts is sufficient to calculate reasonable means and standard deviations".

after the count of any one hemacytometer sample we end up with two sets of ten numbers (each number is probably about 20-40 cells) one set is the viable cells and the other is the non viable cells. The ten numbers (viable cells) can give us SDs and sums and means for that condition, and totals say between 200 and 400 cells. The other ten numbers (non viable cells) give us the data we need to compare the two conditions. From this we can derive a viability percent of that sample. What's wrong with that?
 
For one more time I wish to thank the posters who devote time in composing informatory and simple to understand posts for us that want to learn and get informed about issues that are related to public health but we have not studied Sciences.

I know that it's a very difficult and time consuming task, I appreciate your effort very much.

Bill Hoyt's last post where he explains the Baylor Lab Procedure is another good example.

Thanks Bill.
 
Ive just looked at the Baylor site, and find that is exactly the procedure we followed, except they forgot to say that you must leave the Trypan dye a set few minutes before the count, and most textbooks recommened a 20x objective, since the cells are rather too small to count with a x10 objective. It is important to mix the dye and leave it the same number of minutes each time, otherwise the solution is not comparable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom