Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

Actually dismissed with the accuser's lawyer threatening to appeal.

Hey, guys, let's note that's what's been dropped is one woman's civil suit against Cosby for defamation. This has nothing to do with the criminal charges he's facing.
 
I'm surprised. Next step is to see if it stands up on appeal.

At the risk of being wrong twice, I don't think it will stand up, but either way it will be interesting to see what the decision says.

I really think you are wrong here, based on this exchange cited in the article:

“You would agree with me,” he asked the lawyer, John P. Schmitt, “that you never obtained a written agreement from the Commonwealth, from Mr. Castor, that your client would never be prosecuted?”

Mr. Schmitt said, “I have a signed statement.”

To which Mr. Steele replied: “You have a press release.”

That is very flimsy stuff. I wouldn't allow my client to waive his fifth amendment rights on that basis.
 
But aren't verbal contracts enforceable? The usual problem is lack of proof. Doen't the press relase count as proof? Sound appealable to IANAL.
 
But aren't verbal contracts enforceable? The usual problem is lack of proof. Doen't the press relase count as proof? Sound appealable to IANAL.

Verbal contracts are enforceable in limited circumstances. There are some types of agreement that must be written and other agreements must follow a certain form. Compare selling bubble gum to selling a car to selling land. An agreement to exchange money for the item is just the beginning for the later two.

It is not my area of law, but my understanding is that this sort of agreement, to be binding on those who later hold the same office, has to be done in a particular form.

The prosecutor now says he intended to bind the county, but he didn't follow the procedure necessary to bind the county. And Cosby's attorneys didn't make sure he followed that procedure. That is why I mentioned malpractice earlier.
 
I really think you are wrong here, based on this exchange cited in the article:

Could be I am. I see it in terms of allowing the state to bait and switch by way of employees acting beyond their responsibilities and not suffering the consequences. If it were the cops doing it, we'd want to bend toward the defendant's rights as a default.

That is very flimsy stuff. I wouldn't allow my client to waive his fifth amendment rights on that basis.

Yeah, one presumes Cosby's lawyer had a say in the decision to accept the offer. Has he/she weighed in?

Is the question whether or not the prosecutor had the power to make the offer and follow through, or whether or not he followed the formal process to do so? If it's the first, maybe it stands. If it's the second, I think that's very weak.
 
Could be I am. I see it in terms of allowing the state to bait and switch by way of employees acting beyond their responsibilities and not suffering the consequences. If it were the cops doing it, we'd want to bend toward the defendant's rights as a default.

Yeah, one presumes Cosby's lawyer had a say in the decision to accept the offer. Has he/she weighed in?

Is the question whether or not the prosecutor had the power to make the offer and follow through, or whether or not he followed the formal process to do so? If it's the first, maybe it stands. If it's the second, I think that's very weak.

As I said above, not may area of the law. But, when it comes to incriminating testimony I would want something more than a signed press release.
 
As I said above, not may area of the law. But, when it comes to incriminating testimony I would want something more than a signed press release.
Handling immunity agreements would be something a prosecutor would do a lot. I'm very suspicious of a former prosecutor who says he intended to confer immunity but then failed to execute the agreement. If he wasn't claiming otherwise, I'd further suspect that the agreement wasn't properly executed because the prosecutor was taking advantage of sloppy defense lawyering.
 
Handling immunity agreements would be something a prosecutor would do a lot. I'm very suspicious of a former prosecutor who says he intended to confer immunity but then failed to execute the agreement. If he wasn't claiming otherwise, I'd further suspect that the agreement wasn't properly executed because the prosecutor was taking advantage of sloppy defense lawyering.

My thoughts are similar, although I wonder how many immunity agreements one deals with in that jurisdiction. I really don't know if "a lot" is accurate in this case.
 
My thoughts are similar, although I wonder how many immunity agreements one deals with in that jurisdiction. I really don't know if "a lot" is accurate in this case.
Maybe, maybe not, but choosing whom to prosecute is the biggest power any prosecutor has in their arsenal, and any potential defendant would want immunity if at all possible. In other words, knowing the ins and outs of immunity would be an absolute requirement for any prosecutor.
 
Could be I am. I see it in terms of allowing the state to bait and switch by way of employees acting beyond their responsibilities and not suffering the consequences. If it were the cops doing it, we'd want to bend toward the defendant's rights as a default.
.....

It's interesting that you make that point. Cops routinely lie to suspects to get confessions, and the courts have upheld their right to do so. How many video interrogations have you seen where the cop says something like "We just need to figure out what happened so you can go home," or "The judge'll give you a break if you tell him your side?" The current prosecutor is arguing that "immunity" requires a formal, written agreement filed with a court, not just a particular prosecutor saying "I'm not charging you now." It's hard to see how an informal oral promise by one guy binds the entire state forever. A true immunity agreement also usually requires the defendant to do something in exchange, like testify in court against co-conspirators. The former prosecutor's promise didn't actually require Cosby to do anything, like testify truthfully and completely about crimes he may have committed, and in the civil deposition his lawyer actually stopped him from answering some questions that would have been especially damaging to answer. I think Cosby's lawyers lost when they waved a press release and claimed it was an immunity agreement.
 
It's interesting that you make that point. Cops routinely lie to suspects to get confessions, and the courts have upheld their right to do so. How many video interrogations have you seen where the cop says something like "We just need to figure out what happened so you can go home," or "The judge'll give you a break if you tell him your side?" The current prosecutor is arguing that "immunity" requires a formal, written agreement filed with a court, not just a particular prosecutor saying "I'm not charging you now." It's hard to see how an informal oral promise by one guy binds the entire state forever. A true immunity agreement also usually requires the defendant to do something in exchange, like testify in court against co-conspirators. The former prosecutor's promise didn't actually require Cosby to do anything, like testify truthfully and completely about crimes he may have committed, and in the civil deposition his lawyer actually stopped him from answering some questions that would have been especially damaging to answer. I think Cosby's lawyers lost when they waved a press release and claimed it was an immunity agreement.

The case wouldn't be nearly as strong if we didn't have that prosecutor now saying that, "Yes, indeed, I did intend it to be immunity."
 
Verbal contracts are enforceable in limited circumstances. There are some types of agreement that must be written and other agreements must follow a certain form. Compare selling bubble gum to selling a car to selling land. An agreement to exchange money for the item is just the beginning for the later two.

It is not my area of law, but my understanding is that this sort of agreement, to be binding on those who later hold the same office, has to be done in a particular form.

The prosecutor now says he intended to bind the county, but he didn't follow the procedure necessary to bind the county. And Cosby's attorneys didn't make sure he followed that procedure. That is why I mentioned malpractice earlier.

I suppose that's the risk people run if they can't afford to hire the best lawyers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom