Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
We use Sigma's Brightline hemacytometers.
As far as I know, "Brightline" just refers to the fact that the haemocytometer slide is mirrored.

I'm with Prester John. I'd like to know what the grid ruling pattern is. For example, we use the Improved Neubauer grid for platelet counting.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
Rolfe said:
But remember his experience. Cigarettes cause lung cancer. No doubt a lot of the establishment weren't too happy about that discovery. But nobody could suppress it (though they argued against it, of course), and Professor Doll got a knighthood. That's what happens when you're right.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.

[bold face mine]

Yeap. We must put this paragraph somewhere in the forum where everybody can see it. It's one of the bottom lines of this thread.
 
Regarding the lymphocyte experiment, I have a few things to add.

I agree with Hans regarding possible confounders. In particular, as Hans identified, mu metal shielding is NOT 100% effective against magnetic fields - unless it is unreasonably thick and supercooled as well (as I mentioned before in relation to the AB experiment).

I personally don't see any problem with the harmonizer being coiled, it will still form an antenna that is basically dependent on its total length (if one end of it was referred to ground which it wasn't), however that is largely irrelevant in this instance. Doubly so if the gold wire was in contact with it or even in close proximity to it (capacitive coupling). The key point here is that antenna only ACTS as an antenna if it is connected to a source and sink.

What has not been addressed at all is field geometry. If you put a cellphone in a shielded box then there will be complex standing waves and interference patterns within the box. In some cases these may actually cancel out the fields. In other cases they may enhance the field to the point where thermal effects become highly relevant. In particular, there seems to be no measure of the adiabatic temperature of the sample itself during the experiment, which is a very significant oversight and confounder.

ANY metal at all, introduced into the field pattern of the mobile in the box will cause a shift in the internal standing wave patterns. Therefore it is extremely likely that an ordinary metal coin, a piece of wire, a nail or some other metal object would distort the fields sufficiently to significantly alter the results. Even non metals would affect the results if they act as absorbers.

One of the confounders, by no means the least significant, is the gold wire itself. If the cell phone was on standby then it would have been pulsing. The pulsing itself would represent a discontinuity in the Fourier Transform of the carrier signal itself - and would result in a large spread of harmonics. Some of these harmonics may well react with the gold wire (as an antenna) and result in additional confounding effects.

Then of course there are separate issues of exactly where fields are referred to. If there is not a source and sink for the field generator then there is no actual field. We don't know if the box was grounded, or if the mobile was grounded etc., etc. If I read the report correctly and the mobile was actually OUTSIDE the box with the wire simply leading in, then all the shielding etc is irrelevant, the wire itself is a conduit for almost any external interference. This alone completely invalidates the whole experiment.

Unless the absolute, precise relative position of all components is known, the size, geometry etc., of the box, the phone itself, the circuits within the phone and so on, then there can be no meaningful interpretation of the results since the fields cannot be calculated.

In addition to all the above we don't know if the phone had a step back function or if the field was at all consistent. In fact, we don't know if there was a field at all.

Humidity was not controlled, which could affect any fields present (if any). No measurements were made of ionizing and penetrative sources.

In short, there are so many confounders that no conclusion at all can be drawn from the above. And that is before we even consider the issue of what constitutes "lymphocyte viability" and whether the Trypan Blue test is accurate or reliable under such conditions. I'll address that separately later.
 
If Roger was right, what could be the effects be on an adult? What are the main biological differences that would make a child more susceptible? If I cranked up the electromodingle relative to body mass would that exhibit a similar and/damaging effect? I like to build on Roger's original proven theories.
 
cogreslab said:
We use Sigma's Brightline hemacytometers. These are scored to give four very large squares in each corner and 16 smaller squares on each flank, then in the centre a smaller grid again. We use the four corner suares which have I think 16 squares within them, plus the middle one. There are two wells on the hemacytometer, so we count both. This gives us ten readings for each count, which are then summed and averaged. We take this aggregated average for statistical purposes. It's fairly common procedure (see Ali, a great little book on the Separatioin of Human blood Cells, page 34). Sigma used to describe the protocol in their catal;ogue, but not in recent years if I recall.

The scoring is similar to the "improved" Neubauer ruling.

(edited after I nipped into the lab to check the hemacytometers).
No wonder you are confused by the question of whether your sample is large enough. The above is only a process that was used to count a single sample. It is NOT the same, as you infer from a previous post (below) that you performed multiple tests on multiple samples

By one sample, do you mean from one isolated culture or from one exposure? In fact we counted (12 I think) hemacytometer squares and quantified these separately. Normally we use three runs and on different dates, but for the endogenous field studies the results were so surprising we did six separate cultures. Then we did six again. The effect was surprisingly robust.

Your report on your "study" categorically states that you prepared one culture, divided it into 5 samples and tested only them. The above quote implies that you performed this procedure twelve times on twelve different cultures.

Either the report on your website is inaccurate or your statement above is misleading.

So which is it?

a) One culture providing five samples on one test
or
b) six separate cultures, "did again"?
 
Prester John said:
Improved Neubauer

http://www.embl-heidelberg.de/ExternalInfo/karsenti/countingcells.html

Fuchs Rosenthal

http://www.hausserscientific.com/FuchsRosenthaldirect.htm

These are the ones i have used:)

Your description sounds like the improved neubauer.
Thanks! I was staring at the diagram of the Improved Neubauer in my own text-book last night, as I was just finishing off the chapter on side-room haematology that the Merck Veterinary Manual commissioned me to write. I tried to scan it to post here, but the scan was a mess. (Come to mention it, the one on the web page isn't much better! And it's not very literate, and the actual method is like nothing I've ever seen, but the grid is at least recognisable.)

The point is, I hope you're not counting adjacent squares. You're supposed to count four or five separate non-adjacent squares (depending on the type of cell being counted) [Edited to add: I see you did do that], and check that there's no more than a 10% variation between the highest and lowest counting cell.

You know, this method can be really subjective. I hope all counts are done blinded, with the people counting not knowing which sample is which. It was an error similar to this that caused Jacques Benveniste to embarrass himself and all of science by inducing Nature to publish a completely delusional paper.

The Blessed Virgin Mary.
 
Yes, all counts are done blind in our lab: it's much more fun that way, in any case!

The phone was outside the mu metal box, held on a wooden clamp, and the wire led into the box and then into the sealed phial containing the cells, but not so the wire dipped into the culture medium. This version of the box was a single skin, about an mm thick, of the kind often used in electronics engineering tio keep out stray fields.

I take your point about the difficulties in measuring the exact fields being applied. It would be nice to do that, of course, but given that fields from a cellphone are all over the place anyway, depending e.g. on battery strength over time, it served little purpose when we specified the model and its operating conditions for anyone wishing to replicate.

We were trying to see if a) there was any adverse effect from the phone anyway, since if not the experiemnt was useful only to report that, and in that case we would need to get proper measurement data.

b) if the device could in any way mitigate such effects on viability as were there. Against that background the precise field strength was not vital information. Yes, the wire also might collect and feed stray fields into the exposed culture. We presumed that any such would be the same for exposed and control samples, and our Farnell spectrum analyser indicated no difference in spectra in any of the positions used.

Of course there are many other parameters than viability, and several ways of measuring viability. We were constrained in the amoun t of work we could do on this project.

BY using this simple and well characdterised trypan blue test on all these devices we can get a comparatve idea of their efficacy (many if not most of the devices like that we test show no effects and the results don't make it out of the lab. Now and again we find a device that shows some promise.)
 
"Your report on your "study" categorically states that you prepared one culture, divided it into 5 samples and tested only them. The above quote implies that you performed this procedure twelve times on twelve different cultures".

The results we reported in the study you examined were from a single culture, and were not repeated at that time. About a year later I think it was we repeated the study but with more facets, seeing the same effects. The time we did the six repeats was not on that device but on the endogenous field study, because we felt this latter finding might be worth publication in the literature. Normally we don't bother to publish at all (except at conferences say, by way of a poster or platform presentation), since unlike the academic fraternity we are unconcerned about the Citations Index. Many of our studies are negative anyway, and of little interest to any but ourselves.

I am of the opinion that the desperate need to get published for the sake of justifying tenure is counterproductive and leads to a repetitious science. But you all know what I mean there: it's an oft quoted criticism of the peer review publication system.
 
cogreslab said:
"Your report on your "study" categorically states that you prepared one culture, divided it into 5 samples and tested only them. The above quote implies that you performed this procedure twelve times on twelve different cultures".

The results we reported in the study you examined were from a single culture, and were not repeated at that time. About a year later I think it was we repeated the study but with more facets, seeing the same effects. The time we did the six repeats was not on that device but on the endogenous field study, because we felt this latter finding might be worth publication in the literature. Normally we don't bother to publish at all (except at conferences say, by way of a poster or platform presentation), since unlike the academic fraternity we are unconcerned about the Citations Index. Many of our studies are negative anyway, and of little interest to any but ourselves.

I am of the opinion that the desperate need to get published for the sake of justifying tenure is counterproductive and leads to a repetitious science. But you all know what I mean there: it's an oft quoted criticism of the peer review publication system.
Since you brought this study up as further "proof", could you point us to a report on the experiment so that we can examine the results.

The mainstay of modern science is repeatability of results.

That you now shun the peer review publication system after quoting "cite" after "cite" of peer review publicaions in a vain effort to appeal to authority is risible in the extreme.
 
DionysianSmile said:
If Roger was right, what could be the effects be on an adult? What are the main biological differences that would make a child more susceptible? If I cranked up the electromodingle relative to body mass would that exhibit a similar and/damaging effect? I like to build on Roger's original proven theories.

The infant and child are still growing. The proportion of mitosis is likely to be higher therefore, since new cells are being formed at a faster rate. I ahve set out in previous posts why human infants are particularly vulnerable: their myelination process is incomplete for some months after birth. This makes them more susceptible to EMF exposures imho.
 
EHocking said:



That you now shun the peer review publication system after quoting "cite" after "cite" of peer review publicaions in a vain effort to appeal to authority is risible in the extreme.

No it's not. we only publish when there is something of importance to tell. Some authors publish the same findings in different guises year after year, a practice I was criticising.

Pleased to se you notice I make frequent citations from the peer reviewed literature. Some might argue that this shows I know the literature relevant to the issue.
 
cogreslab said:


No it's not. we only publish when there is something of importance to tell. Some authors publish the same findings in different guises year after year, a practice I was criticising.
...
I'm sure I am not alone on this thread in being interested in the results of this follow-up experiment that your laboratory performed, especially since you the results forward as further support for your argument.

As this is the case, and you know what us sceptics are like, could you please share this research with us as it is quite pertinent to the discussion currently being undertaken.

The alternative is for us to merely ignore your later experiment as purely anecdotal if we are unable to verify it. You have already pointed out that the initial 5 sample experiment was flawed, what protocol changes had you made to remedy this in the latter experiment?
 
cogreslab said:

...Pleased to se you notice I make frequent citations from the peer reviewed literature. Some might argue that this shows I know the literature relevant to the issue.
Most here would not.

But my point was that you quote publications that suit your cause and ignore those that do not.

Example being your reticence in describing the latter 12 sample experiment you performed, while quite happy to quote it as supporting your premise that the "harmoniser" is anything other than a placebo or a talisman.
 
cogreslab said:
Yes, all counts are done blind in our lab: it's much more fun that way, in any case!

The phone was outside the mu metal box, held on a wooden clamp, and the wire led into the box and then into the sealed phial containing the cells, but not so the wire dipped into the culture medium. This version of the box was a single skin, about an mm thick, of the kind often used in electronics engineering tio keep out stray fields.

Thanks for explaining that. How big was the box? And how did the wire enter the box? I mean was there just a hole drilled in it? And if so, how big? Was there some insulator plugging the hole and supporting the wire etc? How much of the wire was inside the box as opposed to outside? And how far was the wire end from the culture medium? Was the wire pointed at the end or flat? These are all relevant and important factors.

cogreslab said:
I take your point about the difficulties in measuring the exact fields being applied. It would be nice to do that, of course, but given that fields from a cellphone are all over the place anyway, depending e.g. on battery strength over time, it served little purpose when we specified the model and its operating conditions for anyone wishing to replicate.

What bothers me particularly is that on the basis of the information given I can't establish whether there was ANY field at all inside the box! Was the box grounded? Was the cell phone grounded in any way?

There is far too little information to enable replication!

cogreslab said:
We were trying to see if a) there was any adverse effect from the phone anyway, since if not the experiemnt was useful only to report that, and in that case we would need to get proper measurement data.

b) if the device could in any way mitigate such effects on viability as were there. Against that background the precise field strength was not vital information. Yes, the wire also might collect and feed stray fields into the exposed culture. We presumed that any such would be the same for exposed and control samples, and our Farnell spectrum analyser indicated no difference in spectra in any of the positions used.

A spectrum analyser would be singularly inappropriate as a measure of what was present. You would want to see the time domain information not the frequency domain. There would be no harm in adding frequency domain information to a time domain reading but on its own it would be unlikely to pick up anything significant. Also I am very puzzled as to how the spectra could be the same in all positions used. There are constant changes in the spectral pattern of ambient noise. If you got the same readings at different times in different places then something is seriously wrong with those readings.

For example, one of the things you should have picked up was radio stations. The content of radio stations does not stay the same all the time! The whole point of a radio station is that it has a continuously changing content and output. I don't think anybody would bother to set up radio stations (commercial) with a single constant tone output - that would be slightly boring as programme content! :)

Also I cannot possibly see how you can say that the precise field strength is not vital information. Are you kidding?! Your whole argument on here about EMF's etc is that the exposure levels are too HIGH. You believe that lower exposures are safer than higher ones and complain about other people's experiments where you claim they failed to measure all the parameters you believe they should of the relevant fields. In YOUR own experiments you have reached sweeping conclusions based on NO field measurements AT ALL!!!! How do you know that the fields inside the box were not MULTIPLIED by your experimental setup? Your results may be based on an abnormally HIGH field exposure, completely atypical of fields encountered in normal cirumstances, and yet you think that is NOT RELEVANT?!!!

cogreslab said:
Of course there are many other parameters than viability, and several ways of measuring viability. We were constrained in the amoun t of work we could do on this project.

BY using this simple and well characdterised trypan blue test on all these devices we can get a comparatve idea of their efficacy (many if not most of the devices like that we test show no effects and the results don't make it out of the lab. Now and again we find a device that shows some promise.)

So why don't you publish the negative reports? Science is all about showing results, good and bad. If you only show the results that fit the hypothesis then that is definitely NOT science.

Just how many devices have you tested?
 
I thought the later study was already on our website, or on the website of the Implosion people. I will have a look, and ask permission if I can release this (I can see no reason why not, but some of our work is not released thorugh the request of clients).
Please forgive me tonight but we are installing a new Polaris Q shortly and there are things I must do pre-installation.
 
Pragmatist said:

Thanks for explaining that. How big was the box? And how did the wire enter the box? I mean was there just a hole drilled in it? And if so, how big? Was there some insulator plugging the hole and supporting the wire etc? How much of the wire was inside the box as opposed to outside? And how far was the wire end from the culture medium? Was the wire pointed at the end or flat? These are all relevant and important factors.*snip*
I don't mean to walk all over your more than expert demolish....er... appraisal of Cogreslab techniques, so please excuse the interruption, but one of the *other* things that struck me with the description of this experiment was that the control did not have a gold wire in place as did all the other samples.

As such it doesn't strike me that the "control" sample.....was.

If fact if I was to be facetious, you could argue that gold wire was the common protective agent in this experiment.
 
Non Blinded counting: "It was an error similar to this that caused Jacques Benveniste to embarrass himself and all of science by inducing Nature to publish a completely delusional paper".

I could not let this one through: I thought JB blinded the data and the investigating team pasted the codes to the ceiling inside tinfoil? Then they photographed it frequently with a video camera (clever trick that!). Was I wrong to think this?
 
EHocking said:

I don't mean to walk all over your more than expert demolish....er... appraisal of Cogreslab techniques, so please excuse the interruption, but one of the *other* things that struck me with the description of this experiment was that the control did not have a gold wire in place as did all the other samples.

As such it doesn't strike me that the "control" sample.....was.

If fact if I was to be facetious, you could argue that gold wire was the common protective agent in this experiment.

Agreed. I'm genuinely trying to be fair here and give Roger a good hearing, but I must agree that so far things look decidedly suspicious to say the least!

I can think of dozens of possible influencing factors that have apparently not been taken into account, and the gold wire itself accounts for at least 3 of those. There might even be a legitimate argument that the gold itself had an adverse effect on lymphocyte viability regardless of whether it was in contact with the culture or not. But I'll save that until I know more about the experiment.

So far, the information is totally inadequate to draw any sensible conclusion at all, except that the probability is that the experiment is meaningless and invalid. I hope Roger will fill in the blanks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom