Pragmatist
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- May 12, 2004
- Messages
- 1,529
cogreslab said:At that time we were at the data collection/hypothesis forming stage rather than any further. The first test was to see if there was any effect at all, and the second was to see (inter alia) if any such effect also lasted after time and EMF exposure. The second Harmoniser results were not very strong, and I hope this message came over in our findings. As I have said elsewhere, that we advertise this product at all is marginal to us, and of no impact on our activities.
It seemed to me that the reason for introducing the Harmoniser work was simply to brand me as a fraud, rather than as a researcher. Then later to criticise its methodology as typical of our published work. The taske ohome message is that we do not reject anything simply because it seems counterintuitive, but giv these devices a fair trial in a scientific scenario where no one else is prepared to do so for fear of being branded a nutcase. We have no axe to grind either way re the Harmoniser or any other of the devices which pop up from time to time.
I heard a rumour that goldfish are supposed to have a memory that only lasts for 7 seconds. I don't know if that is true of goldfish, but I certainly suspect it applies in some other cases!
Don't worry Rog, I'll remind you. This thread STARTED with discussion of the harmonizer and similar "devices". Now, whilst you have made numerous efforts to hijack it to something else, that remains the first and foremost issue in the minds of many, it was not something "introduced".
Regardless of whether its methodology is typical of your published work it goes a long way to telling us about your methodology in general. Your astounding error rate, your ignorance of basic scientific procedures, and above all, your committment to truth and/or ethical behavior. If you believe that your harmonizer work is even remotely credible, that tells us just about all we need to know about how credible ANY of your work is.
It is of course good that you are prepared to give "counterintuitive devices" a fair trial. Except that you don't. Your "scientific scenario" is anything but scientific. You don't show the negatives. And by your own admission, you are concerned about maintaining a "commercial advantage" as well, and you don't actually care whether the thing "works" or not, or if the public are deceived. So there is no fairness here, and we are knee deep by now in your "axe grindings"!

