Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

You accused me of finding substantiation in one party not because of the research I did on that party, but because of horrible labels that you yourself imposed on those parties.

Actually, we don't know what research you did on Scotti nor how you substantiated his bone fides, but you turned on a dime when he made allegations from your initial position which involved a lot of innuendo against Cosby's female accusers.

Personally I tend to refrain from judgment if there has been one accusation against someone (with no proof). If there's been a whole bunch of similar accusations, that's enough for me to conclude that they're probably true.

I'm not sure how you can accept that to be a "probably" if the person is both extremely rich and popular.

In that situation I would need to know a bit of background history on each accuser to try and surmise if they are just seeing some interview revenue in their future (or the almighty "book deal") before going anywhere close to "probably".

This was part of your attempts to police what others should say about Cosby:

I'm just trying to make damn sure we don't have a trash Bill Cosby thread before we know he deserves one.

But when ddt posted something about Scotti, you suddenly announced:

Well that definitely shows that the promiscuity and adultery is well evidenced. That man really has no reason to lie at all, he is not the type of person who would give two ***** about a book deal or interview money. Or fame. Or just plain sick. (Perhaps a vendetta but it would have to be something so huge to just be extremely unlikely.)

My willingness to believe the rape allegations has increased dramatically.

I suppose we could go beyond probably whereas before we were not allowed near the word. That's why I asked if we could now have a trash Bill Cosby thread. Hence my question...

Permission to have a trash Bill Cosby thread?

Well unless someone corrects me on my interpretation of the reliability of Frank Scotti:




...then the massive amounts of adultery at least is fairly solidly evidenced, so trash away. My thoughts go out to his wife Camille. Even if she is the type to be knowingly compliant, and has had a wonderful largely due to her husband, I still feel bad for her.

I thought it was odd that you maintained again that Scotti is reliable. Please keep that in mind. Yet you were concerned with the feelings of Cosby's wife. Surely if Scotti is reliable then what about the actresses that Cosby raped? No feelings for them?

So you were then asked about Scotti's reliability:

There's an awful lot of smoke for there not to be fire.

That said, how do you know this? And know it so well that you proclaim it as unvarnished fact?

Certainly you said Scotti was a reliable man, so the first part of the next post is beyond question an accurate characterization of what you said. The second combines your apparent disregard for the actresses, and the motives you insinuated might be behind the allegations. So again, I don't think my characterization is incorrect. And bear in mind, even if you trust the reliability of Scotti, you still haven't presented your evidence.

Well that type of person is a reliable man, not some flighty floozy actress who probably just wants to sell books and revive a career, or something.

That is not fair. Scotti has much more information in the public realm than they do.

The kind of background research you could easily do if chose to do some research instead of posting slanderous accusations.

Scotti literally has a few magnitudes more information available than the accusers do. Go see for yourself.

Again, for those who seem to not be able to grasp science. Finding information about one person does not suddenly mean information does not exist about the other person. It just was not as readily available. It is not that hard of a concept to understand.

By saying I found substantiation about one person does not mean that suddenly another person is beyond substantiation.

So again you refer to the evidence you found that demonstrates Scotti's reliability, yet you don't offer it up. You make a claim towards having used "science" which is a little obscure in this context. Could you perhaps flesh out what you mean by science. Did you state a hypothesis, a methodology for testing it and present your results? I do not think so. Is it possible for independent researchers to follow what you did and replicate your findings? Not if you keep it a secret like this.

Could not possibly be phrased with more bias.

Person X and Person Y start out with the exact same amount of question marks.

Research is done on Person X that shows the question marks might not be in question.

That research shows absolutely no bias or disdain about Person Y what-so-ever. No light is shed on Person Y by that research.

And yet you chose to imply that it did.

If you mean by Person Y, the actresses making the claims then you did indeed float the idea they were looking for money for appearing on interviews or for selling books. Why? Because Cosby's rich and famous! Of course, that's not how these allegations have resurfaced. They have resurfaced because another comedian brought it up and because of people on the internet "meming" him.
 
I thought it was odd that you maintained again that Scotti is reliable. Please keep that in mind. Yet you were concerned with the feelings of Cosby's wife. Surely if Scotti is reliable then what about the actresses that Cosby raped? No feelings for them?

I think your issue is a fundamental misunderstanding of logic. The argument put forth is that Scotti is reliable on promiscuity and adultery. The error you make is in conflating "promiscuity and adultery" with "drugging and raping."

Wilt Chamberlain claimed to have slept with 20,000 women, in your opinion, does that mean he drugged and raped them?

Feeling sorry for Cosby's wife because of his promiscuity and adultery makes sense under the circumstances.
 
Last edited:
I think your issue is a fundamental misunderstanding of logic. The argument put forth is that Scotti is reliable on promiscuity and adultery. The error you make is in conflating "promiscuity and adultery" with "drugging and raping."
Wilt Chamberlain claimed to have slept with 20,000 women, in your opinion, does that mean he drugged and raped them?
Feeling sorry for Cosby's wife because of his promiscuity and adultery makes sense under the circumstances.

In fact, the poster I was responding to made that jump...

Well that definitely shows that the promiscuity and adultery is well evidenced. That man really has no reason to lie at all, he is not the type of person who would give two ***** about a book deal or interview money. Or fame. Or just plain sick. (Perhaps a vendetta but it would have to be something so huge to just be extremely unlikely.)

My willingness to believe the rape allegations has increased dramatically.
 
I did some research on him to answer the first part of your sentence.
By all means then, explain how it is that you know his motives.

The second part of your sentence is something I never said and would never say. I believe that is called a strawman.
Nope. You proclaimed facts that clearly aren't knowable, your private research notwithstanding.
 
In fact, the poster I was responding to made that jump...

"My willingness to believe the rape allegations has increased dramatically" does not equal "I accept all rape allegations against Bill Cosby to be true."

One's willingness to entertain an opinion does not mean they accept the opinion as true.
 
Another issue not discussed is the way the male-dominated entertainment industry has a long history of allowing attractive young women to be sexually exploited by powerful men within the industry.
The "casting couch" was a running joke in the 60's and 70's, as I recall since I heard some jokes about it as a kid and had to ask some people what was being talked about.
Great. First of all, Cliff Huxtable had awful sweaters.
A misdemeanor, not a felony.
I don't see the point in un-ringing those bells. Cosby was a recipient of those honors and he's also going to be remembered as a serial drugging rapist. Those realities can coexist.
Add me to the vote on this point.
I think his sexy fun times are behind him.
Blue pills may help with that ...

The error you make is in conflating "promiscuity and adultery" with "drugging and raping."

Wilt Chamberlain claimed to have slept with 20,000 women, in your opinion, does that mean he drugged and raped them?
Agreed.
Feeling sorry for Cosby's wife because of his promiscuity and adultery makes sense under the circumstances.
About a decade ago some splash in the news had to do with Cosby and his affairs. His wife had to put up with that. I suspect that she had to put up with his affairs her whole married life, given how much travel he did as an entertainer.
Now this. I feel for her as well.
"My willingness to believe the rape allegations has increased dramatically" does not equal "I accept all rape allegations against Bill Cosby to be true."

One's willingness to entertain an opinion does not mean they accept the opinion as true.
Also agreed.

Say it ain't so, Bill. :(
Thought: The ability of an internet lynch mob, or an SI reporter, to get a message out (of unknown veracity) is a disturbing trend in the modern age. (I refer to the Duke Lacrosse case).

But is it believable that, in the entertainment industry, from the 60's to the 90's, a star diddled a lot of gals and felt entitled to do so? In so doing, did same star do some stuff that was wrong?

Yes, it is believable, which is what makes this case believable ... regardless of what the facts are at ground level.

Sad, as the Cos was always a fave of mine.
Not hard to believe that in this case, the 'smoke/fire' issue probably fits. :(
 
Thought: The ability of an internet lynch mob, or an SI reporter, to get a message out (of unknown veracity) is a disturbing trend in the modern age. (I refer to the Duke Lacrosse case).

But is it believable that, in the entertainment industry, from the 60's to the 90's, a star diddled a lot of gals and felt entitled to do so? In so doing, did same star do some stuff that was wrong?

Yes, it is believable, which is what makes this case believable ... regardless of what the facts are at ground level.

Sad, as the Cos was always a fave of mine.
Not hard to believe that in this case, the 'smoke/fire' issue probably fits. :(

I would tend to agree. The issue I see is that not all the women are claiming rape but their stories are being used to support the actual claims of rape. My understanding, as of last count, was that 3 women claim rape and that one of those stories is in serious doubt, namely Janice Dickinson's.

I really don't care if Bill Cosby had sex with every woman in California. The only ones I care about are the ones who say it was against their will. For example, when you are a big enough star to be on the Tonight Show, I don't see how you can claim an in balance of power as the reason you gave Bill Cosby a blow job in the green room. In my opinion, that was consensual sex.
 
I would tend to agree. The issue I see is that not all the women are claiming rape but their stories are being used to support the actual claims of rape. My understanding, as of last count, was that 3 women claim rape and that one of those stories is in serious doubt, namely Janice Dickinson's.

I really don't care if Bill Cosby had sex with every woman in California. The only ones I care about are the ones who say it was against their will. For example, when you are a big enough star to be on the Tonight Show, I don't see how you can claim an in balance of power as the reason you gave Bill Cosby a blow job in the green room. In my opinion, that was consensual sex.

How many women does he have to have sex with against their will before you call him a rapist?
 
How many women does he have to have sex with against their will before you call him a rapist?

Qayak very clearly said that he counts those he had sex with against their will as rape victims. I think he doubts the allegations, though at this point it's hard to discount all of the evidence.
 
How many women does he have to have sex with against their will before you call him a rapist?

1. And the evidence was building but then 25% of the evidence was put into serious doubt (On a quick recount, there are 4 women who make claims of drugging and raping).

Why haven't you mentioned anything about the fact that the evidence suggests one of the women isn't being honest?
 
Qayak very clearly said that he counts those he had sex with against their will as rape victims. I think he doubts the allegations, though at this point it's hard to discount all of the evidence.

That's accurate. I doubt the allegations but that's nothing new. I doubt Cosby's claims too, and the lawyer that says all the allegations were debunked years ago.
 
Last edited:
How many women does he have to have sex with against their will before you call him a rapist?

Dang you, now I have that melody stuck in my head. :(



{edit to add} Nommed, but I won't vote for you. Bastard. I really really hate that song.
 
Last edited:
1. And the evidence was building but then 25% of the evidence was put into serious doubt (On a quick recount, there are 4 women who make claims of drugging and raping).

Why haven't you mentioned anything about the fact that the evidence suggests one of the women isn't being honest?

There are 17 women listed here. Nearly all allege drugging, three specifically allege rape, others, sexual assault. Some of them don't allege rape because they cannot remember what happened, due to the drugs.
 
1. And the evidence was building but then 25% of the evidence was put into serious doubt (On a quick recount, there are 4 women who make claims of drugging and raping).

Why haven't you mentioned anything about the fact that the evidence suggests one of the women isn't being honest?

If you need only one then why are you doubting three?


Why haven't you mentioned anything about the fact that the evidence suggests that Cosby is a lying lecherous rapist.
 
If you need only one then why are you doubting three?

I doubt everyone until actual evidence is presented.

Why haven't you mentioned anything about the fact that the evidence suggests that Cosby is a lying lecherous rapist.

For the same reason I haven't said the women are lying, conniving, gold diggers.

Wanna talk about the impact the discredited claim has on the overall allegations or do you want to continue with your tizzy fit?
 
I doubt everyone until actual evidence is presented.



For the same reason I haven't said the women are lying, conniving, gold diggers.

Wanna talk about the impact the discredited claim has on the overall allegations or do you want to continue with your tizzy fit?


What do you consider actual evidence?

Tizzy fit?? I haven't heard that one in a coon's age.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom