Pragmatist said:
It may be highly improbable that any molecules of the substance remain, but nobody can say that NO molecules of the substance remain.
Sorry, I know this isn't really the point, but I just wanted to comment on this one quickly. It's the mind-boggling enormity of the dilutions that makes it possible to say that, to any reasonable definition of "NO". Because of the small volumes used to actually prepare the dilutions, one tends not to appreciate just how far this exponential x 100 diluting actually gets you. The often-used 30C (which some still describe only as intermediate potency, because much larger dilutions aren't uncommon) is something like one molecule in a container several times the size of the Earth.
It's difficult to get a precise take on this because the homoeopathic mother tinctures aren't usually pure solutions in the first place (mashed-up weeds and things like that), and the initial concentration isn't specified. However, if you express it as the probability that any one 5 ml sample of the final dilution will have a single molecule in it, well, it's a lot worse than the odds of winning the lottery. So, "NO molecules", except for one in several
squillion bottles which will have
one molecule? A bit hair-splitting here, aren't we?
Unless of course you take into account that odd solute clumping effect reported in some very dilute solutions (which I have to say I have never observed in my laboratory). In that case, some bottles may have a handful of molecules - but the chance of getting such a bottle is correspondingly even remoter.
We were discussing this in another thread, when a homoeopathic apologist had said, look, if you put a kilo of sugar into the sea, of course it's still there. BSM worked out that at that dilution factor, there would be one molecule in a 10 ml sample of sea water, assuming uniform mixing and no disappearing of the sugar. WAY more concentrated than homoeopathic dilutions. If you put that kilo of sugar into a container of water 1,000,000 times that volume, what would your chances be of getting even one molecule back in a 10 ml sample? That's what we're dealing with here. Only more so.
Also, thinking about how little substance that really is, I had to conclude that there would be no practical way to measure that 1 molecule per 10 ml, the sensitivity of the assays just won't cut it to any reasonable amount of evaporation and concentrating of the samples. So, practically speaking, I don't have a problem with "no molecules".
The Blessed Virgin Mary.