Bioelectromagnetics

Cleopatra: Is there anywhere a help file to explain how the items above this box work? Or how to imput tables, or pictures?
 
Pragmatist

Please add to your list Mr. Coghill's claims that because of the Establishment scientists lost research funds. This was a very serious accusation that would shed some light if we could verify it.

We still wait to hear from Dr. Henshaw.
 
You misrepresent your products.

How can I do that? They are on our website shop (except for Acumed, which I thought had been removed. Someone just now tells me the product is still available in Boots however, so my belief they had gone bust may be wrong).

True, we have done some in vitro reports for products of third parties, and in most cases we say that these do not mean the product works in vivo. But these are not our products.

For some reason we are persistently accused of selling crystals, but we don't sell crystals.

I am still puzzled as to how you have reached that conclusion.
 
cogreslab said:
It would also help if you abandoned the continued and rather stale, unreasonable and not by any means supportable attacks on my ethics, character, qualifications, and all the other red herrings you have brought to bear in your efforts to avoid the issue when you cannot win the argument, to some other place (I have a part of the anatomy in mind).

Sorry for the double posting before, I got a database error and it timed out so I hit submit again because I thought it hadn't got through.

Roger: Let's address this issue rationally.

Firstly, yes, some people have been unkind to you initially. But in all fairness, when you make improbable claims one has to expect that sort of thing. Nobody is stopping you from making your case.

On your website you maintain your "challenge" which is morally and ethically repugnant to any civilised human being. It is also probably illegal as I have mentioned. You claim to understand that it is immoral and unethical, yet you refuse to remove and/or modify it on the grounds that some other parties do worse (in your opinion). I would simply remind you that unethical behaviour in others does not excuse it in yourself. As long as you maintain that position you cannot reasonably expect to be treated with anything OTHER than contempt.

Therefore sir, I put it to you, that YOU brought the issue of your ethics right into our faces. Do not expect us to ignore it!

It is also perfectly legitimate to question the character of someone who engages in immoral and unethical behavior.

In addition, you have frequently raised your qualifications in support of your arguments. You have even claimed intellectual superiority to others on the basis of your alleged qualifications. Therefore, once again, it is YOU who have brought the question of your qualifications into the arena so to speak. It is the nature (if not the DUTY) of skeptics to question EVERYTHING. Therefore you cannot possibly reasonably claim to be surprised or offended that some skeptics attempt to verify and/or test whether your claims of superior qualification are indeed true.

The fact that you make money out of selling devices that are of questionable validity and may mislead the public is also relevant. It brings the question of your motives for doing so, and any profit you make from this activity also into the spotlight.

You have frequently been insulting, condescending and sarcastic to others. You persist in this behavior. Regardless of whether or not it may be justified in your own mind, if you want it to stop then you have to stop doing it yourself. Personally, I don't care if you insult me, and I am quite happy to insult you back. But a lot of the insults you attract are expressions of frustration and exasperation because of your constantly evasive behavior AND the fact that some of your assertions are outright insults to the intelligence of others. If you try being straightforward and honest for a change you might gain more respect.

In addition, some of it is just silly joking. I often make silly jokes because that's my character. Human beings are complex and not all the same. One has to make allowances for individual expression.

You have frequently been insulting to people who have NOT insulted you first. You persist in applying epithets to groups of people without any apparent recognition that the actions of an individual do NOT necessarily apply to whatever group they fall into. You cannot possibly claim to be surprised that if you insult ALL skeptics that other skeptics then consider you fair game.

Your own posting above illustrates my points perfectly. You appeal for people to treat you with respect and you end it with an insult to those very people. Are you HONESTLY surprised that you will attract flak for that?

Another point is that near the beginning of this thread, you insulted Darat, quite unreasonably as he hadn't done what you accused him of. But you made the point there that you felt that others were failing to admit when they were wrong. A classical phrase springs to mind here - "et tu brute"! YOU almost NEVER admit when you are wrong. You have been PROVEN wrong time and time again. Your tactic is to simply avoid the issue. Where are YOUR admissions to that effect? Or apologies? You cannot reasonably expect others to apply a standard that you do not have the common courtesy to apply yourself. If you do not display intellectual honesty yourself, you are not in any position to demand it of others!

And finally, as just one concrete example of what I am saying. Yesterday you stated explicity in a posting that Dr's Lai and Singh had made a fundamental (and somewhat stupid) error in one of their experiments. I then proved that your assertion was wrong and asked you to apologise to Dr's Lai and Singh for misrepresenting their work. I didn't ask you to apologise to ME. So what happened Roger? You still haven't admitted you were wrong, nor have you made any apology.

As I have said elsewhere, you are a prime example of "Don't do as I do, do what I say". That, sir, is hypocrisy, pure and simple.
 
You misrepresent your research

This is also untrue. The peer reviewed work is there for all to see. Some of our research is commercial in confidence so we don't represent that at all. So when did we misrepresent our research? Do you not mean that other sites have misreported, or misrepresented our research, often without our knowledge or consent.
 
Your catalogue of judgements underlines my chief complaint about the posts on this thread:

I have identified numerous places above where categorical and inaccurate unsupported value judgments, mainly personal attacks on me, or my work, have been posted, without any attempt to justify them.

e.g: When I pointed out that the first four pages of my posts have been removed, you put into my mouth the claim that it is a deliberate consipracy. All I actually said was it was unfair!

Your attack on my degrees and the rather unfair (to put it mildly) claim that Iam variously:

a liar
a fraud
an idiot
etc

had to be deflated by someone with a better knowledge, who told you you were wrong and that you should cool down. Others have briought a good deal of evidence tyo this thread that my concerns about EMF have substance.
 
cogreslab said:
You misrepresent your education.

Not at all; but other posters have persistently dredged up misrepresentations. You won't find any fraudulent claims about my education on my site or in the posts on this one.

Excellent! We shall take you at your word. In which case you will surely not mind spelling out for us PRECISELY what your qualification in biology is.

I think we established that it was something in "Biological Sciences" but there is still some confusion as to whether it's a BA or something else, and what actual grade it is, and whether there was any particular specialisation within that title.

I forgot to mention in my last post that any evasion automatically invites suspicion that someone is trying to hide someone, which then also inevitably leads one to question their motives. Perhaps this is an opportunity to clear the air so to speak.
 
Well I don't really care so much about Mr.Coghill's education ( although I am sure that he has studied the Classics) but he is the one who has repeatedly brought it as an argument.

As Pragmatist was kind enough to remind us we have some very simple issues here.

Mr. Coghill promotes crystals that suppose to protect people from EMF without indicating that he doesn't know if those crystals work in vivo. When asked if he has contacted the firm to ask them to correct this huge mistake he replies that it's not to his interest to oblige the company that sells those crystals to modify their advertisment.

What sort of reply is that? If I wasn't religious I would reply to this question myself.

Even if Mr. Coghill was laureated with a Nobel Award this along with his Challenge would be enough to make people suspicious and reject his claims.

I will keep reposting this until I get a satisfying answer.
 
You misrepresent your products.

How can I do that? They are on our website shop (except for Acumed, which I thought had been removed. Someone just now tells me the product is still available in Boots however, so my belief they had gone bust may be wrong).

True, we have done some in vitro reports for products of third parties, and in most cases we say that these do not mean the product works in vivo. But these are not our products.

For some reason we are persistently accused of selling crystals, but we don't sell crystals.

I am still puzzled as to how you have reached that conclusion.

"Designed to help swollen ankles, tired and aching feet" Bullsh!t

"An organic food supplement especially designed to protect and boost the immune system" Bullsh!t

"Helps your dog get a better night sleep. This product is ideal for, arthritic joints, muscular complaints, skin problems, aches and pains, poor circulation" Bullsh!t

"Help your body’s own natural ability to heal itself, by improving your circulation" Bullsh!t


If you think "bullsh!t" is inappropriate, then provide, please two citations to randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies, published in peer-reviewed journals, and from two separate laboratories and research groups, supporting ANY of the above product claims.

Hey, see Roger, you not only can respond to multiple-part posts, you can EVEN merge two or more together, and respond to them! Unholy bovine, ain't science marvellous?



Your catalogue of judgements underlines my chief complaint about the posts on this thread:

I have identified numerous places above where categorical and inaccurate unsupported value judgments, mainly personal attacks on me, or my work, have been posted, without any attempt to justify them.

e.g: When I pointed out that the first four pages of my posts have been removed, you put into my mouth the claim that it is a deliberate consipracy. All I actually said was it was unfair!

Your attack on my degrees and the rather unfair (to put it mildly) claim that Iam variously:

a liar
a fraud
an idiot
etc

had to be deflated by someone with a better knowledge, who told you you were wrong and that you should cool down. Others have briought a good deal of evidence tyo this thread that my concerns about EMF have substance.
Bullsh!t, bullsh!t, bullsh!t, roger dodger. Your "better knowledge" continues to prove to be riddled with laughable errors, twisting of facts, dodging of questions, deflecting of issues, and dodgey dodgey word games.

Nearly every "attack," as you describe them, has been firmly based in evidence provided by you or uncovered by us.
 
cogreslab said:
You misrepresent your products.

How can I do that? They are on our website shop (except for Acumed, which I thought had been removed. Someone just now tells me the product is still available in Boots however, so my belief they had gone bust may be wrong).

True, we have done some in vitro reports for products of third parties, and in most cases we say that these do not mean the product works in vivo. But these are not our products.

For some reason we are persistently accused of selling crystals, but we don't sell crystals.

I am still puzzled as to how you have reached that conclusion.

And here is an example of one your responses that might be considered evasive. It was reasonably obvious from the context of the statement that "your products" referred to the products sold on your web site. It did not make (nor reasonably intend) any fine semantic distinction between products manufactured by others and sold by you, and products actually manufactured by you. When any of us refer to "your products" we are clearly referring to the products that you sell.

There is also a legitimate issue as to the extent to which you ENDORSE products that you do not actually sell directly. Your endorsements may be considered as auxiliary to a sales effort. I agree that you have never claimed to sell crystals as far as I am aware. But the question asked by Cleopatra related to your apparent endorsement of someone else's product. I, for one accept your statement that you did not directly endorse the product. But if anyone else sees reasonable evidence that suggests that you DO, then surely it is in your interests to deal with the matter decisively. If you claim a third party is misrepresenting you, then please ACT to end that misrepresentation. Because if you do not, if you are aware of the misrepresentation and do nothing to stop it, then one can only assume that you at least tacitly CONSENT to the misrepresentation. And that in itself is a form of misrepresentation.

An example is all the alleged misquotations of your qualifications as "Dr Coghill". If you really are concerned about this then you need to act to stop it. If you do not, we, and others will assume that maybe it suits your purposes for the misrepresentation to not only continue, but also to be propagated to others in the future.
 
I've started a thread in the science forum about carcinogenesis for Mr Coghill. If however mr coghill continues to talk about carcinogenesis on this thread i will respond on this thread.


regards

PJ
 
cogreslab said:
Your catalogue of judgements underlines my chief complaint about the posts on this thread:

I have identified numerous places above where categorical and inaccurate unsupported value judgments, mainly personal attacks on me, or my work, have been posted, without any attempt to justify them.

e.g: When I pointed out that the first four pages of my posts have been removed, you put into my mouth the claim that it is a deliberate consipracy. All I actually said was it was unfair!

Your attack on my degrees and the rather unfair (to put it mildly) claim that Iam variously:

a liar
a fraud
an idiot
etc

had to be deflated by someone with a better knowledge, who told you you were wrong and that you should cool down. Others have briought a good deal of evidence tyo this thread that my concerns about EMF have substance.

I assume you are addressing me?

And did I not apologise for any misstatement?

I refused to apologise for asking, because that was legitimate and continues to be.

I am not aware that I ever made any claim about the removal of your initial posts being part of a conspiracy etc., please would you show me where I made the alleged claim, and if necessary I will apologise for that.

I am also not aware that I called you an idiot in the process of questioning your qualifications. Once again, if I did I am prepared to apologise for that as soon as you point out to me where I did so and I can check the context.

With regard to other matters, you have made some frankly idiotic statements. I reserve the right to call a spade, a spade. As I said to you once before, if the shoe fits... If you don't want people to call you an idiot, stop acting like one.

I also note that you classify ANYTHING you don't want to hear as an "unsupported value judgement". It's become so old that its now quite meaningless. And don't forget, EVERYONE has the right to express an opinion as long as they make clear the distinction between opinion and fact.

As for your claims about EMF having substance, that depends on what your actual claim is. Nobody has disputed, as far as I am aware, the generic proposition that EMF CAN be harmful under certain conditions. What HAS been disputed is your claim as to the LEVEL of danger, and the NATURE of the danger i.e. electrical/magnetic etc. And, once again, I remind you that this was NOT the original issue you were asked to answer. You may of course address that issue, nobody is stopping you. But please don't use it to avoid answering the issues that were raised PRIOR to that and which you have still not answered satisfactorily.
 
Pragmatist said:
There is also a legitimate issue as to the extent to which you ENDORSE products that you do not actually sell directly. Your endorsements may be considered as auxiliary to a sales effort. I agree that you have never claimed to sell crystals as far as I am aware. But the question asked by Cleopatra related to your apparent endorsement of someone else's product. I, for one accept your statement that you did not directly endorse the product. But if anyone else sees reasonable evidence that suggests that you DO, then surely it is in your interests to deal with the matter decisively. If you claim a third party is misrepresenting you, then please ACT to end that misrepresentation. Because if you do not, if you are aware of the misrepresentation and do nothing to stop it, then one can only assume that you at least tacitly CONSENT to the misrepresentation. And that in itself is a form of misrepresentation.

Pragmatist.

It's this crystal that brought Mr. Coghill to this forum and he came here in order to defend it.

I have in my hands the flyer ( in Greek) that advertizes the product and it says that " The crystal has been tested sucessfully by the aknowldged laboratory " Coghill Research Laboratory" of Great Britain.

Now see the irony. Some years earlier Roger Coghill sues a store in Wales and now other stores in Britain and in Greece might increase the sales of the cell phones because Mr. Coghill advises people to buy cell-phones with no fear if they use this crystal.

This is too much and it's not like his theatrical challenge, it's real. People that they were hesitating to let their kids use cell phones might reconsider because Roger Coghill says so and look at this endless thread. It's filled with preaching about the morality of science, the risks that they are concealled by an invisible establishment and stuff.
 
Tricky said:
Very interesting, Cleopatra. Is there any chance you could scan that flyer and post it here? Or is that illegal?

Illegal? No. It's published on line as well.

Check here. This is the home page, you can see that there is a Greek version of the page too.

Here is the claim in English that the crystal has been tested by Mr. Coghill's Lab and here is in Greek. The Greek version is tad different because it says that Dr. Coghill is an aknowledged expert in Great Britain in the field of Electromagnetics.

Here is a photo of the flyer one can find in the largest computer shop in Athens, this is where I found it.
 
Cleopatra said:


I The Greek version is tad different because it says that Dr. Coghill is an aknowledged expert in Great Britain in the field of Electromagnetics.


"Dr." Coghill?
 
Cleopatra said:


Pragmatist.

It's this crystal that brought Mr. Coghill to this forum and he came here in order to defend it.

I have in my hands the flyer ( in Greek) that advertizes the product and it says that " The crystal has been tested sucessfully by the aknowldged laboratory " Coghill Research Laboratory" of Great Britain.

Now see the irony. Some years earlier Roger Coghill sues a store in Wales and now other stores in Britain and in Greece might increase the sales of the cell phones because Mr. Coghill advises people to buy cell-phones with no fear if they use this crystal.

This is too much and it's not like his theatrical challenge, it's real. People that they were hesitating to let their kids use cell phones might reconsider because Roger Coghill says so and look at this endless thread. It's filled with preaching about the morality of science, the risks that they are concealled by an invisible establishment and stuff.

Cleopatra: there wasn't any link with the post, but don't worry I can find it in the earlier thread.

I agree absolutely. And there is yet a further aspect to all this as well. Roger sued Wayne Morgan for selling mobile phones without a warning. He admits that Mr Morgan had no intention of causing harm and was happy to tell anyone the truth. Roger's real beef was with the mobile phone companies. Roger thought that he was justified in attacking and causing great inconvenience and inarguably some suffering to Mr Morgan because he felt it was for the "greater good".

And yet, when his own name is used to endorse a probably worthless and misleading product, Roger does a Pontius Pilate and washes his hands of the matter. He feels no moral responsibility to correct the error. He couldn't care less about the greater good if it puts HIM to any minor inconvenience.

This, to my mind shows ethical and moral bankruptcy. He sees no problem in destroying an innocent in order to get at his "enemy" (and doesn't his challenge propose the very same?), his argument is basically that the end justifies the means. But at the same time, when we see the REAL extent of his committment to the "greater good", we can only conclude that its all a sham. He does not have the greater good in mind if he doesn't act on this. So then his real motives come sharply into question do they not?
 
Dr. Kitten:

No no thanks for catching it. "Mr". Roger Coghill.

I do not edit my post, I post the correction here.

Pragmatist which post you need?
 
A quick summary of the original issue and how it has developed here, just so there is no more avoidance (updated to add Cleopatra's point about Henshaw etc.):

1. Roger sells a range of devices that amongst other things basically claim to "protect against EM radiation" (in one form or another - I am generalizing).

2. Roger claims he can "scientifically prove" the effectiveness of said devices.

3. Roger endorses a range of products made by other people as being effective (in-vitro). But any lay person reading these things would be unlikely to understand the distinction between in-vitro and in-vivo because it isn't spelled out in plain english for the most part.

4. Roger advertises these devices for sale in a manner that implies to any casual observer that they DO protect in-vivo, he avoids responsibility for this by saying that he DID mention only in-vitro in his "scientific reports".

5. Roger claims that his "scientific test" proves that "endogenous fields protect blood lymphocytes". He will not give a clear and unambiguous definition of "endogenous fields".

6. Roger further claims that his experimental technique not only proves the existence of said "endogenous fields" but also that his experiment is a valid metric of whether or not lymphocytes are "protected" by his (and other) devices. He has avoided answering repeated, direct questions as to certain specifics of this experiment.

7. Roger claims that he is only interested in the public welfare and that he is the victim of a conspiracy by various agencies including the NRPB. However, he admits conspiring himself with other unspecified individuals to bring a legal attack on a mobile phone vendor. He will not disclose his own financial involvement in this conspiracy or how much he benefits from others who have undisclosed agendas and interests of their own.

8. Roger claims that because of the Establishment scientists lost research funds, and he cited Dr Henshaw in support of this theory. Dr Henshaw has not replied to any query as to whether this is true or not.

These issues have still not been properly addressed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom