Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

That is not so much a supposition, no. It is, however, a reasonable, rational conclusion to draw from all the evidence that we are currently aware of. Do you not agree?

We seem to have missed a step here. We were talking about the relative plausibilities of accusations of rape and eating pancakes. I know that we didn't move on from that, because that's what the post you're responding to was about, and I know that you know we didn't move on from that because you deliberately cut out most of the post in order to try to ignore it.

So, why not back up and answer the post that you quoted?
 
Do you do believe it is reasonable to believe that there is probably some truth underlying twenty independent allegations that a particular person did a thing which people are known to sometimes do?

Yes.

Dear Colander,

Why do I have to answer your questions, but you do not have to answer mine ?

Best regards,
Belz... (with three dots, see ?)
 
Of course. Finding the testimony of almost 20 women giving detailed and consistent reports that they were raped by the same fellow convincing is only due to convenience and emotional needs.

That in no way ressembles what I said, especially when you read it for context, but I suppose doing that is not as fun and thrilling as getting outraged and offended at something you imagine I meant.
 
We seem to have missed a step here. We were talking about the relative plausibilities of accusations of rape and eating pancakes. I know that we didn't move on from that, because that's what the post you're responding to was about, and I know that you know we didn't move on from that because you deliberately cut out most of the post in order to try to ignore it.

So, why not back up and answer the post that you quoted?

Your attempt at splitting hairs is a silly one. Sexual assault happens. Pancake House breakfasts happen. Far more people have committed sexual assault than have ever even set foot inside of a Pancake House, but still: neither of those things are inherently implausible events.
 
Last edited:
Your attempt at splitting hairs is a silly one. Sexual assault happens. Pancake House breakfasts happen. Far more people have committed sexual assault than have ever even set foot inside of a Pancake House, but still: neither of those things are inherently implausible events.

Would you or would you not require the same threshold of evidence for both ?
 
That in no way ressembles what I said, especially when you read it for context, but I suppose doing that is not as fun and thrilling as getting outraged and offended at something you imagine I meant.

I believe my reply was on point, and I'm not feeling any "fun" or "thrills". I am offended by the combo of juvenile celebrity worship and misogyny that helps make these type of bullies feel untouchable.
 

Then congratulations! We all agree! It's not irrational or unreasonable for people to conclude, based on the available evidence, that Bill Cosby has probably done rape.

Dear Colander,

Why do I have to answer your questions, but you do not have to answer mine

Mine are better?
 
I believe my reply was on point, and I'm not feeling any "fun" or "thrills". I am offended by the combo of juvenile celebrity worship and misogyny that helps make these type of bullies feel untouchable.

And that is a huge problem. But what I said was this: most opinions are not directed at finding the truth. I didn't imply that you had this opinion for ***** and giggles, but simply that my belief is that we should aspire to more than opinions that we find satisfying.
 
Then congratulations! We all agree! It's not irrational or unreasonable for people to conclude, based on the available evidence, that Bill Cosby has probably done rape.

And there's the key difference between your conclusion here and the post I was responding to: probably.

Mine are better?

Possibly, but it would be more civil if you didn't expect them to be the only ones answered.
 
And there's the key difference between your conclusion here and the post I was responding to: probably.

Hip hip hooray.

Possibly, but it would be more civil if you didn't expect them to be the only ones answered.

Yes, but if I had tried to answer any of your questions, we'd still be stuck here arguing about them. Not only that, but also it would be a pretty darn boring argument that nobody else here would have any fun reading. So overall I like my way better.
 
Last edited:
Thought experiment for you, Belz. If twenty different people on twenty separate occasions tell you they've seen me at Pancake House of a Sunday eating breakfast, would it be reasonable for you to conclude that I've been to the Pancake House? Would it be rational? Why or why not?

It reflects poorly on you to propose a thought experiment without having acknowledged or performed this one:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10337292&postcount=72
 
New Rule:

Everyone has to answer every question put by another poster, no matter how trivial, how poorly phrased or how irrelevant.

Because.... well, if you don't answer, then I win the Internets!

So why is it everyone seems to think you're right and I'm not? You all have thirty minutes to respond, but be aware that you've got one thing going against you.... I'm right, and I know it and I can prove that be constantly re-asserting it, and whinging like a grade schooler. But if you don't answer I will hound you all until you do.
 
Asking unproductive questions and calling your opponent "uncivil" when they ignore your questions is a thing so common on the internet and so very annoying that someone came up with a slang term for it. It's called sea-lioning. And we don't have to take it.
 
Last edited:
Asking unproductive questions and calling your opponent "uncivil" when they ignore your questions is a thing so common and annoying that someone came up with a slang term for it. It's called sea-lioning. And we don't have to take it.

Damn! That is priceless. I need that for my Let's Drive the No-True-Skeptics to Their Figurative Knees movement, which is in its infancy.

I'm going to go be nice and buy some Amway **** and lobby to give out "Sea Lion" as a custom title. (I usually hate memes, but getting introduced to this one is so timely, I'm taking that as a sign.)
 
That said, how do you know this? And know it so well that you proclaim it as unvarnished fact?


I did some research on him to answer the first part of your sentence. The second part of your sentence is something I never said and would never say. I believe that is called a strawman.



Well that type of person is a reliable man, not some flighty floozy actress who probably just wants to sell books and revive a career, or something.


That is not fair. Scotti has much more information in the public realm than they do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom