cogreslab said:
There's been quite a lot of overnight comment on this Harmoniser thing, so let me here put down our conclusions re the first study for readers:*snip*
Others have addressed these points so I'll leave that
Having conceded these problems, I am pleased to see that our culture preparation protocols, method and use of blind counting, and statistical analyses of the captured data are not in contention.
Then you are not paying attention to the discussion here. I am currently attempting to untangle your second report on the Harmoniser. It is, besides being disorganised, full of errors. The following is merely a cursory observation of the most glaring.
Method and Materials
There is no numbering of the samples in the Method and Materials section, because of this it is difficult to correlate the study A, B and C to the samples 1 through 12. In addition to this confusion, there is direct contradiction between the samples described in this section with the tabulated data and further in the Discussion section. This would appear to be due to ommission of precision in this section and later introduction of "detail" in the Discussion section.
Tabulated data
1. The first (unnumbered) totals table in the Summary section does not equal the summarised results in Table 1. This confusion is exacerbated by the rewording of the sample sets and indeed does not relate to the description of the samples given in Method and Materials, nor in the Discussion.
2. Table 1 in turn does not correlate to the first table in the Method and Materials section that purports to summarise the samples described in that section and further introduces a sample description that is not even mentioned in Meth&Mat
3. Table 2. There was absolutely no description of Meth&Mat for describing the process whereby this data was obtained. Also, the Harmoniser used (from the title) was NOT the same as described for the previous sample. Sample titles are worded differently than the preceding table so positive identification of the sample is difficult.
4. Table 3 does not reflect the results of Table 1. You may think it is pedantic that the difference is only 3 (in favor of viable), but it is an example of the sloppiness inherent throughout this report.
5. Table 4. Not one of the sample results from Table 1 are correctly listed here. So much so, that the 1 "energised" sample in section A is listed as "unenergised" in T1 and the 2 "non-energised" samples in B correlate to 2 "energised" samples in T1.
Discussions
As above, the discussion details either do not correspond to those in the Method and Materials section. This section then introduces descriptions of samples and treatment that are not even mentioned in the Method section NOR the Tabulated data.
Conclusions
Besides being mealy-mouthed and ignoring most of the results, presented anyway, are based on results that have been incorrectly summarised and do not reflect the experiment as run.
As I said, this is merely a first pass - is it worth my while to get into the detail, or do you perhaps have a redraft of this "report" that accurately represents the experiment conducted?