Bioelectromagnetics

cogreslab said:
Koch had learned with previous experiments on dogs that the quinone structure does not affect rabies favourably, so he treated some with diphenoquinone, one part to a billion, and some he used a serial system of carbonyls without the quinone structure, but of course is seen twice in parabenzoquinone. (you can imagine just how electronegative the oxygen end of these serial carbonyls is going to be! It will pull electrons off most structures). Koch accordingly used a dose of only a billionth of a microgram in a dose of 10 micrograms of distilled water. In the treated cases.

Oh, for goodness sake! As if we needed any MORE proof that you are simply spouting BS that you don't actually understand!

Would you please tell me what electrical charge an electron has? An electron is negatively charged, no?

So please would you explain to me how an electronegative radical can "PULL electrons off most structures"?

EXTREMELY BASIC PHYSICS (so basic it doesn't even come in at "101", this has to be "001" level!) - LIKE CHARGES REPEL!!!!!!

Jeez, this rubbish is TRULY an insult to anyone's intelligence!
 
MRC_Hans said:
Ranges? I thought you just changed the detector head. Anyhow, I fail to see what spectrophotometers have to do with any of the subjects at hand.

Mmm, I have a professional endoscope with a laser light source, an oscilloscope, several digital voltmeters, a couple of weathstone bridges, a multi-waveform function generator, an RS323 break-out pad, and a regulated power supply. Is that enough to make me a scientist or should I get a spectrum analyzer, too?

Hans

You'd have to change the emitter as well. The old ones were separate discrete instruments, I don't know if more modern ones are modular these days.

But I agree, it's of little relevance.

Hey, you know what? *I'VE* got a spectrum analyser! (smugness). So that PROVES that I MUST be a scientist! I will have to change my title to "Garbage Collection Scientist"! :)
 
Pragmatist said:


Oh, for goodness sake! As if we needed any MORE proof that you are simply spouting BS that you don't actually understand!

Would you please tell me what electrical charge an electron has? An electron is negatively charged, no?

So please would you explain to me how an electronegative radical can "PULL electrons off most structures"?

EXTREMELY BASIC PHYSICS (so basic it doesn't even come in at "101", this has to be "001" level!) - LIKE CHARGES REPEL!!!!!!

Jeez, this rubbish is TRULY an insult to anyone's intelligence!

I had glossed right over that one! This isn't even physics, pragmatist, this is basic chemistry. High school chemistry.
 
hey i've got a Beckman DU 640B spectrophotometer, and an ABL 700 (which is not a spectrophotometer i hasten to add) within about 2 meters of me right now. Does that mean i'm a scientist or is ownership important in these matters?
 
Since you like Peyton Rous so much, before I begin, here is a quotation from his Nobel Prize speech in 1966:

"What can be the nature of the generality of neoplastic changes, the reason for their persistence, their irreversibility, and for the discontinuous, steplike alterations that they frequently undergo? A favorite explanation has been that oncogens cause alterations in the genes of the cells of the body, somatic mutations as these are termed. But numerous facts, when taken together, decisively exclude this supposition".
 
Prester John said:
hey i've got a Beckman DU 640B spectrophotometer, and an ABL 700 (which is not a spectrophotometer i hasten to add) within about 2 meters of me right now. Does that mean i'm a scientist or is ownership important in these matters?

Well, you know what they say, possession is 9/10th's of the law! :)
 
MRC_Hans said:
Ahh, Lucy! Welcome on the Roger Coghill bashing team. Nice text! Of course it sorta puts a big hole into Mr. Coghill's claims about the multitude of cases of childhood leukaemia caused by power lines. And it also serves t odebunk his claims about the evil cover-up conspiracy. Seems there might be an effect, but it is too cmall to be visible from UK stastistics alone.

Good work, Luci! Does this mean that you no longer think Mr. Coghill is a genious?

.... Or... *gasp*:eek: could it be that you simply don't understand the implications of the report you cited?

Hans

You could indeed be right, Hans. You could indeed. But as far as I'm concerned here, the thread is about Bioelectromagnetics and the associated risks of chronic em exposure. Well, at least it was at the start of the thread. lol! The article reinforces the overall evidence that supports the claims about the associated risks.
 
Hey, I'm beginning to like this Rous. Here's another insight from the same speech, this time for those arguing for genetic transfer:

Nature sometimes seems possessed of a sardonic humor. In the 1930's a group of American geneticists, long concerned with the incidence of "spontaneous" tumors in rodents, undertook to determine how a pronounced liability of female mice of certain strains to develop mammary carcinomas as they grow old is inherited; and by breeding tests they came upon the astounding fact that this liability reaches the young from their mothers. How can this be? Was it passed on through the ovum, the placenta, or what? A member of their group made a revealing test soon afterwards. He arranged for some of the young of the strain under study to be suckled from birth by mice of a breed in which the cancers do not occur; and the mice thus wet-nursed never had any! His later work showed that the liability to these cancers had been due to a virus passed on to the young in their very first milk. This virus lay latent within them until they matured, and then it caused orderly, benign tumors in the breasts of the females; and from these growths carcinomas derived by steplike changes like those already described. To this day no virus directly responsible for the cancers has been obtained from these, but only the "milk virus" producing the benign growths. The problem of the actuating cause of the cancers remains unsolved like that of the V x 2 carcinoma of rabbits4. In both instances the virus causing the benign tumor was no more than an initiator of the malignant growth deriving from them.

Any way, Congrats on finding my little buried gaffe. I wondered if anyone would spot it, especially since I had already pointed out that like charges repel in an earlier thread. You should know by now I like a good wind up. But then so do you b****rs!
 
drkitten said:


This mistake from a classicist? I'm rather surprised at you, Mr. Coghill.

Eratosthenes had an accurate estimate of the diameter of the round earth about 200 BCE; by the high middle ages, it was an accepted part of the standard cosmology. Heck, Dante (14th century) even knew about time zones....

You are right there. The Hellenistic culture were the first to really posit the "What if..." way of thinking. It is a philospohy that is sadly overlooked by many of todays closed-minded scientists.

I think the point is that there is no divine scientific 'Truth'. Science progresses one grave at a time.
 
cogreslab said:
Since you like Peyton Rous so much, before I begin, here is a quotation from his Nobel Prize speech in 1966:

"What can be the nature of the generality of neoplastic changes, the reason for their persistence, their irreversibility, and for the discontinuous, steplike alterations that they frequently undergo? A favorite explanation has been that oncogens cause alterations in the genes of the cells of the body, somatic mutations as these are termed. But numerous facts, when taken together, decisively exclude this supposition".

For pity's sake, you don't understand what he said here, do you? He is speaking of the histological changes of cancer. He is not questioning the genetic origin, but commenting on the lack of understanding (in 1966) of how the neoplastic character of malignancies arise. His comment, sir, concerned the lack of understanding of the regulation of gene expression and the lack of understanding of cellular differentiation.
 
...and you will of course recall that the speech was in 1966 and it was not until 1971 that Howard Temin suggested that oncogenes might be found in normal cells, and it was not until the mid 70's that the first gene homologous to the v-src gene found.

Anyway i rather suspect you are diverting the discussion, rather than deal with basic mistakes you have made in your Koch essay.
 
Lucianarchy said:
You could indeed be right, Hans. You could indeed. But as far as I'm concerned here, the thread is about Bioelectromagnetics and the associated risks of chronic em exposure. Well, at least it was at the start of the thread. lol! The article reinforces the overall evidence that supports the claims about the associated risks.

Luci, let's get this clear so nobody is in any doubt.

Roger hijacked Cleopatra's thread which was specifically addressing the issue of the woo woo protective devices that Roger sells, as well as his general credibility and ethics. Roger attempted to wriggle out of that by starting THIS topic, insisting it was an issue of "bioelectromagnetics" and that he would answer HERE. And then he immediately started attempting to redirect the discussion to HIS theories regarding EM safety etc. Here is his posting from the other thread:

cogreslab said:
I would be grateful if all comments etc regarding bioelectromagnetics in any of its aspects be directed to my thread titled Bioelectromagnetics, where quite a decent dialogue seems to be developing. It saves me looking at several different threads to keep in the argument. Must go now. I will be going back to this issue of amplification on that thread later.

Now, nobody is stopping him or anyone else from addressing that. The issue of general EM safety is NOT being addressed in any thread, because Roger is making specific claims, and most of us are concerned with addressing untenable CLAIMS.

As a matter of simple courtesy if nothing else, we should address Cleopatra's issues first as it legitimately has priority. Roger's claims regarding EM come second. His theories regarding cancer take a very dim third in my mind. Every time he is proven wrong in one area he tries to change the subject.

If you want to debate the general issue of EM safety, without reference to Roger's specific claims, then why not start a new thread?
 
"If you want to debate the general issue of EM safety, without reference to Roger's specific claims, then why not start a new thread?".

Certainly this thread is getting unwieldy, and I am puzzled as to how all my first four pages of comment have disappeared completely, leaving only the responses of critics. Bit unfair, that, to put it mildly!

May I suggest that we move all discussion of cancer mechanisms to a new thread, rather than destroy all this argument about EMF which was the reason i started the thread.

It would also help if you abandoned the continued and rather stale, unreasonable and not by any means supportable attacks on my ethics, character, qualifications, and all the other red herrings you have brought to bear in your efforts to avoid the issue when you cannot win the argument, to some other place (I have a part of the anatomy in mind).
 
A quick summary of the original issue and how it has developed here, just so there is no more avoidance:

1. Roger sells a range of devices that amongst other things basically claim to "protect against EM radiation" (in one form or another - I am generalizing).

2. Roger claims he can "scientifically prove" the effectiveness of said devices.

3. Roger endorses a range of products made by other people as being effective (in-vitro). But any lay person reading these things would be unlikely to understand the distinction between in-vitro and in-vivo because it isn't spelled out in plain english for the most part.

4. Roger advertises these devices for sale in a manner that implies to any casual observer that they DO protect in-vivo, he avoids responsibility for this by saying that he DID mention only in-vitro in his "scientific reports".

5. Roger claims that his "scientific test" proves that "endogenous fields protect blood lymphocytes". He will not give a clear and unambiguous definition of "endogenous fields".

6. Roger further claims that his experimental technique not only proves the existence of said "endogenous fields" but also that his experiment is a valid metric of whether or not lymphocytes are "protected" by his (and other) devices. He has avoided answering repeated, direct questions as to certain specifics of this experiment.

7. Roger claims that he is only interested in the public welfare and that he is the victim of a conspiracy by various agencies including the NRPB. However, he admits conspiring himself with other unspecified individuals to bring a legal attack on a mobile phone vendor. He will not disclose his own financial involvement in this conspiracy or how much he benefits from others who have undisclosed agendas and interests of their own.

These issues have still not been properly addressed.
 
A quick summary of the original issue and how it has developed here, just so there is no more avoidance:

1. Roger sells a range of devices that amongst other things basically claim to "protect against EM radiation" (in one form or another - I am generalizing).

2. Roger claims he can "scientifically prove" the effectiveness of said devices.

3. Roger endorses a range of products made by other people as being effective (in-vitro). But any lay person reading these things would be unlikely to understand the distinction between in-vitro and in-vivo because it isn't spelled out in plain english for the most part.

4. Roger advertises these devices for sale in a manner that implies to any casual observer that they DO protect in-vivo, he avoids responsibility for this by saying that he DID mention only in-vitro in his "scientific reports".

5. Roger claims that his "scientific test" proves that "endogenous fields protect blood lymphocytes". He will not give a clear and unambiguous definition of "endogenous fields".

6. Roger further claims that his experimental technique not only proves the existence of said "endogenous fields" but also that his experiment is a valid metric of whether or not lymphocytes are "protected" by his (and other) devices. He has avoided answering repeated, direct questions as to certain specifics of this experiment.

7. Roger claims that he is only interested in the public welfare and that he is the victim of a conspiracy by various agencies including the NRPB. However, he admits conspiring himself with other unspecified individuals to bring a legal attack on a mobile phone vendor. He will not disclose his own financial involvement in this conspiracy or how much he benefits from others who have undisclosed agendas and interests of their own.

These issues have still not been properly addressed.
 
cogreslab said:
Certainly this thread is getting unwieldy, and I am puzzled as to how all my first four pages of comment have disappeared completely, leaving only the responses of critics. Bit unfair, that, to put it mildly!
By all means, cite that as more evidence of this wide-ranging conspiracy!

May I suggest that we move all discussion of cancer mechanisms to a new thread, rather than destroy all this argument about EMF which was the reason i started the thread.
You are the chief problem, here, roger dodger. Make no mistake about it. You post 10 responses to a single post. You deflect. You distract. You are the root cause of this discursive thread and the sole cause of the lack of resolution to any issues.

It would also help if you abandoned the continued and rather stale, unreasonable and not by any means supportable attacks on my ethics, character, qualifications, and all the other red herrings you have brought to bear in your efforts to avoid the issue when you cannot win the argument, to some other place (I have a part of the anatomy in mind).
These "attacks" are all squarely rooted in your own words and deeds:
o You misrepresent your education
o You misrepresent your products
o You misrepresent your research

Other than those small problems, roger, of course, there is no reason to question your ethics, character or qualifications. And on the matter of qualifications, sir, there again, you are the sole cause of the problem. You began calling for, nay, demanding, the qualifications of several posters on this thread. You then began squealing as we began to investigate your own qualifications.

The duplicity is yours and yours alone.
 
I happen to have saved the first pages of the thread Mr. Coghill. Do you want me to repost any of your first posts here?
 
You are the chief problem, here, roger dodger. Make no mistake about it. You post 10 responses to a single post. You deflect. You distract. You are the root cause of this discursive thread and the sole cause of the lack of resolution to any issues.

It is not easy to asnwer posts demanding ten complicated answers in one replying post. On many occasions I have found myself timed-out, and this has meant either i dont respond or I split the replies up, to avoid timeouts. Gradually |I am learning how the mechanics iof this site work, but there are still things I cannot do e.g. quotes, pictures, and this against a backgroundn of four or five persistent questioners and debunkers, so I have to stop and defend some outrageous attacks.
 
Mr. Coghill what is that you don't know? You can always ask us or a moderator to help you out.

At the beginning you knew well to quote what happened later?
 
You misrepresent your education.

Not at all; but other posters have persistently dredged up misrepresentations. You won't find any fraudulent claims about my education on my site or in the posts on this one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom