Bioelectromagnetics

Prester John said:
hey i've got a Beckman DU 640B spectrophotometer, and an ABL 700 (which is not a spectrophotometer i hasten to add) within about 2 meters of me right now. Does that mean i'm a scientist or is ownership important in these matters?
Youp! ABL700 blood gas analyzer from Radiometer, Denmark. I worked 11 years for Radiometer. SURE it makes you a scientist!

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Since you like Peyton Rous so much, before I begin, here is a quotation from his Nobel Prize speech in 1966:

"What can be the nature of the generality of neoplastic changes, the reason for their persistence, their irreversibility, and for the discontinuous, steplike alterations that they frequently undergo? A favorite explanation has been that oncogens cause alterations in the genes of the cells of the body, somatic mutations as these are termed. But numerous facts, when taken together, decisively exclude this supposition".
Uhh, Roger: Do you possibly have a few references on cancer and such that are less than about 40 years old? You know, a few things have happened in science since then :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
*snip*
It would also help if you abandoned the continued and rather stale, unreasonable and not by any means supportable attacks on my ethics, character, qualifications, and all the other red herrings you have brought to bear in your efforts to avoid the issue when you cannot win the argument, to some other place (I have a part of the anatomy in mind).
Well, again, lumping it all in one thread was YOUR idea, not anybody else's.

The attacks on your ethics and character are only stale because you do not answer question on that subject. But I'll gladly try to revive them, and make a supportable attack:

I have twice earlier called you a liar and a swindler. Those who know me can tell you that I do not usually make such accusations, and certainly not lighheartedly. It is interesting that you have not reacted; if somebody called me a liar and a swindler, I would at the very least demand evidence, and failing that, an apology.

I'll make it simple here. On your website you have advertized a device called the Harmonizer for sale (in case this advertisment should suddenly be discontinued, I have ensured that documentation is held by independent parties). You claim that this device will protect against all types of RF waves. The device is a small metal pendant. Since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around, and since it will only cover an negligible part of the wearer's anatomy at any one time, the claim is a lie. Since you try to make people pay you money based on that lie, you are a swindler.

Just indicate if you want to make you case here or in a different thread.

As to what this has to do with the main subjects of the thread, well it is one yardstick with which to evaluate your honesty and credibility.

Your qualifications are, of course, far from irrelevant. I do not hereby mean your formal degrees, which may or may not be relevant, but your evident level of knowledge and understanding within the disciplines in which you profess to make research and attempt to speak with authority.

Hans
 
To Hans:

You said ( of a small device called the Harmoniser):

"The device is a small metal pendant. Since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around, and since it will only cover an negligible part of the wearer's anatomy at any one time, the claim is a lie".

As usual Hans, you offer no evidence whatsoever about this device, no studies reporting negative effects, no scientific references, just your own value judgements based on 19th century physics.

Let's take a closer look:

a) "since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around"

Well do you know we have somewhere in our museum a little device. It is much smaller than a cat, and even smaller than a mouse. It is sold on the open market worldwide. It emits radio frequencies. But my goodness cats and mice just disappear into the distance when it is switched on. Yet I can't hear it and it doesn't affect me at all. (We don't sell this btw). What do you make of that Hans: because it is smaller than the animals it clearly affects, I presume it is a lie and swindle.

b) "since it will only cover a part of the wearer's anatomy it is a lie and a swindle".

Actually I have another device. I don't wear it around my neck, but I often have it in my breast pocket. A couple of friends had a similar thing. One of them bought it on the advice of the other. It was far too small to cover their neck, let alone their entire bodies. After using this thing for about six months one got lymphoma of the neck, just at the place where he used to operate it. To look at this thing you wouldn't expect that. A few months later the second friend also contracted lymphoma. In the same place, and on the same side he used to put the thing.

Of course it couldn't be any connection, since the thing was too small. It must be a lie on their part and a swindle, of course.

Now |I have another thing. Instead of a battery it absorbs only body heat and gets warm that way. It is made of a conductive metal, and in a curious shape but essentially a long rod turned into two spirals. At extremely weak levels, well below most instrument measureablity it radiates by transducing the thermal energy. Of course there is not similarlty between the two types of device, The first is a lie and a swindle, as you have proposed, because they are too small to have any effect on larger objects. And the second?

Maybe we had better do some tests first to disprove it has any biological effects on the cells of our bodies nearby, which are quite a few orders of magnitude smaller than this curious object.

Open your minds.
 
cogreslab said:
To Hans:

You said ( of a small device called the Harmoniser):

"The device is a small metal pendant. Since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around, and since it will only cover an negligible part of the wearer's anatomy at any one time, the claim is a lie".

As usual Hans, no evidence whatsoever about this device, no nstudies reporting negative effects, no scientific references, just your own value judgements based on 19th century physics.

Let's take a closer look:

a) "since it is too small to interfere with most of the tyu
pes of radio emission around"

Werll do you know we have somewhere in our museum a little device. It is much smaler than a cat, and even smaller than a mouse. It is sold on the open market worldwide. It emits radio frequencies. But my goodness cats and mice just disappear when it is switched on. Yet I can't hear it and it doesn't affect me at all. (We don't sell this btw). What do you make of that Hans: because it is smaller than the animals it clearly affects, I presume it is a lie and swindle.
It can be shown how that device works and exactly what it emits. But that is not the question.

What does your pendant emit? What sort of emission interferes with all types of RF waves? Unless you can describe how the device works, I'll have to say that you still appear to be a swindler.
 
Well Tricky, that is a great step forward! As you say, unless you can explain how it works (or, I suppose how it doesn't work, to be fair) you should be making any claims; or disclaims, to be equally fair.

Take the point?
 
In homage to Mercutio's thread:

There once was a bunch of pathetics
who pursued all potential heretics
With rude words like "woo"
and worse than that too,
Until Bioelectromagnetics.
 
So I see that we are returning to the pseudo-scientific bla bla ignoring the point of the whole discussion.

Nice limerick Roger I appreciate your sense of humor and I will nominate your post for the language award.

Now let's talk business.
 
cogreslab said:
Well Tricky, that is a great step forward! As you say, unless you can explain how it works (or, I suppose how it doesn't work, to be fair) you should be making any claims; or disclaims, to be equally fair.
Then simply explain how it works, fair enough?
 
Roger, I want to amend my claim that you are a liar and a swindler. You are also an idiot.

cogreslab said:
To Hans:

You said ( of a small device called the Harmoniser):

"The device is a small metal pendant. Since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around, and since it will only cover an negligible part of the wearer's anatomy at any one time, the claim is a lie".

As usual Hans, no evidence whatsoever about this device, no studies reporting negative effects, no scientific references, just your own value judgements based on 19th century physics.

No, i will not bother to direct you to elementary textbook knowledge about the way electromagnetic waves propagate. Do your own basic homework. That is the least one can expect of somebody who claims to be a scientist. And of course, since you make a claim, you provide the evidence, remember?

Let's take a closer look:

a) "since it is too small to interfere with most of the types of radio emission around"

Well do you know we have somewhere in our museum a little device. It is much smaler than a cat, and even smaller than a mouse. It is sold on the open market worldwide. It emits radio frequencies. But my goodness cats and mice just disappear into the distance when it is switched on.

No, it emits sound waves (and the effect is debatable). You know, this is bl**dy pathetic; I know more about your device than you do.

Yet I can't hear it and it doesn't affect me at all. (We don't sell this btw). What do you make of that Hans: because it is smaller than the animals it clearly affects, I presume it is a lie and swindle.

It may or may not be, but it is certainly irrelevant to the Harmonizer. After all, radio waves do not behave like cats and mice ;).

b) "since it will only cover a part of the wearer's anatomy it is a lie and a swindle".

Actually I have another device. I don't wear it around my neck, but I often have it in my breast pocket. A couple of friends had a similar thing. One of them bought it on the advice of the other. It was far too small to cover their neck, let alone their entire bodies. After using this thing for about six months one got lymphoma of the neck, just at the place where he used to operate it. To look at this thing you wouldn't expect that. A few months later the second friend also contracted lymphoma. In the same place, and on the same side he used to put the thing.

Of course it couldn;'t be any connection, since the thing was too small. It must be a lie on their part and a swindle, of course.

It may be, or it may not be, but it is irrelevant.

Now |I have another thing. Instead of a battery it absorbs only body heat and gets warm that way. It is made of a conductive metal, and in a curious shape but essentially a long rod turned into two spirals. At extremely weak levels, well below most instrument measureablity it radiates by transducing the thermal energy.

It radiates IR waves, which are easily detectable. The rest is technobabble.

Of course there is not similasrltity between the two tyopes of device, The fisrt is a lie and a swindle, as you have proposed, because they are too small to have any effect on larger objects. And the second?

Whatever it could radiate, how does that enable it to protect the bearer against RF emissions? Your silly technobabble isn't even logically consistent. The device is slightly warm so it naturally emits some heat. How does that heat interfere with radio waves? Are you mad or something?

Maybe we had better do some tests first to disprove itn has any biological effects on the cells which are quite a few orders of magnitude smaller than this curous object.

Open your minds. [/B]
Booo! Honestly, Roger, you disappoint me. Couldn't you have done better than that?

Or is your knowledge of physics really that bad? :rolleyes:

Hans
 
Sure, Tricky, be glad to offer some thoughts about that. But why don't we get Hans's mindset opened first? He has condemned something he doesn't understand without asking or trying to find out anything about it or its concept. My grannie would have condemned TV as a lie and a fraud for the same lack of reasons, simply because it was outside her frame of reference at that time.
On her understanding, forged in line with the received opinion of the day, she would have been looking to find the man inside the TV set.

Be skeptical, of course. It is an essential and precious quality. but open your minds.
 
cogreslab said:
Well Tricky, that is a great step forward! As you say, unless you can explain how it works (or, I suppose how it doesn't work, to be fair) you should be making any claims; or disclaims, to be equally fair.

Take the point?
No. YOU claim it works. YOU charge people money for it. YOU document that it works.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Sure, Tricky, be glad to offer some thoughts about that. But why don't we get Hans's mindset opened first.
No, let's not. I am very curious about this device, because it appears to be able to transcend the laws of physics. My mind is open. Let's see what you have for filler.
 
To Hans:

And until you have heard that evidence, Hans, you stop calling me a liar and a swindler. In this country people are judged innocent until proved guilty, and not the other way around.
 
cogreslab said:
Sure, Tricky, be glad to offer some thoughts about that. But why don't we get Hans's mindset opened first? He has condemned something he doesn't understand without asking or trying to find oput anything about it or its concept. My grannie would have condemned TV as alie and a fraud for the same lack of reasons, simply because it was outside her frame of reference at that time.
On her understanding, forged in line with the received opinion of the day, she would have been looking to find the man inside the TV set.

Open your minds.
Dear Roger. I happen to know the laws of physics (apparantly unlike you). Of course, the laws of physics are always amendable, given sufficient proof. So, Roger, PLEASE do explain how your little copper tube double spiral is able to:

1) Interfere with EM waves that have a wavelength much longer than the device.

2) Interfere with EM waves that do not pass it.

The world eagerly awaits your response, which, should it be viable, will call for an almost complete rewriting of basic electromagnetic theory.

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
To Hans:

And until you have heard that evidence, Hans, you stop calling me a liar and a swindler. In this country people are judged innocent until proved guilty, and not the other way around.
I can't wait to hear it. When you have presented it, I shall publicly withdraw my statements. Till then, they stand.

Hans
 
It radiates IR waves, which are easily detectable. The rest is technobabble.


Wow, I can hardly believe this breakthrough! You are actually conceding this thing is emitting IR by thermal transduction? Any idea at what IR frequencies, - is it far IR for example or near IR? Let's say 4-14 microns in length, perhaps?
 
O.K. at this point I note that apparently several things have again been evaded (if Roger would care to address them properly now, I will retract that statement).

To Roger:

1.) Are you prepared to admit that you were wrong about the Lai/Singh experiment not taking electric fields into account?

2.) Are you prepared to apologise (to Dr's Lai and Singh) for misrepresenting their experiment?

3.) Would you please clarify the outstanding issue about your biological qualification?

4.) Are you prepared to take any action in respect of the web sites etc., that you claim are misrepresenting you? And if so, what and when?
 
cogreslab said:
Wow, I can hardly believe this breakthrough! You are actually conceding this thing is emitting IR by thermal transduction? Any idea at what IR frequencies, - is it far IR for example or near IR? Let's say 4-14 microns in length, perhaps?
That shows how it doesn't work. Now can we have your explanation on how it does work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom