1. Not true. Front hooves are in the correct position, rear hooves are simply not preserved within the body of the cast and/or obliterated by the slurry-like mud immediately to the animal's right (as evidenced by several depressions that have the appearence of collapsed, slumped holes. They are preserved behind it though...but...he said, I said, so whatever, everyone look at the cast yourselves and make up your own minds.
2. Not true. Cows roll as they stand too. My explanation was lacking, but by "roll" I was referring to how the animal digs in its wrists, while at the same time extending its hind legs down into the substrate after partially tucking them up closer (but still not under) to the body. Horses do it far more athletically, but all hoofed animals can and do stand with a sort of rolling action to re-center their gravity since in the resting position, their hips are at 90 degrees to the dorsal vertebral column. That requires rotation of the lumbar vertebrae to rotate the legs from the side to the downward position, ie., rolling.
3. Not true. Hair details are preserved, though somewhat obscured and easily overlooked, from where the wrist dug in and shifted in the ground as the animal put its weight down while standing...see "he said, I said" though, then look at it for yourselves if yuo ever get a chance.
4. Where? Please do show these key areas and also refer to earlier posts regarding the tendency of hollow and buoyant hair (not specifically addressed in those posts, but worth mentioning) to be very mobile and buoyant in a muddy, cohesive substrate. The hair flow on the cast is identical to a large cervid. You highlighted an area on my interpretation as having completely wrong hair flow patterns, yet offered no explanation. When I went and re-examined the specimen, I found that my interpretation was for the most part correct...I only needed to adjust the metacarpal hairs that were too schematic in the initial sketch...but what about the body? Do tell...
5. Not true. Individual hairs are very difficult to differentiate in muddy substrate impressions. What's probably actually happened with these "3 inch long" hairs is that the tract of individual hairs is following a slight crease or undulation in the skin. Look at any horse, cow, or ungulate of your chosing to see the same exact thing. Also, a single hair can leave a long trail behind it if it is pulled along the substrate for a distance before being lifted. I doubt anyone would confidently guess hair length from a part of the body that was clearly mobile as the animal either sat, adjusted, or stood (like an appendage of an ape or cervid).
I realize that all I'm doing here is saying: "No no no and here's why," but I do appreciate colobus sharing his observations and information. This is the best way to share, air-out, and thoughtfully debate any topic. He offers his views based on his experience, and I offer mine, and anyone else can pipe up too with relevant observations and/or references, don't be shy!
Now, if I may be so bold as to make my own list of glaring points why it clearly is an elk lay: new_lmaosmiley.gif
1) the hindlimb morphology is 100% identical to a partially folded elk leg. the thigh, shin, and metatarsals, complete with ligament and calcaneal tuber are all plainly visible and exactly the correct proportion.
2) the upwards flair of the dorsal margin of the iluim and its musculature are plainly visible and very characteristic of an elk.
3) the hair flow is identical to an elk's (see above though, then take a look at some photos and decide for yourself).
4) the tail is clearly present and of the right length to be an elk (far shorter than a deer).
5) the paired wrist imprints are a key diagnostic characteristic of ungulate lays and are clearly preserved, complete with reveresed hair flow on the left one, sunk in at 45 degrees to the viscous mud.
6) elk hoofprints are found immediately behind, immediately in front of, and immediately to the sides of the main imprint...it's surrounded.
7) all measurements of limb length, body proportion, and hoof size fall well within the size range of an elk. For example, the entire lay length is 48", while elk range from 39"-52" (see Elbroch, 2003).
8) no evidence for dermatoglyphic skin is preserved on the "heels" of the Skookum cast. The partially mushed imprints reveal hair flow patterns typical of the shorter metacarpal hairs on the lower limbs of ungulates. Again, refer to "he said, I say." The look at some of apeman's and tube's posts on what exactly dermatoglyphics look like as opposed to what artefacts and other impressions look like.
Not one of these points has yet been countered and/or disproved (except maybe 3, but not very convincingly). If anyone with a vivid enough imagination examines the cast, it could also be turned into: a kudu, an okapi, a large bonobo, a lion, a tiger, a tail-less mountain lion, a gigantic hairy-nosed wombat, Oprah Winfrey, and/or anything else with appendages and a hairy body. But sticking to what's actually observable, what's actully preserved, and what's actually been reported about the circumstances surrounding the find, it's virtually impossible to make a convincing and reasonable case for it to be something other than an elk. That's my only point. Other prints and tracks have a lot more going for them. If BF really do lounge around in mud puddles, rolling their nuts around for fun, it should be easy enough to set up some game cams near likely places (like, I dunno...Skookum Meadow) and catch one in the act. Otherwise, this impression is destined to simply join the other array of curiosities that continue to offer no compelling evidence that a huge, apple-eating, mud-loving, ape-man is lurking in wait of documentary film crews to taunt with his genitalia.