MRC_Hans
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2002
- Messages
- 24,967
Mmm this is strange. I have a couple of times asked Roger for the details about his in vitro experiment with the Harmonizer device. He has not replied. Since the information is near at hand, I'm tempted to suspect that he'd rather I did not look at it.
But I will. It is right here.
Analysis
Now, of course the first and foremost criticism of this experiment is that there is 1 (one) sample of every group. This alone is enough to reject the trial, since, while you may do math on the results, you cannot make any stastistical conclusions, simply because you cannot determine standard distributions for any of the groups. Since the test uses continous data of good resolution and credibility, it would not have taken much to overcome this obstacle: A mere 3 samples per group would have been enough.
Another serious problem is described here:
- Temperature differences.
- Humidity differences.
- Exposure to other ambient fields.
- Exposure to electrostatic discharge.
- Exposure to light.
- Exposure to mechanical disturbances.
This is a secondary reason to dismiss the trial.
A number of smaller problems exist, e.g.:
- The degree of exposure from the cellphone is unknown.
- It is not clear how cells were selected for counting, it is just stated that at least 500 were counted from each sample. Even it the counting is blinded, this procedure is doubtful.
- Devices were exposed to the harmonizer by connecting them via a wire that was brought into contact with the device. The wire remained in the sample (a similar wire was in the other samples). Obviously this means that even if a better designed test should verifiy this result, the test does not show anything about the Harmonizer device as such, since it does not exclude the possibility that touching the wire to any metal object would have the same effect.
Finally, both the begining and the end of the report contains a lot of irrelevant data cited from uncertain sources, and a lot of unsubstantiated speculation.
The information about the resonance frequenct of the harmonizer device is implausible. The frequency cited (625MHz) is based on half-wave resonance of a wire the lenght of an uncurled device, but since the device is curled in a double spiral, this assumption is wrong. It would be fairly easy to measure the actual resonance frequency, but it seems rather irrelevant.
My conclusion
The test is basically flawed, because the sample size is too small to enable the conclusions made, and because there are many serious potential confounders. Also, the design is not well suited to test for the desired effect, because even without the flaws, it would not be possible to reach an unambigous conclusion based on the results.
Mmm, Roger, you are awfully fond of Trypan Blue counts and samples in mu-metal containers with gold-wires. Are those the only kind of tests your laboratory can do
?
Hans
But I will. It is right here.
Analysis
Now, of course the first and foremost criticism of this experiment is that there is 1 (one) sample of every group. This alone is enough to reject the trial, since, while you may do math on the results, you cannot make any stastistical conclusions, simply because you cannot determine standard distributions for any of the groups. Since the test uses continous data of good resolution and credibility, it would not have taken much to overcome this obstacle: A mere 3 samples per group would have been enough.
Another serious problem is described here:
So the samples were placed in three different locations during the test. This means that a number of confounding factors could exist, most pertinently:One Personal Harmoniser-exposed sample and one unexposed sample were placed in separate mu-metal boxes and then exposed overnight to a Philips 301 mobile phone on standby, by means of a separate 30cm gold wire leading into each box. For the same period one Implosion-exposed sample and one unexposed sample were also placed in separate mu-metal boxes, into which separate but adjacent gold wires were introduced, but kept in a separate room and not near the cellphone. The final (fifth) sample was enclosed in a mu-metal box and then placed inside a double skinned mu-metal container for the duration of the experiment and maintained at 20 ° C.
- Temperature differences.
- Humidity differences.
- Exposure to other ambient fields.
- Exposure to electrostatic discharge.
- Exposure to light.
- Exposure to mechanical disturbances.
This is a secondary reason to dismiss the trial.
A number of smaller problems exist, e.g.:
- The degree of exposure from the cellphone is unknown.
- It is not clear how cells were selected for counting, it is just stated that at least 500 were counted from each sample. Even it the counting is blinded, this procedure is doubtful.
- Devices were exposed to the harmonizer by connecting them via a wire that was brought into contact with the device. The wire remained in the sample (a similar wire was in the other samples). Obviously this means that even if a better designed test should verifiy this result, the test does not show anything about the Harmonizer device as such, since it does not exclude the possibility that touching the wire to any metal object would have the same effect.
Finally, both the begining and the end of the report contains a lot of irrelevant data cited from uncertain sources, and a lot of unsubstantiated speculation.
The information about the resonance frequenct of the harmonizer device is implausible. The frequency cited (625MHz) is based on half-wave resonance of a wire the lenght of an uncurled device, but since the device is curled in a double spiral, this assumption is wrong. It would be fairly easy to measure the actual resonance frequency, but it seems rather irrelevant.
My conclusion
The test is basically flawed, because the sample size is too small to enable the conclusions made, and because there are many serious potential confounders. Also, the design is not well suited to test for the desired effect, because even without the flaws, it would not be possible to reach an unambigous conclusion based on the results.
Mmm, Roger, you are awfully fond of Trypan Blue counts and samples in mu-metal containers with gold-wires. Are those the only kind of tests your laboratory can do
Hans