Bioelectromagnetics

Hi Cleopatra: I know you may not believe this but in the UK the jazz club (in a local pub) closes at around eleven p.m., though I guess in Greece that is when it's cool enough to go out on the town: hence the relatively early start (around 7-30 to 8-00 pm).
 
Re water cooled incubators etc.

The Cambridge biochem lab uses a watercooled incubator inside of which they put a double skinned mu metal lidded container to house the cells. We found that all these water type systems (even domestic aquariums) give out very high electric fields. So we use an identical mu metal container (produced by the same supplier) but put it into an aircooled incubator and check the temp with thyristors feeding into a 64 channel data logger. We do the same with the respiration experiments and the Clarke electrode, though in that case there is no way out of using the glass envelope they supply, nor with the magnetic stirrer and motor underneath the chamber.

Anyone with a sensible solution to this problem re exposure to EMF with Clarke oxygen electrodes?
 
Rolfe (I think it was) said in a previous post: "What magnets will do, when you hang them round horses' legs, is keep them immobile quite effectively and so facilitate healing of minor lamenesses. Of course, any other way of stopping the horse using the leg too much will work just as well.

I am tempted to get sidetracked here. The effect of the static magnet on the horse's hoof is on the blood flow, where it improves the bioavailability of molecular oxygen, thereby aiding the healing process. In e.g. laminitis the redirected circulatory path has been responsible for the condition, by bypassing the lower end of the soft lamina. The static magnets improve this cuirculatiion and lead to relief if not to curative action. It is nothing to do with the leg wrapping.
 
cogreslab said:
Re water cooled incubators etc.

The Cambridge biochem lab uses a watercooled incubator inside of which they put a double skinned mu metal lidded container to house the cells. We found that all these water type systems (even domestic aquariums) give out very high electric fields. So we use an identical mu metal container (produced by the same supplier) but put it into an aircooled incubator and check the temp with thyristors feeding into a 64 channel data logger. We do the same with the respiration experiments and the Clarke electrode, though in that case there is no way out of using the glass envelope they supply, nor with the magnetic stirrer and motor underneath the chamber.

Anyone with a sensible solution to this problem re exposure to EMF with Clarke oxygen electrodes?

Nothing like clear english to explain yourself eh.

Ok never heard of a thyristor,

http://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/0,,sid9_gci778571,00.html

Thyristors are used in motor speed controls, light dimmers, pressure-control systems, and liquid-level regulators.

So what you do is use an ordinary incubator for maintaining the temperature of your samples. Air cooled (or heated) as you say. Isn't the incubator electrically powered ? Don't you find that the temperature is a lot less stable in an air incubator.? We use a comperterised continual monitoring system for loads of our incubators and fridges/freezers, the temperature is very unstable although it does maintain the correct average. This is due to the thermal properties of air (it don't hold onto the heat very well), so you get heating period followed by cooling period, so an up down temperature graph. This is why water baths are used, better thermal stability. Do you not see this as a problem ?
 
cogreslab said:
The effect of the static magnet on the horse's hoof is on the blood flow, where it improves the bioavailability of molecular oxygen, thereby aiding the healing process.
This is complete nonsense. It has been shown many times that magnets have absolutely no effect on blood flow and moreover are not capable of having any effect on blood flow.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
cogreslab said:
Re water cooled incubators etc.

The Cambridge biochem lab uses a watercooled incubator inside of which they put a double skinned mu metal lidded container to house the cells. We found that all these water type systems (even domestic aquariums) give out very high electric fields. So we use an identical mu metal container (produced by the same supplier) but put it into an aircooled incubator and check the temp with thyristors feeding into a 64 channel data logger. We do the same with the respiration experiments and the Clarke electrode, though in that case there is no way out of using the glass envelope they supply, nor with the magnetic stirrer and motor underneath the chamber.

Anyone with a sensible solution to this problem re exposure to EMF with Clarke oxygen electrodes?

Whoa!!!! THYRISTORS? You ARE kidding right? Are you saying that you have some kind of phase controlled heating system in this "EMF free" incubator?

For the benefit of the lay audience, a thyristor is a kind of electronic switch. But they are usually used in phase controlled systems. Phase control is a technique used in dimmer switches and some heat regulation systems. It involves switching a device on and off rapidly in sequence with the mains, but with part of the normal mains cycle cut off. The result of doing this in practice is a HUGE amount of electromagnetic NOISE!

The one thing you CAN guarantee about a thyristor phase control system is that it generates LOADS of high frequency EMF's! It's one of the "dirtiest" techniques around for radio noise. And Roger is using THIS to create an EMF "noise free" environment?

It gets ever more surreal!
 
cogreslab said:
To EHocking:

You said: "doesn't require me, surely, to point out that you have merely performed two "studies" on only two samples, does it? Even to a (medical) lay person it is obvious that these "studies" cannot convey "adequate statistical power".

I said our published studies, by which I meant the bedplace study and the endogenous fields study, both of which were peer review published, and not the Harmoniser experiments. Apologies for the lack of clarity here.
You know as well as I do we were discussing the harmoniser experiments, since we were discussing the relevance of n=1 studies, ie:
"Both our two published reports mentioned in this thread report on sufficient samples to give the studies adequate statistical power.
.....
As for this criticism about our two Harmoniser studies being an n=1 sample, "

As for the second experiment, do you have any intention of clarifying the data you provided in this report, or are you happy for me to review the report as it stands?
 
cogreslab said:
Wading past your immaculate rhetoric Bouncer, I cannot see for the life of me what you are driving at:

you say:

"One does sufficient basic counts so that the collection of counts is sufficient to calculate reasonable means and standard deviations".

after the count of any one hemacytometer sample we end up with two sets of ten numbers (each number is probably about 20-40 cells) one set is the viable cells and the other is the non viable cells. The ten numbers (viable cells) can give us SDs and sums and means for that condition, and totals say between 200 and 400 cells. The other ten numbers (non viable cells) give us the data we need to compare the two conditions. From this we can derive a viability percent of that sample. What's wrong with that?
Which part of this don't you understand, roger dodger? The basic count is not the count within one grid! The basic count is derived from repeated, collected together counts of the grids. One selects, lets say, to use 5 grids. The cell count in each grid is made. Sum those counts. Write it down. Do it again. Write it down. Do it again. Write that down. Now sum those three numbers and divide by 3. That mean is now the basic count. One basic count.
 
cogreslab said:
Originally posted by EHocking...(learn how to quote, Mr. Coghill)
A blood test on a patient to determine an illness/condition is HUGELY different to a series of experimental protocols to test an hypothesis. It is obvious you do not see this, but I cannot fathom that you do not know this as a "scientist".

At that time we were at the data collection/hypothesis forming stage rather than any further. The first test was to see if there was any effect at all, and the second was to see (inter alia) if any such effect also lasted after time and EMF exposure. The second Harmoniser results were not very strong, and I hope this message came over in our findings.
Actually, no, this did not come over in your finding since you state in the summary:

"The results showed that the protected cells enjoyed much higher post exposure viability compared with cells which do not have the benefit of the Harmoniser. Furthermore it did not seem to matter that the water in the Harmoniser had been imploded more than a year prior to the study, or that the Harmoniser had itself been previously exposed to ambient radiation. This study therefore confirmed the results of a previous study and leads us to conclude that the device lives up to its protective claims"

What part of the above quote, which is repeated on the CIR site as an endorsement, conveys the message that "The second Harmoniser results were not very strong.."?

Furthermore, the data is misrepresented at this statement, in my opinion, in order to give this positive result for your customer. Here is the table of data quoted with this statement (as an example of the deplorable reporting standards throughout this "study"

As an example, the very first table in the summary section at the start of the report states:


<TABLE border="1">
<TR><TH>Cell Numbers<TH>Viable (%)<TH>Non-Viable<TH>Total
<TR><TH>Protected by Harmoniser<TD>433 (72.8%)<TD>162<TD>595
<TR><TH>Mu metal shielded*<TD>384 (60.9%)<TD>246<TD>630
</TABLE>
*standardised to same vol. as protected cells

1. Why was it necessary to standardise the samples to the same volume?
2. HOW was this "standardisation performed?
3. Why do the numbers, for either category, not match those presented in "Table 1. Summarised results"

Here is the raw count as per Table 1.
<TABLE border="1">
<TR><TH>Cell Numbers<TH>Viable (%)<TH>Non-Viable<TH>Total
<TR><TH>Protected by Harmoniser<TD>500 (71.1%)<TD>203<TD>703
<TR><TH>Mu metal shielded*<TD>346 (71.2%)<TD>140<TD>486
</TABLE>
* (My annotation) As stated in the first line of the Discussion section:
"An examination of the four controls (1-4) suggests that the cells least perturbed, i.e. encased in triple skinned mu-metal..."

At this point I withold my judgement on the above in anticipation of you explaining the discrepancies between the results shown and your summation of same. Certainly 71.1% compared to 71.2% does NOT support your statement,
""The results showed that the protected cells enjoyed much higher post exposure viability compared with cells which do not have the benefit of the Harmoniser."

As I have said elsewhere, that we advertise this product at all is marginal to us, and of no impact on our activities.

While you may claim to have no financial interest in the sale of the product, you certainly should have an interest in your "studies" being used to advertise it,
http://www.implosionresearch.com/cir1/testimonials.pdf
"The Mobile Phone Personal Harmoniser has a significantly protective effect against exposure to electromagnetic fields and radiations from mobile phones."

It seemed to me that the reason for introducing the Harmoniser work was simply to brand me as a fraud, rather than as a researcher. Then later to criticise its methodology as typical of our published work.

You have yet to show us cause to think otherwise. Would you care to address the data misrepresentation in this second "experiment"?
The taske ohome message is that we do not reject anything simply because it seems counterintuitive, but giv these devices a fair trial in a scientific scenario where no one else is prepared to do so for fear of being branded a nutcase. We have no axe to grind either way re the Harmoniser or any other of the devices which pop up from time to time.
This is the point Mr.Coghill. Your studies are NOT fair trials. My criticism so far has been on the sloppiness in your reports which misrepresent and obfuscate the results of your studies.

The unfounded conclusions of which are then quoted as endorsments of products that what you have already admitted to be no better than talismans or placebos.

I await clarification of the data, before getting properly stuck in to this report.
 
This is acutely embarrasing! Here we have a 65 years old man who claims to have an academic education and who claims to run a research laboratory. And he needs to have explained the most basic things about stastistical evaluation of results.

Roger, either you are desperately trying to smokescreen the fact that you have been doing worthless research, or you are definitely unqualified to do research at all.


cogreslab said:
*snip*

The total population is the entire culture of millions of cells in this case. From this we take samples and expose them (or not) so we have several sample populations each still with thousands of cells. Each cell in this case a "cat", because they will either be blue or white (ginger or black/white) after the trypan dye is added.

No, Roger. ALL the cells within one sample (which has been exposed or not) are homogenous. If that sample is NOT homogenous, you have another problem, namely that the part of the sample you choose for counting may not be representative of the whole sample. So, to make ANY assumption at all on the sample, you must assume that it is homogenous. This means that any multiple counts and stastistics you do WITHIN that sample ONLY serve to improve the confidence of the counting operation, to get as precise count for that sample as possible. But you still end up with ONE figure for ONE sample. So each cell is no more a "cat" than each cell of a cat is a cat.

*snip*

This is what we did. There is nothing wrong with that approach, although it would have been nice to repeat the exercise three times.

Roger I will not insult you by assuming that you are stupid or ignorant enough to believe one word of the explanation you give. No, you are perfectly aware that it is nonsense, and you are simply hoping that you can put up enough smoke-screen to slip away.

It will not work.

You are a fraud. A pathethic fraud.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*
after the count of any one hemacytometer sample we end up with two sets of ten numbers (each number is probably about 20-40 cells) one set is the viable cells and the other is the non viable cells. The ten numbers (viable cells) can give us SDs and sums and means for that condition, and totals say between 200 and 400 cells. The other ten numbers (non viable cells) give us the data we need to compare the two conditions. From this we can derive a viability percent of that sample. What's wrong with that?
Nothing wrong with that. Nothing at all! You have arrived at a credible viability count FOR THAT SAMPLE. But you STILL HAVE ONLY ONE SAMPLE.

Duh!

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Ive just looked at the Baylor site, and find that is exactly the procedure we followed, except they forgot to say that you must leave the Trypan dye a set few minutes before the count, and most textbooks recommened a 20x objective, since the cells are rather too small to count with a x10 objective. It is important to mix the dye and leave it the same number of minutes each time, otherwise the solution is not comparable.
And it is important to have more than one sample :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
Another example of Roger's lack of knowledge for the collection. I'll soon have to ask you to slow down, Roger, or I'll NEVER make my deadline with Claus.


cogreslab said:
Re water cooled incubators etc.

The Cambridge biochem lab uses a watercooled incubator inside of which they put a double skinned mu metal lidded container to house the cells. We found that all these water type systems (even domestic aquariums) give out very high electric fields.

Give out fields? And what has EM qualities to do with the water part? Face it, you at some time measured a field around a domestic aquarium and now you think that applies to all water based systems :rolleyes:.

So we use an identical mu metal container (produced by the same supplier) but put it into an aircooled incubator and check the temp with thyristors feeding into a 64 channel data logger.

Thermistors, you idiot. Thermistors are the ones you measure temperature with. Thyristors are used for regulation curcuits. And what do you use a 64 channel logger for? With a homogenous temperature, what would you use 64 channels for? This is such nonsense that I have to suspect you are simply making it up.

We do the same with the respiration experiments and the Clarke electrode, though in that case there is no way out of using the glass envelope they supply, nor with the magnetic stirrer and motor underneath the chamber.

Yeah, the magnetic stirrer :roll:. That is a bit of a wrench in your works, ehh?

Anyone with a sensible solution to this problem re exposure to EMF with Clarke oxygen electrodes?

Ground the water.

You are just spouting fancy words. You don't know the first thing about what you are doing.

Hans
 
PJ said:

So what you do is use an ordinary incubator for maintaining the temperature of your samples. Air cooled (or heated) as you say. Isn't the incubator electrically powered ? Don't you find that the temperature is a lot less stable in an air incubator.? We use a comperterised continual monitoring system for loads of our incubators and fridges/freezers, the temperature is very unstable although it does maintain the correct average. This is due to the thermal properties of air (it don't hold onto the heat very well), so you get heating period followed by cooling period, so an up down temperature graph. This is why water baths are used, better thermal stability. Do you not see this as a problem ?

Yes at first we found a 1 deg C difference across the incubator space (using thermistors, not thyristors!) The heater unit in our incubator was at one side. But if we left it for some time the effect of the mu metal container was to even this out considerably and in the end we could obtain very close (c. 0.1 deg C) tolerance. With the Clarke electrode it was even worse: there was a 2 degree difference between the waterbath and the water jacketonly a foot away! Only by having abouit 4 matched thermistors logging at various points in the exposure system were we happy that we had the problem under ciontrol.
 
Mmokay, but what about the rest of the nonsense? What do you use a 64 channel data LOGGER for. Do you need 64 temperature points? Can you feed logger output into the temp regulation system? How does the regulation system function? (Thyristors, perhaps ;)?

Hans
 
No we use these 64 channel loggers to pick up other information around the experimental environment such as humidity and light intensity as well as ambient electric and magnetic fields. We may only use about six thermistors, and another 6 other feeds of various kinds. The Squirrel loggers dont give us more than about a dozen imputs, even though they are more benchtop friendly.
 
How do you measure ambient electrical fields without disturbing them?

Hans
 
Ground the water.

Good suggestion. We tried that with an earthwire from the bath going out of the lab into the ground outside and various variations on that theme. Surprisingly it didn't work, the fields were still high. Maybe a thicker earthwire, or some such? There was definitely no unbalanced ground return current.
 
How do you measure ambient electrical fields without disturbing them?

Most studies use a plexiglass stand holdiong the probe about a metre off the ground. Handhelds use the person holding them as an antenna, so that way be dragons! In the end one has to settle for the best one can achieve, but there is always an element of perturbation whatever you do. It's not easy: also the plates cannot be too far apart, say about 20 cm. If you go around any room there are sometimes quite startling and unexpected variatiions, due say to damp walls, lighting circuits from the floor below, even street lightn ing outside can change the electrical environment dramatically when they come on, as can white meter usage from appliances switching onto economy at midnight. We sure needed our 64 channel loggers (we have eight of these) to collect this kind of environment in (unpublished) tests inside homes. Alan Preece also did some work in this area which he published, being a great buddy of Bill Kaune, who is the king of this measurement area. (You wil see Bill's name pop up in nearly every major epi study).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom