That seems like communism, not justice.
"To each according to his crime, from each according to his ability to pay." - Karl Marx, probably
More seriously, we've been taxing ourselves in order to pay for the kind of justice we want. Even Bill Cosby has already paid his part of the social obligation for this. It does not seem like justice to me to go to him now and say that he owes more than the taxes he's already paid, for the punishment we wish to give him. If he needs to pay more for the cost of incarcerating an elderly convict, then we all need to pay more.
Or we need to restructure our tax code, our criminal justice system, and our collective sense of what criminal justice means.