Bioelectromagnetics

Cogreslab,

This is not a definitive site, still looking but this page here says:
76% of cases are over 50
Again I think it's a problem with your reading comprehension skills again. Although breast cancer is a major killer of young women, the incidence is still higher for older women. Basically breast cancer kills a high proportion of the very small number of women who die in the age range 34-54.

Rather more contract it when they are over 50
 
cogreslab said:
Many blood tests are based on one single culture isolate (maybe from a few BD vacutainers but still one drawing), and the patient does not have to give the sample three times on separate days.
Don't you just love the way Roger calmly ignores the shredding he's had on the really appalling area of the n=1 study, and latches on to something (breast cancer rates) where he thinks he's still got a rag of an excuse left?

Anyway, I want to go back to the diagnosis on the single blood sample for a moment. We do this all the time. Because the background work has been done well enough, and with a big enough patient pool, to enable us to know how firmly one result enables us to classify the patient as having a particular condition. We're building on the past data of hundreds in the initial studies of the test, thousands while the test was still being evaluated clinically, and probably millions in the time the test has been a routine part of clinical investigation.

Roger, on the other hand, is looking at a novel situation. He's trying to establish the effect de novo. One sample???

:dl:

The very fact that he can advance this argument at all demonstrates his intellectual bankruptcy, and his utter desperation to find some way to validate his fraudulent products.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.

(And I still think that saying "BD vacutainers" is a beautiful demonstration of his desperation to appear as a knowledgeable insider, while actually knowing bugger-all.)
 
..and from the bbc

http://www.bbc.co.uk/health/conditions/breastcancer.shtml

(you really should try posting links Roger)

The risk of breast cancer increases with age - about 80 percent of women diagnosed are over 50 and half of those are over 60.

I think tho' Roger you have rather more pertinent points to address :

whereas the link between EMF and breast cancer is with women of child bearing age (oestrogen positive receptor cancers), where inhibition of melatonin is implicated.

Wot no reference, just another empty claim without basis.

As well as the general destruction of your ideas by Hans, Pragmatist et al.
 
PJ says: "There is a significant number of breast cancers in the range 40-49"

His buddy says: "breast cancer is very rare under fifty"

You cannot both be right!

Moreover there is plenty of evidence of an EMF breast cancer link.

See: The Melatonin Hypothesis: Breast cancer and use of electrric power, (Stevens, Wilson, and Anderson, eds.) Battelle Press 1997, especially pages 555-701 (The section titled Direct Evidence).

Once again these so-called experts display their hopeless ignorance!

I am shortly in a position to deal with your other load of BS concerning n=1 statistics. So don't slink off yet, Hans.
 
The point is Roger you are taking me up on a point of semantics. Rare is a subjective definition. In response to your criticism you have had evidence showing the actual frequency of breast cancer in different age groups. Decide for yourself if you want to call it rare, very rare, infequent, it doesn't really matter the figures are the evidence.


In return after, making a huge claim, you quote a reference from a book, now excuse me if i don't buy into that immediatly. How about epidemiological studies showing a link ? Real science Roger, not just the word play you are so fond of.

oh and a last point, since you seem to enjoy irrelevant nit picking

Once again these so-called experts display their hopeless ignorance!

I've specifically stated earlier in the thread i'm not an expert. Guess that makes you wrong again.
 
Prester John said:
The point is Roger you are taking me up on a point of semantics. Rare is a subjective definition. In response to your criticism you have had evidence showing the actual frequency of breast cancer in different age groups. Decide for yourself if you want to call it rare, very rare, infequent, it doesn't really matter the figures are the evidence.

...snip...

And rare does not mean insignificant. Kilometre wide asteroids hitting the earth are rare but not insignificant.
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*
I am shortly in a position to deal with your other load of BS concerning n=1 statistics. So don't slink off yet, Hans.
That should prove interesting ;). Does it mean that you are actually perusing text-books, or are you just about to dream up more science fiction?

Edited to add: Oh, and who talked about slinking off? No worries, mate. I'm here for as long as it takes, but it'll be gloves off from now on.

Hans
 
but it'll be gloves off from now on.

You were a bare knuckle fighter from the start, Hans. Us "gyppoes" and "scrapyard dealers" are used to that form of combat, so watch out.

I amj going to put your teeth all over Pontypool.
 
cogreslab said:
but it'll be gloves off from now on.

You were a bare knuckle fighter from the start, Hans. Us "gyppoes" and "scrapyard dealers" are used to that form of combat, so watch out.

I amj going to put your teeth all over Pontypool.
Certainly a knock-down, drag-out fight based on any of the following:

- knowledge of electromagnetism
- knowledge of biology
- experiment design and execution
- statistical analysis
- reading comprehension

Is unlikely to go in your favour I suggest that you DO let your fists do the talking - so to speak - as that appears to be the only avenue open to you.
 
cogreslab said:
but it'll be gloves off from now on.

You were a bare knuckle fighter from the start, Hans. Us "gyppoes" and "scrapyard dealers" are used to that form of combat, so watch out.

I amj going to put your teeth all over Pontypool.
I never called you a gyppo (whatever that is) or a scrapyard dealer. I called you a liar and a swindler. If you are so sure of youself, why did you not deal with me while the going was nice? That would have made you look so much better as a scientist.

Mmmm, guess I'll have to look up Pontypool....:rolleyes:

Hans
 
Our Hans, despite his protests about being a scientific independent, and engaged in exposing my vile commercial interests, in reality is simply trying to protect his own livelihood here.

We have heard he is a Vet, and that he supports their fraternity presumably by providing diagnostic support. These are the group who regularly rips off the public by charging exorbitant fees for penny-cost chemicals (see my previous post, and Hans's lame response - one can always justify charging a high price it seems). They have a nice lifestyle, these vets: 4WD cars etc.

Then along comes magnet therapy, and it is clearly helping animal health, especially with racehorses where there is a good deal of money at stake. Hans sees this as a threat to his little game: magnets don't cost much compared to piperazines, and what's more they last for a long time.

So Hans makes it his business to attack any magnetic therapy devices, becauase that way he can protect his own selfish interests. That is Hans, folks. Whether they are adjuvant to the health profession or for the public good or not is of no interest to him.
 
cogreslab said:
Our Hans, despite his protests about being a scientific independent, and engaged in exposing my vile commercial interests, in reality is simply trying to protect his own livelihood here.

We have heard he is a Vet, and that he supports their fraternity presumably by providing diagnostic support. These are the group who regularly rips off the public by charging exorbitant fees for penny-cost chemicals (see my previous post, and Hans's lame response - one can always justify charging a high price it seems). They have a nice lifestyle, these vets: 4WD cars etc.

Then along comes magnet therapy, and it is clearly helping animal health, especially with racehorses where there is a good deal of money at stake. Hans sees this as a threat to his little game: magnets don't cost much compared to piperazines, and what's more they last for a long time.

So Hans makes it his business to attack any magnetic therapy devices, becauase that way he can protect his own selfish interests. That is Hans, folks. Whether they are adjuvant to the health profession or for the public good or not is of no interest to him.

Just coz i thought it was worth saving.
 
cogreslab said:
.........Then along comes magnet therapy, and it is clearly helping animal health, especially with racehorses where there is a good deal of money at stake. Hans sees this as a threat to his little game: magnets don't cost much compared to piperazines, and what's more they last for a long time.......
I take it that you have some evidence for this claim. That's evidence acquired in a properly conducted study rather than evidence acquired through a series of anecdotes.
 
Ayee, Roger! If you are gonna fight dirty, TRY to put your mind into it, otherwise there will be no sport in it.

cogreslab said:
Our Hans, despite his protests about being a scientific independent, and engaged in exposing my vile commercial interests, in reality is simply trying to protect his own livelihood here.

You earlier accused me of being on the payroll of the electricity board, which I informed you, quite correctly, that I'm not. That is all the scientific independence I have ever claimed.

We have heard he is a Vet, and that he supports their fraternity presumably by providing diagnostic support. These are the group who regularly rips off the public by charging exorbitant fees for penny-cost chemicals (see my previous post, and Hans's lame response - one can always justify charging a high price it seems). They have a nice lifestyle, these vets: 4WD cars etc.

Now, I know this is difficult for you, but DO try to get the most simple facts straight (if all else fails, browse this thread for information), and you will find that I'm not the vet.

Then along comes magnet therapy, and it is clearly helping animal health, especially with racehorses where there is a good deal of money at stake. Hans sees this as a threat to his little game: magnets don't cost much compared to piperazines, and what's more they last for a long time.

Keep digging, Roger :roll:.

So Hans makes it his business to attack any magnetic therapy devices, becauase that way he can protect his own selfish interests.

Slight problem there, Roger boy: While I may have hinted that I think they are crap, I have not attacked the permanent magnet devices. You see, they are not my area of expertice, and, unlike SOME people here (wink, wink, nudge, nudge) I like to know what I am talking about.

That is Hans, folks. Whether they are adjuvant to the health profession or for the public good or not is of no interest to him.

And that's Roger, folks. Just blather on, d*mn the facts, full speed ahead :rolleyes:.

Really, this kind of exchanges belong in the flame-war forum, so if you want to go there, I'm game. Better improve your legwork, though ;).

Hans
 
Well, it doesn't look as though we are going to get any details of the alleged electromagnetic setup of Roger's experiment, so I would like to take a moment to look at the Trypan Blue exclusion test.

I don't pretend to be an expert in biology but it seems to me that there are some serious questions about the reliability of Trypan Blue exclusion in a test of this type.

I am aware of one piece of unpublished research in which researchers found that human fibroblasts, when exposed to RF radiation, exhibited an unusual effect. They found that the gap junctions of the cells would open and close cyclically over a period of several minutes and would admit macromolecular dyes. An undyed control sample remained perfectly viable under the same exposure, and even the dyed sample was viable, at least for a while. The conclusion was that dye exclusion was an unreliable measure of cell viability in cases of RF exposure because the dye would not necessarily be excluded by viable cells. Now of course, as this is unpublished and is ongoing research (not mine) I cannot give any proof of this, and it cannot be considered as evidence. The only reason I mention it is because it started me thinking about Trypan Blue, and whether or not the same effect has been realised in other published research. I don't know the answer to that, maybe the biologists on here will know more.

However, it appears that there are legitimate questions about the accuracy of dye exclusion methods, and trypan blue in particular.

The trypan blue test is a test of whether a dye molecule can pass the cell membrane. It is ASSUMED that if a dye molecule DOES pass the membrane, that the membrane is damaged, and that the cell is not viable. Furthermore, if the dye does NOT pass the membrane it is ASSUMED that the cell is viable.

There are many known instances where a non viable cell will not pass trypan blue because the membrane is not damaged. Examples include irradiated cells that have suffered nuclear damage, and certain types of internal cytotoxicity. One interesting case is the recent UPSET experiments (see: http://www.isi.edu/~vernier/upset.html) where it is proposed that very short pulses of EM radiation can affect the internal contents of cells without damaging the cell membrane. It seems to me that since we are talking about the (alleged) effects of RF in Roger's experiment, that taking the above into account, including Roger's own claim about adverse EM effects on mitochondrial membranes, that trypan blue exclusion is a singularly poor way of assessing cell viability where radiation of any sort is concerned.

It is also well known that transient electroporation will open channels in cell membranes without necessarily damaging overall cell viability. In which case trypan blue could be admitted by viable cells.

So even if Roger's "experiment" is legitimate in other respects (which it clearly isn't), then this will potentially be a major confounding factor that will screw up the results. It would appear that it is NOT reasonable to draw any conclusions about lymphocyte VIABILITY from a crude test like trypan blue exclusion alone.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom