Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Correa Neto, actually, I have looked at some Cambrian specimens! Nothing spectacular, but some Cruziana, Skolithos, and Arenicolites in outcrops of the Flathead Sandstone in Wyoming. But I'll look at any trace, anywhere, for any reason...well...mostly any reason!
Why you ask?

I'm working at a NeoProterozoic-Lower Cambrian basin, and some drill cores show what's been interpreted as bioturbations. Intrites, Planolites and Cochlichnus, have ben described (at outcrops if I am not mistaken).

I'm a structural geologist working with mineral exploration, so ichnofossils are not exactly my speciality. It was suggested the particular structures from the cores could be sand dikes (the basin has evidence for synsedimentary tectonic activity). I was considering getting in touch with people from Rio who work with this stuff, but since a paleoichnologist just showed up, I think I could not miss the opportunity of at least asking for some tips, even if at the risk of causing a thread derail.
 
No problem. Go ahead and e-mail me if you want to keep the thread from boring everyone to death with our talk of all things bioturbational.
 
This is the part that I have a tough time with. To be regularily seen by the lay then you have to at least sometimes be seen by the not-so-lay or the not-so-unarmed or the not-so-paying-attention-to-the-road....

All, of course, has reportedly happened. The John Mionczynski situation comes to mind.

I know we've gone over that and rarity ad pukem but for me it does give me doubt even against my own experience we don't have any conclusive proof of any of the above happening.

That's right. There's no conclusive proof for those to whom it hasn't happened.
 
No problem. Go ahead and e-mail me if you want to keep the thread from boring everyone to death with our talk of all things bioturbational.
Little boy: "Daddy, what's 'bioturbational'?" Father (pauses a moment, looks over newspaper): "Well you see, that son, is a new ecologically friendly method for producing turbans in the 21st century.":D
 
It's interesting to me, though not unexpected, that none of the proponents of the Skookum Cast being a real-live imprint of a hominid have offered the slightest bit of evidence to disprove the elk imprint interpretation. Probably because there is none.:D
 
*crazy eyes* Pfft... Desertyeti, man, are you not listening to what Meldrum is saying!? Calcanial (sp?) tendon! Jeez, did you not cover that or what? Huh? Oh, nevermind.:D
 
There's been some discussion here on how important is/was Skookum cast to Meldrum. It seems he may not think of it as the most important piece of evidence around.

My fishy-O-meter beeped when I read about it because bigfoot would have to lay down and roll in the mud to get the fruits. Why not just bend or kneel to get them?

Kitakaze, easy on the sake...
 
My fishy-O-meter beeped when I read about it because bigfoot would have to lay down and roll in the mud to get the fruits. Why not just bend or kneel to get them?
Yes, pick a card from the house of wild speculation. Me, I'll take any card having to do with bigfoot being able to sense cameras.
Kitakaze, easy on the sake...
*burp* Sorry. BTW, shochu's nicer. Disclaimer: Kitakaze takes it easy on the sake and the shochu.
 
Here's Jeff's take on it as of May, 2006.
I of course, disagree with him as do the people I've consulted with who work quite a bit with elk, deer, and other ungulate traces. We're just not as verbose! (Sorry Jeff!):o

THE SKOOKUM BIGFOOT BODY CASTING, 2000, IS STILL A RATHER
CONTROVERSIAL TOPIC. DON'T YOU THINK THE IMPRESSION LENDS ITSELF TO
MULTIPLE INTERPRETATIONS?
Certainly multiple interpretations have been offered by various individuals, some without
the benefit of ever having examined the cast. The only alternate interpretation, excluding
hoaxing, initially worthy of serious consideration was that the imprint was made by an
elk. However, this hypothesis was readily falsified by comparing the impression to those
left by elk, to their anatomy, hair patterns, and behavior. At this point, no reasonable
argument can be made for elk as the responsible candidate. I
found it curious how readily
many individuals adopted an opinion that the reconstructed posture was quite
unreasonable for a large primate. Rick Noll recently filmed a gorilla at the Seattle Zoo
feeding in precisely this posture, right down to the heel plants. It ate selectively and
sloppily as was also indicated at the site.
 
So it seems he thinks its important...

Well, at this point, one could argue that gorillas are not truly bipedals, while bigfeet are supposed to be. OK, gorillas were filmed doing the "Skookum move" at a zoo. Such behavior would be expected to be common in the wild? If its not, then what were the odds of getting a mud imprint of a rare creature doing an unlikely move?

But I guess this path will lead us anywhere...

Honest question:
Is it truly possible that testicles of a primate -even a large one- can leave a mark in the mud?

I never sat naked in mud, only in sand. My personal faulty unreliable anedoctal piece of evidence (fine grained beach sand) indicates that its a bit unlikely. No, don´t ask, I will not make any experiments and post pics. I think most people here do not deserve to be submitted to such images...

Desertyeti, found no pics of the particular parts of the cores with the possible bioturbations. Guess I was too focused on other stuff... In two weeks I'll be back to the project and then I will send you some pics.
 
Last edited:
...However, this hypothesis was readily falsified by comparing the impression to those left by elk, to their anatomy, hair patterns, and behavior....

That statement indicates that Dr. Meldrum compared the impression to those left by elk.

Is that true?

Did you do such comparisons, DY?
 
Sounds great. I'll keep an eye out for the photos.
My first comment would be that dewatering structures or dikes would show upwards deformation of the laminae surrounding them, whereas burrows would likely be surrounded by downward-bending laminae. Intrites might look like a dewatering pipe from above (bedding plane view), but from the side, should be less regular. And Cochlichnus should be very diagnostic on the bedding plane surface, but could be hard to differentiate from Planolites or Paleophycus in core.

I know, I know...it sounds pretty dull, but everyone, try saying Cochlichnus and not laughing (look up pronunciation elsewhere).
 
Glad you asked Huntster!
I don't know whether or not Meldrum did what he claims, since nothing's ever been published on the specimen and therefore, there's no way to evaluate his claims of dissimilarity (although looking at the images I've provided clearly disproves his statement about readily falsifying the elk scenario...in fact it supports it absolutely).

I compared the impression to published photos of elk lays, showed photos of the impression to people who have studied elk lays, and even looked at a cow and deer lay (basically the same thing, but for those who want to point and cheer and say "HAH! He didn't look at an elk lay in person!", go right ahead). The cast fulfilled every single criterion I could find, as well as every single criterion my collegues who study animal sign could find for being an elk lay. So, I'm left with the assumption (yes, a dangerous thing) that either Jeff isn't seeing what tracking specialists and myself are seeing, or somehow, he's mistaken about examining an elk trace.
 
...try saying Cochlichnus and not laughing (look up pronunciation elsewhere).

As an old, pre-Vatican II altar boy, I had a decent command of Latin pronunciations. In fact, we had "names" which sounded a lot like Cochlichnus that we sinfully used on each other.

Who was the sick bastage who named the poor creature such without it being around to defend itself?
 
....I compared the impression to published photos of elk lays, showed photos of the impression to people who have studied elk lays, and even looked at a cow and deer lay (basically the same thing, but for those who want to point and cheer and say "HAH! He didn't look at an elk lay in person!", go right ahead). The cast fulfilled every single criterion I could find, as well as every single criterion my collegues who study animal sign could find for being an elk lay......

Does that include the act of arising from the lay?

I admittedly haven't participated much on Skookum Cast debate either here or at BFF, but I remember lots of folks making an issue of the placement of hooves upon arising.

Does the Skookum Cast remain consistent with that in mind.

Finally, is there any indication that the elk stepped into the mud to get the bait? I find it difficult to imagine that an elk would lay down a few feet away from fruit in the mud, then rise and leave.
 
Yep, I watched the cow rise, and sho' mutt, it sort of roll-heaves itself to the side, then up and out. This is evident in the Skookum Cast. As I've said before, the hooves are exactly where they'd be expected. Anyone claimnig otherwise is either being deceitful or doesn;t know what they're talking about frankly.

It's important to remember too, that the bait was left in a muddy area...the muddy area was there because it's an elk lay. Ungulates re-use their lays several times daily and over many months. The elk that left the print probably nibbled on some fruit either before or after it plopped down. In the cast are indications of prolonged use of the lay over multiple episodes...more on that in the more detailed study report...
 
Hmmm.... I've heard this discussion before..... :D

I was playing the part of desertyeti, as I recall, but I used only photos of Elk doing their thing.

The descriptions of the cast were revealing as well.

The activities of the BFRO crew were damning as well, to me.
 
I thought all he saw was a shadowy silhouette through the material of his tent?

RayG

That's right. He even slapped at it through the tent fabric.

Then the shadowy silhouette later threw pine cones at him as he sat huddled before a fire with his gun in his hand.

I've never seen bears throw pine cones. I've seen squirrels do so, but not on such a regular basis, nor have I ever seen squirrels that big.

But, I've got little experience with Colorado squirrels.

Maybe you can educate me?
 
That's right. He even slapped at it through the tent fabric.

Then the shadowy silhouette later threw pine cones at him as he sat huddled before a fire with his gun in his hand.

He never actually saw the shadowy silhouette throwing pine cones. He had drifted off to sleep, and awoke some time later, never catching a glimpse of any bigfoot, nor able to clearly identify his pine cone assaillant.

I've never seen bears throw pine cones. I've seen squirrels do so, but not on such a regular basis, nor have I ever seen squirrels that big.

He never saw anything throwing pine cones either, and only assumed it was bigfoot. He never once got a clear, unobstructed view of a bigfoot -- not when it was crashing his tent down around his ears, OR when it supposedly tossed pine cones at him. Not exactly a first class, grade-A bigfoot encounter.

http://www.rfthomas.clara.net/news/bringback.html

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom