Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Originally Posted by Huntster :
It doesn't "most convince me of the reality of bigfoot." It's an example of an outstanding witness.

Just to clarify, do you think it's one of the best because of the qualifications of the witness, the actual quality of his report, or both?

I think the qualifications of the witness is the significant aspect of that event.

I think it's more significant than Joe Sixpack reporting the same.

I'd certainly agree IF he was able to clearly identify his tent attacker. He wasn't, so we're left with what he thinks he saw.

While there was no clear visual sighting, Mionczynski's biology background is significant as he experienced the animal's behavior.
 
For anyone interested, the "official" excuse, er...explanation of the Skookum Cast has been posted on Bigfootforums.com by one of the researchers who've been slaving away for 6 years on it.

It manages to capture the: "yes it looks exactly like an elk lay....but...hey...look at that one part over here....it sort of looks kind of like a human heel, doesn't it? Huh? Y'think?" argument flawlessly. Of course, I'm just a trained ichnologist...what do I know?:rolleyes:
 
For anyone interested, the "official" excuse, er...explanation of the Skookum Cast has been posted on Bigfootforums.com by one of the researchers who've been slaving away for 6 years on it.

It manages to capture the: "yes it looks exactly like an elk lay....but...hey...look at that one part over here....it sort of looks kind of like a human heel, doesn't it? Huh? Y'think?" argument flawlessly. Of course, I'm just a trained ichnologist...what do I know?:rolleyes:

Here is the link..

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=15671

You are doing an excellent job of countering their ' analysis '...


You are sooooooooo, destroying someone's 15 minutes, and the death throws
are entertaining to watch.

I feel a little guilty for gloating about this.. ( Just a little, mind you .. )
 
No, I don't, and I never said I did.

However, I've repeatedly stated that it's provocative (or should be).

Fine Fudster....you never said you did....it's just that it would seem that you confuse provocative with useless is all



No, the door isn't closed yet. If it matters, it's just another qualified opinion (unlike yours or mine; and, oh, btw, I never recorded an opinion on the silly thing one way or the other, because I never saw it; did you?).

Did I see it? By this do you mean....in person? I mean because as i've stated before....I don't live in Hairy Biped country and a trip there is cost prohibitive for me especially just to stare at an ELK print.....errrr......Bigfeet arse cast.

I have however seen it on the Interweb many times and from many different angles. I also have seen it on the LMS and every single time I saw it....it looked like an ELK print!! Desert Yeti's study just reinforces my opinion.

Just another qualified opinion? Fudd stop fighting it...that mush in your skull is trying to tell you something. It's trying to tell you...that ELK are known to dwell in the area,that they kneel down and roll in mud all the time, and that ELK can leave butt prints to.

It's than asking you to couple that with the fact that it makes no sense that any animal would roll over it's own nuts in mud to grab an apple that it could have just knelt down and picked up with minimal effort.

Than it wants you to multiply that by how little the BFRO jackarses who found the thing in the first place put into finding the actual arse that left the print (allegedly)

Finally it wants you to combine all of this with the high wishful thinking factor held by all concerned in the whole thing and voila....you reach the logical conclusion........ELK PRINT!!



Yeah. Your argument goes a long way. You've never seen the thing, yet you can argue.

Your opinion isn't worth the crack of an ass.

Oh Fudd....do I actually need to have seen the actual cast? I've seen the pictures. I've seen Pope Meldrum's diagram...I can tell he's full of poop and I always felt it was what it turn's out to have been.......an ELK PRINT!!

Please.........Forty years of photographic technological advances have brought out more detail from the film, not less. And that detail shows that Patterson either built a much better "suit" than that day's Hollywood productions, or it was the real thing.

More Detail?!?!?! They doctored it up Fudd...c'mon youre not the stupid...are ya? The only flick even worth considering is the OG PGF because it hasn't been tampered with. It's still not very overwhelming but at least it's the unedited version.So if your ok with the PGF:The Footer's Cut,how we wish it looked when it was originally filmed!! version than so be it....it just makes you look ridiculously gullible is all.


Thank you. You finally admit that the evidence has nothing to do with it. It's all ideology. Nothing more.

And evidence never has had much to do with it Fudster....especially given the fact that Bigfoot Apologist never has had much evidence...or least evidence that was worth much.



You're beyond help.

........and you'd be the authority on being beyond help Fudd especially given your behavior here.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster :
No, I don't, and I never said I did.

However, I've repeatedly stated that it's provocative (or should be).

Fine Fudster....you never said you did....it's just that it would seem that you confuse provocative with useless is all

I don't. You do.

Originally Posted by Huntster :
No, the door isn't closed yet. If it matters, it's just another qualified opinion (unlike yours or mine; and, oh, btw, I never recorded an opinion on the silly thing one way or the other, because I never saw it; did you?).

Did I see it? By this do you mean....in person?

That's right.

I mean because as i've stated before....I don't live in Hairy Biped country and a trip there is cost prohibitive for me especially just to stare at an ELK print.....errrr......Bigfeet arse cast.

I'm even farther away, and that's why I didn't go see it. I'm also not impressed enough to drive over a few hours to see it. I think (and always have) that even if it was a bonafide cast of a sasquatch ass, it won't matter a twit.

I have however seen it on the Interweb many times and from many different angles. I also have seen it on the LMS and every single time I saw it....it looked like an ELK print!! Desert Yeti's study just reinforces my opinion.

Armchair quarterbacking. Your opinion is worthless.

Than it wants you to multiply that by how little the BFRO jackarses who found the thing in the first place put into finding the actual arse that left the print (allegedly)

They were in the area for days, using night vision equipment every night. They went through a hellava lot more effort than you, or anybody else commenting on the situation.

Originally Posted by Huntster :
Yeah. Your argument goes a long way. You've never seen the thing, yet you can argue.

Your opinion isn't worth the crack of an ass.

Oh Fudd....do I actually need to have seen the actual cast? I've seen the pictures.

You've seen the PG film, too.

Originally Posted by Huntster :
Please.........Forty years of photographic technological advances have brought out more detail from the film, not less. And that detail shows that Patterson either built a much better "suit" than that day's Hollywood productions, or it was the real thing.

More Detail?!?!?! They doctored it up Fudd

Prove it.
 
They were in the area for days, using night vision equipment every night.

And they found zip ..

They went through a hellava lot more effort than you, or anybody else commenting on the situation.

Ever heard about climbing a ladder that's leaning against the wrong wall ?

And as soon as they had their Bigfoot butt print, they did virtually nothing
to find the critter that left it...

Here we do find a real parallel to PGF event...
 
kitakaze said:
Interesting November '67 Jack Webster radio interview with Patterson and Gimlin. I paid special attention to the parts where they disagreed with an aspect of the others account.
Fair enough, Diogenes. I posted this a while back in the PGF thread and now as then I don't post as an attempt to try and validate the PGF but anyway maybe someone can post a similar document pertaining to the Skookum cast and we can have a good look at what parallels there may be in regards to their immediate follow-ups (or lack thereof) and see just how similar they are.
 
Fair enough, Diogenes. I posted this a while back in the PGF thread and now as then I don't post as an attempt to try and validate the PGF but anyway maybe someone can post a similar document pertaining to the Skookum cast and we can have a good look at what parallels there may be in regards to their immediate follow-ups (or lack thereof) and see just how similar they are.

Well, we need the Bigfoot proponents to show us what they did to try to find the critter who made the cast..

I believe it was Lal who told us that according to Noll, ' ambulance chasing ' doesn't work. Can't argue with that ...

We discussed this extensively in one of the other threads..
We heard lots of excuses why these professionals, out looking for a Bigfoot, spent hours making a cast of the print, rather than trying to track whatever made it.
 
Well, we need the Bigfoot proponents to show us what they did to try to find the critter who made the cast..

I believe it was Lal who told us that according to Noll, ' ambulance chasing ' doesn't work. Can't argue with that ...

We discussed this extensively in one of the other threads..
We heard lots of excuses why these professionals, out looking for a Bigfoot, spent hours making a cast of the print, rather than trying to track whatever made it.
So if we are to assert a parallel between the events of the PGF and the Skookum cast then certainly it's fair to remember that in the case of the PGF we reasonably either have a deliberate hoax or a genuine unkown hominid encounter caught on film as opposed to the Skookum cast where we very likely have an example of biased bigfoot researchers tailoring a mundane find as reason for greater support to their cause. Is the parallel in the motivations or results of their efforts?
 
Last edited:
This is just one more example of skeptics doing way more than they should.

No one has shown any evidence whatsoever that the skookum cast has anything to do with a bigfoot.

I went to great lengths to show it was probably an elk lay, as did others.

Why? We don't have to.

No evidence whatsoever links that cast to bigfoot. None.

People just claim it was made by bigfoot.

That's it. Thats the link to bigfoot. Somebody said so.
 
LTC8K6 said:
This is just one more example of skeptics doing way more than they should.

No one has shown any evidence whatsoever that the skookum cast has anything to do with a bigfoot.

I went to great lengths to show it was probably an elk lay, as did others.

Why? We don't have to.

No evidence whatsoever links that cast to bigfoot. None.

People just claim it was made by bigfoot.

That's it. Thats the link to bigfoot. Somebody said so.
Kudos to you for making that effort, LTC. You'd hope it would skip out a little farther. Nothing at all stopped the Skookum proponents as claiming it as evidence of BF or getting far too much mileage out of it.

Huntster said:
I agree. Stop it. I think skeptics have done way more than they should.

Sit down and shut up.
Come now, Huntster. Hardly called for.
 
I'm joking.

But, that's okay. Huntsters aren't supposed to screw around.
Correct. Only scwewy wabbits. At times like this I like to think, considering there's no one in my real life I could do so with, I like to imagine you, LTC, and I sitting in a nice pub and discussing the topic over a few pints. I like to think that we all have enough respect, tact, courtesy, and genuine interest in the others opinion to have a very fine and lively discussion on the subject. Oh, and look. There's RayG and Diogenes at another table who come and join us and it gets even more interesting. We toss around the ins and outs of sasquatches and have a very fine time. Then Beckjord crawls out of a dark corner and we all flip a table on him and call it a night. And there you have the joy of bigfoot.:D
 
Correct. Only scwewy wabbits....

Dos damned scwewy wabbits!!

At times like this I like to think, considering there's no one in my real life I could do so with, I like to imagine you, LTC, and I sitting in a nice pub and discussing the topic over a few pints.

What! You don't have anybody to go kill a box of beer with!

My problem is that I have too many friend who need help destroying beer. At least, that's what Mrs. Huntster says.........

I like to think that we all have enough respect, tact, courtesy, and genuine interest in the others opinion to have a very fine and lively discussion on the subject. Oh, and look. There's RayG and Diogenes at another table who come and join us and it gets even more interesting. We toss around the ins and outs of sasquatches and have a very fine time. Then Beckjord crawls out of a dark corner and we all flip a table on him and call it a night....

Actually, if I didn't know about Ray's fun and games with the guy, I'd think Beckjord would be a kick to drink with. Heck, I probably wouldn't even need the alcohol. He's such a trip, I'd think I was on LSD just listening to him.
 
Well, we need the Bigfoot proponents to show us what they did to try to find the critter who made the cast..

I believe it was Lal who told us that according to Noll, ' ambulance chasing ' doesn't work. Can't argue with that ...

We discussed this extensively in one of the other threads..
We heard lots of excuses why these professionals, out looking for a Bigfoot, spent hours making a cast of the print, rather than trying to track whatever made it.

As far as I know, the BFRO has never returned to Skookum meadows for any kind of follow up expedition. It's not like climbing to 15,000 feet in the Himalaya looking for the Yeti. The Skookum impression was found 25 feet beside a forest service road. You can simply drive there!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom