Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

And that is a huge problem. But what I said was this: most opinions are not directed at finding the truth. I didn't imply that you had this opinion for ***** and giggles, but simply that my belief is that we should aspire to more than opinions that we find satisfying.

I agree 100% with that belief... but I didn't become convinced about Cosby because it was satisfying, but because I find the available evidence compelling.

When I first heard these allegations, and the lawsuit he settled, many years ago, I thought it was likely he had drug-raped a few women. After having carefully read the consistent accounts from a large number of diversified victims (and other stories supporting their depictions of his lowlife character), I don't believe it's "likely" anymore. I'm convinced Cosby is a serial drug rapist , and I think this is a more than reasonable conclusion.

I do aspire to draw conclusions on more than "satisfying opinions"... like those displayed by Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck and other Cosby defenders currently ridiculing the accusers as a femanazi lynch mob.
 


Say I am researching two people, call them X and Y. I find information about person X that substantiates their claims. Me doing that does not suddenly mean that Y's claims are unsubstantiated.

And yet that is exactly what you accused me of doing.
 
Say I am researching two people, call them X and Y. I find information about person X that substantiates their claims. Me doing that does not suddenly mean that Y's claims are unsubstantiated.

And yet that is exactly what you accused me of doing.

Not following you.
 


Perhaps you did not notice that you posted in a line of 3 posts?

Here they are, posts 133, 148, and 149. Each specifically quotes the one above it.

Well that definitely shows that the promiscuity and adultery is well evidenced. That man really has no reason to lie at all, he is not the type of person who would give two ***** about a book deal or interview money. Or fame. Or just plain sick. (Perhaps a vendetta but it would have to be something so huge to just be extremely unlikely.)

My willingness to believe the rape allegations has increased dramatically.
There's an awful lot of smoke for there not to be fire.

That said, how do you know this? And know it so well that you proclaim it as unvarnished fact?


There's an awful lot of smoke for there not to be fire.

That said, how do you know this? And know it so well that you proclaim it as unvarnished fact?

Well that type of person is a reliable man, not some flighty floozy actress who probably just wants to sell books and revive a career, or something.



Everyone should be the same default amount of suspect. No matter if they are a "reliable man" or a "flighty floozy actress".

If you were accusing me of making a judgement on such horrible characterizations then that is just sick.

Scotti just so happened to be someone who has lots of information available in the public domain.
 
Of course. Finding the testimony of almost 20 women giving detailed and consistent reports that they were raped by the same fellow convincing is only due to convenience and emotional needs.

And here is the link I was mentioning:

Here's the 1969 Bill Cosby Routine About Wanting to Drug Women's Drinks

Cosby's dozen-plus accusers tell similar stories: that, after having a drink with Cosby, they felt drugged and confused as he had his way with them. Curiously, Cosby himself once made such scenarios the center of a stand-up routine: Witness "Spanish Fly," a cut from his now-unfortunately titled 1969 LP It's True! It's True!.

In it, Cosby describes being a kid and hearing about a wonder drug -- "Spanish Fly" -- that would make a girl go crazy once it was put into her drink. He presents this as a horny/goofy lark of an idea, a myth that kids buy into all over the world. More disturbingly, Cosby then describes his adult interest in such a drug, especially on a trip he took to Spain with Robert Culp of I Spy -- both Culp and Cosby, he claims, were desperate to get their hands on some Spanish Fly.
 
Perhaps you did not notice that you posted in a line of 3 posts?

Here they are, posts 133, 148, and 149. Each specifically quotes the one above it.








Everyone should be the same default amount of suspect. No matter if they are a "reliable man" or a "flighty floozy actress".

If you were accusing me of making a judgement on such horrible characterizations then that is just sick.

Scotti just so happened to be someone who has lots of information available in the public domain.

So you are saying that he is a reliable man, whereas there are question marks around the accusers:

I'm not sure how you can accept that to be a "probably" if the person is both extremely rich and popular.

In that situation I would need to know a bit of background history on each accuser to try and surmise if they are just seeing some interview revenue in their future (or the almighty "book deal") before going anywhere close to "probably".

What kind of background research enabled you to give Scotti the all-clear whereas with the anonymous actresses and not so anonymous actresses you put the likelihood of them doing this for book deals or interview revenue much higher?
 
Unfortunate. Why are there statutes of limitations on such a severe crime ?

Are there? If so, that is depressing.

Well, let me put it this way: if someone claims to have eaten pizza this week-end, I'll take their word on it. If they claim to have eaten pizza and I know they hate pizza, I might be suspicious and look for confirmation, assuming I even care. If someone claims to be able to fly with the power of their mind, since this would overthrow physics, in addition to allowing me to go on trips without having to pay for the plane tickets, I'll be looking for very strong supporting evidence. Accusations of rape fall somewhere down the middle: I care enough to want some confirmation before I jump to conclusions, either way.



It doesn't. You have misread what I said: the threshold of evidence changes.

This is irrelevant, however, to my point about rationality and not jumping to conclusions.

I think the evidence is pretty strong now.
 
What kind of background research enabled you to give Scotti the all-clear whereas with the anonymous actresses and not so anonymous actresses you put the likelihood of them doing this for book deals or interview revenue much higher?


The kind of background research you could easily do if chose to do some research instead of posting slanderous accusations.

Scotti literally has a few magnitudes more information available than the accusers do. Go see for yourself.

Again, for those who seem to not be able to grasp science. Finding information about one person does not suddenly mean information does not exist about the other person. It just was not as readily available. It is not that hard of a concept to understand.

By saying I found substantiation about one person does not mean that suddenly another person is beyond substantiation.
 
So you are saying that he is a reliable man, whereas there are question marks around the accusers.


Could not possibly be phrased with more bias.

Person X and Person Y start out with the exact same amount of question marks.

Research is done on Person X that shows the question marks might not be in question.

That research shows absolutely no bias or disdain about Person Y what-so-ever. No light is shed on Person Y by that research.

And yet you chose to imply that it did.
 
Unfortunate. Why are there statutes of limitations on such a severe crime ?

The purpose and effect of statutes of limitations is to protect defendants. There are three reasons supporting the existence of statutes of limitations, namely:
(a) a plaintiff with good causes of actions should pursue them with reasonable diligence;

(b) a defendant might have lost evidence to disprove a stale claim; and

(c) long dormant claims have more cruelty than justice in them (Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th edition). The general rule is the limitation period begins when the plaintiff’s cause of action accrues or is made to be aware of the injury that might have happened a long time ago (e.g., asbestos injury).

With a case such as rape I think that unfortunately it is very difficult to be anything other than one person's word against another's in many if not most cases.

In Japan there is was a statute of limitations on murder. There have, apparently, been cases of murderers turning up at police stations after the term has expired and confessing, knowing that they cannot be prosecuted for it. I don't suppose it does much for their future employment prospects, however.

Looks like it has been abolished:

In a rare move, Justice Minister Keiko Chiba enforced a new law Tuesday abolishing the statute of limitations for murder on the same day the bill passed the Diet so an unsolved 1995 murder case wouldn’t expire at midnight.

The bill for amending the code of criminal procedure was enacted in a Lower House plenary session in the afternoon.

On April 28, 1995, farmer Haruhiko Sunami, 70, and his wife, Midori, 66, were found decapitated inside their burned-down home in Kurashiki, Okayama Prefecture. A kitchen knife was found in the farmer’s stomach.

Chiba did not initially plan to enforce the bill immediately but began to work toward it as soon as she learned about the Sunami case, according to government sources. The bill passed the Upper House on April 14.

http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/20...imitations-in-murder-cases-axed/#.VHa_FdKsWRA
 
The kind of background research you could easily do if chose to do some research instead of posting slanderous accusations.

I have not made any "slanderous accusations". Not unless you have made libellous insinuations ("Almighty book deal".)

Scotti literally has a few magnitudes more information available than the accusers do. Go see for yourself.

Again, for those who seem to not be able to grasp science.

Ha ha!

You're not doing "science". ;)

Finding information about one person does not suddenly mean information does not exist about the other person. It just was not as readily available. It is not that hard of a concept to understand.

By saying I found substantiation about one person does not mean that suddenly another person is beyond substantiation.

I still don't understand the grammar of this at all.
 
Perhaps we should refrain from condemning or exonerating him until the evidence is weighed in and a verdict delivered ?

Considering the time that has passed since these incidents are supposed to have happened the only additional evidence that is likely to be presented is more victim statements. So it's still likely to be words against words and baring anything else we are still going to be where we are right now.
 
I think the evidence is pretty strong now.

I think Janice Dickinson's story is very much in question. She claims Cosby drugged and raped her in his hotel room in Lake Tahoe and yet in her autobiography she says this about the incident:

He kissed me, full on the lips, then went off to dress and we went downstairs, to dinner, where Cosby spent the next two hours talking about himself. It was An Evening with Bill Cosby. A Tribute to Bill Cosby. [...]

After dinner he asked me back to his room, and I went. But I stopped myself at the door. “I’m exhausted,” I said, begging off. His eyebrows went a little funny.

“Exhausted?” he asked, and it was clear he was trying hard to keep his temper in check. “After all I’ve done for you, that’s what I get? I’m exhausted.”

“Well, gee, Bill,” I stammered. “If I had known it was going to be like this—”

He waved both hands in front of my face, silencing me. Then he gave me the dirtiest, meanest look in the world, stepped into his suite, and slammed the door in my face.

In the original story she never went into his room. In her new story she went in, was drugged and raped. That's a bit of a discrepancy.

She claims her publishers edited the text after Cosby's lawyers read an advance copy. They say they never read anything regarding her book before it was published. It will be interesting to see what the publishing company has to say about it. No doubt they would have some written correspondence to back up her claims.
 
Your attempt at splitting hairs is a silly one. Sexual assault happens. Pancake House breakfasts happen. Far more people have committed sexual assault than have ever even set foot inside of a Pancake House, but still: neither of those things are inherently implausible events.

And your inability to admit when you've said something stupid is even sillier. But that's the world in which we live.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom