Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

The case wouldn't be nearly as strong if we didn't have that prosecutor now saying that, "Yes, indeed, I did intend it to be immunity."

Even if that's what he intended, neither he nor Cosby's lawyers followed the required procedures. "Ah, gee, I meant to file my taxes on time, I meant to take that gun out of my suitcase before I got on the plane, I meant to stop at the stop sign so I wouldn't hit that schoolbus" etc. doesn't cut much ice in a legal proceeding. And I don't really understand how the deposition can even be an issue if it's not used against him at trial. The new prosecutor can pursue the case with Constand's testimony and the testimony of his other victims without using a word of Cosby's deposition.
 
Ye4ah but when the basis for prosecuting the case now is "new evidence" consisting of rumors and gossip, a verbal immunity ought to count just as much.
 
Ye4ah but when the basis for prosecuting the case now is "new evidence" consisting of rumors and gossip, a verbal immunity ought to count just as much.
I supposed I could check a legal dictionary but as far as I know victim testimony is not "rumors and gossip," even if you try to paint some of the alleged victims as liars and whores.
 
I supposed I could check a legal dictionary but as far as I know victim testimony is not "rumors and gossip," even if you try to paint some of the alleged victims as liars and whores.

Got ANY legal proof that they are victims? Rape kits? Toxicology? Eye witnesses?
 
Got ANY legal proof that they are victims? Rape kits? Toxicology? Eye witnesses?

The testimony of the alleged victim is evidence. In Pennsylvania it is sufficient evidence to get a criminal case to the jury.

The victim’s uncorroborated testimony is sufficient to support a rape conviction. Commonwealth v.Wall, 953 A.2d 581, 584 (Pa.Super.2009).

link

So proof enough in a legal sense, but up to a jury to believe or not believe the alleged victim.
 
That's one of the ways rape culture is perpetuated, victims of rape believe (along with their rapists and general public) that testimony is not legal evidence. Words spoken in court very much are legal evidence, if not physical evidence. But little of legal evidence is, despite what police procedurals would have you believe.
 
I don't think there should be a statue of limitations for rape, and would go as far as to say it's unjust, so find it ironic that he seems to have been disadvantaged by poor legal advice.
 
The testimony of the alleged victim is evidence. In Pennsylvania it is sufficient evidence to get a criminal case to the jury.

Also the number one cause of false convictions.

There is a debate in Canada right now brought on by the Jiam Ghomeshi case. Many feel the defendant should not be permitted to mount a defence against victim testimony. I think the first witness on the stand illustrated why it is so important that a vigorous defence be allowed.
 
Imaginary people feel the defendant should have no defense.

You mean like The Ottawa Citizen which used the "Special place in hell" quote of Medeline Albright in reference to Ghomeshi's lawyer because she dared to accept him as a client.

Or all the media outlets, and now a famous Canadian author, who have claimed she has retraumatized the accusers even though other defence lawyers have stated she has taken it quite easy on them. Or all the articles written saying it should be easier to convict people like Ghomeshi. The only way it is easier is to not allow him a defence. There has never been a presumption of innocence and yet it is the cornerstone of the Canadian judicial system.

And then of course there are the comments after any article about Ghomeshi.
 
You mean like The Ottawa Citizen which used the "Special place in hell" quote of Medeline Albright in reference to Ghomeshi's lawyer because she dared to accept him as a client.

Or all the media outlets, and now a famous Canadian author, who have claimed she has retraumatized the accusers even though other defence lawyers have stated she has taken it quite easy on them. Or all the articles written saying it should be easier to convict people like Ghomeshi. The only way it is easier is to not allow him a defence. There has never been a presumption of innocence and yet it is the cornerstone of the Canadian judicial system.

And then of course there are the comments after any article about Ghomeshi.

Isn't there a thread about Jian? I'm surprised that no one has posted there recently. :(
 
Yeah where is the Ghomeshi thread. I'm still of the opinion of where there is that much smoke there is fire. But those first two witness could not have come off worst. It's too bad if they were truly victims, but based on what I've seen so far, there is no way I could see a beyond a reasonable doubt standard.
 
Smoke, fire, sure. But trials need to deal with the exact lightening strike.

A perp's former record is not allowed to be considered in evidence. Especially when there is no physical evidence anyhow. Oh sure, it is enough to make him suspected, but next step is to look for real evidence to prove 'beyond a reasonable doubt".

I could see the prosecutor presenting his case, the defense asking for a motion to dismiss, and the motion being granted.
 
That second link - the Salon article with all the coverups and people who knew what was going on - it makes me realize that Cosby (whether found guilty or not) is just the tip of the iceberg regarding the drugs and sex that went on in Hollywood at that time. Hell, it was bad outside Hollywood!

I'll never understand the whole celebrity "thing". They are just people, and chances are that they are more screwed up than the rest of us.
 
That second link - the Salon article with all the coverups and people who knew what was going on - it makes me realize that Cosby (whether found guilty or not) is just the tip of the iceberg regarding the drugs and sex that went on in Hollywood at that time. Hell, it was bad outside Hollywood!

I'll never understand the whole celebrity "thing". They are just people, and chances are that they are more screwed up than the rest of us.

One difference is that rich celebrities are surrounded by people paid to tell them how wonderful they are and protect them from the consequences of their actions. A lot of men might treat women badly, but most of them don't have agents sending them pretty young girls, producers and bodyguards shielding their dressing room doors, doctors writing quaalude prescriptions, etc.
 
One difference is that rich celebrities are surrounded by people paid to tell them how wonderful they are and protect them from the consequences of their actions. A lot of men might treat women badly, but most of them don't have agents sending them pretty young girls, producers and bodyguards shielding their dressing room doors, doctors writing quaalude prescriptions, etc.
Nup. Bill is just scum
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom