Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

Even if they stuff him in a geriatric ward or a old-folks home surrounded by a picket fence the added costs to take care of him might make it reasonable to seek other solutions. Letting him serve out his sentence in his home wouldn't place him "above the law" nor would it necessarily compromise public safety and could be a perfectly proportional and humane solution considering his age. Lets be smart about this.

Confining an astronomically wealthy serial rapist to a life of luxurious comfort surrounded by his pathetic toadies is an obscene perversion.
 
Confining an astronomically wealthy serial rapist to a life of luxurious comfort surrounded by his pathetic toadies is an obscene perversion.

Indeed. The fact that he got away with serial rape for so long shouldn't excuse him from prison. If he becomes truly infirm, as opposed to exaggerating his health problems to engender jury sympathy, I'm sure there's a prison hospital to accommodate him. House arrest in a 2-bedroom home might be punishment. The same isn't true if one's home is virtually a palace.
 
Indeed. The fact that he got away with serial rape for so long shouldn't excuse him from prison. If he becomes truly infirm, as opposed to exaggerating his health problems to engender jury sympathy, I'm sure there's a prison hospital to accommodate him. House arrest in a 2-bedroom home might be punishment. The same isn't true if one's home is virtually a palace.

Yeah, this. I don't have a problem with the idea in general, but in the case of Cosby it wouldn't be much different from just letting him off entirely.

Maybe there should be completely separate prisons for people over the age of 65.
 
Last edited:

Prosecutorial misconduct denies justice once again

ETA: The linked story seems to focus on prohibited witnesses, but other analysis seems to put the blame on a non-prosecution statement the DA used in order to compel Cosby to testify in a civil trial. Cosby gave incriminating testimony at the civil trial against him under the reliance that he would not be prosecuted, the DA tried to turn around and use that testimony in a criminal trial. Obviously this does not withstand further scrutiny.

This is the key finding of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania that explains its reversal of the Cosby decision: the prior DA promised non-prosecution to force Cosby to waive his Fifth Amendment privilege and testify in a civil case, he did, then they prosecuted him with it.

https://twitter.com/Popehat/status/1410288809745412097
 
Last edited:
Prosecutorial misconduct denies justice once again

ETA: The linked story seems to focus on prohibited witnesses, but other analysis seems to put the blame on a non-prosecution statement the DA used in order to compel Cosby to testify in a civil trial. Cosby gave incriminating testimony at the civil trial against him under the reliance that he would not be prosecuted, the DA tried to turn around and use that testimony in a criminal trial. Obviously this does not withstand further scrutiny.
https://twitter.com/Popehat/status/1410288809745412097


More here:
Bill Cosby had his conviction for sexual assault overturned by a Pennsylvania appeals court on Wednesday, a decision that will set free a man whose case had represented the first high-profile sexual assault trial to unfold in the aftermath of the #MeToo movement.
....
In their 79-page opinion, the judges wrote that a “non-prosecution agreement” struck with a previous prosecutor meant that he should not have been charged in the case, and that Mr. Cosby should be discharged. They barred a retrial in the case.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/30/arts/television/bill-cosby-release-conviction.html

But nobody says he's not guilty.

The prosecutors at least got him convicted and sent him to prison. The decision seems to be that he should never even have been charged.
 
Last edited:
Cosby has a life sentence no matter how you look at it...

his reputation was already trash, but it's undoubtedly better for him to be spending his final years a free man than to rot and possibly die in prison. There's really no silver lining to this, the DA botched it and a known serial rapist is escaping justice.
 
Cosby has a life sentence no matter how you look at it...

Not really. He's still got a vast fortune, he can live and travel where he wants, and I'll bet if he sold tickets to a Trump-like tour about how the system screwed him, he get plenty of takers.
 
his reputation was already trash, but it's undoubtedly better for him to be spending his final years a free man than to rot and possibly die in prison. There's really no silver lining to this, the DA botched it and a known serial rapist is escaping justice.

In theory he would have escaped justice anyway, since it was never his intention to give incriminating testimony at his criminal trial. Still, I think it would have been ethically more sound to give up the civil case and hang tough on the criminal case.
 
Last edited:
In theory he would have escaped justice anyway, since it was never his intention to give incriminating testimony at his criminal trial. Still, I think it would have been ethically more sound to give up the civil case and hang tough on the criminal case.

It's hard to speculate now how these cases would have shaken out had Cosby not testified.

Perhaps both cases would have been successful regardless, perhaps not. We'll never know thanks to the DA botching it so badly.
 
Legal commentators are saying that it's very unusual for a court to vacate a verdict on the grounds the Pennsylvania court did.
You can't tell me Cosby's celeb status has nothing to do with this.
AH well, he will NEVER get his reputation back, since it painfully clear he got out on a technicality. COntrayt to some opinion, I think he will simply live out the rest of his days in seclusion. No way he can launch a comeback tour sucessfully.
 
The whole non-prosecution agreement stinks to high heaven. A longer thread examining it, but this sums it up nicely:

In Castor's emails urging his successor not to reopen the case, he repeatedly claims the agreement not to prosecute Cosby was made at the victim's request: "That was what the lawyers for the plaintiff wanted and I agreed."

Castor was lying. The victim had no idea about the deal.

https://twitter.com/TheViewFromLL2/status/1410296325942435841

2 of the judges on the appeal are openly speculating in the decision about whether or not the agreement was the result of a corrupt bargain.

HOLY CRAP. Justice Dougherty, co-signed by Chief Justice Baer, expressly putting on the table the suggestion that Bruce Castor's decision not to prosecute Bill Cosby was part of a corrupt deal.

https://twitter.com/adambonin/status/1410283181857722370
 
Last edited:
Legal commentators are saying that it's very unusual for a court to vacate a verdict on the grounds the Pennsylvania court did.
You can't tell me Cosby's celeb status has nothing to do with this.
Cosby's celeb status had nothing to do with this. Unusual or not, the decision seems appropriate to me.

What I'm worried about now is that apparently this kind of bait and switch by DAs happens so much that there's actually a distinct pattern, and that this decision runs counter to that pattern.

AH well, he will NEVER get his reputation back, since it painfully clear he got out on a technicality. COntrayt to some opinion, I think he will simply live out the rest of his days in seclusion. No way he can launch a comeback tour sucessfully.
His reputation had a good run. It made him fabulously wealthy. It enabled a rapey lifestyle and protected him from its consequences for decades. Now he's 83, which is not a bad time in life to retire into a life of seclusion with his vast wealth, and stop giving a **** about his reputation.

I am definitely NOT in the silver lining, at least he got some kind of punishment camp. As far as I'm concerned, it looked dicey there for a while, but in the end he got away.
 
Cosby's celeb status had nothing to do with this. Unusual or not, the decision seems appropriate to me.

What I'm worried about now is that apparently this kind of bait and switch by DAs happens so much that there's actually a distinct pattern, and that this decision runs counter to that pattern.


His reputation had a good run. It made him fabulously wealthy. It enabled a rapey lifestyle and protected him from its consequences for decades. Now he's 83, which is not a bad time in life to retire into a life of seclusion with his vast wealth, and stop giving a **** about his reputation.

I am definitely NOT in the silver lining, at least he got some kind of punishment camp. As far as I'm concerned, it looked dicey there for a while, but in the end he got away.

The only silver lining is that he spent 2 years in the clink while waiting for his appeal. Other than that, you're right that he pretty much got away with it all.
 
If he has any brains, his next move should be to head to a country that has no extradition treaty with the U.S. There's plenty of other potential criminal cases out there against him.

Fortunately for us (and regrettably for him), there aren't that many non-Third World countries without treaties, and even those don't have to accept anybody. It's hard to believe Cuba, China, Russia etc. would have any reason to give Cosby sanctuary.
https://www.offshore-protection.com/offshore-blog/non-extradition-countries-the-best-place-to-run-to
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom