Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

And yet we are rational men and women, are we not ? Do we need to make a judgment in order to feel good about all this ? I see no problem holding on that judgment, though I will admit that none of this looks good for Cosby at all, and I lean more towards guilt than innocence. You won't see me with a pitchfork, however.

And shouldn't we aspire to act more rationally than not ? The problem on debates like this is that there are basically two types of posters: those who defend the accused to the point of implying or outward saying that all accusers are liars or worse, and those who immediately assume that, where there's smoke, there's fire, and that the accused is guilty. Precious few voices of reason. Why is that ? Are we required to reach a decision right away ?

The accusations are evidence. It is not irrational to consider what evidence there is and come to a reasonable conclusion.

It isn't just the women making the claims, there have been employees who performed functions that consequently made them complicit in Cosby's behavior. Some of them are coming forward with information too.
 
Okay so are we now all agreed now that it is not irrational or unreasonable for people to believe that the twenty or so plausible allegations that Cosby sexually assaulted someone mean that Cosby probably has sexually assaulted someone

I think you might have skipped a couple of steps, here: 1) To what goalposts are you refering ? 2) why are you attempting to put words in my mouth that I did not utter ?

I'd say that concluding that I agree with you on anything when we're discussing a disagreement is dishonest of you.
 
The accusations are evidence.

Of course they are, and the evidence is mounting. The fact that non-victims are supporting these claims is very damning.

It is not irrational to consider what evidence there is and come to a reasonable conclusion.

I was responding specifically to this post:

He's a serial rapist who drugged his victims so they couldn't fight back. Eff his comedy albums.
 
I think you might have skipped a couple of steps, here: 1) To what goalposts are you refering ? 2) why are you attempting to put words in my mouth that I did not utter ?

I'd say that concluding that I agree with you on anything when we're discussing a disagreement is dishonest of you.

Okay so it is "dishonest" to say that you agree that believing twenty plausible allegations is reasonable. And yet, per your earlier post in this thread

And shouldn't we aspire to act more rationally than not ? The problem on debates like this is that there are basically two types of posters: those who defend the accused to the point of implying or outward saying that all accusers are liars or worse, and those who immediately assume that, where there's smoke, there's fire, and that the accused is guilty. Precious few voices of reason. Why is that ? Are we required to reach a decision right away ?


It would seem as though you don't not agree that believing twenty plausible allegations is more irrational than not and disqualifies one from being considered (by you) to be one of the "precious few voices of reason".

Are you ever going to explain what your position actually is, or are you just going to leave us puzzling over what is quite possibly the worst logic problem ever written?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we should refrain from condemning or exonerating him until the evidence is weighed in and a verdict delivered ?

If I was on a jury, I would. But I'm not, so I can express my opinion that he's a drug raping, sickening creep.
This.
As the statute of limitations has passed, a verdict likely certainly will never be delivered.
And this. And FTFY. And all the more reason that people should not withhold their opinion, if they feel inclined to air it. And I don't mean that in a witch-hunt fashion.

I also believe OJ is a murdering piece of crap, despite the "verdict".
What do these two people have in common, so that one reminds you of the other?
They're both men? And both American?

I have a feeling which answer you're angling for, though. But the OJ trial is the most notorious case in recent American history of a wrong acquittal, so I can see why anyone would bring that one up. No reason to play the race card.
 
Okay so it is "dishonest" to say that you agree that believing twenty plausible allegations is reasonable.

It's dishonest to dodge my questions and then simply assume that I agree with anything that you feel you can type in the post where you presume that I agree with you. I don't even know how you managed to think it was a good idea.

You also don't not agree that believing twenty plausible allegations is reasonable.

Again, please refrain from making me say things I did not say or imply. This is also a dishonest tactic.

Are you ever going to explain what your position actually is

I have done so already. If you think it is unclear, perhaps you could tell me what you wish me to clarify.

or are you just going to leave us puzzling over what is quite possibly the worst logic problem ever written?

Your penchant for hyperbole, incredulity and uncivility is endearing, but useless.
 
If I was on a jury, I would. But I'm not, so I can express my opinion that he's a drug raping, sickening creep. I also believe OJ is a murdering piece of crap, despite the "verdict".

Who used to make jokes about doing that (according to a link upthread)
 
This.

And this. And FTFY. And all the more reason that people should not withhold their opinion, if they feel inclined to air it. And I don't mean that in a witch-hunt fashion.

Yes. And If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice.

And I don't mean that in a Witch Hunt sense. It's not even from Witch Hunt. It's from Freewill.
 
Last edited:
Why should they not be the same? They do not differ in plausibility.

I would suggest that they do differ in plausibility, unless you're suggesting that the percentage of the population that eats pancakes is the same as the percentage of the population that rapes people. I would suggest that one number is lower and therefore the event described is less plausible.
 
I would suggest that they do differ in plausibility, unless you're suggesting that the percentage of the population that eats pancakes is the same as the percentage of the population that rapes people. I would suggest that one number is lower and therefore the event described is less plausible.

The category is rich, famous men who rape women.
 
I would suggest that they do differ in plausibility, unless you're suggesting that the percentage of the population that eats pancakes is the same as the percentage of the population that rapes people.

The supposition isn't just that I eat pancakes. It's that I've gone to a particular pancake-serving restaurant at some time in the past. The percentage of the population that has gone to any one particular Pancake House is almost certainly orders of magnitude lower than the percentage of the population that has committed rape, so by your logic that makes the rape allegations more plausible than the Pancake House allegations, does it not?
 
Last edited:
It's dishonest to dodge my questions and then simply assume that I agree with anything that you feel you can type in the post where you presume that I agree with you. I don't even know how you managed to think it was a good idea.

Again, please refrain from making me say things I did not say or imply. This is also a dishonest tactic.

I have done so already. If you think it is unclear, perhaps you could tell me what you wish me to clarify.

Colander ?
 
Colander ?

Dear Belz

Do you do believe it is reasonable to believe that there is probably some truth underlying twenty independent allegations that a particular person did a thing which people are known to sometimes do? Why or why not?

Best
colander
 
Last edited:
What do these two people have in common, so that one reminds you of the other?

Obviously, I'm a racist raging against black criminals who get away with violent crimes.

Or maybe I'm referring to an example of a high profile jury verdict everyone's heard of as an example of why verdicts don't necessarily have anything to do with objective truth.
 
Personal opinions aren't, either. Mostly they are directed at the search for a convenient conclusion that fits with one's biases and emotional needs. Mostly.

Of course. Finding the testimony of almost 20 women giving detailed and consistent reports that they were raped by the same fellow convincing is only due to convenience and emotional needs.
 
The important thing, now that this history has been so well publicized, is that women will be extra careful about spending time alone with him.
 
The supposition isn't just that I eat pancakes. It's that I've gone to a particular pancake-serving restaurant at some time in the past. The percentage of the population that has gone to any one particular Pancake House is almost certainly orders of magnitude lower than the percentage of the population that has committed rape, so by your logic that makes the rape allegations more plausible than the Pancake House allegations, does it not?

Oh, well, the supposition isn't that Bill Cosby just raped some women, it's that he raped some specific women, so that makes it even more unlikely again.

It was you that insisted that the examples must be directly comparable, which is why you specified that it had to be 20 times you'd eaten at that place, was it not? So, rather than talking about people who have raped anybody, we have to talk about the percentage of the population who have raped those specific 20 women.

If, you know, your argument is going to be consistent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom