Negative studies?
(edited to distinguish my comments from the abstracts)
1. Electromagnetic Fields and Breast Cancer on Long Island: A Case-Control Study
Schoenfeld et al. Am. J. Epidemiol..2003; 158: 47-58.
Schoenfeld ER, O'Leary ES, Henderson K, Grimson R, Kabat GC, Ahnn S, Kaune WT, Gammon MD, Leske MC; EBCLIS Group.
Department of Preventive Medicine, School of Medicine, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, NY 11794-8036, USA.
[email protected]
The EMF and Breast Cancer on Long Island Study (EBCLIS) was a case-control study designed to evaluate the possible association between exposure to electromagnetic fields (EMFs) and breast cancer. Eligible women were participants in the population-based Long Island Breast Cancer Study Project, were under 75 years of age at enrollment, were residentially stable, and were identified between August 1, 1996, and June 20, 1997. Of those eligible, 576 cases and 585 controls participated in EBCLIS (87% and 83%, respectively). In-home data collection included various spot and 24-hour EMF measurements, ground-current magnetic field measurements, wire mapping of overhead power lines servicing the home, and an interview. Odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals were based on multivariate logistic regression analyses. All odds ratios were close to 1 and nonsignificant. For the highest quartile of 24-hour EMF measurements, the odds ratio was 0.97 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.69, 1.37) in the bedroom and 1.09 (95% CI: 0.78, 1.51) in the most lived-in room. For the highest exposure category of ground-current measurements, the odds ratio was 1.13 (95% CI: 0.88, 1.44) in the bedroom and 1.08 (95% CI: 0.85, 1.38) in the most lived-in room. These and other EBCLIS results agree with other recent reports of no association between breast cancer and residential EMF exposures.
Note on Study design: The researchers estimated the EMF exposure of 576 women with breast cancer and 585 women of the same age who had never been diagnosed with breast cancer. They made their estimates by measuring the levels of electromagnetic radiation in the women's homes and evaluating the electrical wiring outside the homes. They also interviewed the women to assess exposure to EMF at the workplace. All the women had been living at their Long Island homes for at least 15 years. The women ranged in age from 20 to 74, but most of them were older than 50.
So there were two confounders in this study:
First the women in this study were mainly more than 50 years old in the mid 1990s, whereas the link between EMF and breast cancer is with women of child bearing age (oestrogen positive receptor cancers), where inhibition of melatonin is implicated.
Secondly (once again) only the magnetic component was collected and this was via spot and 24 hour measurements, thereby diluting the nocturnal bedplace measurements. So this study, though negative in outcome, is not very useful because it omits the E-feid exposures and focuses on an age group least likely to suffer from melatonin inhibition. The ground current results even so (the only parameter where an electric field element is remotely likely) showed a slightly elevated incidence with ORs of 1.13 and 1.08.
2. Lancet. 1999 Dec 4;354(9194):1925-31.
Comment in: Lancet. 1999 Dec 4;354(9194):1918-9.
Exposure to power-frequency magnetic fields and the risk of childhood cancer. UK Childhood Cancer Study Investigators. (the UKCCCR magnetic fields study)
[No authors listed]
BACKGROUND: Previous studies have suggested an association between exposure to power-frequency electromagnetic fields (EMF) and the development of childhood malignant disease, especially leukaemia and tumours of the central nervous system. We investigated the relation between all childhood cancer and exposure to power-frequency magnetic fields. METHODS: The UK Childhood Cancer Study was a population case-control study covering the whole of England, Wales, and Scotland. All children with a confirmed malignant disorder were potentially eligible. For each case, we matched two controls on date of birth and sex, randomly chosen from the list of the Family Health Services Authority in England and Wales or Health Board in Scotland. In the main study, 3838 cases and 7629 controls were interviewed. The EMF part of the study included only one control per case, and household EMF measurements and school measurements where relevant were taken on 2226 matched pairs. These measurements, adjusted for historical line load and appliance fields, were used to estimate average exposure in the year before the date of diagnosis, or an equivalent date for controls. Analyses were by conditional logistic regression, incorporating a census-derived deprivation index used as a measure of socioeconomic status. FINDINGS: For children with mean exposures of more than 0.2 microT compared with children with mean exposures of less than 0-1 microT, the adjusted odds ratios were 0.92 (95% CI 0.47-1.79) for acute lymphoblastic leukaemia, 0.90 (0.49-1.63) for all leukaemia, 0.46 (0.11-1.86) for central-nervous-system tumours, 0.97 (0.46-2.05) for other malignant disease, and 0.87 (0.56-1.35) for all malignant disease combined. Higher exposures (>0.4 microT) were recorded for only 17 (<0.4%) individuals (eight cases, nine controls). INTERPRETATION: This study provides no evidence that exposure to magnetic fields associated with the electricity supply in the UK increases risks for childhood leukaemia, cancers of the central nervous system, or any other childhood cancer.
My comment: How curious that although ORs are cited for the mean exposures at or below 0.2uT, no ORs are reported in the abstract for the exposures above that, and one has to dig in the actual paper to find these. They turn out to be between 1.4 and 1.68, a clearly elevated incidence. This study did not address electric fields, but did show an elevated incidence where mean magnetic field exposure was 0.4uT. Therefore it is by no means an entirely negative study, and moreover one has to ask why only 17 cases in that bracket were recruited into the study.
3. Am J Epidemiol. 1999 May 1;149(9):831-42.
Erratum in: Am J Epidemiol. 1999 Jul 15;150(2):223.
Power-frequency electric and magnetic fields and risk of childhood leukemia in Canada.
McBride ML, Gallagher RP, Theriault G, Armstrong BG, Tamaro S, Spinelli JJ, Deadman JE, Fincham S, Robson D, Choi W.
Cancer Control Research Programme, British Columbia Cancer Agency, Vancouver, Canada.
In a case-control study of childhood leukemia in relation to exposure to power-frequency electric and magnetic fields (EMF), 399 children resident in five Canadian provinces who were diagnosed at ages 0-14 years between 1990 and 1994 (June 1995 in British Columbia and Quebec) were enrolled, along with 399 controls. Exposure assessment included 48-hour personal EMF measurement, wire coding and magnetic field measurements for subjects' residences from conception to diagnosis/reference date, and a 24-hour magnetic field bedroom measurement. Personal magnetic fields were not related to risk of leukemia (adjusted odds ratio (OR) = 0.95, p for trend = 0.73) or acute lymphatic leukemia (OR = 0.93, p for trend = 0.64). There were no clear associations with predicted magnetic field exposure 2 years before the diagnosis/reference date or over the subject's lifetime or with personal electric field exposure. A statistically nonsignificant elevated risk of acute lymphatic leukemia was observed with very high wiring configurations among residences of subjects 2 years before the diagnosis/reference date (OR = 1.72 compared with underground wiring, 95% confidence interval 0.54-5.45). These results provide little support for a relation between power-frequency EMF exposure and risk of childhood leukemia.
My comment: The point to notice here is that the results are based on personal magnetic fields as indicated from instruments worn on the body, and various period measurements of which 24 hours bedroom measurements were one data collection group. Thus these data were diluted, (unless of course the child spent day and night in the bedroom, which is highly unlikely. There was an elevated OR when wiring codes were assessed. Wiring code configurations (unlike the magnetic fields reported) do include the electric component. This study is not only positive in that regard, but it clearly flags the possibility of an E-field related elevation.