Bioelectromagnetics

Yeah, it seems Roger is quite eager at grabbing the opportunity to change to a street fight. Not surprising, considering his merits so far at scientific debate. Pity his street fighting proficiency seems to be on par with his scientific skills :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
Prester John said:
Just coz i thought it was worth saving.
Yup. Hysterical.

Last I heard of it. Hans was an engineer working for a pharmaceutical company which makes (among other things) insulin. Maybe these magnets are a wonder cure for diabetes?

The depth of Roger's ignorance is abysmal. Piperazine really is a penny-cost chemical, and would be sold for a lot less than one of these fancy magnetic set-ups. But since all piperazine treats is roundworms, and there are much better anthelmintic preparations available these days, most bottles of the stuff are sitting gathering dust at the back of the pharmacy shelves.

Since when did we have the claim that magnets killed roundworms? And since when was piperazine the drug of choice for worming expensive racehorses anyway?

What magnets will do, when you hang them round horses' legs, is keep them immobile quite effectively and so facilitate healing of minor lamenesses. Of course, any other way of stopping the horse using the leg too much will work just as well.

This really is pathetic. Vets' business is looking after animals, in the round as it were. Charging for the actual therapy is only a part of it, and when it comes to drug therapy (as opposed to surgery), quite a small part really. If magnets had anything to offer, they would be incorporated into the therapeutic approach just like everything else. The peddlars of the magic magnets make plenty money from them, vets could do the same if they wanted to. In fact, to their shame, some do. But fortunately most of them prefer to deal ethically in things that are actually effective.

There's no conspiracy, Roger. At least, not unless you are the one conspiring.

The BVM(S) (who doesn't have a 4WD and doesn't want one - a 6 year old Peugeot 306 if anyone is interested).
 
cogreslab said:
Then along comes magnet therapy, and it is clearly helping animal health, especially with racehorses where there is a good deal of money at stake. Hans sees this as a threat to his little game: magnets don't cost much compared to piperazines, and what's more they last for a long time.

So Hans makes it his business to attack any magnetic therapy devices, becauase that way he can protect his own selfish interests. That is Hans, folks. Whether they are adjuvant to the health profession or for the public good or not is of no interest to him.

From someone who complains so much about "unsupported value judgements" we have yet another nice little blanket tirade against an entire profession. And not even the RIGHT profession at that! :)

Roger, you are concerned about EMF effects on the basis of a series of published papers which seem to indicate that they may cause damage to an organism. But what about published papers that seem to indicate that STATIC magnetic fields cause similar damage to an organism? FOr example, this one:

http://joh.med.uoeh-u.ac.jp/pdf/E43/E43_6_13.pdf

I note also that you didn't answer my question about why the ELF's caused by blood pulsing through a static magnetic field are somehow "beneficial" whilst all others are so harmful?
 
Effects of 10-T Static Magnetic Field on Human Peripheral Blood Immune Cells
Issn: 0033-7587 Journal: Radiation Research Volume: 159 Issue: 6 Pages: 775-779
Authors: Onodera, Hiroshi, Jin, Zhe, Chida, Susumu, Suzuki, Yasushi, Tago, Hideaki, Itoyama, Yasuto
DOI: 10.1043/0033-7587(2003)159<0775:EOTSMF>2.0.CO;2


ABSTRACT

Onodera, H., Jin, Z., Chida, S., Suzuki, Y., Tago, H. and Itoyama, Y. Effects of 10-T Static Magnetic Field on Human Peripheral Blood Immune Cells. Radiat. Res. 159, 775–779 (2003).

The exposure of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) was performed in a 10-T static magnetic field. Without lymphocyte stimulation, there were no significant differences in the viability of the exposed and unexposed CD4+ T cells, CD8+ T cells, B cells, and natural killer (NK) cells. The expression of Th1 type chemokine receptor, CXCR3, and Th2 type receptor, CCR3, was unaltered after magnetic-field exposure. No differences were observed in the naive T cells and memory T-cell subclasses in either CD4+ or CD8+ T cells. In contrast to the unstimulated condition, the magnetic-field exposure reduced the viability of phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-activated T cells in both the CD4+ and CD8+ subclasses. In particular, the number of PHA-treated naive CD8+ T cells (CD45RA+CD4–CD8+) was markedly decreased after the magnetic-field exposure, while PHA-treated memory CD8+ cells (CD45RA–CD4–CD8+) were resistant to the exposure. The number of PHA-treated naive CD4+ T cells (CD45RA+CD4+CD8–) and memory cells (CD45RA–CD4+CD8–) was markedly decreased to a similar degree. Thus the susceptibility of lymphocytes to the magnetic-field exposure differed among activated T-cell subtypes. The magnetic-field exposure significantly increased the death of PHA-stimulated lymphocytes by apoptosis. These results suggest that a strong static magnetic field has acute effects on immune cells during cell division, while the field exposure has a minimal effect on immune cells in a nondividing phase.
 
Melatonin and breast cancer: a prospective study.
Journal of the National Cancer Institute. 96(6):475-82, 2004 Mar 17
Travis RC. Allen DS. Fentiman IS. Key TJ.


RESULTS: No statistically significant differences in urinary 6-sulfatoxymelatonin concentrations were observed between women who developed breast cancer and control subjects among premenopausal or postmenopausal women (P=.8 and P=.9, respectively). When data from premenopausal and postmenopausal women were combined in a multivariable analysis adjusted for potential confounders and grouped into three categories defined by 6-sulfatoxymelatonin tertiles of control subjects, the level of 6-sulfatoxymelatonin excreted was not statistically significantly associated with the risk of breast cancer (odds ratio [OR] for breast cancer = 0.95, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.55 to 1.65, comparing the middle category with the lowest category of 6-sulfatoxymelatonin concentration, and OR = 0.99, 95% CI = 0.58 to 1.70, comparing the highest category with the lowest category).


Urinary 6-sulfatoxymelatonin is a validated marker for circulating melatonin levels.
 
From: http://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/52/23/6522

Induction of c-fos gene expression by exposure to a static magnetic field in HeLaS3 cells

M Hiraoka, J Miyakoshi, YP Li, B Shung, H Takebe and M Abe
Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, Kyoto University, Japan.


Effects of a static magnetic field on cell growth and c-fos oncogene expression were investigated. HeLaS3 cells exposed to the magnetic field of 0.18-0.2 T for 1-6 days were not affected in the cell growth. Exposure to the magnetic field did not enhance the effects of X-rays or heat treatment which caused the transient cell growth delay. c-fos mRNA in the HeLaS3 cells was undetectable in untreated cells, but the expression was induced in cells by the magnetic field exposure for 2-24 h. The amounts of the mRNA expression changed time dependently with a peak at a 6-h exposure. c-fos was expressed following the heat treatment at 45 degrees C for 10 and 15 min, and the expression was further enhanced by the treatment of cells with heating followed by 4 h of the magnetic field exposure. Exposure of the cells to a static magnetic field may affect some cellular metabolic events leading to the c-fos gene expression.

From: http://biomag.eng.fsu.edu/biomag2.html

The experimental results showed an increase in the erythrocyte osmotic fragility when exposed to 0.15 tesla magnetic field.

and......

Low osmotic resistance may lead to intravascular hemolysis, which may cause a reduction of the erythrocyte life span and hence lead to anemia (Oyewale et al., 1997) if not treated.


Just to prove that the citations game and cherry picking is a sport open to all! :)
 
The issue of single sampling in pilot cellular studies.

In published studies of effects on cells it is customary to present data with the average of three values +/- SDs. This is particularly important where the SD is large or the assay not frequently published. In cases where the assay is well known however, and the cell type of interest well characterised, it can be a more realistic presentation of the exposure to offer one sample (subject to certain caveats) than multiple data collected from one culture.

This is because the counting procedure inevitably takes time, during which period the cells are degrading or changing in some other way (e.g. under the influence of light cells can change size, not to mention the effects of other environmental EM fields over time, notoriously difficult to exclude from the experimental set-up), and therefore the results are being confounded. In the case of exposure to electric or magnetic fields there is now a wealth of literature and a large number of protocols available to guide study design. It is clear from this literature that multiple cultures are unlikely to add much precision to the results gained from a single sample. Obviously single sampling has the advantage of lower cost (e.g. one third of the cost of three values) and by limiting the risk of extraneous exposures an arguably more accurate portrayal of the effect under study, and is therefore most of use for pilot studies where a broad range of investigations are underway. Single sampling can also often assist in the design of larger studies, and avoid costly, redundant, or needless procedures.

As one example of this take Moisescu, Pologea-Mararu et al.,
Effects of low intensity pulsed electric fields on the endocytosis of cells in culture
Persented at EBEA by Carol Davila Lab. (Bucharest) jointly with CNRS, Institut Gustave-Roussy, Villejuif, Paris

This study investigated why the exposure of cells in culture to low intensity pulsed electric fields increases the fluid phase endocytitic rate. One of these factors could be the resting transmembrane difference of potential. With the aim of defining if the resting potential transmembrane voltage of the cells plays a role in the field induced acceleration of the endocytosis, the cells were exposed to pulsed electric fields in mediums with different pH and various ionic compositions.

In the resulting data every column presented the average of three values. However the SDs were extremely small compared with their absolute values, and with small variances (variance is in any case simply the square of the SD). In that study single sampling would have produced the same results, and served to establish that the effect of the electric pulses is not modified by inoculation medium pH range changes in the range of pH between 6 and 8.

Whereas studies designed for peer review publication are best likely to achieve publication with multiple values, studies carried out for internal pilot reasons and for impecunious clients canl provide initial answers to research questions and assist materially in the design of larger studies where the results are promising. In the case of the work on the Personal Harmoniser the cellular studies were only a small part of the client’s investigations, and for which funding was limited. It was clearly stated in the conclusions to this study that a) the in vitro results presented were no guarantee that the effect would be observed in vivo, and b) that a clinical trial would be necessary to establish efficacy. Though the client has other research results available to him it is not for us to disclose those, only some of which we are privy to.

Schorr and Karten (1966) documented all articles in three issues of eleven of the most read medical journals from an intense biostatistical viewpoint, and found that of 149 papers only 28 were judged acceptable on their criteria, and nearly all the remainder were in need of biostatistical revisions. Nevertheless the large majority of these papers still added usefully to knowledge of their scientific area of interest.

Method of Trypan blue exclusion test for viability is a well tried and tested method of evaluating cellular viability, and lends itself to simple descriptive statistical analysis, since the cells are categorised simply on a yes/no basis, in that the simplest data consists of unordered dichotomous observations (0-1 scale). Using a standard hemacytometer and standardised cell concentrations it is easy to replicate such studies. The ratio of target population to total population is also easily derivable. The three major sources of error in cell studies are biological, temporal and measurement error. To avoid biological variation only one subject must be in the exposure conditions used for such investigations. To avoid temporal variation the count must be completed in a reasonably short time. To avoid measurement error only one observer should carry out the count. Since different counters often qualitatively differ, and lack standardisation. The need to restrict the counter however itself imposes a fatigue restriction on the data collection.

With the trypan test the likelihood measurement error is low, since it is not difficult to distinguish blue from white in the squares of equal area and volume seen with low magnification in a hemacytometer. According to the concentration chosen, moreover, the number of cells within each square is also quite controllable, so that there are not a too large number present for counting. These are some of the reasons why trypan blue exclusion offers a robust method amenable to statistical analysis. It is an assay which our laboratory has used for a number of years, and hence are comfortable with a single count approach in cases where the client’s primary objective is at a clinical not an in vitro level. Because of this we are comfortable with the reproducibility of the observations, their normal distributions in exposed and unexposed conditions, and through our control of the ambient EM environment (e.g. use of triple skinned mu metal containers, sterile conditions such as vertical laminar flow hoods, and the ability to control temperature to within 0.1degree C), the low likelihood of unusual occurrences.
 
Top PJ: Re your quote, did you realise that a 10T static magnetic field is some 2 or 3 times the strength of the average MRI machine?

Yes with so many references in the literature it is easy to cherry pick, and the strength of argument needs to derive from an overview and argument based on a good understanding of the literature. This is reallyonly gained by:
a) keeping a large and uptodate library of the incoming relevant studies and over many years
b) attending (and unlike some, staying awake in*) the conferences relevant to the science of interest.
c) conversing in depth and by email with colleagues in the same field
d) reading the actual texts, not simply the abstracts or the media coverage with its attendant spin (there have been some awful errors in the press, sometimes maybe helped by obfuscatory PR), or website links.
e) trying out some of the claims in your own lab, just for the sake of it.
f) being very self critical
g) submitting your ideas to the rough treatment of this forum.

Being a biologist I am good at climbing cherry trees. But how many of the above do you do routinely


* don't worry Ben, your secret is safe with me!
 
Top PJ: Re your quote, did you realise that a 10T static magnetic field is some 2 or 3 times the strength of the average MRI machine?

Yes with so many references in the literature it is easy to cherry pick, and the strength of argument needs to derive from an overview and argument based on a good understanding of the literature. This is reallyonly gained by:
a) keeping a large and uptodate library of the incoming relevant studies and over many years
b) attending (and unlike some, staying awake in*) the conferences relevant to the science of interest.
c) conversing in depth and by email with colleagues in the same field
d) reading the actual texts, not simply the abstracts or the media coverage with its attendant spin (there have been some awful errors in the press, sometimes maybe helped by obfuscatory PR), or website links.
e) trying out some of the claims in your own lab, just for the sake of it.
f) being very self critical
g) submitting your ideas to the rough treatment of this forum.

Being a biologist I am good at climbing cherry trees. But how many of the above do you do routinely?


* don't worry Ben, your secret is safe with me!

sorry for the accidental repeat: it seems the software won't delete it as promised.
 
To cogreslab re you said:

Top PJ: Re your quote, did you realise that a 10T static magnetic field is some 2 or 3 times the strength of the average MRI machine?

Your attention to details is quite astounding, i'm off to join Hans in his Vetinary Surgery. :D
 
cogreslab said:


Both our two published reports mentioned in this thread report on sufficient samples to give the studies adequate statistical power.

I doesn't require me, surely, to point out that you have merely performed two "studies" on only two samples, does it? Even to a (medical) lay person it is obvious that these "studies" cannot convey "adequate statistical power".
I don't think you have demonstrated my "lack of knowledge in the field" at all demonstrably. On several occasions my facts when challenged have proved correct.

Still no comment on my review of your second "experiment" (others have already done the number on the first). I'm quite prepared to discuss your lack of ability to present your "experimental" data in a coherent report.
As for this criticism about our two Harmoniser studies being an n=1 sample, we blind-counted hundreds if not thousands of viable versus non-viable cells from one culture. Though it would have increased the statistical power to repeat the isolation and culture a number of times this was not within our gift. Many blood tests are based on one single culture isolate (maybe from a few BD vacutainers but still one drawing), and the patient does not have to give the sample three times on separate days.
A blood test on a patient to determine an illness/condition is HUGELY different to a series of experimental protocols to test an hypothesis. It is obvious you do not see this, but I cannot fathom that you do not know this as a "scientist"
 
Rolfe said:
Yup. Hysterical.

Last I heard of it. Hans was an engineer working for a pharmaceutical company which makes (among other things) insulin. Maybe these magnets are a wonder cure for diabetes?

The depth of Roger's ignorance is abysmal. Piperazine really is a penny-cost chemical, and would be sold for a lot less than one of these fancy magnetic set-ups. But since all piperazine treats is roundworms, and there are much better anthelmintic preparations available these days, most bottles of the stuff are sitting gathering dust at the back of the pharmacy shelves.

Since when did we have the claim that magnets killed roundworms? And since when was piperazine the drug of choice for worming expensive racehorses anyway?

What magnets will do, when you hang them round horses' legs, is keep them immobile quite effectively and so facilitate healing of minor lamenesses. Of course, any other way of stopping the horse using the leg too much will work just as well.

This really is pathetic. Vets' business is looking after animals, in the round as it were. Charging for the actual therapy is only a part of it, and when it comes to drug therapy (as opposed to surgery), quite a small part really. If magnets had anything to offer, they would be incorporated into the therapeutic approach just like everything else. The peddlars of the magic magnets make plenty money from them, vets could do the same if they wanted to. In fact, to their shame, some do. But fortunately most of them prefer to deal ethically in things that are actually effective.

There's no conspiracy, Roger. At least, not unless you are the one conspiring.

The BVM(S) (who doesn't have a 4WD and doesn't want one - a 6 year old Peugeot 306 if anyone is interested).

And if anyone else is interested I too have an R reg Peugeot 306.

Re the Polish stuidy, we would never use a water bath to control cell temp since it is usually electrically heated hence delivers high E-feilds to the samples and completely confounds the experiment.

There are quite a few studies indicating that static magnets help with sprains and aches in animals. The Norfield scintigraphy study on laminitis is quite a classic, though some have criticised its design. We don't do animal experiments (nor on infants either for that matter, though some would say otherwise) but we have occasionally worked under the supervision of vets, with remedial interventions at their request.
 
Piperazine really is a penny-cost chemical, and would be sold for a lot less than one of these fancy magnetic set-ups.

Damn! And I paid a small fortune for my panomec! (OK I know its ivermectin), but not much less for the piperazines, around ten quid a syringe if I remember, having now sold my three Welsh cobs.
 
To EHocking:

You said: "doesn't require me, surely, to point out that you have merely performed two "studies" on only two samples, does it? Even to a (medical) lay person it is obvious that these "studies" cannot convey "adequate statistical power".

I said our published studies, by which I meant the bedplace study and the endogenous fields study, both of which were peer review published, and not the Harmoniser experiments. Apologies for the lack of clarity here.
 
cogreslab said:
Top PJ: Re your quote, did you realise that a 10T static magnetic field is some 2 or 3 times the strength of the average MRI machine?

Yes with so many references in the literature it is easy to cherry pick, and the strength of argument needs to derive from an overview and argument based on a good understanding of the literature. This is reallyonly gained by:
a) keeping a large and uptodate library of the incoming relevant studies and over many years
b) attending (and unlike some, staying awake in*) the conferences relevant to the science of interest.
c) conversing in depth and by email with colleagues in the same field
d) reading the actual texts, not simply the abstracts or the media coverage with its attendant spin (there have been some awful errors in the press, sometimes maybe helped by obfuscatory PR), or website links.
e) trying out some of the claims in your own lab, just for the sake of it.
f) being very self critical
g) submitting your ideas to the rough treatment of this forum.

Being a biologist I am good at climbing cherry trees. But how many of the above do you do routinely?

* don't worry Ben, your secret is safe with me!

sorry for the accidental repeat: it seems the software won't delete it as promised.

Oh for God's sake! You want us to believe you are a meticulous scientist and you can't even address the correct person!

*I* am perfectly aware of how strong 10T is. So what about 7 mT?

a) Which obviously in your case doesn't include, actually reading, or comprehending the material.

b) Same as (a) except for listening and comprehending.

c) And clearly not understanding a word they are saying, unless they are all equally incompetent.

d) Is something you have demonstrated many times that you don't do.

e) Which is all very well if you actually understand what you are doing.

f) N/A - again something that doesn't apply to you.

g) Hallelujah! You scored one! :)

I don't do many of the above, garbage collectors don't find much need for it! But I am an expert in spotting garbage when I see it! :)
 
A blood test on a patient to determine an illness/condition is HUGELY different to a series of experimental protocols to test an hypothesis. It is obvious you do not see this, but I cannot fathom that you do not know this as a "scientist".

At that time we were at the data collection/hypothesis forming stage rather than any further. The first test was to see if there was any effect at all, and the second was to see (inter alia) if any such effect also lasted after time and EMF exposure. The second Harmoniser results were not very strong, and I hope this message came over in our findings. As I have said elsewhere, that we advertise this product at all is marginal to us, and of no impact on our activities.

It seemed to me that the reason for introducing the Harmoniser work was simply to brand me as a fraud, rather than as a researcher. Then later to criticise its methodology as typical of our published work. The taske ohome message is that we do not reject anything simply because it seems counterintuitive, but giv these devices a fair trial in a scientific scenario where no one else is prepared to do so for fear of being branded a nutcase. We have no axe to grind either way re the Harmoniser or any other of the devices which pop up from time to time.
 
Another feature of that 7mT Polish study I don't like was the way they pooled the bloods before isolation, thereby raising questions over the antagonism of the lymphocytes to non-self environments. They should have kept the samples separate.
 
cogreslab said:
Another feature of that 7mT Polish study I don't like was the way they pooled the bloods before isolation, thereby raising questions over the antagonism of the lymphocytes to non-self environments. They should have kept the samples separate.

You may have a point, not being a biologist, I wouldn't know personally. But I do note the following, "We did not find any statistically significant differences between unexposed lymphocytes incubated with medium alone and those incubated with iron ions". And all the lymphocytes were the same in all cases, it's just funny how only the ones with FeCl2 and mag field were significantly affected.
 
Cogreslab said:
Re the Polish stuidy, we would never use a water bath to control cell temp since it is usually electrically heated hence delivers high E-feilds to the samples and completely confounds the experiment.

Got my BS meter going, so how do you control cell temp then, maybe in an incubator? However they're electrical too, not that many gas powered incubators around. Of course a water bath provides better temperature stability than an incubator.
 
It has been troubling me that one poster was unable to afford to go sailing.
So here are Coghill's rules of how to afford/go sailing:

1. Never go sailing. In case you get smitten with the bug to repeat the experience (more likely you will puke more mightily than Bouncer's bird) get someone take a picture of yourself whilst puking up. (any handy skeptic will love to do that for you).

2. Never own your own boat. If you want to experience boat owenership, simply stand in a shower and tear up ten pound notes. Coghill's rule of boat ownership: the denomination of the note in this exercise equals 1.4 times the square root of the boat's length at the waterline.

3. Learn how to be a foredeck hand and practice knots and astronavigation (you can do this by doing astrological charts for your neighbours and friends: it doesn't mean much, but the spherical geometry of astro is astrology in reverse).
4. When invited, bring copious amounts of Gin and Tonic, and leave plenty behind after the trip.

5. Learn Morse code jargon: Alpha, Bravo and especially Whisky etc.

6. Bring a sharp knife and a bottle opener gadget. You will certainly need the latter, and probably also the former to cut yourself out of the rigging after a B2 knockdown.

7. Do not make passes at the skipper's wife.

8. Borrow a pair of yellow wellies from your local affluent vet (aka BVM).

Armed with these rules you should have a costless and longterm sailing experience. Off now to the jazz club in my R Reg. Good weekend to all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom