Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:


This would apply to every epi study ever conducted ion childhood leukemia: are you going then to dismiss them all?

Not true, epidemiological studies tend to look at addresses and nearness to whatever they are investigating. They don't go into houses and measure fields like you did. The advantage of the epdimeiological study is size.

"Quantity has a Quality all of its own."

:p
 
cogreslab said:
"You are comparing yourself with Newton and Faraday"

Only in the sense that these men carried out experiments at their own cost thorugh curiousity, and I suggested that this seems to be something of an English tradition, e.g. Peter Mitchell (the chemiosmosis hypthesis).

Can't you get ANYTHING right Roger?!

Michael Faraday did not do his experiments at his own cost. He was funded largely by the Royal Institution and also by gifts from Sir Humphrey Davey, and other influential backers, right down to his first employer, who was a bookbinder!

Sheesh! You truly ARE ignorant!
 
MRC_Hans said:
About the advertising bit: Sure! I read the report before I criticised it (I usually do), and the reason I mentioned advertizing was that it was in the report. That Roger later has a different explanation is, unfortunately, not unique. In the Harmonizer report, he also suddenly remembered that temperature and humidity had been under control, when that point was brought up.

Sorry, I was under the impression that you'd been looking at a different document to the one I quoted. No matter, it just once again highlights Roger's lack of concern for the truth.
 
To EHocking:
You said: I am endeavouring to put together a coherent summary of all the errors and inconsistencies in his report and present it here for critique.

That's fine by me. I welcome any serious critical comments on our work. That's how science should work. We don't expect an easy time coming to this forum!
 
cogreslab said:


This would apply to every epi study ever conducted ion childhood leukemia: are you going then to dismiss them all?
Why would it apply to them? First of all, many of the studies I have seen do not include in situ measurements at all, they simply compare disease incidence in areas with calculated high levels to control areas. Secondly, as you are so fond of pointing out, most if not all studies measure magnetic fields, which are much simpler to measure with good confidence.

Hans
 
Pragmatist said:


Can't you get ANYTHING right Roger?!

Michael Faraday did not do his experiments at his own cost. He was funded largely by the Royal Institution and also by gifts from Sir Humphrey Davey, and other influential backers, right down to his first employer, who was a bookbinder!

Sheesh! You truly ARE ignorant!

Faraday was born at Newington, Surrey, near London. He received little more than a primary education, and at the age of 14 he was apprenticed to a bookbinder. There he became interested in the physical and chemical works of the time. After hearing a lecture by the famous chemist Humphry Davy, he sent Davy the notes he had made of his lectures. As a result Faraday was appointed, at the age of 21, assistant to Davy in the laboratory of the Royal Institution in London.

In other words for seven years he supported his own researches.
Edited by LuxFerum: 
To add the link to the original article:
http://www.phy.hr/~dpaar/fizicari/xfaraday.html
 
cogreslab said:
Regarding the persistent strength of the association, you are virtually alone in denying this.
Am I ?

The studies I referenced yesterday were officially undecided. Remember:
``The magnetic component of EMFs has been under suspicion for some time, but this major study provides firm evidence that exposure to the levels of magnetic fields found in the UK does not augment risk for childhood disease,'' said Richard Doll, the chairman of the UK Childhood Cancer Study
. I asked Sir Richard personally at an NRPB meeting to do this for the reasons already stated. He declined to respond to my criticisms at the time, and passed the question to another person present to answer.
Well at least he isn't as rude as we are when the brush-off is required eh ?
 
cogreslab said:
To EHocking:
You said: I am endeavouring to put together a coherent summary of all the errors and inconsistencies in his report and present it here for critique.

That's fine by me. I welcome any serious critical comments on our work. That's how science should work. We don't expect an easy time coming to this forum!

If that is the case then why won't you give us sufficient information to assess the electromagnetic conditions of the experiment? I have asked many questions, some as far back as 20 pages of responses ago - I'm still waiting for an answer.
 
Did the use of a gold wire confound the study?

"and the gold wire itself accounts for at least 3 of those. There might even be a legitimate argument that the gold itself had an adverse effect on lymphocyte viability regardless of whether it was in contact with the culture or not. But I'll save that until I know more about the experiment".

Yes, this possibility occurred to us too. So we created a second control in our endogenous field study, where an identical culture had a short gold wire led through the cap and sealed in place so that no part of the gold wire protruded beyond the sealing gel.

The data from this control showed no elevation in viability, except in one run where it was clearly elevated. When we looked to see why, we found the gold wire had somehow poked through the sealing gel and was therefore exposing the cells inside.

So we do not think the results are only because of the gold wire or some related cvhemical reaction.
 
To PJ:

In the EMF epi studies several do exactly that, i.e. go into homes and measure various rooms (e.g. the UKCCCR study, Savits Wachtel, 1988, the Southern Californian study, etc.) One study (Tomenius, 1982 and 1986) couldn't go into the homes so he measured the fields strengths on the door steps, and still found a positive association. Please familiarise yourself with this literature before that sort of ignorant comment.
 
The Don said:

Am I ?

The studies I referenced yesterday were officially undecided. Remember:


Well at least he isn't as rude as we are when the brush-off is required eh ?

Actually he was quite rude: in an effort to deflect the question he asked if perhaps i would care to describe the shortcomings in our own study, which I proceeded to do.
 
"this major study provides firm evidence that exposure to the levels of magnetic fields found in the UK does not augment risk for childhood disease,'' said Richard Doll, the chairman of the UK Childhood Cancer Study".

Carefully chosen words. Notice he does not say "EMF" or include the electric component, as the media and the utilities would have him do.
 
cogreslab said:
Actually he was quite rude: in an effort to deflect the question he asked if perhaps i would care to describe the shortcomings in our own study, which I proceeded to do.
Well in which case, don't make it sound like you had a chummy conversation at the end of which he got a minion to sort things out on your behalf
. I asked Sir Richard personally at an NRPB meeting to do this for the reasons already stated. He declined to respond to my criticisms at the time, and passed the question to another person present to answer.
 
"The whole thing was videoed, not specifically the envelope".

Interesting you should mention this. The moment I read it I went and took out my old Toshiba video camera and measured the ELF electric and magnetic fields around it. They were horrendously higher than ambient even a metre away. Then I learned that the visiting team had continually brought the video camera right upto the test tubes from day four onwards.

Ha Ha! Now you are asking me for the precise EMF environment in our study (as if I didn't know what it might be in our lab!).

JB was too naive to see what was going on there imho.
 
If that is the case then why won't you give us sufficient information to assess the electromagnetic conditions of the experiment? I have asked many questions, some as far back as 20 pages of responses ago - I'm still waiting for an answer.

Now you have finally condemned the high dilution experiments out of your own mouth as being flawed though deliberate exposure to ELF EM fields by the investigating team, I will shortly give you the data you asked about.
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*
Now you have finally condemned the high dilution experiments out of your own mouth as being flawed though deliberate exposure to ELF EM fields by the investigating team, I will shortly give you the data you asked about.
The JB experiment is entirely off topic, but do you mean to say that homeopathic preparations will not work if there is a cam-corder in the room?? :roll:

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
There's been quite a lot of overnight comment on this Harmoniser thing, so let me here put down our conclusions re the first study for readers:*snip*

Others have addressed these points so I'll leave that
Having conceded these problems, I am pleased to see that our culture preparation protocols, method and use of blind counting, and statistical analyses of the captured data are not in contention.
Then you are not paying attention to the discussion here. I am currently attempting to untangle your second report on the Harmoniser. It is, besides being disorganised, full of errors. The following is merely a cursory observation of the most glaring.
Method and Materials
There is no numbering of the samples in the Method and Materials section, because of this it is difficult to correlate the study A, B and C to the samples 1 through 12. In addition to this confusion, there is direct contradiction between the samples described in this section with the tabulated data and further in the Discussion section. This would appear to be due to ommission of precision in this section and later introduction of "detail" in the Discussion section.
Tabulated data
1. The first (unnumbered) totals table in the Summary section does not equal the summarised results in Table 1. This confusion is exacerbated by the rewording of the sample sets and indeed does not relate to the description of the samples given in Method and Materials, nor in the Discussion.
2. Table 1 in turn does not correlate to the first table in the Method and Materials section that purports to summarise the samples described in that section and further introduces a sample description that is not even mentioned in Meth&Mat
3. Table 2. There was absolutely no description of Meth&Mat for describing the process whereby this data was obtained. Also, the Harmoniser used (from the title) was NOT the same as described for the previous sample. Sample titles are worded differently than the preceding table so positive identification of the sample is difficult.
4. Table 3 does not reflect the results of Table 1. You may think it is pedantic that the difference is only 3 (in favor of viable), but it is an example of the sloppiness inherent throughout this report.
5. Table 4. Not one of the sample results from Table 1 are correctly listed here. So much so, that the 1 "energised" sample in section A is listed as "unenergised" in T1 and the 2 "non-energised" samples in B correlate to 2 "energised" samples in T1.
Discussions
As above, the discussion details either do not correspond to those in the Method and Materials section. This section then introduces descriptions of samples and treatment that are not even mentioned in the Method section NOR the Tabulated data.
Conclusions
Besides being mealy-mouthed and ignoring most of the results, presented anyway, are based on results that have been incorrectly summarised and do not reflect the experiment as run.

As I said, this is merely a first pass - is it worth my while to get into the detail, or do you perhaps have a redraft of this "report" that accurately represents the experiment conducted?
 
cogreslab said:


Faraday was born at Newington, Surrey, near London. He received little more than a primary education, and at the age of 14 he was apprenticed to a bookbinder. There he became interested in the physical and chemical works of the time. After hearing a lecture by the famous chemist Humphry Davy, he sent Davy the notes he had made of his lectures. As a result Faraday was appointed, at the age of 21, assistant to Davy in the laboratory of the Royal Institution in London.

In other words for seven years he supported his own researches.

Firstly I remind you that you said EXPERIMENTS, not RESEARCHES.

Faraday's main experiments commenced once he had full access to the Royal Institution laboratory. Prior to that he was largely confined to LEARNING from books and public lectures. Faraday was very poor. So poor he couldn't afford the books OR the lectures. It was George Riebau the bookbinder who let him read the books brought in for binding, and "Mr Dance" who gave him the ticket to Davy's lecture. Prior to that it was Riebau who gave him a few spare pennies so he could attend John Tatum's lectures. And it was Riebau who set up a room at the back of his shop for Faraday to experiment in and contributed to Faraday's initial learning experiments.

In 1812, Faraday wrote to Sir Joseph Banks begging him for a job, ANY job, at the Royal Institution in order to have the opportunity to learn, work and perform experiments in science. Precisely because he did NOT have the resources to follow a scientific career on his own. Banks turned him down.

It's quite probable that Faraday put some of his own money into his early learning experiments. But he received substantial support from Riebau and others, and none of these early experiments were of any note compared to his later work once he had access to the Royal Institution.
 
cogreslab said:
To PJ:

In the EMF epi studies several do exactly that, i.e. go into homes and measure various rooms (e.g. the UKCCCR study, Savits Wachtel, 1988, the Southern Californian study, etc.) One study (Tomenius, 1982 and 1986) couldn't go into the homes so he measured the fields strengths on the door steps, and still found a positive association. Please familiarise yourself with this literature before that sort of ignorant comment.

I made an extrpolation from the WCISU work which was wrong. Remark withdrawn.

For example all of these negative studies measured EMF levels:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=12835286

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=10622294

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=10221320


Perhaps you can now state whether or not the outlier in your study was obtained from TV advertising.
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*

Ha Ha! Now you are asking me for the precise EMF environment in our study (as if I didn't know what it might be in our lab!).

Yes, that might be interesting. And in general, your reports are very hazy on eletromagnetic data. I think I know the reason, but it is very unfortunate, since electromagnetics are sorta pivotal in yout theories.

JB was too naive to see what was going on there imho.

Or maybe he does not share your beliefs about EM (not that I disagree about him being naive;)).

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom