Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
Well, I've just waded through the posts overnight. Disappointingly they are mostly value judgements, with no scientific imput whatsoever.

Some of the illogicalities are amusing, however:

When I cite a reference it is construed as "an appeal to authority"
When anyone else does so it is a "citation" and commands respect. Where's the fairness and even handedness in that?
...
That'd be my post (try QUOTING PEOPLE Roger!)

My assessment of your appeal to authority was based on the fact that you seem to think the number of your "cites" conveys weight to your argument.

As has been demonstrated, if you had actually read the "cites" you quote, you would see that they do not support your position.
 
The JB experiment is entirely off topic, but do you mean to say that homeopathic preparations will not work if there is a cam-corder in the room??

I am not a homeopathist, so I have no idea even if these so called preparations work or not.

I was only referring to the effects on white blood cells (neutrophils in JBs case) of ELF EM fields. There I do believe that leucocytes are exquisitely sensitive to such fields at well below the "thermal levels", and respond to them, or are inhibited by them. I am not alone in this view.
 
Perhaps you can now state whether or not the outlier in your study was obtained from TV advertising


No, the outlier was not so obtained, but as I said only a very few, say three or four, were obtained that way. I have not performed the exercise but I would go further and say that even if these few cases were excluded the results would still be the same, and even if the outlier was excleuded the results would be the same. We did a subset of measurements taken at the actual pillow, (none of the advert recruits were thereby included) and that gave an 8 fold OR, but we did not publish this.

This was moreover, clearly indicated as a pilot study to see if any larger study might be worthwhile. That is why we continually ask for the reanalysis of the UKCCCR data, which covers far more cases.
 
cogreslab said:
"The whole thing was videoed, not specifically the envelope".

Interesting you should mention this. The moment I read it I went and took out my old Toshiba video camera and measured the ELF electric and magnetic fields around it. They were horrendously higher than ambient even a metre away. Then I learned that the visiting team had continually brought the video camera right upto the test tubes from day four onwards.

Ha Ha! Now you are asking me for the precise EMF environment in our study (as if I didn't know what it might be in our lab!).

JB was too naive to see what was going on there imho.

You really do talk some crap Roger!

Firstly I take it that you know for a fact that the investigating team used an old Toshiba video camera identical to yours?

Secondly, if these ALLEGED fields were such a big confounder then why didn't Benveniste object?

Why did Benveniste subsequently allow close filming of follow up experiments by other researchers? Even several years later?

And asking whether or not the box was grounded and how much of the wire was protruding etc., is hardly asking you for the precise EMF environment of your study!

But I am very glad to hear that you DID measure the precise EMF environment in such detail. Perhaps you would be kind enough to give us that information in addition to the questions I have asked, that will allow me to make a much fairer assessment. Thank you.
 
But, since all samples in JB's experiment were exposed to the infamous cam-corder, it should not skew the experiment in a serious way. If it had thrown the experiment totally off track, the results at large should have been significantly different from the earlier, non-videoed, experiments. None of the reports show this.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Did the use of a gold wire confound the study?

"and the gold wire itself accounts for at least 3 of those. There might even be a legitimate argument that the gold itself had an adverse effect on lymphocyte viability regardless of whether it was in contact with the culture or not. But I'll save that until I know more about the experiment".

Yes, this possibility occurred to us too. So we created a second control in our endogenous field study, where an identical culture had a short gold wire led through the cap and sealed in place so that no part of the gold wire protruded beyond the sealing gel.

The data from this control showed no elevation in viability, except in one run where it was clearly elevated. When we looked to see why, we found the gold wire had somehow poked through the sealing gel and was therefore exposing the cells inside.

So we do not think the results are only because of the gold wire or some related cvhemical reaction.
See my previous post on your second "experiment". Your reporting is confused, disorganised and therefore confounding to the reader. This "control" you describe here was not outlined in the Method and Materials, but introduced later in the discussion. You did the same with describing ALL the sample treatment in the second experiment and ALSO the introduction of the static magnet as an afterthought in the Discussion section.

Would you consider rewriting this report following (at least) high school level reporting methodology so that it can be read coherently by the reader.

The unprofessional manner in which these reports are presented do nothing to instil confidence for the reader in the conclusions you derive from poorly presented experimental material.
 
"You really do talk some crap Roger!

Firstly I take it that you know for a fact that the investigating team used an old Toshiba video camera identical to yours?

Secondly, if these ALLEGED fields were such a big confounder then why didn't Benveniste object?

Why did Benveniste subsequently allow close filming of follow up experiments by other researchers? Even several years later?"

No I don't talk crap: half this thread has been concerned with the impact of ELF EMF on cells and organic processes, and here is a good example where Nature has relied upon results confounded by their own action.

Yes I make the reasonable assumption given similar techniology that there would also be an EMF field close to other makes of video camera. - a reasonable, (not crappy) assumption!

JB didn't object because he was not well informed about the bioelectromagnetics literature (even though others like Maddox were) , but saw the work from a chemical viewpoint only.
 
Roger, you are making an unfounded assumption here. According to your theory, the camara might have distorted the experiment.

Mmmm, not much to discuss here anyway. I wonder if it is time to sum up, or do you want to address some of the points made earlier (including much earlier)?

Is there any part of Roger's edifice left standing?

Hans
 
If it had thrown the experiment totally off track, the results at large should have been significantly different from the earlier, non-videoed, experiments. None of the reports show this.

With respect, yes they do. See Nature 334: p288 (28 July 1988):

the para beginning "We witnessed a total of seven runs..." refers.
 
Labs tend to be stuffed full of electrical equipment. I wonder how much difference a video camera would make.
 
With respect, yes they do. See Nature 334: p288 (28 July 1988):
Nah. If you wanna discuss JB's experiment, start a thread for it, I'm not going to get drawn into a discussion about what constitutes a significant difference in his experiments.

How about addressing the topics at hand?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
.... the effects on white blood cells (neutrophils in JBs case) ....
No, Roger. They were basophils. That's the whole point. "Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE."

You know all about why the blinded experiment didn't work (and apparently not for the obvious reasons, according to you), but you haven't even sussed the very basics of the experiment.

Ooops, there goes Roger's credibility yet again.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
cogreslab said:
Negative findings:

"So why don't you publish the negative reports? Science is all about showing results, good and bad. If you only show the results that fit the hypothesis then that is definitely NOT science".

A number of reasons:

1. Journals don't often want to publish negative reports. This issue is often addressed in discussions elsewhere than here..
2. This is indeed useful information when developing some new device/technique, and of value to competitors (e.g. to avoid goiing down a blind alley).
3. It wastes peoples' time reading what doesn't happen, I suppose.
4. We do publish on our website at least one negative report, e.g. the studies trying to see if the south/north pole of a magnet makes any difference in its biological effects as some have claimed (it doesn't) in an effort to dispel some of the folklore of magnet therapy.

Missed this earlier.

1. You don't have to publish in journals. You publish the positive reports on your web site not in journals. The negatives should be right next to them.

2. The use of it is arguable! :) However, this is definately not science then. It's just a matter of crass commercial interest. And if you are truly an independent scientist interested solely in truth then how can you have "competitors"? This is a confirmation that you either have a direct commercial interest yourself, or that you have a specific commercial interest in promoting one device above another.

3. It saves people spending money on useless rubbish and being deceived - if you are right. So here is the confirmation that you don't really care if people are deceived.

4. Wow you published ONE negative report, hallelujah! But of course that negative just happens to also be in favour of your commercial claims.

Well, at least we have it confirmed that there is no attempt at any real science here and the whole thing is purely commercial.
 
cogreslab said:
Did the use of a gold wire confound the study?

"and the gold wire itself accounts for at least 3 of those. There might even be a legitimate argument that the gold itself had an adverse effect on lymphocyte viability regardless of whether it was in contact with the culture or not. But I'll save that until I know more about the experiment".

Yes, this possibility occurred to us too. So we created a second control in our endogenous field study, where an identical culture had a short gold wire led through the cap and sealed in place so that no part of the gold wire protruded beyond the sealing gel.

The data from this control showed no elevation in viability, except in one run where it was clearly elevated. When we looked to see why, we found the gold wire had somehow poked through the sealing gel and was therefore exposing the cells inside.

So we do not think the results are only because of the gold wire or some related cvhemical reaction.

Since you maintain that the wire is the source of a field, then how did the sealing gel block this field?

What happened when you used different wires? For example did you use carbon electrodes?
 
EHocking said:
Others have addressed these points so I'll leave that

Then you are not paying attention to the discussion here. I am currently attempting to untangle your second report on the Harmoniser. It is, besides being disorganised, full of errors. The following is merely a cursory observation of the most glaring.
Method and Materials
There is no numbering of the samples in the Method and Materials section, because of this it is difficult to correlate the study A, B and C to the samples 1 through 12. In addition to this confusion, there is direct contradiction between the samples described in this section with the tabulated data and further in the Discussion section. This would appear to be due to ommission of precision in this section and later introduction of "detail" in the Discussion section.
Tabulated data
1. The first (unnumbered) totals table in the Summary section does not equal the summarised results in Table 1. This confusion is exacerbated by the rewording of the sample sets and indeed does not relate to the description of the samples given in Method and Materials, nor in the Discussion.
2. Table 1 in turn does not correlate to the first table in the Method and Materials section that purports to summarise the samples described in that section and further introduces a sample description that is not even mentioned in Meth&Mat
3. Table 2. There was absolutely no description of Meth&Mat for describing the process whereby this data was obtained. Also, the Harmoniser used (from the title) was NOT the same as described for the previous sample. Sample titles are worded differently than the preceding table so positive identification of the sample is difficult.
4. Table 3 does not reflect the results of Table 1. You may think it is pedantic that the difference is only 3 (in favor of viable), but it is an example of the sloppiness inherent throughout this report.
5. Table 4. Not one of the sample results from Table 1 are correctly listed here. So much so, that the 1 "energised" sample in section A is listed as "unenergised" in T1 and the 2 "non-energised" samples in B correlate to 2 "energised" samples in T1.
Oh, forgot:
6. Table 5. Last two samples noted as VDU exposed. From Table one and the Method and Materials section, these we samples 4 and 3, respectively, controls that were set next to VDUs that were not turned on.

Your conclusion here is totally wrong.

Discussions
As above, the discussion details either do not correspond to those in the Method and Materials section. This section then introduces descriptions of samples and treatment that are not even mentioned in the Method section NOR the Tabulated data.
Conclusions
Besides being mealy-mouthed and ignoring most of the results, presented anyway, are based on results that have been incorrectly summarised and do not reflect the experiment as run.

As I said, this is merely a first pass - is it worth my while to get into the detail, or do you perhaps have a redraft of this "report" that accurately represents the experiment conducted?
 
cogreslab said:
For each group (e.g. the exposed culture) we counted ten separate squares in the hemacytometer. In each we identified the viable and the non-viable. That gave us twenty separate figures. From this it is possible to derive SDs, means, and sums, for the viable and the non viable cells ie. the data needed to test for significance within that group.
You know, words just fail me. Which doesn't happen often, I can assure you.

Ten haemocytometer squares!!! As I said, one normally counts four or five non-congruent squares (depending on the type of cell being counted) per sample. That is ONE sample. ONE result. You check that the variation between the squares is no more than 10%, if it is more than that the haemocytometer chamber hasn't filled uniformly and you have to clean it and fill it again. Then you use the sum of the four (or five) squares to derive your ONE result.

So Roger counted ten squares. For a single sample. That's sort of equivalent to measuring the same sample twice, just to check you were right the first time. Good idea, it's called precision-checking, but you don't then claim to have data points you can do statistics on! The lack of understanding embodied in this protocol is just so breathtaking I stand in awe.

To use Hans' neat analogy of the two cats, a 2.5 kg black-and-white, and a 6 kg tabby. This is as if you weighed each cat 10 times, did mean and SD calculations on the results, and then announced solemnly that you'd just proved statistically that tabby cats are heavier than black-and-white cats.

(Except it's worse than that, because a single haemocytometer square isn't even a measurement, it's only one-fifth of a measurement.)

Hans, there's only one problem. Garfield was a marmalade cat.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
Rolfe said:
You know, words just fail me. Which doesn't happen often, I can assure you.

Ten haemocytometer squares!!! As I said, one normally counts four or five non-congruent squares (depending on the type of cell being counted) per sample. That is ONE sample. ONE result. You check that the variation between the squares is no more than 10%, if it is more than that the haemocytometer chamber hasn't filled uniformly and you have to clean it and fill it again. Then you use the sum of the four (or five) squares to derive your ONE result.

So Roger counted ten squares. For a single sample. That's sort of equivalent to measuring the same sample twice, just to check you were right the first time. Good idea, it's called precision-checking, but you don't then claim to have data points you can do statistics on! The lack of understanding embodied in this protocol is just so breathtaking I stand in awe.

" A total of 300 - 400 cells should be counted, since the counting error is approximated by the square root of the total count. "

Baylor College of Medicine Laboratory procedure
 
Pragmatist said:
It may be highly improbable that any molecules of the substance remain, but nobody can say that NO molecules of the substance remain.
Sorry, I know this isn't really the point, but I just wanted to comment on this one quickly. It's the mind-boggling enormity of the dilutions that makes it possible to say that, to any reasonable definition of "NO". Because of the small volumes used to actually prepare the dilutions, one tends not to appreciate just how far this exponential x 100 diluting actually gets you. The often-used 30C (which some still describe only as intermediate potency, because much larger dilutions aren't uncommon) is something like one molecule in a container several times the size of the Earth.

It's difficult to get a precise take on this because the homoeopathic mother tinctures aren't usually pure solutions in the first place (mashed-up weeds and things like that), and the initial concentration isn't specified. However, if you express it as the probability that any one 5 ml sample of the final dilution will have a single molecule in it, well, it's a lot worse than the odds of winning the lottery. So, "NO molecules", except for one in several squillion bottles which will have one molecule? A bit hair-splitting here, aren't we?

Unless of course you take into account that odd solute clumping effect reported in some very dilute solutions (which I have to say I have never observed in my laboratory). In that case, some bottles may have a handful of molecules - but the chance of getting such a bottle is correspondingly even remoter.

We were discussing this in another thread, when a homoeopathic apologist had said, look, if you put a kilo of sugar into the sea, of course it's still there. BSM worked out that at that dilution factor, there would be one molecule in a 10 ml sample of sea water, assuming uniform mixing and no disappearing of the sugar. WAY more concentrated than homoeopathic dilutions. If you put that kilo of sugar into a container of water 1,000,000 times that volume, what would your chances be of getting even one molecule back in a 10 ml sample? That's what we're dealing with here. Only more so.

Also, thinking about how little substance that really is, I had to conclude that there would be no practical way to measure that 1 molecule per 10 ml, the sensitivity of the assays just won't cut it to any reasonable amount of evaporation and concentrating of the samples. So, practically speaking, I don't have a problem with "no molecules".

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
BillHoyt said:
" A total of 300 - 400 cells should be counted, since the counting error is approximated by the square root of the total count. "

Baylor College of Medicine Laboratory procedure
I think in practice we're not as stringent as that for what is usually a side-room estimation primarily concerned with finding out whether the patient is reasonably normal or anything but normal.

However, Roger's approach is simply stunning! Not only do we not count all that many cells, we use the way the grid is laid out to derive totally meaningless statistics to bamboozle the unwary magnetophile. I have to admit, I'm impressed.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
Rolfe said:
No, Roger. They were basophils. That's the whole point. "Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE."

You know all about why the blinded experiment didn't work (and apparently not for the obvious reasons, according to you), but you haven't even sussed the very basics of the experiment.



The Blessed Virgin Mary.

Sorry, Rolfe! Of course I meant basophils (and I actually had the Nature paper in my hand at the time!).

But I agree. I don't want to go into all that old stuff just now, but would rather keep on topic and pick up on the three epi studies being regarded as negative (the links were pointed to in a recent post) and though tonight is difficult, I wish to make some points about those in detail, since all of three of them need closer scrutiny.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom