Bioelectromagnetics

Negative findings:

"So why don't you publish the negative reports? Science is all about showing results, good and bad. If you only show the results that fit the hypothesis then that is definitely NOT science".

A number of reasons:

1. Journals don't often want to publish negative reports. This issue is often addressed in discussions elsewhere than here..
2. This is indeed useful information when developing some new device/technique, and of value to competitors (e.g. to avoid goiing down a blind alley).
3. It wastes peoples' time reading what doesn't happen, I suppose.
4. We do publish on our website at least one negative report, e.g. the studies trying to see if the south/north pole of a magnet makes any difference in its biological effects as some have claimed (it doesn't) in an effort to dispel some of the folklore of magnet therapy.
 
There's been quite a lot of overnight comment on this Harmoniser thing, so let me here put down our conclusions re the first study for readers:

We concluded:

"Human peripheral blood lymphocytes cultured in Personal Harmoniser-energised nutrient medium in vitro remain more viable and more numerous than unenergised or unexposed cells similarly cultivated. The device also appears to exercise a protective effect in vitro against radiation from cellphones on standby. The study cannot be used to argue that the same effects occur in the live body (in vivo).

It will be interesting to see if similar effects can be demonstrated in vivo. This might involve a sample of human subjects of sufficient size to yield acceptable statistical power, whose blood count before and after exposure to the device and to cell phone radiations is evaluated. It will also be important to establish by replication whether the transfer of the energised influence at a distance to unenergised water noted here is a real effect. An attempt should also be made to characterise the frequencies at which the influence is operating, and the mechanism of interaction."

please note:

1. We pointed out this in vitro study should not be taken to mean it works in vivo.

2. Like others here we also suggested it would be useful to characterise the exxposure parameters and seek a mechanism.
3. We said that replication was important to see if the effect was indeed real.

Regarding Hans's main criticism: (the sample size in this study was too small, since only one sample was used) I am inclined to agree with him. We should have taken perhaps three separate cultures rather than just one. This means three times as much work and three times as much cost, but the client was unwilling to expend this at one time. If the funding had been available we would have done a bigger experiment. The client later came back with more funding.

When counting there is moreover only a finite time available before the heat and light and other events degrade the cells. This in turn limits the sample size.

Having conceded these problems, I am pleased to see that our culture preparation protocols, method and use of blind counting, and statistical analyses of the captured data are not in contention. That we put in a large amount of preliminary information (which Hans criticised, surprisingly to me) was because so few are familiar with this field or the literature background, and we thought it might of use to those wanting to learn more about this area.
 
Well, I've just waded through the posts overnight. Disappointingly they are mostly value judgements, with no scientific imput whatsoever.

Some of the illogicalities are amusing, however:

When I cite a reference it is construed as "an appeal to authority"
When anyone else does so it is a "citation" and commands respect. Where's the fairness and even handedness in that?

Cogbashing is not working, folks. My schoolboy physics is the same physics that is being described by the WHO!

Magnetic fields are not there if the load is switched off. Electric fields are there all the time the kettle lead is connected to the mains. This means that chronic exposure to EMF lies largely with the electric component. Sorry, if that upsets you, but it is a main reason for investigating the electric component at ELF frequencies via epidemiology.

The utilities (and indeed the UKCCR) have conspicuously failed to do this properly, yet claim that EMF (not magnetic fields alone, which is all they have concentrated on) in its entirely are not causally related to childhood cancer.

It was a clever ruse on their part, but only when there is at least one large and well conducted study of the ELF electric component's impact in the child's bedplace (not spot readings - which are uncharacterisitc - , nor 48 hours measurements - which are thereby diluting the data to one third- , nor portable measures -which capture daytime exposures but not night time- ) can one begin to say anything about EMF (in its entirety).

This is because there is no relation at all between the electric and magnetic components of an EM wave at ELF frequencies. Skreak all you like about my physics knowledge, but that is the basic position, and you very well know it.
 
cogreslab said:
Well, I've just waded through the posts overnight. Disappointingly they are mostly value judgements, with no scientific imput whatsoever.
Well don't read your own posts then
cogreslab said:
...... This means that chronic exposure to EMF lies largely with the electric component. Sorry, if that upsets you, but it is a main reason for investigating the electric component at ELF frequencies via epidemiology.

The utilities (and indeed the UKCCR) have conspicuously failed to do this properly, yet claim that EMF (not magnetic fields alone, which is all they have concentrated on) in its entirely are not causally related to childhood cancer.....
I take it then you withdraw the UKCCCR as a source when suggesting that there is a link.

You have still not yet:

- Demonstrated that there is an epidemiological link - the latest trials suggest there isn't one
- Identified a way in which the "electric component" causes caner in a way that is consistent with funadamental scientific principles

Never mind demonstrating how the talisman can help beyond

[paraphrase] We don't know whether it works but even if it doesn't it's no worse than nothing[/paraphrase]

which is at odds with what you have on your website and is a disingenuous position at best
 
cogreslab said:

Having conceded these problems, I am pleased to see that our culture preparation protocols, method and use of blind counting, and statistical analyses of the captured data are not in contention.

Personally i've not the experience to critique your isolation + preperation methods.

The counts are a little odd, for sample A the total count was over 600, for all the others the counts were in the region 510 - 530 (ish). Maybe this just shows the subjectiveness of manual counts. As Rolfe pointed out they are subjective (is it on the line or not, decision time).

Of course what is needed is confirmation by an independant reputable laboratory.
 
cogreslab said:
To Hans:

By one sample, do you mean from one isolated culture or from one exposure? In fact we counted (12 I think) hemacytometer squares and quantified these separately. Normally we use three runs and on different dates, but for the endogenous field studies the results were so surprising we did six separate cultures. Then we did six again. The effect was surprisingly robust.
You prepared 5 samples, A, B, C, D, and E. All got different combinations of exposure/non-exposure. This means that you have only one sample per exposure. This does not enable you to estimate the normal distribution of each, and thus you cannot make any conclusion about whether they belong to different populations. In other words, you cannot reject the null hypothesis.

Let me give a (slightly silly) example: Suppose you examine two cats. One is black and white, the other is a tabby. They are same gender and appr. same age. The black and white weighs 2.5kg, the tabby weighs 6kg (:eek: that you, Garfield?). Can you conclude that tabby cats are heavier than black and white cats?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*
1. We pointed out this in vitro study should not be taken to mean it works in vivo.

Yes, but you nevertheless on your website claim that the device works in vivo.

Also, when making an in vitro experiment, it is normal to provide a rationale for why you assume that the result is relevant for the in vivo sitiation. After all, that is the purpose of such studies.


*snip*

Regarding Hans's main criticism: (the sample size in this study was too small, since only one sample was used) I am inclined to agree with him. We should have taken perhaps three separate cultures rather than just one. This means three times as much work and three times as much cost, but the client was unwilling to expend this at one time. If the funding had been available we would have done a bigger experiment. The client later came back with more funding.

I'm sorry, but that does not fly. As a scientist, you cannot claim that the reason you made a worthless experiment was that you could not obtain funding for a good one. Any serious scientist would turn down such a proposition.

When counting there is moreover only a finite time available before the heat and light and other events degrade the cells. This in turn limits the sample size.

As already mentioned, it is the sample number per group that is my main concern.

Having conceded these problems, I am pleased to see that our culture preparation protocols, method and use of blind counting, and statistical analyses of the captured data are not in contention. That we put in a large amount of preliminary information (which Hans criticised, surprisingly to me)

You have a way with words, Roger. I did not criticise that you put a lot of initial information in the report, I criticised the QUALITY of that information. It is largely irrelevant speculation, references to anciant superstition, etc. - Not something that belongs in a scientific report.

was because so few are familiar with this field or the literature background, and we thought it might of use to those wanting to learn more about this area.

There is nothing educational in a lot of woowoo references and idle speculation.
Note please, Roger, that I'm trying to treat you as a scientist here.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Well, I've just waded through the posts overnight. Disappointingly they are mostly value judgements, with no scientific imput whatsoever.

Why should that disappoint you? That's all YOU have ever had to offer!

cogreslab said:
Some of the illogicalities are amusing, however:

When I cite a reference it is construed as "an appeal to authority"
When anyone else does so it is a "citation" and commands respect. Where's the fairness and even handedness in that?

Where's the fairness and even handedness in cherry picking the bits of references that suit you and totally ignoring the parts that contradict every word you say? Which is of course your usual practice.

cogreslab said:
Cogbashing is not working, folks. My schoolboy physics is the same physics that is being described by the WHO!

Crap. The laymans description of certain limited aspects of physics on the WHO website is at a schoolboy level. But THEIR schoolboy physics is at least correct, yours isn't!

cogreslab said:
Magnetic fields are not there if the load is switched off. Electric fields are there all the time the kettle lead is connected to the mains. This means that chronic exposure to EMF lies largely with the electric component. Sorry, if that upsets you, but it is a main reason for investigating the electric component at ELF frequencies via epidemiology.

More crap. Not even remotely related or logical.

cogreslab said:
The utilities (and indeed the UKCCR) have conspicuously failed to do this properly, yet claim that EMF (not magnetic fields alone, which is all they have concentrated on) in its entirely are not causally related to childhood cancer.

No. Although not all studies are properly comprehensive, the essential problem is that you don't have the capability or the education to understand the technicalities of what HAS been done. The fact that you are incapable of recognising the scientific facts does not imply in any way that they don't exist.

cogreslab said:
It was a clever ruse on their part, but only when there is at least one large and well conducted study of the ELF electric component's impact in the child's bedplace (not spot readings - which are uncharacterisitc - , nor 48 hours measurements - which are thereby diluting the data to one third- , nor portable measures -which capture daytime exposures but not night time- ) can one begin to say anything about EMF (in its entirety).

And that of course would be your own study? Yes, I thought so. Your study shows the same experimental precision and integrity as the rest of what you do - i.e. none.

In fact, I found something about your study that may interest Hans. I'll post that separately.

cogreslab said:
This is because there is no relation at all between the electric and magnetic components of an EM wave at ELF frequencies. Skreak all you like about my physics knowledge, but that is the basic position, and you very well know it.

So how does a mains transformer work then? Doh! :rolleyes:
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*

Cogbashing is not working, folks.

If having your arguments shot to bits practically all the time, and not being able to defend them is not a bashing in your book, I wonder what is.

My schoolboy physics is the same physics that is being described by the WHO!

But you do not present yourself as a schoolboy, Roger, remember? You are claiming to be a SCIENTIST. You are comparing yourself with Newton and Faraday :rolleyes:.

Magnetic fields are not there if the load is switched off. Electric fields are there all the time the kettle lead is connected to the mains. This means that chronic exposure to EMF lies largely with the electric component. Sorry, if that upsets you, but it is a main reason for investigating the electric component at ELF frequencies via epidemiology.

How often have you seen a high-voltage power line that was unloaded?

The utilities (and indeed the UKCCR) have conspicuously failed to do this properly, yet claim that EMF (not magnetic fields alone, which is all they have concentrated on) in its entirely are not causally related to childhood cancer.

Because most studies use geographical distribution, they don't measure fields at all. You see, if there is no overrepresentation of disease in people living under power lines, it does not matter if it is the magnetic or the electric field that is NOT causing it :rolleyes:.

It was a clever ruse on their part, but only when there is at least one large and well conducted study of the ELF electric component's impact in the child's bedplace (not spot readings - which are uncharacterisitc - , nor 48 hours measurements - which are thereby diluting the data to one third- , nor portable measures -which capture daytime exposures but not night time- ) can one begin to say anything about EMF (in its entirety).

Why does it matter when there is no overall effect?

This is because there is no relation at all between the electric and magnetic components of an EM wave at ELF frequencies. Skreak all you like about my physics knowledge, but that is the basic position, and you very well know it.

I think you are being deliberately obtuse here. Sure, your kettle has an electric field and no magnetic field (to speak of), but what has this to do with power lines? Since the load pattern of power lines is well known and easy to document, it is no problem to figure out the ratio between the electrical and the magnetic components.

Hans
 
Hans, remember this discussion you had with Roger? I found a report by Roger on the web site below that throws some more light on it. The emphases are mine.

cogreslab said:
You raise three criticisms (and then claim others unspecified, as a catch all).

Let's take your first criticism:

"1) Your active group is not representative. You acquired that group through advertizing for patients. In other words, there is a high probability that the selection favored patients where exposure to electric fields was suspected. The correct method would be to select subjects randomly among all known patients".

This is not correct: we began by acquiring cases from the Wessex Health Authority until they were told by LRF not to help us, or lose their own project funding for the UKCCCR study. (I still have a copy of the letter in my files). The second group of cases were acquired at random from a distinct geographical area in the database of a charity, none of whom had any idea whatsoever of the electric or magnetic fields in their homes. Virtually none of the final candidates were living near overt sources of EMF. To gain as many cases as possible in this pilot study we went on a TV programme and acquired a few more cases that way, but not many. To suggest that this group is biased is nonsense. If anything it illustrates that the establishment from the outset was sufficiently concerned at what we might find they deliberately tried to hinder the study. All these methods of candidate acquisition are seen commonly in epi studies.

From: http://www.wave-guide.org/archives/...bmission-to-the-Tucson-NIEHS-meeting----.html

1.8 In order to resolve this question of electric field insult we
undertook a study of the measured ELF electric (and magnetic) fields
in the bedplaces of some 60 children with leukaemia compared with an
equal number of matched healthy controls. This was peer reviewed and
published in 1995 (Coghill, Steward et al., Europ. J. Cancer Prev. 5:
153-158), but was presumably not considered by the Working Group
because we were forced through lack of Health Authority cooperation to
rely on advertisements for part of our case sample. We recognised at
the time the deficiency of this approach,
but took the view that none
of the participants were capable of taking EM field measurements over
a 24 hr period, and that there was therefore little risk of bias.

1.9 The exclusion of all studies relying on advertising is not in our
view a reasonable exclusion where measured EM fields are concerned,
and the Working Group was wrong, in the circumstance where they have
only two studies of electric field exposures available to them, to
ignore consideration of our study.
 
Well, that's consistent with normal Roger Coghill thinking:

the Working Group was wrong, in the circumstance where they have
only two studies of electric field exposures available to them, to
ignore consideration of our study
Roger recons that a crappy study is better than no study (especially if it supports your position).

About the advertising bit: Sure! I read the report before I criticised it (I usually do), and the reason I mentioned advertizing was that it was in the report. That Roger later has a different explanation is, unfortunately, not unique. In the Harmonizer report, he also suddenly remembered that temperature and humidity had been under control, when that point was brought up.

Edited to add: Of course, another nasty problem with that study was that the measuring of the fields was not blinded. The operator must in many cases have been aware if he was setting up the equipment in a leukaemia home. And since measuring of elecrical fields is extremely tricky business (something Roger seems blithely unaware of), that alone could overthrow the results.

Hans
 
Roger also confirmed that the results included at least 1 outlier. Given the small size of the study, and that the study was then futher subdivided, this outlier(s) would have had a large effect on the statistical analysis.

Roger did not say whether the admitted outlier was included in the study as a response to the TV advertising. If so then it is an obvious bias.
 
cogreslab said:
Well, I've just waded through the posts overnight. Disappointingly they are mostly value judgements, with no scientific imput whatsoever.
Roger,

You ignored the vast majority of my responses to your citations. Twice now. How arrogant and ignorant of you to write this sweepingly dismissive pap once again. Your dodges are not working. How about actually engaging in a conversation here, huh?
 
To Hans:

"As a scientist, you cannot claim that the reason you made a worthless experiment..."

No it was not at all worthless, Hans, it needed a larger set of samples. For example. say we had repeated the study twice more on some subsequent occasions. The three together would have satisfied your need for more data in order to derive a distribution. Eventually as i say the client found some more money so we could continue looking at this device.

But take a look at this:

For each group (e.g. the exposed culture) we counted ten separate squares in the hemacytometer. In each we identified the viable and the non-viable. That gave us twenty separate figures. From this it is possible to derive SDs, means, and sums, for the viable and the non viable cells ie. the data needed to test for significance within that group.
 
"You are comparing yourself with Newton and Faraday"

Only in the sense that these men carried out experiments at their own cost thorugh curiousity, and I suggested that this seems to be something of an English tradition, e.g. Peter Mitchell (the chemiosmosis hypthesis).
 
Pragmatist said:


If you want a REAL bad case of indigestion, check THIS one out!

http://www.neilos.com.au/pdf/Research Report - Harmoniser Tests.pdf

Make sure you're not eating anything while you're reading it or you'll choke! If the pendulum doesn't do it, I guarantee the hard boiled egg slicer will! :)
I'll get to it for a laff
None of these reports (Roger's that is) give sufficient information to make any sense of the setup, at least not in electromagnetic terms.
I printed the second of Roger's "research" into the Harmoniser and am attempting to recreate his tabulated results. HAH! There are numerous errors in the tablulated data, incorrect listings of samples and contradictions between
a) the stated method
b) the tabulated data
c) description of method in the results
e) description of the *samples" in the results
f) introduction of a completely different sample set

... it goes on...

I am endeavouring to put together a coherent summary of all the errors and inconsistencies in his report and present it here for critique.
 
MRC_Hans said:
Well, that's consistent with normal Roger Coghill thinking:



Edited to add: Of course, another nasty problem with that study was that the measuring of the fields was not blinded. The operator must in many cases have been aware if he was setting up the equipment in a leukaemia home. And since measuring of elecrical fields is extremely tricky business (something Roger seems blithely unaware of), that alone could overthrow the results.

Hans

This would apply to every epi study ever conducted ion childhood leukemia: are you going then to dismiss them all?
 
The Don said:

Well don't read your own posts then

I take it then you withdraw the UKCCCR as a source when suggesting that there is a link.

You have still not yet:

- Demonstrated that there is an epidemiological link - the latest trials suggest there isn't one
- Identified a way in which the "electric component" causes caner in a way that is consistent with funadamental scientific principles


No, I don't withdraw the UKCCCR as a possible source: the authors have the ability to reanalyse their data so as to report the nocturnal bedplace exposures instead of burying them in 48 hours measurements. I asked Sir Richard personally at an NRPB meeting to do this for the reasons already stated. He declined to respond to my criticisms at the time, and passed the question to another person present to answer.

Regarding the persistent strength of the association, you are virtually alone in denying this.

As for identifying the possible mechanisms of interaction between weak ELF E-fields and organic life processes, I have alluded to several, including of course the melatonin hypothesis.

It now turns out that PBLs emit melatonin when challenged by PHA (Carrillo-Vico et al., FASEB Jan 2004) and we will be seeing whether this vital response is inhibited when these cells are exposed to EMF later this year.
 
cogreslab said:
To Hans:

"As a scientist, you cannot claim that the reason you made a worthless experiment..."

No it was not at all worthless, Hans, it needed a larger set of samples. For example. say we had repeated the study twice more on some subsequent occasions. The three together would have satisfied your need for more data in order to derive a distribution.

Yes, if you replicated the expriment exactly several times, that would increase your sample size. But you did not do that, you made only that one experiment.

Eventually as i say the client found some more money so we could continue looking at this device.

But you did not repeat the experiment.

But take a look at this:

For each group (e.g. the exposed culture) we counted ten separate squares in the hemacytometer. In each we identified the viable and the non-viable. That gave us twenty separate figures. From this it is possible to derive SDs, means, and sums, for the viable and the non viable cells ie. the data needed to test for significance within that group.

*sigh*
You prepared 5 (five, fünf, cinco) vials. You used them as follows:

A. Energised, not exposed

B. Energised, PCN exposed

C. Not energised. Not exposed

D. Not energised, PCN exposed

E. Control: not energised, unexposed

That makes 5 populations of 1 (one, ein, uno).
I have not challenged the precision of you counting operation (but others have, I notice), but you cannot compare two populations of one stastistically. I'm sorry, but that is simply how it is.
Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom