Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

Making unsupported claims won't get him charged, it just makes his claim that the women are lying more believable.

Unsupported? It was from his own testimony about why he was prescribed drugs. To seduce women. I guess he could have been lying about that, but why are you doubting his testimony?
 
Unsupported? It was from his own testimony about why he was prescribed drugs. To seduce women. I guess he could have been lying about that, but why are you doubting his testimony?

That doesn't mean what you think it means. What's the difference between what he said and your buying a bottle of wine for dinner with a woman tonight, or a bag of pot? Nothing. You want it to mean something but it has nothing to do with consent which is what rape hinges on.
 
That doesn't mean what you think it means. What's the difference between what he said and your buying a bottle of wine for dinner with a woman tonight, or a bag of pot? Nothing. You want it to mean something but it has nothing to do with consent which is what rape hinges on.

Hang on. Pot and booze? That's just to help her relax. Honest.
 
Hang on. Pot and booze? That's just to help her relax. Honest.

No, it was there for both of us to partake if we chose to. It's stupid statements like yours that make a mockery of rape claims and perpetuate the myth that women are just infants and shouldn't be allowed to make their own decisions.

And before you go down this road: Explaining the problems with the evidence is not the same as defending Cosby.
 
No, it was there for both of us to partake if we chose to. It's stupid statements like yours that make a mockery of rape claims and perpetuate the myth that women are just infants and shouldn't be allowed to make their own decisions.

The drugs and alcohol aren't there to take her ability to make decisions away, the drugs and alcohol just help her make the right decision.
 
The drugs and alcohol aren't there to take her ability to make decisions away, the drugs and alcohol just help her make the right decision.

Maybe she brought the wine and pot because I was making dinner. Was I raped?

Maybe she brought the wine and I had the pot. Then who raped who?

Offering someone a drug, them accepting and then the two of you having sex does not constitute rape.

And why haven't you afdressed the fact that in several of the cases the police have stated there are no grounds for charges, that is Cosby could not have done what he was accused of. I think your outrage has trumped your rationality.
 
Last edited:
Maybe she brought the wine and pot because I was making dinner. Was I raped?

Maybe she brought the wine and I had the pot. Then who raped who?

Offering someone a drug, them accepting and then the two of you having sex does not constitute rape.

Most people are aware of the effects of alcohol, and how much they would be affected by a certain amount. They would have no way of being certain what drugs Cosby was offering them, nor what the effects would be.
 
And why haven't you afdressed the fact that in several of the cases the police have stated there are no grounds for charges, that is Cosby could not have done what he was accused of. I think your outrage has trumped your rationality.

That's an interesting premise - being innocent of some nefarious acts means I am not guilty of others. We could call it the Karma defense. I bet we could sum up all the women Cosby didn't rape and it would be in the millions. Simple math tells us the probability that he raped any random woman has got to be close to zero.
 
And why haven't you afdressed the fact that in several of the cases the police have stated there are no grounds for charges,

Woah. Hold on a minute. Just a few posts ago you said this happened "every time" there was a claim. Now it's just "several".

So which are the cases where the police haven't stated there are no grounds for charges, and shouldn't we be examining them instead?
 
Woah. Hold on a minute. Just a few posts ago you said this happened "every time" there was a claim. Now it's just "several".

No, I did not. I said "everytime there were verifiable details given" which is several of the cases.The rest are very vague.

So which are the cases where the police haven't stated there are no grounds for charges, and shouldn't we be examining them instead?

When there is no verifiable evidence available what do you propose we "examine?"
 
That's an interesting premise - being innocent of some nefarious acts means I am not guilty of others. We could call it the Karma defense. I bet we could sum up all the women Cosby didn't rape and it would be in the millions. Simple math tells us the probability that he raped any random woman has got to be close to zero.

Do read what you write? The person playing the numbers game is you. I am simply looking at the available evidence. You are using the "shear numbers" argument and ignoring the evidence.
 
Most people are aware of the effects of alcohol, and how much they would be affected by a certain amount. They would have no way of being certain what drugs Cosby was offering them, nor what the effects would be.

Maybe. Drugs were retty common at the time and in those circles. These were prescription drugs with their strength known not street drugs of unknown strength and composition.
 
Do read what you write? The person playing the numbers game is you. I am simply looking at the available evidence. You are using the "shear numbers" argument and ignoring the evidence.

Does the testimony of the women who say he drugged and raped them count as evidence? Does the number of women who say it count as evidence? Does Cosby's deposition count?

It's all just people telling stories right? Did Cosby have access to the drug in question? The women? Means, motivation, opportunity. They aren't tantamount to a sex tape, but they are a start.
 
Does the testimony of the women who say he drugged and raped them count as evidence?

No, and neither does Cosby's denial. They are each just a claim. Evidence would be the information used to decide which claim is true, or more likely true.

Does the number of women who say it count as evidence?

It could but I don't think so in this case because the claims are not independent. All the claims made after the comedian's joke went viral would be tainted. There are procedures for finding victims because the power of suggestion is very strong. The way these came out flies in the face of those procedures. We can see that is the case because several of the late claims have fatal flaws. There are recent cases of charges being dismissed for this exact reason.


Does Cosby's deposition count?

Absolutely. As I pointed out though, there is more than one interpretation to his words. "Seduce" does not mean "render them unconscious so I can rape them." That was my point with the wine. I could say "I bought an expensive case of wine in the hopes of seducing women" or I could say "I carry a lot of cash in hopes of seducing people into sex." It doesn't mean I am a rapist. It simply means that I think people get seduced by different things. Some like wine, some money, some drugs.
It's all just people telling stories right?

We know that is definitely the case in several of the later claims.

Did Cosby have access to the drug in question? The women? Means, motivation, opportunity. They aren't tantamount to a sex tape, but they are a start.

Yes, it was a start but it hasn't panned out. If you only listen to the claims of the accusers and cherry pick one sentence out of his deposition, I agree, guilty as ****. But there is a lot of other evidence that works well in his defence and he will get to defend himself if it ever goes to trial.
 
No, and neither does Cosby's denial. They are each just a claim. Evidence would be the information used to decide which claim is true, or more likely true.
......

Seems like this goes back to the beginning of the thread. Testimony is evidence. It is distinct from physical evidence, and the jury can decide how much or little weight to give it, but it is evidence. If the witness says "That's the man who robbed me!," and the defendant says "I was at a bar with a dozen friends!," they are both offering evidence, subject to examination, corroboration and challenge. Most criminal charges aren't supported by DNA and security videos.
http://evidence.uslegal.com/testimony/
 
Sounds to me that none of the evidence matters n this case. BC was given amnesty. Done.

Now, if some other gal has a good case, perhaps she can use the un-sealed affidavit for evidence? But that doesn't seem right either, BC was given amnesty for that testimony against himself?

Any other actual cases pending?
 
Sounds to me that none of the evidence matters n this case. BC was given amnesty. Done.
....

Not so fast. The current DA says a grant of immunity (not "amnesty") is the result of a specific legal procedure, the steps for which were not followed by the previous DA. That question will be resolved by the courts. Moreover, we don't know if the previous DA said "We won't use the deposition against you" or "We won't prosecute based on what we know now," vs. "We will never prosecute you no matter what." If it's not the latter, then nothing prevents the current DA from prosecuting based on evidence the previous DA didn't have, which might include the accounts of similar conduct by dozens of other women.
 
Not so fast. The current DA says a grant of immunity (not "amnesty") is the result of a specific legal procedure, the steps for which were not followed by the previous DA. That question will be resolved by the courts. Moreover, we don't know if the previous DA said "We won't use the deposition against you" or "We won't prosecute based on what we know now," vs. "We will never prosecute you no matter what." If it's not the latter, then nothing prevents the current DA from prosecuting based on evidence the previous DA didn't have, which might include the accounts of similar conduct by dozens of other women.

I would have a slight smile if it turns out his high priced attorneys didn't cover their client's interests before letting him testify. It may be the first enjoyable act of malpractice I have ever encountered.
 
I would have a slight smile if it turns out his high priced attorneys didn't cover their client's interests before letting him testify. It may be the first enjoyable act of malpractice I have ever encountered.
And it sure would be. Getting signed immunity (or a plea agreement) from the prosecutor seems like it should be an absolute requirement before allowing a client to offer potentially incriminating testimony anywhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom