Bill Cosby's social media ploy backfires

We're not on a jury, son.

And yet we are rational men and women, are we not ? Do we need to make a judgment in order to feel good about all this ? I see no problem holding on that judgment, though I will admit that none of this looks good for Cosby at all, and I lean more towards guilt than innocence. You won't see me with a pitchfork, however.

And shouldn't we aspire to act more rationally than not ? The problem on debates like this is that there are basically two types of posters: those who defend the accused to the point of implying or outward saying that all accusers are liars or worse, and those who immediately assume that, where there's smoke, there's fire, and that the accused is guilty. Precious few voices of reason. Why is that ? Are we required to reach a decision right away ?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps we should refrain from condemning or exonerating him until the evidence is weighed in and a verdict delivered ?

If I was on a jury, I would. But I'm not, so I can express my opinion that he's a drug raping, sickening creep. I also believe OJ is a murdering piece of crap, despite the "verdict".
 
And yet we are rational men and women, are we not ? Do we need to make a judgment in order to feel good about all this ? I see no problem holding on that judgment, though I will admit that none of this looks good for Cosby at all, and I lean more towards guilt than innocence. You won't see me with a pitchfork, however.

Nobody here has a pitchfork. This is a discussion on the internet. People are using their words to talk about a thing. That is exactly what is supposed to be happening.

And shouldn't we aspire to act more rationally than not ? The problem on debates like this is that there are basically two types of posters: those who defend the accused to the point of implying or outward saying that all accusers are liars or worse, and those who immediately assume that, where there's smoke, there's fire, and that the accused is guilty. Precious few voices of reason. Why is that ? Are we required to reach a decision right away ?

Thought experiment for you, Belz. If twenty different people on twenty separate occasions tell you they've seen me at Pancake House of a Sunday eating breakfast, would it be reasonable for you to conclude that I've been to the Pancake House? Would it be rational? Why or why not?
 
Last edited:
If I was on a jury, I would. But I'm not, so I can express my opinion that he's a drug raping, sickening creep. I also believe OJ is a murdering piece of crap, despite the "verdict".

I don't see why we should hold ourselves to different standards when not in court, but I suppose that's your right.

If twenty different people on twenty separate occasions tell you they've seen me at Pancake House of a Sunday eating breakfast, would it be reasonable for you to conclude that I've been to the Pancake House? Would it be rational? Why or why not?

Yes. Yes. Because the preponderance of evidence meets my standard for trivial events like that.

I also notice that you asked questions rather than answer mine. Would you like to do so now ?
 
Yes. Yes. Because the preponderance of evidence meets my standard for trivial events like that.

Why should the "triviality" of the event matter for you when deciding whether or not you feel those twenty independent accounts are on target? Plausibility should matter, sure. But "triviality"? Why would that affect the likelihood you place on the accounts being true?

Surely you are not saying that the reasonableness and rationalitude of believing there to be some truth to twenty plausible independent accounts of an event rests on your own subjective judgement as to how "trivial" you feel the event is?
 
Last edited:
I don't see why we should hold ourselves to different standards when not in court, but I suppose that's your right.

Because the standards used in a courtroom are not directed at a search for the truth. Those standards are used to manage a heavily taxed criminal justice system as efficiently as possible.

I'm not deciding the good doctor's fate. I'm forming a reasonable opinion based on the consistency, and breadth of the victim's statements. Taken together, they are convincing to me.
 
Last edited:
Why should the "triviality" of the event matter for you when deciding whether or not you feel those twenty independent accounts are on target?

Well, let me put it this way: if someone claims to have eaten pizza this week-end, I'll take their word on it. If they claim to have eaten pizza and I know they hate pizza, I might be suspicious and look for confirmation, assuming I even care. If someone claims to be able to fly with the power of their mind, since this would overthrow physics, in addition to allowing me to go on trips without having to pay for the plane tickets, I'll be looking for very strong supporting evidence. Accusations of rape fall somewhere down the middle: I care enough to want some confirmation before I jump to conclusions, either way.

But "triviality"? Why would that affect the likelihood you place on the accounts being true?

It doesn't. You have misread what I said: the threshold of evidence changes.

This is irrelevant, however, to my point about rationality and not jumping to conclusions.
 
If I was on a jury, I would. But I'm not, so I can express my opinion that he's a drug raping, sickening creep. I also believe OJ is a murdering piece of crap, despite the "verdict".
What do these two people have in common, so that one reminds you of the other?
 
Well, let me put it this way: if someone claims to have eaten pizza this week-end, I'll take their word on it. If they claim to have eaten pizza and I know they hate pizza, I might be suspicious and look for confirmation, assuming I even care. If someone claims to be able to fly with the power of their mind, since this would overthrow physics, in addition to allowing me to go on trips without having to pay for the plane tickets, I'll be looking for very strong supporting evidence. Accusations of rape fall somewhere down the middle: I care enough to want some confirmation before I jump to conclusions, either way.

I'm sorry but this answer doesn't make any sense. Flying around through mind power is physically impossible. Going to Pancake House isn't. Drug-rape isn't, either. That's why most people here are treating these allegations the same way they would treat the Pancake House sightings: by provisionally concluding that there probably were some drug-rapes and pancake breakfasts happening here. That is not irrational or unreasonable.
 
Flying around through mind power is physically impossible.

Yes, that's precisely why I would ask for more solid evidence for it.

Going to Pancake House isn't. Drug-rape isn't, either.

Do you believe that the standard of evidence for those two things is the same ? Let's change the parameters of your question a bit: what if a single person said they saw me go to the Pancakes. Would that be enough for you to conclude that I did ? What if a single person accused someone of rape ?
 
Do you believe that the standard of evidence for those two things is the same ?

Why should they not be the same? They do not differ in plausibility. Perhaps I will feel moar sadz if I believe Bill Cosby is a raper than I will if I believe myself to be a pancake glutton, but assigning probabilistic weight to my own emotionally-based reluctance to believe something is hardly the rational thing to do here.

Let's change the parameters of your question a bit

Since we're talking about whether it's rational to believe the allegations against Bill Cosby, it's more illustrative if we use an analogy that matches the Cosby situation in as many respects as possible. Therefore, we'll stick with twenty people having seen me at Pancake House.
 
Last edited:
Why should they not be the same? They do not differ in plausibility.

Let's make sure we understand each other: you as readily conclude that someone commited rape based on a single report than you do that someone went to a restaurant ?

Perhaps I will feel moar sadz if I believe Bill Cosby is a raper than I will if I believe myself to be a pancake glutton, but assigning probabilistic weight to my own emotionally-based reluctance to believe something is hardly the rational thing to do here.

Actually, assigning probabilistic weight to your emotionally-based biases is exactly what I think you are doing, here.

Since we're talking about whether it's rational to believe the allegations against Bill Cosby, it's more illustrative if we use an analogy that matches the Cosby situation in as many respects as possible.

Yes, and in that sense it makes sense to have twenty people "accusing" you of going to pancakes. However my purpose was to determine whether you truly have the same threshold of evidence for all claims. I do not believe that you do, nor should you.
 
Let's make sure we understand each other: you as readily conclude that someone commited rape based on a single report than you do that someone went to a restaurant ?

Sorry, Belz. I get that you really want to move those goalposts, but it's not happening.

Yes, and in that sense it makes sense to have twenty people "accusing" you of going to pancakes. However my purpose was to determine whether you truly have the same threshold of evidence for all claims. I do not believe that you do, nor should you.

I am trying to use Socratic questioning to get you to explain to us (and to yourself) exactly what reasoning you are using here to get to your conclusion that it is somehow irrational to believe that there is probably some truth to twenty plausible independent allegations. Can you explain this reasoning? Or is that not possible for you at this time?
 
Yes, that's precisely why I would ask for more solid evidence for it.



Do you believe that the standard of evidence for those two things is the same ? Let's change the parameters of your question a bit: what if a single person said they saw me go to the Pancakes. Would that be enough for you to conclude that I did ? What if a single person accused someone of rape ?

I thought we were discussing Cosbys' case.

If we're playing "what if" then what if 100 women claimed they raped them and they had video, witnesses and a signed confession, would you then believe them?

Better yet, what if you address the facts of this case.
 
Sorry, Belz. I get that you really want to move those goalposts, but it's not happening.

I'm trying to understand what you are saying. To what goalposts are you refering ? Do you even know what the expression means ?

I am trying to use Socratic questioning to get you to explain to us (and to yourself) exactly what reasoning you are using here to get to your conclusion that it is somehow irrational to believe that there is probably some truth to twenty plausible independent allegations.

Speaking of fallacies, why are you attempting to put words in my mouth that I did not utter ?

I thought we were discussing Cosbys' case.

If we're playing "what if" then what if 100 women claimed they raped them and they had video, witnesses and a signed confession, would you then believe them?

Better yet, what if you address the facts of this case.

I have made the point of my question very clear. Please do not attempt to pretend that I didn't.
 
I'm trying to understand what you are saying. To what goalposts are you refering ? Do you even know what the expression means ?



Speaking of fallacies, why are you attempting to put words in my mouth that I did not utter ?

Okay so are we now all agreed now that it is not irrational or unreasonable for people to believe that the twenty or so plausible allegations that Cosby sexually assaulted someone mean that Cosby probably has sexually assaulted someone
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom