Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
Is this the kind of research you BVMs do (I'd better be careful how I write BVMs, in view of my classical education):
OK, this is pretty off-topic now, but it's intriguing me. Given that Roger, quite incomprehensibly, didn't seem to realise I was a vet until at least a page later....
OF COURSE! The penny has finally dropped! Rolfe's a complete BVM! I couldn’t understand the apparent dedication to scientific truth, the complete refusal to accept that static magnets might be any thing else than a con trick, the nervousness when one of his colleagues had the honesty to admit that medicine might be more than just a load of tablets.

Now it finally comes out: Rolfe is a BVM! A veterinarian, ....[snipped hysterical rant against the veterinary profession....]
.... anyway, has anybody any idea at all what Roger meant by that first quote, and the odd writing of "BVMs"? Did he really think I was claiming to be the Blessed Virgin herself?

Rolfe (Bachelor of Veterinary Medicine and Surgery, for the abbreviation-challenged).
 
Pragmatist said:


Agreed. I'm genuinely trying to be fair here and give Roger a good hearing, but I must agree that so far things look decidedly suspicious to say the least!

I can think of dozens of possible influencing factors that have apparently not been taken into account, and the gold wire itself accounts for at least 3 of those. There might even be a legitimate argument that the gold itself had an adverse effect on lymphocyte viability regardless of whether it was in contact with the culture or not. But I'll save that until I know more about the experiment.

So far, the information is totally inadequate to draw any sensible conclusion at all, except that the probability is that the experiment is meaningless and invalid. I hope Roger will fill in the blanks.
I don't think you'll be much more impressed by his second experiment on the harmoniser for the manufacturer.

http://www.implosionresearch.com/cir1/coghill 2.htm

I've not yet digested it. But on a quick scan the detail of the approach and method is not unlike the last one, so without doubt, the same questions will be raised.

I don't think I would have passed high school chemistry if I had submitted a report this vague. Conjecture only, but it smacks more of a series of experiments commissioned a manufacturer to prop it's advertising that true "research".

Just the thing that Mr.Coghill is accusing the government and National Grid companies of. PKB indeed?
 
Rolfe said:
...... anyway, has anybody any idea at all what Roger meant by that first quote, and the odd writing of "BVMs"? Did he really think I was claiming to be the Blessed Virgin herself?

Rolfe (Bachelor of Veterinary Medicine and Surgery, for the abbreviation-challenged).
I think Mr.Coghill is falling back on his formal education.

Bottom jokes would have been de rigeur at about which level of schooling?
 
cogreslab said:
Non Blinded counting: "It was an error similar to this that caused Jacques Benveniste to embarrass himself and all of science by inducing Nature to publish a completely delusional paper".

I could not let this one through: I thought JB blinded the data and the investigating team pasted the codes to the ceiling inside tinfoil? Then they photographed it frequently with a video camera (clever trick that!). Was I wrong to think this?
OK, back on topic.

The studies that were presented in the Nature paper were counted non-blinded. Manually.

The paper looked fine as submitted, but the referees simply didn't believe a word of it. However, they couldn't spot the problem in the text. Benveniste made a big fuss and claimed bias and suppression of his great discovery, and John Maddox (mistakenly in my opinion) agreed to publish, but with a disclaimer and on the condition that he and some colleagues could visit that lab and check how it was done. (I believe he should have delayed the publication until after the visit. Note that the cold fusion proponents got the cold shoulder from the same quarter the following year - once bitten twice shy.)

So John Maddox, Walter Stewart and James Randi visited the lab. It was immediately obvious that there was no deliberate fraud going on, but Maddox spotted that the technicians knew which sample was which while they were doing the counts. Randi devised the blinding code, and the trick of sellotaping the envelope to the ceiling. The whole thing was videoed, not specifically the envelope.

Benveniste and his team were so sure of success that they filled the fridge with champagne and booked a slap-up restaurant for that evening. Then the blinding code was broken and the results turned out to be totally random. It was unconscious operator bias in the counting that had produced the positive results. Also, it transpired that Benveniste had also simply "not counted" runs in his original investigation where the effect hadn't shown up. All to be read about here.

He's still doing it. He claims that a couple of his researchers have a positive effect on the process he thinks he has discovered, they get "good" results while others get random results. I wonder how his special favourites would get on if they were properly blinded again? He's getting very close to the workers like Walach, Milgrom and Thoresen, who understand all too well that homoeopathy has no discernible effect when nobody knows who's been given what, and in their desperation postulate some sort of "magic" influence of the power of the mind of the practitioner.

I've done manual cell counts, often. It's easy to skew things just enough that you'd see a statistically significant effect where there really is none, even unconsciously. It's just a pity Benveniste could never accept this.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
Rolfe said:
OK, this is pretty off-topic now, but it's intriguing me. Given that Roger, quite incomprehensibly, didn't seem to realise I was a vet until at least a page later........ anyway, has anybody any idea at all what Roger meant by that first quote, and the odd writing of "BVMs"? Did he really think I was claiming to be the Blessed Virgin herself?

Rolfe (Bachelor of Veterinary Medicine and Surgery, for the abbreviation-challenged).

I think it's supposed to be an extremely lame play on the fact that old Latin texts didn't have a separate letter "U". So "BUMs" in latin would be rendered "BVMs".

No it wasn't worth waiting for!

What I particularly liked about Roger's quote though was that he seems to think that "a complete dedication to scientific truth" is some sort of epithet! :)
 
EHocking said:
think Mr.Coghill is falling back on his formal education.

Bottom jokes would have been de rigeur at about which level of schooling?
(I still don't get it. Is my mind too pure and unsullied?)

Edited to add: I suppose Pragmatist may be right. Seems about Roger's mental level. Funny he quoted John Burns, also obviously a vet and with the same degree as me, and David Ramey, another vet colleague (so of course commercially biassed, for some reason Roger thinks there would be an embargo on professionals selling magnets if they actually worked), and the penny didn't drop. Never mind the BVMS, what-the-hell does he think MRCVS stands for? And I even said it was the "licence to practice that comes free with the BVMS". This guy is SLOW as well as crude.

Edited again: I note that the name "Burns", in this arial font, gives a similar effect. Is there no end to the scatological references you can squeeze out of vets?

The BVM.
 
Rolfe said:
OK, this is pretty off-topic now, but it's intriguing me. Given that Roger, quite incomprehensibly, didn't seem to realise I was a vet until at least a page later........ anyway, has anybody any idea at all what Roger meant by that first quote, and the odd writing of "BVMs"? Did he really think I was claiming to be the Blessed Virgin herself?

Rolfe (Bachelor of Veterinary Medicine and Surgery, for the abbreviation-challenged).

Rolfe,

He is, I think, making a schoolboy joke regarding the 'classical' Latin letter 'v' being a 'u' -- thereby, to the delight of all his fellow public schoolboys who revere the word (for reasons beyond the comprehension of most ordinary mortals) he is calling you a 'bum'.

As a layman, I appreciate the indefatigable efforts of the true skeptiks here to 'out' this smug charlatan. But I am now even more skeptical of people who represent themselves as 'authority figures' in any way. Who can we trust? I am certainly off the Greens if Mr Goghill is an example of their expertise.

BTW,

weeny, weedy, weechy!

or

Cwusify Wolfe!

would probably also appeal to his puerile sense humour.
 
To get slightly back on topic again, here's the relevant passage from the BBC transcript.
NARRATOR: On 4th July 1988 the investigative team arrived in Paris ready for the final showdown.

SIR JOHN MADDOX: The first thing we did was to sit round the table in Benveniste's lab. Benveniste himself struck us all as looking very much like a film star.

JAMES RANDI: I found him to be a charming, very continental gentleman. He's a great personality. He was very much in control.

JACQUES BENVENISTE: We were quite relaxed because there was no reason why things should not go right.

NARRATOR: The first step was for Benveniste and his team to perform their experiment under Randi's watchful gaze. They had to prepare two sets of tubes containing homeopathic water and ordinary water. If the homeopathic water was having a real effect different from ordinary water then homeopathy would be vindicated. (ACTUALITY EXPERIMENT CHAT) As they plotted the results it was clear the experiment had worked.

JAMES RANDI: There were huge peaks coming up out of it and that was very active results, I mean very, very positive results.

WALTER STEWART: The astonishing thing about these results is that they repeated the claim, they demonstrated the claim that a homeopathic dilution, a dilution where there were no molecules, could actually have some sort of an effect.

NARRATOR: But Maddox had seen that the experimenters knew which tubes contained the homeopathic water and which contained the ordinary water, so perhaps unconsciously, this might have influenced the results, so he asked them to repeat the experiment. This time the tubes would be relabelled with a secret code so that no-one knew which tube was which.

JAMES RANDI: We went into a sealed room and we actually taped newspapers over the windows to the room that were accessible to the hall.

WALTER STEWART: We recorded in handwriting which tube was which and we put this into an envelope and sealed it so that nobody could open it or change it.

NARRATOR: At this point the investigation took a turn for the surreal as they went to extraordinary lengths to keep the code secret.

JAMES RANDI: Walter and I got up on the stepladder and stuck it to the ceiling of the lab.

WALTER STEWART: There it was taped above us as all of this work went on.

JACQUES BENVENISTE: Sticking an envelope to the ceiling was utterly ridiculous. There is no way you can associate that with science.

NARRATOR: With the codes out of reach the final experiment could begin. By now Benveniste had lost control of events.

JACQUES BENVENISTE: It was a madhouse. Randi was doing magician tricks.

JAMES RANDI: Yes I was doing perhaps a little bit of sleight-of-hand with an object or something like that, just to lighten the atmosphere.

NARRATOR: Soon the analysis was complete. It was time to break the code to see if the experiment had worked. Benveniste and his team were brimming with optimism.

JAMES RANDI: Oh my goodness it was party-time, cracked crabs legs and magnums, literally, of champagne packed in ice.

WALTER STEWART: We were going to be treated to a wonderful dinner. The press, many members of the press were there.

JAMES RANDI: John and Walter and I were looking at one another as if to say wow, if this doesn't work it's going to be a downer.

WALTER STEWART: Finally came the actual work of decoding the result.

JAMES RANDI: There was much excitement at the table. Everyone was gathered around.

NARRATOR: Benveniste felt sure that the results would support homeopathy and that he would be vindicated.

JAMES RANDI: That didn't happen. It was just a total failure.

SIR JOHN MADDOX: We said well nothing here is there?

WALTER STEWART: And immediately the mood in the laboratory switched, people burst into tears.

JAMES RANDI: It was general gloom.

NARRATOR: The team wrote a report accusing Benveniste of doing bad science and branding the claims for the memory of water a delusion. Benveniste's scientific reputation was ruined.

JACQUES BENVENISTE: Everybody believed that I am totally wrong. It's simply dismissed. Your phone call doesn't ring anymore. Just like actresses, or actress that have no, are no more in fashion the phone suddenly is silent.

NARRATOR: For now the memory of water was forgotten. Science declared homeopathy impossible once more....
Note that the experiment still worked in the presence of the sceptics, and the null result only appeared after the blinding. So much for the woo-woo claims that the sceptics emit some sort of negative vibes that negate the effect.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
The Mighty Thor said:
He is, I think, making a schoolboy joke regarding the 'classical' Latin letter 'v' being a 'u' -- thereby, to the delight of all his fellow public schoolboys who revere the word (for reasons beyond the comprehension of most ordinary mortals) he is calling you a 'bum'.
Yeah, we get it now. Funny, when he referred to BVM and his "classical education" I still only got the Blessed Virgin Mary reference.

Thanks to all who elucidated the infantile attempt at humour. I like my new sig even better now!

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
EHocking said:

I don't think you'll be much more impressed by his second experiment on the harmoniser for the manufacturer.

http://www.implosionresearch.com/cir1/coghill 2.htm

I've not yet digested it. But on a quick scan the detail of the approach and method is not unlike the last one, so without doubt, the same questions will be raised.

I don't think I would have passed high school chemistry if I had submitted a report this vague. Conjecture only, but it smacks more of a series of experiments commissioned a manufacturer to prop it's advertising that true "research".

Just the thing that Mr.Coghill is accusing the government and National Grid companies of. PKB indeed?

If you want a REAL bad case of indigestion, check THIS one out!

http://www.neilos.com.au/pdf/Research Report - Harmoniser Tests.pdf

Make sure you're not eating anything while you're reading it or you'll choke! If the pendulum doesn't do it, I guarantee the hard boiled egg slicer will! :)

None of these reports (Roger's that is) give sufficient information to make any sense of the setup, at least not in electromagnetic terms.
 
Rolfe said:
WALTER STEWART: The astonishing thing about these results is that they repeated the claim, they demonstrated the claim that a homeopathic dilution, a dilution where there were no molecules, could actually have some sort of an effect.

I absolutely believe that homeopathy is rubbish, but I have just one criticism of what I believe is bad science in the oft repeated skeptic discussions of homeopathy, and it's in that quotation above. The same criticism applies to Benveniste who has often repeated it.

It's the thing about "no molecules of the substance remain".

It may be highly improbable that any molecules of the substance remain, but nobody can say that NO molecules of the substance remain.

Let's say I prepare a "homeopathic" dilution. I take 100 mls of water and add my substance. I then add 1ml of the solution to a further 100ml of water, and repeat the process several times over. Eventually, assuming even distribution of molecules I end up with a dilution that exceeds the Avogadro limit.

But consider this: I repeat the same dilution as before. Only THIS time I take ALL of the original solution, 1ml at a time and add it to 100 identical bottles of water each containing 100ml of water. I then repeat this, each time retaining ALL bottles. Eventually I end up with a ridiculous number of equal bottles. However if I choose any one at random from the whole, I cannot say that "no molecules of the substance remain". Because if I do, and if all bottles are equal, then it follows that there are no molecules in ANY of the bottles! And if that is the case, then the substance has somehow mysteriously disappeared along the way, which is an absurdity!

That is of course NOT a defence of homeopathy! I just think that skeptics ought to be scientifically precise in their criticisms wherever possible.
 
The Mighty Thor said:
As a layman, I appreciate the indefatigable efforts of the true skeptiks here to 'out' this smug charlatan. But I am now even more skeptical of people who represent themselves as 'authority figures' in any way. Who can we trust? I am certainly off the Greens if Mr Goghill is an example of their expertise.

I think you put your finger on it yourself. The people who represent themselves as "authority figures" are usually the ones you can LEAST trust in my experience.

The real "authorities" in most areas are more often than not reluctant to make anything of their qualifications and authority. The ones who make a big issue at the outset about how many letters they have, or how big their laboratories are, are usually the ones to watch out for.

One can of course speculate as to whether boasting of the size of one's laboratory reflects any "adequacy issues"! :)
 
The Mighty Thor said:
But I am now even more skeptical of people who represent themselves as 'authority figures' in any way. Who can we trust? I am certainly off the Greens if Mr Goghill is an example of their expertise.
TMT,

This is the point, IMO, of sites such as JREF's. It is also the point of those of us here who choose NOT to give degrees, affiliations and the like -- those of us who claim to be strip club bouncers and garbage men and janitors. Isolated authority is meaningless.

The most important thing is to learn basic logic and learn the scientific "thought style." Where that is difficult, the best bet is to go with the scientific consensus if the science is more to the "hard" side of the scale and a clear consensus on the question is available. If you can't get there, or don't see it available, keep your wallet in you pants, sip the champagne and nod politely. But sign nothing.

When you find someone you feel you can trust, vet everything. Keep testing them. They say "x," then look it up. Check it out.

There are vast areas where expertise is needed, and these are difficult. There are even more areas, though, where basic logic and basic science can bring you a long way.

Look closely at Coghill's rhetorical techniques. They are inept, but they are also of a pattern. Frequent basic science errors. Blunderbuss. Appeals to authority. Slippery wording. Ducking of questin after question. Red herrings. Subject / motive shift. Appeals to pity.

Then look closely at Coghill's evidence, on the rare occasions it has been presented. Incomplete citations. Lists of citations that, when examined, turn out to be non-germane. Appeals to authority (again.)

No gentle reader of JREF should ever trust anyone because of who they are or claim to be. Ask them for citations. Check out the citations. Test everything. After you've established who is right, maintain a regular schedule of random drug testing. You know, every 10th assertion or so, go look it up. Be sure you can confirm the claims.

This forum (as in real life) is riddled with poseurs. Some are simply delusional, and are to be pitied. Some are delusional, but have an agenda. Some pity there, but also danger to be averted. Others have transparent agendas, that must be countered in public. Finally, others have hidden agendas. They claim to be skeptics, and sometimes look like skeptics, but if your nose is good, you'll realize they smell like wolves and, if your eyes are good, you'll see the seems in the costumes they wear. These are the most dangerous of all. They want your money, your heart, your mind. And they'll take your significant other, too, just to make sure you know what just happened to you.
 
Rolfe said:
Chakras! Acupuncture points! Oh my sainted aunt! (And I haven't even got the the boiled egg slicer yet....)

:dl:

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
Why if it isn't Dr. CW Smith again... ah yes, I'm familiar with his "work".

Whaddya know? CW is right up there on the "The electromagnetic sky is falling!" bandwagon too:

Electromagnetic Man: Health and Hazard in the Electrical Environment

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/t...f=sr_1_1/104-9450094-6619105?v=glance&s=books

What a coinkydink! Who woulda thunk it?

He got a brief mention in a Martin Gardner column in the Skeptical Inquirer a while back:

http://www.csicop.org/si/9809/fringe.html

Cyril Smith, a British electrical engineer, writing on "Is a Living System a Macroscopic Quantum System?", relates "homeopathic potencies" to the Earth's electromagnetic fields that cause dowsing rods to turn.
Yes folks... he does consider the dowsing rod(pendulum) to be a scientific instrument:

http://www.aehf.com/articles/CyrilSmith'99.htm

The writer has developed the technique of dowsing to provide a personal scientific instrument capable of the detection and measurement of weak coherent frequency imprints and signatures in biological and chemical systems where at least a trace of water is involved.
:rolleyes:

Yep... ol' CW registers firmly in the Nuttier Than range on the old Fruitcake-O-Meter.
 
BillHoyt said:

TMT,

This is the point, IMO, of sites such as JREF's. It is also the point of those of us here who choose NOT to give degrees, affiliations and the like -- those of us who claim to be strip club bouncers and garbage men and janitors. Isolated authority is meaningless.

The most important thing is to learn basic logic and learn the scientific "thought style." Where that is difficult, the best bet is to go with the scientific consensus if the science is more to the "hard" side of the scale and a clear consensus on the question is available. If you can't get there, or don't see it available, keep your wallet in you pants, sip the champagne and nod politely. But sign nothing.

When you find someone you feel you can trust, vet everything. Keep testing them. They say "x," then look it up. Check it out.

There are vast areas where expertise is needed, and these are difficult. There are even more areas, though, where basic logic and basic science can bring you a long way.

Look closely at Coghill's rhetorical techniques. They are inept, but they are also of a pattern. Frequent basic science errors. Blunderbuss. Appeals to authority. Slippery wording. Ducking of questin after question. Red herrings. Subject / motive shift. Appeals to pity.

Then look closely at Coghill's evidence, on the rare occasions it has been presented. Incomplete citations. Lists of citations that, when examined, turn out to be non-germane. Appeals to authority (again.)

No gentle reader of JREF should ever trust anyone because of who they are or claim to be. Ask them for citations. Check out the citations. Test everything. After you've established who is right, maintain a regular schedule of random drug testing. You know, every 10th assertion or so, go look it up. Be sure you can confirm the claims.

This forum (as in real life) is riddled with poseurs. Some are simply delusional, and are to be pitied. Some are delusional, but have an agenda. Some pity there, but also danger to be averted. Others have transparent agendas, that must be countered in public. Finally, others have hidden agendas. They claim to be skeptics, and sometimes look like skeptics, but if your nose is good, you'll realize they smell like wolves and, if your eyes are good, you'll see the seems in the costumes they wear. These are the most dangerous of all. They want your money, your heart, your mind. And they'll take your significant other, too, just to make sure you know what just happened to you.

Thanks for that, Bill, and thanks to Prag, too. I agree with your advice. Trouble is that 'most ordinary folk' (I hate that term, but you get the idea) are more easily duped when they are at their most vulnerable. They are usually desperate, weak, ill, not thinking straight, and not in a position to do the necessary checks. So, I want the real professionals here to know that we punters DO appreciate your time and effort in debunking scam artists.

I think QuackWatch is usually fair, too.

But I worry when these kooks claim to influence the government by posing as experts. I suppose there are checks and balances to weed them out. But it all smells of 'lunatics advising the naive (or mercenary) on how to run the asylum.'

Plus, most of us don't get to go sailing at weekends. ;)
 
Psiload said:
Yes folks... he does consider the dowsing rod(pendulum) to be a scientific instrument:

Not to mention the venerable hard boiled egg slicer! I wonder what he'd do with an egg whisk? I shudder to think! And a cheese grater? Oh my! Oops, maybe I shouldn't have mentioned the EW, it's probably classified technology - now the MIB's will be out to get me! :)
 
The Mighty Thor said:


Thanks for that, Bill, and thanks to Prag, too. I agree with your advice. Trouble is that 'most ordinary folk' (I hate that term, but you get the idea) are more easily duped when they are at their most vulnerable. They are usually desperate, weak, ill, not thinking straight, and not in a position to do the necessary checks. So, I want the real professionals here to know that we punters DO appreciate your time and effort in debunking scam artists.

I think QuackWatch is usually fair, too.

But I worry when these kooks claim to influence the government by posing as experts. I suppose there are checks and balances to weed them out. But it all smells of 'lunatics advising the naive (or mercenary) on how to run the asylum.'

Plus, most of us don't get to go sailing at weekends. ;)

I've said the same myself. The weak and vulnerable are always the first targets - and EVERYBODY has weak and vulnerable moments in their lives. Nobody is totally immune.

An interesting case in point. Do a google search on "Bogdanov Brothers" and you'll probably be amazed. It's a contemporary scandal in physics. Two brothers appeared suddenly with a goobledegook theory of advanced quantum physics. It was quickly dismissed as a hoax, but they stuck to their guns. Subsequently it has started numerous arguments and the concensus as far as I am aware is that physicists themselves can't decide whether it's an elaborate hoax or a real theory! So I repeat, NOBODY is immune.

Personally I think the Bogdanov affair just confirms my own opinion that certain areas of physics have become too abstract and have lost touch with reality. Then again, I'm a pragmatist so I would say that, wouldn't I? :)

Luckily we don't have this problem with Roger, we only need a high school physics book to shoot him down! :)

All you need to do is set up a web site. Sell something, ANYTHING, beach pebbles if you like, for $500 each. Call them "transdimensional quantum vortex generators" and you'll be able to afford a yacht in no time! :)
 
In order not to derail this thread, I will set up another to discuss Dr Henshaw's work at the University of Bristol and how it is in no way similar to CogresLab's although it does relate to incidence of Leukemia near power lines.
 
Originally posted by cogreslab They've still got time to give me a Knighthood. What am i supposed to do with it? Sleep in it?

I just saw that and I fell on the floor laughing. You would kill for a Kighthood, Roger. Even I would consider to be arrested in Instabul for a Knight but for the magician of the village? No way.

Don maybe we should send another e-mail to Dr. Henshaw after you start this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom