Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
Ground the water.

Good suggestion. We tried that with an earthwire from the bath going out of the lab into the ground outside and various variations on that theme. Surprisingly it didn't work, the fields were still high. Maybe a thicker earthwire, or some such? There was definitely no unbalanced ground return current.

:dl:

That was cruel Hans! :)
 
How does the regulation system function? (Thyristors, perhaps).

Mercy about the thyristor gaffe! I really was very tired at the time. Normally the instruments have their own feedback systems. our loggers are there to see if these are working, and with what tolerances.
 
I am not going to have much time next week since I am going to Istanbul for the WHO meeting on EMF hazards, but since we have nearly 2000 posts now and nearly 20,000 views, may be it is a good time to review where we have got to.

My position is that the regulatory advice on EMF is conspicuously wrong:

Low frequency:

ELF electric fields as low as 20 V/m can be the cause of serious incapacity in adults, life-threatening to children, and mortal to infants. By contrast the official view is that nothing under 10,000 V/m is anything to worry about. An enormous gap.

I hope I have shown that the existing epi literature has never properly addressed the possibility that ELF electric fields rather than magnetic, are the bioeffector.

High frequency:

The RF/MW environment has changed dramatically with the arrival of mobile telephony. Is there a heath hazard from these extremely weak fields and radiations?

The existing regulation is based on some very dodgy science (a few studies with macaque monkeys were used to set the standards and these still only recognise thermal effects).

Other important countries like China and Russia have far lower PELs. In the West there is a increasing level of public complaint that living near such masts or excessively using handsets has adverse effects. And there is some evidence in the literature (e.g. Helen Dolk et al, 1997), that proximity to RF towers is associated with leukaemia in adults. The position is unclear enough for the Govt to initiate a large research programme.

As for static magnets, the claims of manufacturers is supported to some extent by published work, but this is patchy at present.

Unlike the pharmaceutical industry, where stringent (hopefully) pre-testing of new drugs avoids major mistakes, there is no health-related regulation of cellphone installations on the one hand, nor (except for the efforts of the ASA and the DFT) of static magnet marketing, since producers can satisfy Class 1a regulations quite easily.

Against that background there is clearly a need for a greater research effort, but this is largely shunned by academic institutions as being too fringe.

So we have a situation where questionable protective devices against hazards which are themselves in dispute are under scrutiny, where enormous commercial effects are likely should weak EMF be found hazardous, and where the potential promise of magnet therapy still needs underpinning by sound research and a better understanding of mechanisms (if any).

Not an easy research environment to work in! Nevertheless the job is important if we are to progress, and I thank all for the efforts being put into this issue.
 
Rolfe said:

This is complete nonsense. It has been shown many times that magnets have absolutely no effect on blood flow and moreover are not capable of having any effect on blood flow.


To make that statement you need to produce supporting evidence. I likewise, to support my argument that it does.

Here are a couple of published studies supporting my argument:

GMITROV J
Static magnetic field effect on sinocarotid baroreceptors in humans.
Electro & Magnetobiology v15 i3 p183 p189 1996

OHKUBO C XU S
Acute effects of static magnetic fields on cutaneous microcirculation in rabbits.
In Vivo v11 i3 p221 p225 1997


Where are yours, Rolfe?
 
My comments are in blue.

cogreslab said:
I am not going to have much time next week since I am going to Istanbul for the WHO meeting on EMF hazards, but since we have nearly 2000 posts now and nearly 20,000 views, may be it is a good time to review where we have got to.

My position is that the regulatory advice on EMF is conspicuously wrong:

Your position on most matters is not credible.

Low frequency:

ELF electric fields as low as 20 V/m can be the cause of serious incapacity in adults, life-threatening to children, and mortal to infants. By contrast the official view is that nothing under 10,000 V/m is anything to worry about. An enormous gap.

I hope I have shown that the existing epi literature has never properly addressed the possibility that ELF electric fields rather than magnetic, are the bioeffector.

The existing epi literature doesn't NEED to address the possibility that ELF electric fields are the bioeffector in most cases, as a simple electrical calculation shows that ELF electric fields will be attenuated by huge factors because of the conductivity of the skin and body tissues. Electric fields can be reasonably calculated to be of the order of 10,000,000 times SMALLER inside the body than outside at ELF. Which would put the induced fields much lower than many biological signals and even most natural electrical noise inside the body. Any field that is locally present inside the body at ELF is very much more likely to be due to magnetic induction.

Your theory doesn't make scientific sense and is not supported by any credible facts or data. Your own understanding of even basic electrical principles is so abysmal that you simply don't understand why you are out on a limb.


High frequency:

The RF/MW environment has changed dramatically with the arrival of mobile telephony. Is there a heath hazard from these extremely weak fields and radiations?

That is not currently known.

The existing regulation is based on some very dodgy science (a few studies with macaque monkeys were used to set the standards and these still only recognise thermal effects).

You are not in a position to assert that anyone else's science is "dodgy"! Your own science is virtually non-existent. You are simply not qualified to assess scientific matters that you clearly don't understand even the basic principles of.

Other important countries like China and Russia have far lower PELs. In the West there is a increasing level of public complaint that living near such masts or excessively using handsets has adverse effects. And there is some evidence in the literature (e.g. Helen Dolk et al, 1997), that proximity to RF towers is associated with leukaemia in adults. The position is unclear enough for the Govt to initiate a large research programme.

There is increasing complaint in the west because scaremongers like yourself misrepresent information to the lay public in order to cause panic. There are possible weak associations between certain diseases and the siting of towers etc. There is no definite link established that would rule out factors unrelated to RF. Nor has any consistent and reproducible mechanism been established that would definitely link weak RF exposure to specific disease such as leukaemia.

That does not mean of course that there IS no risk. It simply means that the matter is still under investigation. If people get panicked by scaremongering into forcing premature actions, it is possible that this may actually help conceal the true cause of such disease - IF such disease IS in some way directly related to the siting of masts and towers etc.


As for static magnets, the claims of manufacturers is supported to some extent by published work, but this is patchy at present.

And there are also other studies that show variously that magnets do NOT show any therapeutic effect at practical levels, or indeed that they may actually show HARMFUL effects instead.

Since you assert that it is best not to take any risk with alternating fields on the basis that there might be some possible harm, it is entirely inconsistent with your position where you actively advocate static magnets, which may also possibly have harmful effects.


Unlike the pharmaceutical industry, where stringent (hopefully) pre-testing of new drugs avoids major mistakes, there is no health-related regulation of cellphone installations on the one hand, nor (except for the efforts of the ASA and the DFT) of static magnet marketing, since producers can satisfy Class 1a regulations quite easily.

And you previously falsely asserted that Class 1a regulation required proof of efficacy, which you now contradict.

Against that background there is clearly a need for a greater research effort, but this is largely shunned by academic institutions as being too fringe.

The reason the matter has been branded fringe is because of unscrupulous vendors such as yourself who make wild and unsupportable claims in respect of things like magnets. Every time you are proven wrong, or your science is proved to be faulty or inadequate, you harm your own cause.

So we have a situation where questionable protective devices against hazards which are themselves in dispute are under scrutiny, where enormous commercial effects are likely should weak EMF be found hazardous, and where the potential promise of magnet therapy still needs underpinning by sound research and a better understanding of mechanisms (if any).

We have a situation where questionable protective devices and magnets are sold by people such as yourself with claims that go so far beyond reason and credibility as to beggar belief. In addition to that you make unsupportable claims about hazards that may or may not exist. But your position in so many respects is so far from credibility that even if you were to tell the truth, nobody in their right mind would believe you.

Not an easy research environment to work in! Nevertheless the job is important if we are to progress, and I thank all for the efforts being put into this issue.

One of the biggest problems in the whole area, which you have not realised, is that your own efforts are a major hindrance to proper investigation of these areas. By introducing wild theories and speculations under the guise of facts, and fanning public fears and misconceptions, you are simply making the whole thing much more difficult for all. When credible researchers come up with real and significant results they have to contend with being branded as lunatics because people like you throw out so much lunacy. There is a very real and significant chance that the noise you generate will drown out the quieter and more credible voices of reason.

Your alleged "science" has been thoroughly demolished at every level. It is not just a case that one or two of your "scientific" claims are weak or questionable, but rather that your entire knowledge of science is non-existent. Your mistakes are not minor differences of interpretation, they are so fundamental and so many that your ignorance is utterly humiliating.

Despite this, you still continue to assert that you are a "scientist". You have misrepresented yourself to the public and continue to misrepresent yourself. You engage in the sale of "devices" that are at best highly dubious and questionable, and at worst, downright fraud. You mispresent these devices and continue to try to cover up the fraud with pseudoscientific fiction. You admit that you don't care whether or not you deceive people, and worse that you don't care whether you harm anybody as a result either.

You encourage fear, suspicion and panic amongst the public with pseudoscience. You use the most unethical and execrable means to heighten and promote this panic, for example your "challenge" to kill infants. And profit directly from that panic, by using it to sell your fraudulent wares and yourself as a "scientist".

You attempt to associate yourself with reputable scientists, organisations and societies in such a way that you bring discredit upon them.

Whatever you consider your "mission" here was, it is has failed. You have not only confirmed the worst fears of many reasonable critical thinkers here about your activities, but you have even exceeded those and shown yourself to be much worse than that. Furthermore, you have alienated even those (such as myself) who are willing to entertain the notion that there may be some hazard from power lines etc., worth discussing further.

In short Roger, you have made the most monumental mess! You have brought the entire science of bioelectromagnetics into question and disrepute. It will take a long time in the minds of many to undo the damage you have done here. That is nothing to be proud of.
 
cogreslab said:
Rolfe said:

This is complete nonsense. It has been shown many times that magnets have absolutely no effect on blood flow and moreover are not capable of having any effect on blood flow.


To make that statement you need to produce supporting evidence. I likewise, to support my argument that it does.

Here are a couple of published studies supporting my argument:

GMITROV J
Static magnetic field effect on sinocarotid baroreceptors in humans.
Electro & Magnetobiology v15 i3 p183 p189 1996

OHKUBO C XU S
Acute effects of static magnetic fields on cutaneous microcirculation in rabbits.
In Vivo v11 i3 p221 p225 1997


Where are yours, Rolfe?

Here's a contribution from me, if it helps:

From: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=12403203&dopt=Abstract

Comparison of static and placebo magnets on resting forearm blood flow in young, healthy men.

Martel GF, Andrews SC, Roseboom CG.

Department of Physical Therapy, University of Maryland Eastern Shore, Princess Anne 21853, USA. [email protected]

CONCLUSION: Exposure to static magnets for up to 30 minutes had the same effect on resting forearm blood flow and vascular resistance as placebo magnets. These data suggest that static magnets do not result in significant alterations in resting blood flow.
 
To Pragmatist:

Your typical ranting tirade, embracing as usual a large number of unsupported value judgements isn't worth the paper it isn't written on.

Your alleged demolition of my scientific knowledge consists only of one quibbling argument about the timing of collapse of a radiowave, criticism of one experiment (now conceded to be methodologically correct) for not having been conducted in triplicate, and an over-frantic song and dance about a few typoes, used to allege that I know nothing about the subject.

Your completely wrong assertion about the nature of the electric and magnetic environment is denied not only by me but also by the WHO and even the NRPB, all of whom support my version of the situation.

You clearly have no experience or familiarity with the bioelectromagnetics literature, but need to resort to weblinks selectively biased and slanted by their creators. It is highly improbable that you have ever conducted any bioelectromagnerics research let alone published any. By contrast we have papers in several fully peer reviewed journals and I sit as referee on several others. Whether you like it, or respect the venerable institutions of which I am a member or not, my qualifications as listed were all genuine, despite insinuations on this thread to the contrary. The attempt to suggest I falsify my crdedentials has been completely disproved.

Nor do you attempt to familiarise yourself with the actual texts of the papers you cite, and this has led to retractions when the fuller text is quoted.

As for trying vigorously to brand me as a scaremonger, that is even more transparently without foundation, against a background where even government agencies express concern and ask for large research initiatives into the issue, and that children should actually be discouraged from use of cellphones (Stewart, 2000) and where IARC recently has categorised EMF as a carcinogen. A background where many other sophisticated countries (Sweden, China etc) have far lower PELs, and discourage the placement of powerlines or masts near schools, day care centres or homes. Are the attendees at this WHO meeting also scaremongers?

Regarding the issue of electric fields as the correct metric, it is known that circularly polarised magnetric fieds depress melatonin whereas elliptical or linear ones do not. This is a powerful biophysical argument for the importance of the electric component as a bioeffective metric, since the induced currents and current densities from circularly polarised magnetic fields are much higher (about 40 percent) than the other types. If you want I will set out the calculations, or you can find them in Kato, 1997.

As for your borrowed argument on the issue of induiced currents being far lower than endogenous fields, this was an argument for a while advanced by the utilities until squashed by the work of Gandhi at Utah, which you have probably never read. Your argument completely fails to explain how it is that a number of organisms have exquisite sensitivity to EMF at levels far below those you describe, eg the IR sensiticvity of moths which after some prevarication was finally accepted here, despite several attempts nto deny the truth of my statements.

You may be interested to know that in September we are organising a symposium at the RSM to address the increasing prevalence of electrical sensitivity in humans too, a problem which is leading to serious incapacity in some cases.

In short imho you are running scared, Pragmatist, which is why you now resort to vilification in place of the sober scientific arguments you pretend to espouse. If you cannot produce a scientific argument, at least mind your manners.
 
Mr. Coghill.

Wait a minute!!! A couple of weeks ago I posted a link from the Skeptical Inquirer about the effect of the magnets on the blood circulation. It was in the context of our discussion about the magnetic insoles you sell. There you admitted that we don't have enough proof so as we believe that the magnets actually work and the only argument you brought to me as to why I should buy your insoles is that they last longer. Right! Now you complain in such a manner about the references that Pragmatist posted.

BTW. Where are my magnets? Could you please make sure that Sue has sent my order before you leave for Instabul? Unless you plan to pass by Athens and deliver them yourself . :)
 
cogreslab said:
To Pragmatist:

Your typical ranting tirade, embracing as usual a large number of unsupported value judgements isn't worth the paper it isn't written on.

Your alleged demolition of my scientific knowledge consists only of one quibbling argument about the timing of collapse of a radiowave, criticism of one experiment (now conceded to be methodologically correct) for not having been conducted in triplicate, and an over-frantic song and dance about a few typoes, used to allege that I know nothing about the subject.

Your completely wrong assertion about the nature of the electric and magnetic environment is denied not only by me but also by the WHO and even the NRPB, all of whom support my version of the situation.

You clearly have no experience or familiarity with the bioelectromagnetics literature, but need to resort to weblinks selectively biased and slanted by their creators. It is highly improbable that you have ever conducted any bioelectromagnerics research let alone published any. By contrast we have papers in several fully peer reviewed journals and I sit as referee on several others. Whether you like it, or respect the venerable institutions of which I am a member or not, my qualifications as listed were all genuine, despite insinuations on this thread to the contrary. The attempt to suggest I falsify my crdedentials has been completely disproved.

Nor do you attempt to familiarise yourself with the actual texts of the papers you cite, and this has led to retractions when the fuller text is quoted.

As for trying vigorously to brand me as a scaremonger, that is even more transparently without foundation, against a background where even government agencies express concern and ask for large research initiatives into the issue, and that children should actually be discouraged from use of cellphones (Stewart, 2000) and where IARC recently has categorised EMF as a carcinogen. A background where many other sophisticated countries (Sweden, China etc) have far lower PELs, and discourage the placement of powerlines or masts near schools, day care centres or homes. Are the attendees at this WHO meeting also scaremongers?

Regarding the issue of electric fields as the correct metric, it is known that circularly polarised magnetric fieds depress melatonin whereas elliptical or linear ones do not. This is a powerful biophysical argument for the importance of the electric component as a bioeffective metric, since the induced currents and current densities from circularly polarised magnetic fields are much higher (about 40 percent) than the other types. If you want I will set out the calculations, or you can find them in Kato, 1997.

As for your borrowed argument on the issue of induiced currents being far lower than endogenous fields, this was an argument for a while advanced by the utilities until squashed by the work of Gandhi at Utah, which you have probably never read. Your argument completely fails to explain how it is that a number of organisms have exquisite sensitivity to EMF at levels far below those you describe, eg the IR sensiticvity of moths which after some prevarication was finally accepted here, despite several attempts nto deny the truth of my statements.

You may be interested to know that in September we are organising a symposium at the RSM to address the increasing prevalence of electrical sensitivity in humans too, a problem which is leading to serious incapacity in some cases.

In short imho you are running scared, Pragmatist, which is why you now resort to vilification in place of the sober scientific arguments you pretend to espouse. If you cannot produce a scientific argument, at least mind your manners.
Roger dodger,

I cannot imagine a more delusional post. You are bordering on certifiable here, dodger. You have consistently walked away from criticisms of your claims. You have dodged, deflected, and repeatedly presented absolute rubbish Your scientific gaffes have spanned from biology to physics to laboratory procedures. And yet, like a demented energizer bunny clearly off its meds and broken out of its funny coat with the arms that go backwards, you keep marching through this forum banging your tin pot and wearing your tin foil beanie.

You're a crank, sir, pure and simple. A bullsh!t artist who claims to test worms, but not animals, that bacteria are animals and who defends his morally outrageous infanticide challenge by claiming humans aren't mammals. You deign to excoriate real scientists for their discussion of the self-propogating nature of radio waves, are shown that you are wrong, and you simply adjust your tin beanie, check your batteries, and bang on.

You think you can do statistics on a sample size of 1. You nitwit. Post after post trying to explain to you the hilarious errors in your claimed laboratory research, and you conclude that you're doing it right and we all agree. And you want to return to your appeals to authority after that?

You're full of sh!t. You make claims you can't support and, when called on to support them, offer up papers that have nothing to do with your claims. Case in point: rising child leukemia rates. And you want to accuse others of not reading the citations after that?

Nearly fifty pages here, you bullsh!t artist, and you are still full of sh!t. Adjust your tin beanie all you want, bang your tin pot all you want, but how dare you accuse anybody here of not discussing the issues either scientifically or professionally when it is you who have used every trick in the book to try to cover for your morally bankrupt, vacuous, and intellectually bereft pap; your dimwitted acumen and absolutely impoverished understanding of basic science, laboratory procedures and statistical analysis.

Your willie's too small to actually engage in honest discussion with the big boys. You know it. We know it. All the ladies here have seen it, and have walked away, laughing. Your brain's too small as well. You know it. We know it. The world now knows it, you arrogant puke.
 
I'm changing the rules of this game, here, roger the dodger. I'm puking sick and tired of you and your bullsh!t. Any other skeptics equally fed up as I are welcome to join in.

Topic: Dysmenorrhea

"EFFECTS OF A STATIC MAGNETIC FIELD DEVICE ON MENSTRUAL PAIN:
A DOUBLE-BLIND, PLACEBO-CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL."

1. Was this "paper" ever published, roger dodger, except in ads?
2. If not, Why not?
3. If not, then why the hell did you release it for this ad?
 
Oh I read that in the site and I wanted to ask but I thought that Mr. Coghill would propose me to send me a magnet for free and check it on myself and I am kind of fed up with this tactic and I will repeat why.

I don't believe that magnets can make dysmennorrhea worse but such woo-woo devices train the general public to compromise with the less ( such as the placebo effect) and not expect science to understand first and then have answers for uncomfortable situations like dysmennorrhea.

The tragic is that people like Mr. Coghill are not satisfied by selling magnets for wine. They knock on the door of cancer patients and their families and this is what drives me crazy and also they do a great harm in undermining the trust of the general public in science.

Science doesn't claim that has all the answers how Mr. Coghill claims that? It remains a mystery to me.
 
You are a liar and a delusional lunatic Roger! But you're not going to get away with the lies on here. I'm going to address a few of your ridiculous claims. Let's start with this one:

cogreslab said:
As for trying vigorously to brand me as a scaremonger, that is even more transparently without foundation, against a background where even government agencies express concern and ask for large research initiatives into the issue, and that children should actually be discouraged from use of cellphones (Stewart, 2000) and where IARC recently has categorised EMF as a carcinogen. A background where many other sophisticated countries (Sweden, China etc) have far lower PELs, and discourage the placement of powerlines or masts near schools, day care centres or homes. Are the attendees at this WHO meeting also scaremongers?

Let's look at FACTS instead of your ravings. How about your claim that IARC has classified EMF as a carcinogen?

From: http://www.emfs.info/expert_IARC.asp

IARC

The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) is an agency of the World Health Organisation. Its Unit of Carcinogen Identification and Evaluation has, since 1972, periodically published Monographs which assess the evidence that various agents are carcinogenic and classify the agents accordingly. In June 2001, a Working Group met to consider static and extremely-low-frequency electric and magnetic fields. The key decision was to classify power-frequency magnetic fields as “possibly carcinogenic”.

The complete results have been published as Monograph number 80 and a summary of the key findings and classifications has been released by IARC. The following table assembles the various classifications into a single table.

Power-frequency magnetic fields were classified as “possibly carcinogenic” on the basis of
• “limited” evidence from humans concerning childhood leukaemia,
• “inadequate” evidence from humans concerning all other cancer types, and
• “inadequate” evidence from animals.

Power-frequency electric fields were judged “not classifiable” on the basis of “inadequate” evidence from both humans and animals.

These classifications are consistent with the conclusions reached by the NRPB’s
Advisory Group.

Many other agents have been placed by IARC in the same category of “possibly carcinogenic” see complete list

And here are few items from that list in the same category as power frequency magnetic fields (similar risk level):

Bracken (common fern plant)
Carbon Black (soot)
Styrene (plastic)
Trypan Blue :)
Coffee Drinking
Engine exhaust
Pickled Vegetables
Carpentry and Joinery
Dry Cleaning
Printing Processes
Textile Manufacturing


LIAR!
 
cogreslab said:
Your completely wrong assertion about the nature of the electric and magnetic environment is denied not only by me but also by the WHO and even the NRPB, all of whom support my version of the situation.

The WHO and the NRPB have not said ONE WORD about displacement fields. As far as I am aware they have also not said one word about Red Panda migration patterns. Your logic therefore is that Red Pandas don't exist!

A google search on "displacement current" gives this interesting little message:

Results 1 - 10 of about 10,100 for "displacement current". (0.58 seconds)

Give it up, your ignorance is showing again!

LIAR!
 
Is it just me, or does anyone else experience a fleeting moment of panic when Roger starts throwing out scientific terms?

It's like watching a four-year-old waving a loaded pistol.

Yikes.
 
cogreslab said:
Your alleged demolition of my scientific knowledge consists only of one quibbling argument about the timing of collapse of a radiowave, criticism of one experiment (now conceded to be methodologically correct) for not having been conducted in triplicate, and an over-frantic song and dance about a few typoes, used to allege that I know nothing about the subject.

Thank you for the confirmation that you are totally insane!

I posted about 40 demolitions of your alleged "scientific knowledge" some 20 odd pages back, and that doesn't include everything since. But don't worry, I'm sure Hans is keeping count.

NOT ONE PERSON on here has accepted the "methodology" of your ridiculous experiment. And not one person has "conceded" anything, in respect of that. Most of us have simply given up asking because you refuse to give sufficient detail to allow complete evaluation, but on the basis of the little that we've already seen, EVERYBODY can see that the whole thing is flawed to the core.

And, a few typoes? FEW TYPOES? How about dozens of utter contradictions?! Idiot!

LIAR!
 
Unsurprisingly birdbrain Bouncer has chirped in with a fresh load of pejoratives and a further attempt to change the goalposts!

I wonder if he realises that his concession that few other skeptics have dared to join this argument might indicate that there are very few who agree with him? In my case I have expressly asked that no others in my ken, not even my own staff, join this thread. If I had done so you guys would have been overwhelmed. This is my battle.

OK Bouncer, so you want to talk dysmennorhea. This study is about to be published so far as I know. It takes a while in the peer reviewed literature. But you wouldn't know about that because you've never tried it!
 
NOT ONE PERSON on here has accepted the "methodology" of your ridiculous experiment.

Re non adjacent squares:

Quote from another poser, sorry poster: "(I see you did that)".

Just one example.
 
cogreslab said:
Regarding the issue of electric fields as the correct metric, it is known that circularly polarised magnetric fieds depress melatonin whereas elliptical or linear ones do not. This is a powerful biophysical argument for the importance of the electric component as a bioeffective metric, since the induced currents and current densities from circularly polarised magnetic fields are much higher (about 40 percent) than the other types. If you want I will set out the calculations, or you can find them in Kato, 1997.

Keep digging, you just don't know when to stop and once again your phenomenal ignorance shines through!

You can't polarise a pure magnetic field idiot!

Maxwell's second equation: Div(B)=0

Of course that's way over your head, just like everything else on here.

Read your own statement above:

"issue of electric fields as the correct metric"
"polarised magnetric fieds"
"importance of the electric component"
"polarised magnetic fields are much higher"

Kato huh? Wasn't he Inspector Clouseau's manservant? Sounds about right. You make Clouseau look like a competent genius! :)
 
cogreslab said:
PJ said:

So what you do is use an ordinary incubator for maintaining the temperature of your samples. Air cooled (or heated) as you say. Isn't the incubator electrically powered ? Don't you find that the temperature is a lot less stable in an air incubator.? We use a comperterised continual monitoring system for loads of our incubators and fridges/freezers, the temperature is very unstable although it does maintain the correct average. This is due to the thermal properties of air (it don't hold onto the heat very well), so you get heating period followed by cooling period, so an up down temperature graph. This is why water baths are used, better thermal stability. Do you not see this as a problem ?

Yes at first we found a 1 deg C difference across the incubator space (using thermistors, not thyristors!) The heater unit in our incubator was at one side. But if we left it for some time the effect of the mu metal container was to even this out considerably and in the end we could obtain very close (c. 0.1 deg C) tolerance. With the Clarke electrode it was even worse: there was a 2 degree difference between the waterbath and the water jacketonly a foot away! Only by having abouit 4 matched thermistors logging at various points in the exposure system were we happy that we had the problem under ciontrol.

So you are getting thermal instability because you are using an incubator as opposed to a waterbath. Futhermore this incubator is electrically powered, but you said you don't use a waterbath beacuse of electrical field interference. ?

Perhaps you should re-examine your protocol and determine whether temperature fluctuations could account for any of the differences. With incubators whenever you open the door for whatever reason you loose heat. If all the boxes were in the same incubator, then thoose at the front (near the door) would be most affected by temperature fluctuation, or posibly those nr the heater.
 
cogreslab said:
Ground the water.

Good suggestion. We tried that with an earthwire from the bath going out of the lab into the ground outside and various variations on that theme. Surprisingly it didn't work, the fields were still high. Maybe a thicker earthwire, or some such? There was definitely no unbalanced ground return current.
Roger, educate yourself on how electical fields work. I can give you a private lesson if you like, I used to teach this for the Danish Delta institute at about 90£ per hour, but I'll teach you for free, if you cover my expenses.

If you ground the water system, you may very well measure unchanged or even increased fields around it, but inside it, they will disappear. Thickness of the ground wire is immaterial in this area.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom