Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

That's a nice story.
IMHO, the credentials of the person who reported it may add more credibillity to this story than PGF ever had.

But it has its share of problems.
(1) Anedoctal nature.
(2) If you were a huge powerfull primate you would try to scare a puny human by throwing pines at him?
(3) No follow-up?
(4) There are other possibilities besides a close encounter with a bigfoot, even if some people don't like them. And they do not actually deny Mionczynski's experience. Its nature, however, may be different from what he thinks it was.

Could it have been a true encounter with a bigfoot?
Yes.
Could it have been something else?
Yes.

And?
 
Search my posts. Do any indicate that I "feel good?"

This whole encounter is a 'feel good' report, yet you hold it up as one of the incidents that most convinces you of the reality of bigfoot. There's nothing in this story that connnects it with bigfoot. At no time did Mionczynski ever clearly see a bigfoot, and I'm not aware of any other evidence he presented that supports the bigfoot hypothesis.

This whole thing seems to be a case of taking a natural event, adding a dash of romanticism, stirring in some unconfirmed facts, and presenting it as a bonafide (feel good) bigfoot encounter. Makes for a good campfire story, but little else.

It's time bigfoot supporters start tossing these inconclusive/meaningless reports.

RayG
 
Well I've been away from the Bigfeetsus debate for a few weeks...and it seems nothing much has changed.

Fudd still considers all the pathetic evidence to be "conclusive".

...and it seems that nothing will ever convince him otherwise,cuz dammnit Hairy Bipeds are real!!

Reading DY's Skookum cast analysis was quite interesting....although I've always contended it was an Elk's arse...I'm just no expert on arseprints....Elk,Bigfeet or otherwise...so my opinion is poo pooed by most Bleevers especially when Pope Jeff Meldrum the 1st says it's clearly the arse of a Hairy Biped of Unusual Size.

So now we have a study that pretty much closes the door on Skookum...of course I'd argue that it was only open a (butt)crack to begin with..but that's beside the point.

Down goes Skookum,forced to dwell with the Bossburg prints and dermal ridges as a useless shred of pseudo-evidence.

Which leaves the PGF once again standing alone...oh sorry there's all the "I seen it I swear" stories as well.

In another thread Fudley argues that all the Youtube Biped footage tends to augment the authenticity of the PGF....to which predictably I say...BULLSHYT!!!!!

To me all these Youtube videos are restricted by the Tech that they use.It's far superior to what Roge used on the Sandy Knoll...so they have to film at night...or obscure with trees and crap.......or jiggle the camera. Roge just needed to point his camera and let it take care of the inconclusiveness part.

The PGF is only as important as it's inconclusiveness allows. The PGF's validity is at best an opinion. If you BLEEV than it's the bonafide goods. If you don't BLEEV than it's a crock of hoax puckey. There is nothing "conclusive" about the PGF other than that something was filmed walking across the Bluff Creek Sandbar. What that something was is open to interpretation.

Fudd enjoy's interpreting it as a Hairy Biped of Unusual Size because I don't know I guess it helps him sleep...or whatever.

I find it curious though as to why anyone would argue that rampant hoaxing helps his case in any way.

Help me out here Fuddster would ya?
 
Amazing how quickly things are resolved when "actual" scientists get involved.

There are 'actual' scientists involved with the Skookum cast too, just don't hold yer breath waiting fer one of them to have something published in an 'actual' scientific journal. They seem to be taking their sweet time.

RayG
 
Without two, stinking, still bleeding, complete carcasses, nothing means much to skeptics.

On the contrary. Some clear (i.e., non-fuzzy) photographs would be incredibly significant, especially if they come from different sources and show what's obviously the same creature.

So far, all we have is a bunch of fuzzy photographs, and some obvious fakes. (I find it odd that my mothers, whose hands shake due to MS, is able to take clearer photographs than your average Bigfoot photographer.) The only clear footage is the Patterson tape, which is questionable.

If such a creature exists, I think it would be a crime to kill one just to prove it exists. Sufficient photographic and video recordings would make me happy. "Sufficient," in this case, meaning "clear, not obviously a fake, and preferably coming from multiple sources showing creatures with very similar features."
 
This whole encounter is a 'feel good' report, yet you hold it up as one of the incidents that most convinces you of the reality of bigfoot....

It doesn't "most convince me of the reality of bigfoot." It's an example of an outstanding witness.

Neto and I went around and around and around about biologists in the field not reporting such encounters. Here's one that did. I think it's more significant than Joe Sixpack reporting the same.

End of statement.

At no time did Mionczynski ever clearly see a bigfoot

And if he had, you'd still claim that there is no "evidence."

...and I'm not aware of any other evidence he presented that supports the bigfoot hypothesis.

He clearly stated that he saw the silhouette of a hand, and there was the pine cone throwing testimony.

This whole thing seems to be a case of taking a natural event, adding a dash of romanticism, stirring in some unconfirmed facts, and presenting it as a bonafide (feel good) bigfoot encounter. Makes for a good campfire story, but little else.

Good story teller.

It's time bigfoot supporters start tossing these inconclusive/meaningless reports.

Yeah. And tossing everything else, too.

Nothing but a carcass or two (or three) will do.
 
Well I've been away from the Bigfeetsus debate for a few weeks...and it seems nothing much has changed.

Fudd still considers all the pathetic evidence to be "conclusive".

No, I don't, and I never said I did.

However, I've repeatedly stated that it's provocative (or should be).

So now we have a study that pretty much closes the door on Skookum

No, the door isn't closed yet. If it matters, it's just another qualified opinion (unlike yours or mine; and, oh, btw, I never recorded an opinion on the silly thing one way or the other, because I never saw it; did you?).

...of course I'd argue that it was only open a (butt)crack to begin with..but that's beside the point.

Yeah. Your argument goes a long way. You've never seen the thing, yet you can argue.

Your opinion isn't worth the crack of an ass.

In another thread Fudley argues that all the Youtube Biped footage tends to augment the authenticity of the PGF....to which predictably I say...BULLSHYT!!!!!

To me all these Youtube videos are restricted by the Tech that they use.It's far superior to what Roge used on the Sandy Knoll...so they have to film at night...or obscure with trees and crap.......or jiggle the camera. Roge just needed to point his camera and let it take care of the inconclusiveness part.

Please.........Forty years of photographic technological advances have brought out more detail from the film, not less. And that detail shows that Patterson either built a much better "suit" than that day's Hollywood productions, or it was the real thing.

The PGF is only as important as it's inconclusiveness allows. The PGF's validity is at best an opinion. If you BLEEV than it's the bonafide goods. If you don't BLEEV than it's a crock of hoax puckey.

Thank you. You finally admit that the evidence has nothing to do with it. It's all ideology. Nothing more.

Help me out here Fuddster would ya?

You're beyond help.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
Without two, stinking, still bleeding, complete carcasses, nothing means much to skeptics.
On the contrary. Some clear (i.e., non-fuzzy) photographs would be incredibly significant, especially if they come from different sources and show what's obviously the same creature.

Bullspit.

If such a creature exists, I think it would be a crime to kill one just to prove it exists.

I agree. However, since it is clear that only a carcass (or two, or three) will do the trick, who should we hold responsible for the crime?

Sufficient photographic and video recordings would make me happy.

Somehow, I seriously doubt that.
 
http://www.bigfootencounters.com/articles/biliape_2006.htm

Bili ape is not a new species.

Grover Krantz and his dogs in Smithsonian museum:

http://tinyurl.com/h6kl9
You beat me to it again, LTC. I was thinking of linking both of those. That story on Krantz is a very funny, touching, sad, and honest look at a man that some here have dismissed as an idiot or intellectually dishonest. No matter what one thinks about bigfoot, it's hard not to see Krantz has being an intelligent and willful man. After I read the Bili ape piece I had the distinct suspicion that there was absolutely no new information in there that hasn't already been known for sometime (accept for the claim of an accumulated 20 hours observing). The "Mystery Bili Ape turns out to be a 'fat chimp'" article title also seemed more than a little arrogantly presumptuous. We have the question of an ape that genetic testing seems to firmly place as Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii yet clearly demonstrates anomolous behaviours, living habits, and anatomical features. By Cleve Hicks own admission they came across a large community of animals that had apparently never met humans before and regardless of his assertion that they are nothing more than chimps he still recognizes their anomolous nature and the need for further study.
 
Please.........Forty years of photographic technological advances have brought out more detail from the film, not less. And that detail shows that Patterson either built a much better "suit" than that day's Hollywood productions, or it was the real thing.

I think this line is pretty damn funny.... more detail? Not a chance of that at all. Any more detail is artificial.

However, I'll play. I can't be sure that this greater detail is real, rather than created over time via processing, so how can I trust it?

I would be mighty suspicious of getting greater detail than was available initially from shaky, blurry, 16mm film.

Why can't we all just look at what RP originally shot?
 
It doesn't "most convince me of the reality of bigfoot." It's an example of an outstanding witness.

My bad. When I said "This whole encounter is a 'feel good' report, yet you hold it up as one of the incidents that most convinces you of the reality of bigfoot....", I should have said:

"This whole encounter is a 'feel good' report, yet you hold it up as one of the best individual [bigfoot] encounters..."

Just to clarify, do you think it's one of the best because of the qualifications of the witness, the actual quality of his report, or both?

I think it's more significant than Joe Sixpack reporting the same.

I'd certainly agree IF he was able to clearly identify his tent attacker. He wasn't, so we're left with what he thinks he saw.

RayG said:
At no time did Mionczynski ever clearly see a bigfoot

And if he had, you'd still claim that there is no "evidence."

I'd certainly have further questions, but at least we wouldn't be dealing with shadowy figures in the dark.

He clearly stated that he saw the silhouette of a hand, and there was the pine cone throwing testimony.

Yeah, and he clearly stated that he smacked a bear on the nose. Not once, but twice. No clear observation, no footprints, no clear "evidence."

Good story teller.

On that I agree.

Yeah. And tossing everything else, too.

Nope, just the inconclusive/meaningless reports. There seem to be a great many of them.

Nothing but a carcass or two (or three) will do.

Well, since this is a completely unknown, uncatalogued species, you're probably right.

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom