Bioelectromagnetics

While Roger ponders about what to do with the perhaps frightingly clear questions above, I have looked around for some concrete figures on IR:

The infrared spectrum goes from 0,7 micrometer and down to microwave. There seems to be consensus about putting the limit at 1000 micrometer (yes, that's a millimeter). When I say down, I'm referring to frequency, which is reciprocal to wavelength. BTW, the waves in the the band around high microwaves and low IR is one of the least explored parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. Not that it matters for this discussion.

The wavelenght of the black-body radiation from a surface depends on temperature. Not in the way that a body of a certain temperature emits a certain wavelength, but the emitted band of radiation has a maximum that follows the temperature. This maximum can be calculated as follows:

Lambda (in microns) = 2900/T (in Kelvin).

We then find that an object at 30 degrees celcius will have a maximum around 10 microns.

Thus, we can confirm that Roger's Harmonizer device will actually emit IR waves somewhere in the band 4-14 microns if it is carried on the body of a person :). But, before you rejoice, Roger, there is a trap here. Can you find it ;)?

Hans
 
cogreslab said:
Are you now denying that?

No we not only have physics graduate(employee) , but also physical chemists (weekly visiting consultant).

Well I can imagine that it must be very stressful working in such an environment, and I fully understand why they have to see a "consultant" every week.

Tell them that they have my sympathies and I hope they get better soon. :)
 
MRC_Hans said:
While Roger ponders about what to do with the perhaps frightingly clear questions above, I have looked around for some concrete figures on IR:

The infrared spectrum goes from 0,7 micrometer and down to microwave. There seems to be consensus about putting the limit at 1000 micrometer (yes, that's a millimeter). When I say down, I'm referring to frequency, which is reciprocal to wavelength. BTW, the waves in the the band around high microwaves and low IR is one of the least explored parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. Not that it matters for this discussion.

The wavelenght of the black-body radiation from a surface depends on temperature. Not in the way that a body of a certain temperature emits a certain wavelength, but the emitted band of radiation has a maximum that follows the temperature. This maximum can be calculated as follows:

Lambda (in microns) = 2900/T (in Kelvin).

We then find that an object at 30 degrees celcius will have a maximum around 10 microns.

Thus, we can confirm that Roger's Harmonizer device will actually emit IR waves somewhere in the band 4-14 microns if it is carried on the body of a person :). But, before you rejoice, Roger, there is a trap here. Can you find it ;)?

Hans

Aw Hans, you sprang MY trap! :)

No matter, there's at least THREE MORE traps. Isn't this fun? But a little too easy, it's like shooting fish in a barrel!

It's obvious where Roger was going. Yes, I suspect we were going to hear that it emits these IR waves and these somehow interact with a lymphocyte because they just happen to be the same size (yes *I* know, don't say it yet), and that this somehow constitutes an "endogenous field" that protects lymphocytes against the evil damaging radiation of a cellphone.
 
cogreslab said:
Now that's funny. My Reply button has disappeared!

And it seems like Hans, sensibly, has gone to bed. So now will I. Night, folks!

Roger, as you seem to be having trouble with the board, maybe this will help. The "reply" button only appears on the very last post of a thread and it just allows you to tack a new reply on to the end of the thread.

But there's a much easier way. When you are reading any posting, at the lower right hand corner of each posting there is a blue "quote" button. If you hit that then it will take you to a screen where you can enter your reply.

What *I* do, if it's any help, is I highlight the text in the box when it appears, then click and copy and paste it into a separate window where I have notepad running. I then edit the text in notepad, and when I have finished, I highlight the text in notepad, click, copy and then paste it into the blue reply box, overwriting the original contents of that box.

Then, lower down the reply screen are two buttons. Pressing the "preview" button lets you see how your text will appear (and you can still go back and modify it if it doesn't look right). And when I am happy with the result I hit the "submit" button and then it posts it to the board.

If you do it this way, you won't end up confusing people's postings as you keep doing.

By the way, the commands/graphics in the text are just simple HTML commands. I thought you ran a web design company?

Now, having that out the way, come on Rog, out with it! Let's hear your theory about the IR waves etc., no more messing about.
 
PJ said:

I must have missed the part where you explain how IR penetrates the skin. No more need be said.

And for reference here are some cells sizes:

Erythrocytes : 7.5
Basophils : 9-12
Eosinphils : 9-12
Neutrophils : 10-12
Monocytes : 9-17
Lympocytes : 7-8
Platelets : 2-3

Once more by saying lymphocytes are size 4-14 you have shown a basic ignorance of the subject.


To quote from one of several websites found via Google by keywords "lymphocyte" and "size":

Strictly speaking, there are probably no white cells totally devoid of granules. Azurophilic (non-specific) granules can also be found in lymphocytes and monocytes. However, these cells do not contain specific granules. The lymphocytes vary in size from 6 ?m (slightly smaller than an RBC) to large cells up to 15 ?m in size. The small lymphocytes have only a thin rim of sky-blue cytoplasm. Their nuclei of densely-stained chromatin are generally round or slightly indented on one side. Medium and larger lymphocytes have larger, round nuclei centrally located in a sky-blue cytoplasm. A few azurophilic granules may be present in the cytoplasm. Lymphocytes normally constitute 20–30% of the total leukocyte count, with small lymphocytes predominating. Study the E.M. of a lymphocyte.

Once again you have called me a pejorative, entirely without fouindation, and in this case patently from wrong factual information. If you had any grace PJ you would not only apologise but also admit that your comment clearly applies to yourself. Anyone who has looked at these cells for a few days would quickly know they can vary in size in the way I have described.

Radiation penetrates various depths past the dermis and epidermis dependent on wavelength. Microwaves are less likely to penetrate past that area than ELF, but at IR wavelengths there is reasonably deep penetration.
 
Thanks Prag: is there any way of getting tables in, and how do you embed gifs? Both will be useful later.
 
On the IR topic, first these papers by Callahan include most of the basic ideas about inter organism communication at far IR wavelengths, and give an insight into the notion I want to put forward. Maybe some of you have access to these, since it is a big slog to type out all the relevant passages from hard copy.


CALLAHAN P. S. J.C. NICKERSON et al
Attraction of ants to narrow-band (maser-like) far infrared radiation as evidence for an insect infrared communication system.
Physiol Chem and Phys i14 p139 p144 1982

CALLAHAN P. S.
Intermediate and far infrared sensing of nocturnal insects. Part I. evidences for a far - infrared (FIR) electromagnetic theory of communication and sensing in moths and its relationship to the limiting biosphere of the corn earworm.
Ann. Entomological Soc. of America i58 p727 p745 1965

CALLAHAN P. S.
Nondestructive temperature and radiance measurements on night flying moths.
Applied Optics i7 p1811 p1817 1968

CALLAHAN P. S.
Nonlinear resonance in a biological system.
Applied Optics v20 i220 p3827 p3828 1981

CALLAHAN P. S.
Picket-fence interferometer on the antenna of the noctuidae and pyralidae moths.
Appl. optics i24 p2217 p2220 1985

CALLAHAN P. S.
Tapping modulation of the far infrared (17-um region) emission from the cabbage looper moth pheromone (sex scent)
Applied Optics i16 p3098 3102
 
Hans said:

"Thus, we can confirm that Roger's Harmonizer device will actually emit IR waves somewhere in the band 4-14 microns if it is carried on the body of a person . But, before you rejoice, Roger, there is a trap here. Can you find it ?".

Thanks for the confirmation, but could you say what the trap(s) is/are Hans? It might save us time.
 
cogreslab said:
Once again you have called me a pejorative, entirely without fouindation, and in this case patently from wrong factual information. If you had any grace PJ you would not only apologise but also admit that your comment clearly applies to yourself. Anyone who has looked at these cells for a few days would quickly know they can vary in size in the way I have described.

I'm glad you said that. So maybe you wouldn't mind showing us YOUR grace by answering the questions below that I have posted multiple times. Remember this?


O.K. at this point I note (for the fourth time) that apparently several things have again been evaded (if Roger would care to address them properly now, I will retract that statement).

To Roger:

1.) Are you prepared to admit that you were wrong about the Lai/Singh experiment not taking electric fields into account?

2.) Are you prepared to apologise (to Dr's Lai and Singh) for misrepresenting their experiment?

3.) Would you please clarify the outstanding issue about your biological qualification?

4.) Are you prepared to take any action in respect of the web sites etc., that you claim are misrepresenting you? And if so, what and when?

Based on Roger's reply to Cleopatra, I take it that the answer to 4 is already given and that answer is basically NO.

If this is evaded again, I will it consider it PROOF in support of some value judgements.
 
Perhaps you can point out which part of your quote specifies that lymphocytes are of size 4-14 microns in size. I can't find it. I think you'll find the size i gave is applicable to the majoritory of lymphocytes, it really depends in how much detail you want to go.

Oh are you saying the range is now 6-15 microns ? Keep changing the story roger. The sizes i gave were fairly standard, Prag linked to a site where they are quoted as being bigger than the ranges i gave. Perhaps you have an oversimplistic view of immunology/haematology ? Cell sizes will vary depending on if you are measuring the size in a smear or in a wet prep.

Oh nice diversion btw.
 
I fail to see how ants being attracted to IR has anything to do with the topic at hand. I'm not an ant. How does IR penetrate the skin to affect my lymphocytes?

Have you told the MHRA what your device does? (stimulate lympocytes?)

Did they a) Pee themselves laughing?
or b) Order you to stop selling it and present safety data to them for assessment?
or c) I haven't told the MHRA because it doesn't really do anything?
 
cogreslab said:
Hans said:

"Thus, we can confirm that Roger's Harmonizer device will actually emit IR waves somewhere in the band 4-14 microns if it is carried on the body of a person . But, before you rejoice, Roger, there is a trap here. Can you find it ?".

Thanks for the confirmation, but could you say what the trap(s) is/are Hans? It might save us time.

Oh come on! As if anybody can't see what would happen if he did!

Hans: the trap is....

Roger: ah but that ISN'T my theory, my theory is..(insert technobabble). You really shouldn't jump to conclusions....call yourself a scientist....blah, blah, blah...

Come on Rog, stop prevaricating, out with it! If you have a theory just explain it. It's YOUR theory so the onus is on you. If we have objections/comments we'll state them when we know what it is.
 
cogreslab said:
Thanks Prag: is there any way of getting tables in, and how do you embed gifs? Both will be useful later.

The "IMG" button just above the text entry box on the reply screen will let you insert images. I'm not sure about tables I don't know if the board will interpret HTML table commands, I'll have to try it. But you could always upload a table in image form.
 
O.K. at this point I note that apparently several things have again been evaded (if Roger would care to address them properly now, I will retract that statement).

To Roger:

1.) Are you prepared to admit that you were wrong about the Lai/Singh experiment not taking electric fields into account?

2.) Are you prepared to apologise (to Dr's Lai and Singh) for misrepresenting their experiment?

3.) Would you please clarify the outstanding issue about your biological qualification?

4.) Are you prepared to take any action in respect of the web sites etc., that you claim are misrepresenting you? And if so, what and when?

I admit I had not read the part in Henry's paper which explined what he did to mitigate electric fields (the paper only appeared this month, and I had not seen his preprint (sometimes he sends me these), but this does not mean that what he did was sufficient, and I will be discussing this with him in Washuington in a few weeks tiime.

I didnt misdrespresent the experiment: I simply posted the abstract data, which didnt mention electric fields.

What dfrkitten said is correct: I have an Honours degree in Biiological Sciences from The University of Cambridge. I think that is now established, and btw, if if recall corretly the IoB wanted sight of the certificate before accepting me, inter alia.

I have written to Iob to ask them to change the DR to MR, and I fully expect they will do that. The other b****rs are proving more difficult, and so I am putting a disclaimer on my own site.
 
All very interesting, Mr. Coghill, but how does it work? I've looked at your paper on the subject, and while I can see some tests you have run in vitro, the only thing I have seen about the mechanics of this object is:
Schauberger in the 1920s and 1930s promoted the idea that in nature energy could be reconstituted by cycloid spiral motion of water. These were embodied in a serialised treatise published in Die Wasserwirtschaft (Water Technology), 1930-1931.
And since your experiments were done on a small, in vitro culture of cells, it does not explain how, even if it did work, it could protect a large organism.

So I still await your explanation on how this device.
energiser.jpg
protects people from RF waves. All I can see is that you have latched on to some 70+ year old idea (which has not, in all that time, made it into mainstream science) and tried to make a buck off of it.

But I remain open minded to your explanation. Fire away
 
It appears that there is penetration of IR through the skin, in these cases sufficient to be used diagnostically:

http://www.devicelink.com/mddi/archive/03/06/003.html



edited to add:

In the mid-IR, glucose absorbs strongly with minimal interference from other absorbing species, but sources are not ideal and water absorbs very strongly. The OptiScan noninvasive glucose meter takes advantage of the realization that the human body is an excellent blackbody emitter of mid-IR light at precisely the right spectral region, so the necessary radiation is therefore already present inside the body near enough to the surface (within 10’s of microns) that its emission spectrum may be used to measure glucose.

Unfortunately, the nature of blackbody radiation is such that, if the glucose to be measured is at the same temperature as the tissue that emitted the blackbody radiation, then the glucose will be effectively transparent, and no glucose spectrum will be observed in the emitted light due to the balance of absorption, spontaneous emission, and stimulated emission at equilibrium. Fortunately, this problem can be solved by introducing a temperature gradient—e.g., cooling the surface—where the cooler glucose will absorb more than it will emit. This yields a reasonable glucose absorption spectrum superimposed on the usual smooth blackbody emission spectrum.

http://www.ieee.org/organizations/pubs/newsletters/leos/apr98/midinfrared.htm
 
Prag;

"Oh come on! As if anybody can't see what would happen if he did!

Hans: the trap is....

Roger: ah but that ISN'T my theory, my theory is..(insert technobabble). You really shouldn't jump to conclusions....call yourself a scientist....blah, blah, blah...

Come on Rog, stop prevaricating, out with it! If you have a theory just explain it. It's YOUR theory so the onus is on you. If we have objections/comments we'll state them when we know what it is"


Prag, this kind of post does nothing either for this dialogue or your credibility. If there is an objection based in science please spell it out, instead of insinuating there is a "trap", simply to confuse lay readers, without telling us what you find to be the problem.
 
Pragmatist said:


The "IMG" button just above the text entry box on the reply screen will let you insert images. I'm not sure about tables I don't know if the board will interpret HTML table commands, I'll have to try it. But you could always upload a table in image form.

Just click "Quote", then copy this and tweak it to suit:

<TABLE border="1"
<summary="Should be able to modify this to make it do what you want.">
<CAPTION>Testing, testing</CAPTION>
<TR><TH rowspan="2"><TH colspan="2">Coaster
<TH rowspan="2">
Difference detected
<TR><TH>Magnetic<TH>Non-Magnetic
<TR><TH>Shiraz<TD>Y<TD>N<TD>ndiff
<TR><TH>Cabernet<TD>N<TD>Y<TD>ndiff
</TABLE>
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom