Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

I'm just glad that I'm not stupid and idiotic enough to believe that bigfoot is real.
 
I'm just glad that I'm not stupid and idiotic enough to believe that bigfoot is real.

_1890222_fight300.jpg


Nice childish rebuttal. (as the father of 11 children, I'm somewhat familiar with childish rebuttals)

Scientists sometimes come up with some pretty stupid and idiotic arguments. Like Alfred Wegener, for example, and his wacky hypothesis about drifting contintents. Apparently that's a widely accepted theory now. Go figure.

Why do you believe it's stupid and idiotic to believe that bigfoot may be real? What's wrong with leaving the possibility door open a crack?

Personally, I'm not willing to believe bigfoot is real based upon the existing evidence, but I'm not willing to slam the door closed on the possibility either.

RayG
 
A major part of the problem in interpreting the Skookum Cast is revealing itself (as I figured it might). A couple of peolpe who've looked at it and studied it, as well as my report (hopefully), can't tell front from back on an elk hoof print. Yeah...but they can properly identify an unknown hominid leg, butt, and arm. Wow...is it too early to start drinking?:boggled:
 
I'm just glad that I'm not stupid and idiotic enough to believe that bigfoot is real.

You don't need to believe that bigfoot is real.

Your intellectual capacity (or lack thereof) is clearly illustrated in so many other ways (see sig lines below.....................)
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
That's right. He even slapped at it through the tent fabric.

Then the shadowy silhouette later threw pine cones at him as he sat huddled before a fire with his gun in his hand.

He never actually saw the shadowy silhouette throwing pine cones. He had drifted off to sleep, and awoke some time later, never catching a glimpse of any bigfoot, nor able to clearly identify his pine cone assaillant....

That's correct. Therefore, something large (bear, human, deer, elk, lion, or sasquatch) initially woke him in his tent by poking it. He slapped at it. He thought saw the silhouette of a "hand". He emerged from the tent, built a fire, then sat up with his weapon until reawakened by the pine cones.

I've never seen bears throw pine cones. I've seen squirrels do so, but not on such a regular basis, nor have I ever seen squirrels that big.

He never saw anything throwing pine cones either, and only assumed it was bigfoot. He never once got a clear, unobstructed view of a bigfoot -- not when it was crashing his tent down around his ears, OR when it supposedly tossed pine cones at him.

Again, correct. We (and he) had options to consider:

* A team of bear/squirrel poked his tent, then threw the pine cones
* A human did both
* A sasquatch did both

Do you wish to choose the most likely possibility or add more?

Not exactly a first class, grade-A bigfoot encounter.

The man was a professional wildlife biologist, and in the woods performing wildlife research when this incident occurred.

This is precisely the scenario that Neto and I went around and around and around and around and around and around and around and around and around and around and around and around about for pages. He wrote that such professionals don't report such situations. Do I need to provide the citations and links for everybody's review?

Now I'll bet dollars to donuts that this report is still no damned good, even though it's reported by a professional wildlife biologist, while on duty researching wildlife.
 
Personally, I'm not willing to believe bigfoot is real based upon the existing evidence, but I'm not willing to slam the door closed on the possibility either....

Kenny's problem isn't that he slammed the door on possibilities, but that somebody must have slammed a door on his head. (See sig lines below.......)
 
Again, correct. We (and he) had options to consider:

* A team of bear/squirrel poked his tent, then threw the pine cones
* A human did both
* A sasquatch did both

Do you wish to choose the most likely possibility or add more?

You also forgot some:

The two incidents were simply coincidental, and not causually related. i.e.- a bear poked at his tent and wandered off. Later, the pine cone incident. However, I'd personally like to see the links and citations, as I have not seen this story yet.

Were the pine cones thrown, or did he wake up when he was hit by one? How many were there? These are just the beginnings of questions to answer.

If he didn't actually see the pine cones arcing in, it's a possibility that they simply fell. I've had similar happen while walking in the woods (although the more cones the less likely this becomes). Also, depenedent on the area, some types of pine trees react to heat, opening and dropping their cones (an evolutionary adaptation to seasonal forest fires). This, of course, depends on the type of pine trees in the area he was in.
 
Thank ya Ray. I did not realize that was a link to the original story.

Well, assuming nothing was embellished, 20 pine cones is a bit much for my theory, and he apparently saw them arcing in.

Still, being able to pick out the shape of a hand, in shillouette, in the dark, through a tent, while said appendage is smashing the tent, when you are obviously not awake enough and not able to see well enough to determine a face poking into your tent is not a bear but more humanoid?

Interesting story, but without supporting evidence, it doesn't mean much. And considering the alleged difficulty of finding a foot, and their reknowned elusiveness and shyness, this type of behavior doesn't fit, either.
 
Last edited:
....;.Interesting story, but without supporting evidence, it doesn't mean much.....

Without two, stinking, still bleeding, complete carcasses, nothing means much to skeptics.

And considering the alleged difficulty of finding a foot, and their reknowned elusiveness and shyness, this type of behavior doesn't fit, either.

Actually, this type of behavior has been reported for years.

This was the first time (to my knowledge) that a nocturnal visit including object-throwing was reported by a professional wildlife biologist who was in the woods professionally "biologizing".
 
Actually, this type of behavior has been reported for years.

Well, I'd hope even you can agree that this type of behavior doesn't fit within the actions of a shy, hard to find creature (i.e.-Snow Leopard).

This doesn't help the case, as if BigFeets were predisposed to agressive and curiousity-driven activities such as this, they wouldn't be so hard to track down. The behavior witnessed doesn't match the behavior theorized. So, we're back to the situation where the witness accounts are still contradictory to the other elements of the case for BigFoot.
 
Why do you believe it's stupid and idiotic to believe that bigfoot may be real? What's wrong with leaving the possibility door open a crack?

The same reasons I don't take UFO abductee stories seriously, the same reasons I don't believe Sylvia Browne is psychic, the same reasons I'm not a scientologist.
 
Kenny's problem isn't that he slammed the door on possibilities, but that somebody must have slammed a door on his head. (See sig lines below.......)

The problem is I'm open to the possibility. I just need a bit of scientific evidence to convince me.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
Actually, this type of behavior has been reported for years.
Well, I'd hope even you can agree that this type of behavior doesn't fit within the actions of a shy, hard to find creature (i.e.-Snow Leopard).

I do. The elusiveness of these creatures is extremely different than the elusiveness common of felines.

Harrassment from concealment is a common tactic for primates, including man. Felines use concealment as their classic stalking foundation. Bears use concealment in a manner between the two; they'll crunch around in the woods just out of sight, circling your camp, sometimes popping their teeth and woofing, and generally trying to intimidate you.

This doesn't help the case, as if BigFeets were predisposed to agressive and curiousity-driven activities such as this, they wouldn't be so hard to track down....

Mionczynski, at the time confident enough to slap a bear's nose through tent fabric, was shook up enough to spend the rest of the evening huddled around a fire with a gun in his hand. He has been a sasquatch researcher ever since, and (to my knowledge) hasn't had another encounter. Again, he was a professional wildlife biologist (a Rocky Mountain sheep man, if memory serves me correctly).

The behavior witnessed doesn't match the behavior theorized. So, we're back to the situation where the witness accounts are still contradictory to the other elements of the case for BigFoot.

It's classic primate behavior.

Ever see the chimps and gorillas throwing their feces at the crowds gawking at them at the zoo?
 
This was the first time (to my knowledge) that a nocturnal visit including object-throwing was reported by a professional wildlife biologist who was in the woods professionally "biologizing".


And that means exactly what ?

How does this information support the existence of a North American, non-human primate ?

What kind of follow-up work has Mionczynski done ?

I thought you were above the ' feel good ' stuff ...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom