The Mighty Thor said:
But I am now even more skeptical of people who represent themselves as 'authority figures' in any way. Who can we trust? I am certainly off the Greens if Mr Goghill is an example of their expertise.
TMT,
This is the point, IMO, of sites such as JREF's. It is also the point of those of us here who choose NOT to give degrees, affiliations and the like -- those of us who claim to be strip club bouncers and garbage men and janitors.
Isolated authority is meaningless.
The most important thing is to learn basic logic and learn the scientific "thought style." Where that is difficult, the best bet is to go with the scientific consensus if the science is more to the "hard" side of the scale and a clear consensus on the question is available. If you can't get there, or don't see it available, keep your wallet in you pants, sip the champagne and nod politely. But sign nothing.
When you find someone you feel you can trust, vet everything. Keep testing them. They say "x," then look it up. Check it out.
There are vast areas where expertise is needed, and these are difficult. There are even more areas, though, where basic logic and basic science can bring you a long way.
Look closely at Coghill's rhetorical techniques. They are inept, but they are also of a pattern. Frequent basic science errors. Blunderbuss. Appeals to authority. Slippery wording. Ducking of questin after question. Red herrings. Subject / motive shift. Appeals to pity.
Then look closely at Coghill's evidence, on the rare occasions it has been presented. Incomplete citations. Lists of citations that, when examined, turn out to be non-germane. Appeals to authority (again.)
No gentle reader of JREF should ever trust anyone because of who they are or claim to be. Ask them for citations. Check out the citations. Test everything. After you've established who is right, maintain a regular schedule of random drug testing. You know, every 10th assertion or so, go look it up. Be sure you can confirm the claims.
This forum (as in real life) is riddled with poseurs. Some are simply delusional, and are to be pitied. Some are delusional, but have an agenda. Some pity there, but also danger to be averted. Others have transparent agendas, that must be countered in public. Finally, others have hidden agendas. They claim to be skeptics, and sometimes look like skeptics, but if your nose is good, you'll realize they smell like wolves and, if your eyes are good, you'll see the seems in the costumes they wear. These are the most dangerous of all. They want your money, your heart, your mind. And they'll take your significant other, too, just to make sure you know what just happened to you.