Bioelectromagnetics

Not being a physicist, I have no plans to move outside normal science. I do however want to see if it still works exactly the same at cellular type environments, i.e. at a molecular or submolecular level. Maybe there are a few small mods to make but nothing special, no doubt. I suppose we might call this area quantum biology..
 
"That shows how it doesn't work".

Er, I must have missed somehting here. I thought we had only established that this curious device is emitting IR. A ridiculously weak radiator in fact?

Now I am not a radio engineer, but are not there some rules about how antennae radiate? Isn't the physical length and shape part of the way the resulting signal is characterised? Educate me.
 
cogreslab said:
To Hans:

And until you have heard that evidence, Hans, you stop calling me a liar and a swindler. In this country people are judged innocent until proved guilty, and not the other way around.
So produce the scientific evidence.

Pretty simple request, really.

And since it is *you* who is promoting and selling this device, the onus is on *you* to produce the supporting evidence.
 
While we wait for a reply from Hans, let's descend into the world of the organic cell. Most cells are a few microns across: platelets maybe a couple of microns; erythrocytes probably about five to seven. Lymphocytes can vary but maybe 4 to 14 microns is a good estimate. And then there are the "megalos" (Hey Cleo Megalos is Greek for big, right?) Interesting how all these cells have diameters which are the same lengths as those of the IR region, isnt it? And they are obviously far smaller than this curious thing, which is a lie and a swindle.

And wait a minute, didn't Hans say that if the device was larger than the object it radiated, then it might have an effect? Or did I get that wrong too? (I get so many things wrong, it seems! Must be my age).

But again, in reality are not we all made of cells, anyway, suirrounded by ECF (extracellular fluids). Even though we consider ourselves as one single "organism". So, asa speculation, something which radiates at the same wavelength as the object it encounters might give a buzz to that object too? Er, Isn't that how receiving aerials work, Hans. Educate me.
 
cogreslab said:
Wow, I can hardly believe this breakthrough! You are actually conceding this thing is emitting IR by thermal transduction? Any idea at what IR frequencies, - is it far IR for example or near IR? Let's say 4-14 microns in length, perhaps?

I require proof that the alleged emission is in the range 4 to 14 microns. I do not accept your word that it is in this range. I believe that it should be in a totally different range to that.

Please show the spectral pattern of the device and describe how it was measured. If you don't know how to post it, just ask and we will help you.
 
cogreslab said:
Well Tricky, that is a great step forward! As you say, unless you can explain how it works (or, I suppose how it doesn't work, to be fair) you should be making any claims; or disclaims, to be equally fair.
So please explain how you think it works and provide the scientific evidence particular to that device that supports your claims.
Take the point?
Do you?
 
Good question, Prag! Another mind is opening. But I've got a better idea: why don't I send you one of these things (which is a lie and a swindle, as we all know) and you can use your instruments to find the answer. After, all, you would not believe me, because you say I am no scientist, and even if we have the instruments (spectrum analyusers, oscilloscopes and all that rubbish) we don't know how to use them in this lab. It takes a real scientist like you to do that.


******

Now that's funny. My Reply button has disappeared!

And it seems like Hans, sensibly, has gone to bed. So now will I. Night, folks!
 
Tricky said
That shows how it doesn't work".
cogreslab said:
Er, I must have missed something here. I thought we had only established that this curious device is emitting IR. A ridiculously weak radiator in fact?
Yep. You admit that it doesn't work that way, since IR frequencies are much different than the RF that is is supposed to nullify.

cogreslab said:
Now I am not a radio engineer, but are not there some rules about how antennae radiate? Isn't the physical length and shape part of the way the resulting signal is characterised? Educate me.
I am hoping you will educate me. I stand here with this tremendously open mind hoping you can tell me how this device manages to do what you say it can do. I am not a radio engineer either, though I understand basic principles, so I would not be likely to advertise such a thing unless I had a pretty good idea how it worked. You have advertised it, so I expect you to have done your homework. I am on receiving frequency. Please transmit.
 
cogreslab said:
Good question, Prag! Another mind is opening. But I've got a better idea: why don't I send you one of these things (which is a lie and a swindle, as we all know) and you can use your instruments to find the answer. After, all, you would not believe me, because you say I am no scientist, and even if we have the instruments (spectrum analyusers, oscilloscopes and all that rubbish) we don't know how to use them in this lab. It takes a real scientist like you to do that.

I don't have IR spectrum measuring equipment.

And you cannot claim that anybody would refuse to believe the data unless/until you submit it.

You must HAVE such data already. If you don't, then why would you have any reason to believe the emission lay in the claimed range? And I thought you had qualified physicists in your laboratory? Are you now denying that? You have stated that YOU are not a physicist - that is obvious to us all. But you claim to employ physicists, therefore if your claim is true you have the capability to deliver the requested data do you not?

You asked us earlier to act reasonably toward you. That is what I am doing. I am giving you the opportunity to submit the kind of proof you say you have.
 
cogreslab said:
It radiates IR waves, which are easily detectable. The rest is technobabble.


Wow, I can hardly believe this breakthrough! You are actually conceding this thing is emitting IR by thermal transduction? Any idea at what IR frequencies, - is it far IR for example or near IR? Let's say 4-14 microns in length, perhaps?
Jeeesh, Roger, ANY object that has a temperature above 0 K emits IR waves. Your device will emit according to its temperature. Since that temperature will be somewhere between ambient temperature and body temperature, we are certainly talking far IR. For a few hundred pounds, you can buy an instrument that can measure the temperature within a degree from several yards away.

I dont quite know what you mean by "thermal transduction"; that is not a normally used term, but since the heat energy is largely transferred to the device by heat conduction (from the body heat of the wearer) and is transferred from the device by radiation (some of it), I suppose it is OK to call it "transduction".

Now, having established that, we are waiting to hear what on Earth this has to do with the alleged protective properties of the device :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
*sigh*
cogreslab said:
"That shows how it doesn't work".

Er, I must have missed somehting here. I thought we had only established that this curious device is emitting IR. A ridiculously weak radiator in fact?

Nothing curious about it. After all, it is just a piece of metal. No, it is not a particularly weak radiator, I don't know how you get that idea. It will radiate at frequencies and intensities like any object with a comparable temperature.

Now I am not a radio engineer,

That has been painfully clear for some time.

but are not there some rules about how antennae radiate? Isn't the physical length and shape part of the way the resulting signal is characterised? Educate me.

Certainly! However, this device does not radiate as an antenna. An antenna radiates a wave from a signal that is somehow fed to it as an electrical signal. An object at some temperature radiates IR in a fashion that is called "black body radiation", and this form of radiation is typically litle dependent on the shape of the object, because any point on the surface radiates equally in all directions.


Hans
 
cogreslab said:
While we wait for a reply from Hans, let's descend into the world of the organic cell. Most cells are a few microns across: platelets maybe a couple of microns; erythrocytes probably about five to seven. Lymphocytes can vary but maybe 4 to 14 microns is a good estimate. And then there are the "megalos" (Hey Cleo Megalos is Greek for big, right?) Interesting how all these cells have diameters which are the same lengths as those of the IR region, isnt it? And they are obviously far smaller than this curious thing, which is a lie and a swindle.

And wait a minute, didn't Hans say that if the device was larger than the object it radiated, then it might have an effect? Or did I get that wrong too? (I get so many things wrong, it seems! Must be my age).

Like language. "if the device was larger than the object it radiated" What does that sentence mean? I never heard of anything that radiated an object.

But again, in reality are not we all made of cells, anyway, suirrounded by ECF (extracellular fluids). Even though we consider ourselves as one single "organism". So, asa speculation, something which radiates at the same wavelength as the object it encounters might give a buzz to that object too? Er, Isn't that how receiving aerials work, Hans. Educate me.
Well, at least I can now see where you are heading. That's nice ;).

Soo, what you say is:

- The device is not working by interefering with the incoming RF radiation, which would be against the laws of physics.

- Instead it works by emitting some radiation which enables the cells of the body to better withstand the effect of the RF radiation.

- And this healing radiation is the IR radiation it emits, powered by the body heat of the bearer, possibly agmented by some special radiation characteristic resultant from its particular shape.

Did I get that right?

Edited to add: I will not waste my time addressing the technical points till we have established exactly what the mode of function it is that Mr. Coghill claims is in action.

Hans
 
Cleopatra said:
Well I don't really care so much about Mr.Coghill's education ( although I am sure that he has studied the Classics) but he is the one who has repeatedly brought it as an argument.

As Pragmatist was kind enough to remind us we have some very simple issues here.

Mr. Coghill promotes crystals that suppose to protect people from EMF without indicating that he doesn't know if those crystals work in vivo. When asked if he has contacted the firm to ask them to correct this huge mistake he replies that it's not to his interest to oblige the company that sells those crystals to modify their advertisment.

What sort of reply is that? If I wasn't religious I would reply to this question myself.

Even if Mr. Coghill was laureated with a Nobel Award this along with his Challenge would be enough to make people suspicious and reject his claims.

I will keep reposting this until I get a satisfying answer.


Mr. Coghill could you please answer to this post?
 
Are you now denying that?

No we not only have physics graduate(employee) , but also physical chemists (weekly visiting consultant).
 
Mr. Coghill promotes crystals that suppose to protect people from EMF without indicating that he doesn't know if those crystals work in vivo.

I am not aware of any statement promoting crystals on our website, but perhaps you could point to it?

When you asked me if these things work I told you I didnt know, and the best way of protecting yourself was to limit the duration of your calls.

Most reasonable people would regard that as an answer to your question, IMHO.

I can't force peole to change anything they say on their website, or to stop them misrepresenting our work for their own ends. If you have some way of doing that please tell me and I'll do it!

Cleopatra, this harping on about crytstals is counterproductive.
 
Hans said: However, this device does not radiate as an antenna. An antenna radiates a wave from a signal that is somehow fed to it as an electrical signal.

I do not agree. Does anyone else here agree?
 
cogreslab said:
Cleopatra, this harping on about crytstals is counterproductive.

What I consider counterproductive is to see you arguing about ambiguous matters in a pseudo-scientific way.

You advertize woo-woo crystals. Why you do that?
 
cogreslab said:
Hans said: However, this device does not radiate as an antenna. An antenna radiates a wave from a signal that is somehow fed to it as an electrical signal.

I do not agree. Does anyone else here agree?
What do you not agree with?

That this device does not radiate as an antenna, or that antennae radiate signals from a signal fed to them?

Hans
 
Am i missing something here, is cogreslab saying that because it emits IR in the 4-14 (which is currently a claim, not proven) and because lymphocytes have a size of 4-14 (not true actually) they must interact somehow!!!!!

I must have missed the part where you explain how IR penetrates the skin. No more need be said.

And for reference here are some cells sizes:

Erythrocytes : 7.5
Basophils : 9-12
Eosinphils : 9-12
Neutrophils : 10-12
Monocytes : 9-17
Lympocytes : 7-8
Platelets : 2-3

Once more by saying lymphocytes are size 4-14 you have shown a basic ignorance of the subject.

Also for thoose who care, Mr Coghill has not even posted on the carcinogenesis thread yet. In case you missed it Mr Coghill, its in the science forum
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom