Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Huntsman?

You're obviously "yoinking" the wrong chain there, Yoink.

You really do have a reading disorder, don't you?

I do apologize. To Huntsman.

Okay. The men and the Indians thought it was an elephant. Anything , anything but a sasquatch.............

It's Thompson's account, and Thompson's word. Why do you choose to disbelieve him? Or do you think that he was thinking "large hairy man-like thing" and just chose the word "mammoth" in a moment of confusion?

If I'm not mistaken, 14 inch tracks, 8" wide are really, really small (and quite odd shaped) for an elephant, too.

Yes. Hence "young." I'm assuming that the "men and the Indians" didn't actually have much experience with mammoth tracks either. I assume--like you--that there were no mammoth in the area. I assume that Thompson was right: these were the tracks of a very large bear.

Tell us all about mammoth and elephant tracks, bwana. Tell us if elephants and mammoths have footprints in 6" of snow that go 14" long by 8" wide.

See preceding. The "men and the Indians" (if they ever did say these things that the writer is putting down on paper forty years after they supposedly happened) saw unusually large tracks and came up with "young mammoth"--you ask them what they thought mammoth tracks should look like. Presumably like the large bear tracks that Thompson saw.

Wow. It's not just your reading that's challenged, I see.

If he left it out, we wouldn't have read about it, would we?

In fact, the amazing thing is that it is there at all. If it was an ordinary bear track, he never would have mentioned it.

"If he left it out"? He did leave it out, you moron. I'm asking why would he leave out the most interesting part of the story? Imagine you're Thompson and you find bizarre anomalous tracks. The Indians tell you "These are the tracks of a giant man-like hairy beast--you must not hunt him, he is sacred, he comes into our villages and steals our children" etc. etc. etc. All you're going to write in your journal that night is "found some large bear tracks"? All you're going to write forty years later when you're trying to get a publisher to bite on your story is "the men and the Indians thought it was a young mammoth"? :rolleyes:

But he did, didn't he?

No. He didn't. Try to keep up. He wrote about a "young mammoth." Only to someone desperate to find proof of "Bigfoot" wherever he can is this construable as "probably a large man-like creature."


Have you?

What, and muss up my hair? Scratch my purty white skin?

Yeah. Like an elephant.

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.....................

It just doesn't stop being hilarious to me that you can say "like an elephant. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiight" and don't see that this is exactly parallel to my saying "like bigfoot. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight!" Except that this account actually mentions an elephant like animal but says nothing about Bigfoot. It's just comedy gold every time.

Please do it again. Please?

I don't know much about hairy elephants running around in the woods. Maybe you can fill me in.

Sure. There are none in North America today, and I'm very confident there were none in North America in Thompson's time. On the other hand, there once were (we have lots of evidence of them--unlike Bigfoot). And Thompson's evidence is, if evidence of anything other than a large bear, evidence of the spoor of "a young mammoth." So--if I had to go for "which is likelier" I'd go for the mammoth: perhaps the last of its kind (*sniff!). At least then I know for a fact I'm not postulating an animal that never existed. I know I'm describing and animal that did once live in America. And I know that I'm talking about an animal that is actually mentioned in Thompson's account. The mammoth wins on every single one of these counts.

Why are you so sure that mammoth don't live in America today? Please try to give me one reason that would not also be a reason that we should not believe in Bigfoot.

Yes, PNW natives include child stealing and even kidnap of adults in their stories of sasquatch. There are a couple of reports of such kidnaps even in the 20th Century, one by an Indian and one by a white.

There is no evidence that they eat their human captives though from these two most recent claims, but I suppose it's possible.

And? So why doesn't Bigfoot bother human communities now?

I don't chew tobacco, I prefer chainsaws, I shoot my bears, and I prefer to wear wool hats, thanks.

But I'll consider posting a photo of my hunt next week, if you'd like. If I get a chance to shoot a sasquatch, I'll take it. But I doubt there are any in that neck of the woods.

Too damned many grizzlies...................

Must be difficult for a man like you to find trousers that fit, huh? Let alone the specialized condoms....

Maintain control there, city-slicker. I don't want you to spill that latte.

I hear they're really expensive................

Oh...(giggles girlishly)...there's plenty more where that one came from.
 
The Thompson narrative? Surely you jest?

As I already posted on the BFF here:

David Thompson himself "held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear", and I've not heard of any squatch prints that contain claws. At the end of his narrative about the incident, Thompson again thought it was the track of some "Monster Bear". Bigfoot proponents have used his narrative to foster further belief in something Thompson himself didn't seem convinced of.
Romantics really need to stop using the Thompson report as evidence for bigfoot. Surely you're not a bigfoot romantic Huntster?

RayG
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Huntsman?

You're obviously "yoinking" the wrong chain there, Yoink.

You really do have a reading disorder, don't you?

I do apologize. To Huntsman.

Thank you. (For Huntsman; I'm sure he'll agree).

Me?

No apology is necessary.

Just the admission of screwing up is enough.

After all, we can see that you cannot read............

Quote:
Okay. The men and the Indians thought it was an elephant. Anything , anything but a sasquatch.............

It's Thompson's account, and Thompson's word. Why do you choose to disbelieve him?

I don't disbelieve him. I believe every word.

I disbelieve you.

Or do you think that he was thinking "large hairy man-like thing" and just chose the word "mammoth" in a moment of confusion?

He didn't choose the word, Sherlock.

The Indians did.

Do you still contend that they were talking about "elephants"?

Quote:
If I'm not mistaken, 14 inch tracks, 8" wide are really, really small (and quite odd shaped) for an elephant, too.

Yes. Hence "young."

So, young elephants have odd shaped feet?

I'm assuming that the "men and the Indians" didn't actually have much experience with mammoth tracks either.

I "assume" that too.

Now that you're here, brimmed with experience with "mammoth" tracks, we will all be educated.

I assume--like you--that there were no mammoth in the area.

Wow.

We're approaching the same page.........

Quote:
Wow. It's not just your reading that's challenged, I see.

If he left it out, we wouldn't have read about it, would we?

In fact, the amazing thing is that it is there at all. If it was an ordinary bear track, he never would have mentioned it.

"If he left it out"? He did leave it out, you moron.

If it was left out, why are we debating it?

Why aren't we debating the grizz tracks he saw in the Yukon Territory?

How about the grizz tracks he saw elsewhere?

Have you ever seen grizz tracks?

I'm asking why would he leave out the most interesting part of the story?

What "story"?

He wrote what he saw. He had no control of "the story."

Imagine you're Thompson and you find bizarre anomalous tracks. The Indians tell you "These are the tracks of a giant man-like hairy beast--you must not hunt him, he is sacred, he comes into our villages and steals our children" etc. etc. etc. All you're going to write in your journal that night is "found some large bear tracks"? All you're going to write forty years later when you're trying to get a publisher to bite on your story is "the men and the Indians thought it was a young mammoth"?

Huh?

Look, partner...........

This individual isn't a nameless soul on the Internet. It was David Thompson.

Get a clue.............

Quote:
But he did, didn't he?

No. He didn't. Try to keep up. He wrote about a "young mammoth." Only to someone desperate to find proof of "Bigfoot" wherever he can is this construable as "probably a large man-like creature."

Really?

Than please define "young mammoth", as he was told by the Indians, in the language (of the year 1811, between whites and Athabaskan) of the time.

*Hint: Avoid "elephant."

Quote:
Have you?

What, and muss up my hair? Scratch my purty white skin?

Yes. Have you mussed up your hair, or scratched your purty white skin?

Quote:
Yeah. Like an elephant.

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.....................

It just doesn't stop being hilarious to me that you can say "like an elephant. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiight" and don't see that this is exactly parallel to my saying "like bigfoot. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight!"

Again, YES. It was an elephant.

Except that this account actually mentions an elephant like animal but says nothing about Bigfoot. It's just comedy gold every time.

No doubt about it!

Quote:
I don't know much about hairy elephants running around in the woods. Maybe you can fill me in.

Sure. There are none in North America today, and I'm very confident there were none in North America in Thompson's time. On the other hand, there once were (we have lots of evidence of them--unlike Bigfoot). And Thompson's evidence is, if evidence of anything other than a large bear, evidence of the spoor of "a young mammoth." So--if I had to go for "which is likelier" I'd go for the mammoth: perhaps the last of its kind (*sniff!). At least then I know for a fact I'm not postulating an animal that never existed. I know I'm describing and animal that did once live in America. And I know that I'm talking about an animal that is actually mentioned in Thompson's account. The mammoth wins on every single one of these counts.

Yup. You win.

It was an elephant. It had footprints in 6" of snow that were 14" long and 8" wide.

You win.

Why are you so sure that mammoth don't live in America today?

I'm not. It's just that you're the only one who has tried to convince me that hairy elephants live here.

Look, my youngest daugher had an elephant as an imaginary friend. I've live with them. I've learned to love them.

But my baby gave that damned big, hairy thing up long ago.

I think she was about 6 years old or so. Cousin Eldon shot the damned thing, right in front of her.

I wouldn't have done it. I tend to shoot moose, caribou, deer, and bear.

I've never shot an elephant before. Even an imaginary one.

Quote:
Yes, PNW natives include child stealing and even kidnap of adults in their stories of sasquatch. There are a couple of reports of such kidnaps even in the 20th Century, one by an Indian and one by a white.

There is no evidence that they eat their human captives though from these two most recent claims, but I suppose it's possible.

And? So why doesn't Bigfoot bother human communities now?

For the same reason that Captain Lewis thought the "great white bear" didn't bother human settlements.

Quote:
I don't chew tobacco, I prefer chainsaws, I shoot my bears, and I prefer to wear wool hats, thanks.

But I'll consider posting a photo of my hunt next week, if you'd like. If I get a chance to shoot a sasquatch, I'll take it. But I doubt there are any in that neck of the woods.

Too damned many grizzlies...................

Must be difficult for a man like you to find trousers that fit, huh?

Yup.

Ass is too wide, and legs too short.

Let alone the specialized condoms....

No problem there.

I don't use the things. They don't work.

Quote:
Maintain control there, city-slicker. I don't want you to spill that latte.

I hear they're really expensive................

Oh...(giggles girlishly)...there's plenty more where that one came from.

Not up around here..........
 
The Thompson narrative? Surely you jest?

Nope. I jest not.

Yoink asked for a pre-1900 sasquatch reference. I provided it.

As I already posted on the BFF here:

Quote:
David Thompson himself "held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear", and I've not heard of any squatch prints that contain claws.

I agree. I can't reconcile the reference to claws.

However, Thompson referenced the trackway. He noted it in his journal, and 40 years later wrote of it again.

The natives that were with him obviously disagreed that it was bear.

It was 14" long.

He felt so strongly about it that he noted it in his journal (a man who would not be easily impressed with bear tracks), and noted that the natives with him disagreed with his bear assessment. This was noted in the woods. It was also clearly noted that there was no time (or motivation) to check out the tracks.

He wrote about it years later. Forty years later.

It wasn't bear sign.

I don't think it was elephant sign, either.

You?

At the end of his narrative about the incident, Thompson again thought it was the track of some "Monster Bear". Bigfoot proponents have used his narrative to foster further belief in something Thompson himself didn't seem convinced of.

Obviously, he wasn't. He was clearly skeptical. He outright stated that. He'd seen many, many bear tracks.

Yet:

.....the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear, otherwise that of a very large old Bear, his claws worn away, the Indians would not allow.

Ray, are you ready to abandon David Thompson and joint "Yoink" in stating that the 1st white man to see Jasper National Park couldn't distinguish a bear track there than anywhere else, and that his Native guides couldn't either?

In 6" of snow?

And that he was so impressed by it that he wrote about it some 40 years later?

In the 1850's?

Romantics really need to stop using the Thompson report as evidence for bigfoot.

Surely it isn't evidence of elephants in Alberta.

Surely you're not a bigfoot romantic Huntster?

Nope.

But I am romanced by truth.

Got some?
 
Nope. I jest not.

Yoink asked for a pre-1900 sasquatch reference. I provided it.

If Yoink asked for a squatch reference, why point out an old story that contains no reference whatsoever to squatch?

I agree. I can't reconcile the reference to claws.
Yeah, supposedly squatch have no claws.

However, Thompson referenced the trackway. He noted it in his journal, and 40 years later wrote of it again.
But in his narrative, Thompson makes no references to squatch.

"I saw the track of a large Animal - has 4 large Toes abt 3 or 4 In long & a small nail at the end of each. The Bal of his foot sank abt 3 In deeper than his Toes - the hinder part of his foot did not mark well. The whole is about 14 In long by 8 In wide & very much resembles a large Bear's Track. It was in the Rivulet in about 6 In snow."
40 years later Thompson clarifies:

"January 7th. continuing our journey in the afternoon we came on the track of a large animal, the snow about six inches deep on the ice; I measured it; four large toes each of four inches in length, to each a short claw; the ball of the foot sunk three inches lower than the toes. the hinder part of the foot did not mark well, the length fourteen inches, by eight inches in breadth, walking from north to south, and having passed about six hours. We were in no humour to follow him; the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear, otherwise that of a very large old Bear, his claws worn away, the Indians would not allow...

I now recur to what I have already noticed in the early part of last winter, when proceeding up the Athabasca River to cross the mountains, in company with....Men and four hunters, on one of the channels of the River we came to the track of a large animal, which measured fourteen inches in length by eight inches in breadth by a tape line. As snow was about six inches in depth the track was well defined, and we could see it for a full hundred yards from us, this animal was proceeding from north to south. We did not attempt to follow it, we had not time for it, and the Hunters, eager as they are to follow and shoot every animal, made no attempt to follow this beast, for what could the balls of our fowling guns do against such an animal? Report from old times had made the head branches of this River, and the Mountains in the vicinity the abode of one, or more, very large animals, to which I never appeared to give credence; for these reports appeared to arise from that fondness for the marvellous so common to mankind: but the sight of the track of that large a beast staggered me, and I often thought of it, yet never could bring myself to believe such an animal existed, but thought it might be the track of some Monster Bear."


At no time does Thompson ever mention anything other than Bear or a Mammoth. What native North Americans refer to squatch as a Mammoth? (Mammoth remains, unlike squatch, have been found in North America).

The natives that were with him obviously disagreed that it was bear.
Yeah, according to Thompson, they indicated it was a Mammoth.

It was 14" long.
Whoopie. That alone makes it a squatch?

He felt so strongly about it that he noted it in his journal (a man who would not be easily impressed with bear tracks), and noted that the natives with him disagreed with his bear assessment. This was noted in the woods. It was also clearly noted that there was no time (or motivation) to check out the tracks.
And there was also no mention at any time, of a sasquatch, or any creature resembling a sasquatch. The natives indicated it was a Mammoth. They did not mention squatch.

It wasn't bear sign.
No evidence it was squatch either, yet it gets trundled out whenever romantics start talking about early North American squatch reports. You sure you're not a romantic Huntster?

I don't think it was elephant sign, either.
And Thompson didn't seem to think it was squatch. If it's a report of something that can't be identified (especially since no sighting took place), why on earth is it used as evidence for squatch?

Ray, are you ready to abandon David Thompson and joint "Yoink" in stating that the 1st white man to see Jasper National Park couldn't distinguish a bear track there than anywhere else, and that his Native guides couldn't either?
I abandoned Thompson's Narrative a long time ago, I just wish the romantics would do likewise.

And that he was so impressed by it that he wrote about it some 40 years later?
But he never indicates it was a squatch he was impressed with.

Surely it isn't evidence of elephants in Alberta.
Funny you mention elephants in Alberta, since the Royal Alberta Museum uses a Woolly Mammoth as its logo, and Woolly Mammoth skeleton finds have been fairly common in that province.

But I am romanced by truth.

Got some?
Yes, Mammoth remains have been discovered in Alberta, squatch remains have not. The natives indicated the tracks belonged to a Mammoth, not a squatch. Thompson never specifically mentions bigfoot, sasquatch, bush apes, boqs, Dsonaqua, Gilyuk, Stickman, Seeahtic, or any other native name for the hairy critter. The Thompson narrative is not evidence of bigfoot.

It's true.

RayG
 
Thank you. (For Huntsman; I'm sure he'll agree).

Me?

No apology is necessary.

Just the admission of screwing up is enough.

After all, we can see that you cannot read............

No, it's evidence that I can't write.

I don't disbelieve him. I believe every word.
Every word except two: "young mammoth." Obviously he really meant to write "large hairy man-like animal" but his pen slipped.

I disbelieve you.
No. Your argument--whether you believe it or not--is not with me. It's with Thompson. Thompson says that he thought it was a bear, and that the "men and Indians" thought it was a "young mammoth." You don't like the idea of it being a bear, so you disagree with Thompson. You don't like the idea of it being a "young mammoth" so you disagree with the "men and Indians." As to why you think it's a Bigfoot--well, I guess that's between you and your strange obsession.

He didn't choose the word, Sherlock.

The Indians did.
Huntster, do you imagine that FORTY YEARS AFTER THE INCIDENT he got out his tape recorder and played back what the Indians had said? If you think he actually remembered the word they used, and if you think that they would have used the word "mammoth," then you're just so far out of touch with reality that you've forgotten its address. The word "young mammoth" is Thompson's. It is the word he has chosen, in this account of something that happened FORTY YEARS AGO to describe, as best he recalls, what it was that "the men and the Indians" thought the beast might be. Personally, I think his entire account is flim-flam, but if you want to give it any evidentiary weight whatsoever, then its weight is entirely that the "men and the Indians" though the beast was something like a mammoth.

Do you still contend that they were talking about "elephants"?
I think the passage says what it says, yes. I think that Thompson wants us to picture something like "a young mammoth" because he uses the phrase "young mammoth." If he had wanted us to picture a "large hairy man-like thing" he would almost certainly have used some such phrase as "large hairy man-like thing."

By the way, you're so keen on this being "the Indian's" word. Do you really think they had learnt the word "mammoth"? I assume they would have known the words for "man" and "hairy"--why would they use the arcane word "mammoth" rather than the everyday words "man" and "hairy"? Oh, but don't worry--I know that once again you'll avoid all questions which demolish your fairy tale.

So, young elephants have odd shaped feet?
Apparently the "men and Indians" thought so. This is what Thompson says. If you would prefer an account that said something else, you'll have to find a different explorer. This one thinks that "the men and Indians" thought these were the tracks of a "young mammoth."

Now that you're here, brimmed with experience with "mammoth" tracks, we will all be educated.
Again, you seem to be having some problems with reading comprehension. I don't think these were mammoth tracks. I think they were large bear tracks. You know, like David Thompson does. I'm on the side of the the author that you have championed. I assume that the "men and Indians" didn't know what young mammoth tracks looked like, any more than I do. I assume they'd never seen "young mammoth tracks." However, David Thompson's account is that "young mammoth" is what they guessed the tracks to be. So you have two readings of the tracks to choose from: 1/ David Thompson's reading of them as very large bear tracks (the one I choose), or 2/ the "men and Indians" account of them--as reported by David Thompson--as "young mammoth" tracks.

When offered these two choices you choose option three: "Bigfoot tracks." It is hard for me to see why "Bigfoot tracks" is, to you, any more likely that giraffe tracks, cougar tracks, orangutan tracks, marmoset tracks, lemur tracks or star-bellied-sneetch tracks.

As you yourself put it:

If it was left out, why are we debating it?
You have just forgotten what the point was, haven't you? Let me remind you: if the Indians told him that these were the tracks of a hairy man-like creature the likes of which had never before been reported why wouldn't he have recorded that astonishing fact in his journal? Why wouldn't he have mentioned it in his later account?

Why aren't we debating the grizz tracks he saw in the Yukon Territory?
Huh?

How about the grizz tracks he saw elsewhere?
Double huh?

What is it with you and this desperate attempt to prove that European explorers found bears? Yes. Bears exists. Bears aren't Bigfoot.

Have you ever seen grizz tracks?
No. Remember? I'm the lily-livered city slicker. You're the one who wrassles bears naked and knocks out grizzlies with the power of your schlong.

The fact that I haven't a clue what grizzly tracks look like doesn't magically make "young mammoth" turn into "man-like hairy beast," Hunster--however much you wish it did.

What "story"?

He wrote what he saw. He had no control of "the story."
Riiiiiiiiiight. Noone has ever exaggerated tales of wilderness exploits. Ever. Well...not when they might be desperately siezed upon as "evidence" by the Bigfoot faithful, at least.

He was writing this down FORTY YEARS AFTER IT HAPPENED. It contradicts the account HE WROTE AT THE TIME. You seem to think he was giving testimony under oath and consulting a video he'd made of the events at the same time. Tell me what you were doing forty years ago today, Huntster. Tell me the exact words you used, and the exact words your interlocuters used. What? It's difficult? Well, how about last week. Can you repeat word for word what someone said to you last week? No? Hmmmmm.

This individual isn't a nameless soul on the Internet. It was David Thompson.
Yes. That is why I keep calling him by that name. What is your point?

Get a clue.............
Oh, the irony. It burns!

Than please define "young mammoth", as he was told by the Indians, in the language (of the year 1811, between whites and Athabaskan) of the time.

*Hint: Avoid "elephant."
Again, you're back with your tape-recorder fantasy. He is writing this FORTY YEARS AFTER THE EVENT. By what possible feat of superhuman memory do you suppose that he will have dredged "young mammoth" up as the exact actual words said to him? At the very most I'm willing to believe that he is remembering roughly the kind of beast that the "men and Indians" were trying to describe, and that the phrase "young mammoth" fits that beast best.

Yes. Have you mussed up your hair, or scratched your purty white skin?
Constantly. The absurdity of your "argument" has me pulling my hair all the time.

Again, YES. It was an elephant.
No. Try reading this again veeeeerrryyy sloooowwwwlllyyyy:

1/ I believe, with David Thompson, that these were bear tracks.

2/ The "men and Indians" thought it was something that David Thompson describes as being a "young mammoth." If you can find a way for "young mammoth" to describe "big man-like hairy thing" then you win. As you can't, and as "young mammoth" can only mean "something rather like an elephant" then that's all we've got to work with.

Yup. You win.
Don't I know it, brother. Don't I know it. I only wish it wasn't so easy.

It was an elephant. It had footprints in 6" of snow that were 14" long and 8" wide.
No, it was a bear. The "men and Indians" thought it was a "young mammoth."

By the way, can I take a moment to remind you that every single thing you say to ridicule the "mammoth" theory applies in exactly the same terms to the "bigfoot" theory. You say "but mammoth tracks don't look like that." But if the account did read "large man-like hairy thing" we'd also have to say "but man-like tracks don't look like that." You say "there aren't any mammoth in America. Pfffffttt!" But if it did say "man-like hairy thing" we'd be saying "but there aren't any "man-like hairy things in America." Pfffffttt!" Etc. etc. etc. It's co-me-dy gold, I tell you. You yourself think your own arguments are stupid. All you need to do to see how stupid they are is substitute "mammoth" for "Bigfoot."

Yes. Yes I do.

I'm not. It's just that you're the only one who has tried to convince me that hairy elephants live here.
Sigh. Do I have to spell this out yet again? I believe--just as David Thompson does--that the tracks were bear tracks. The "men and Indians" in Thompson's account from FORTY YEARS LATER argued for "young mammoth." Aren't they silly? Almost as silly as if they'd said "large man-like hairy thing." But not quite that silly.

Look, my youngest daugher had an elephant as an imaginary friend. I've live with them. I've learned to love them.
You have a large man-like hairy thing as an imaginary friend. So I bet you can empathize with your daughter.

But my baby gave that damned big, hairy thing up long ago.
You should learn from the wisdom of your child.

I think she was about 6 years old or so. Cousin Eldon shot the damned thing, right in front of her.
Cousin Eldon ain't quite right in the head, is he?

I wouldn't have done it.
I'm glad to hear that.

I tend to shoot moose, caribou, deer, and bear.
Why shoot them? Don't they just drop dead of fright at the sight of your awesome manliness? Maybe you shoot them afterwards. Kind of like necrophilia only probably not illegal.

For the same reason that Captain Lewis thought the "great white bear" didn't bother human settlements.
That is irrelevant on so many different levels I can't think how to respond to it. Maybe if you'd said "for the same reason that Capt. Kirk decided tribbles were a nuisance" I might have found some way to relate it to the question asked.

No problem there.

I don't use the things. They don't work.
Too much manliness, huh? You probably impregnate inanimate objects just by looking at them.
 
Last edited:
1) There is no way to ascertain from the fossil record whether or not they were more hirsute than we are,

2) Cold weather terrestrial mammals are more furry, bulky, and heavier than mammals in warmer climes

3) The fossil record can determine bulk, and indeed, Neanderthals are known as being more robust and bulky, and

4) They were recognized as a cold weather inhabitant
Bulkier, stockier but still very similar to us. As I told you before, one could stay beside you and you probably would not recognize him/her as a neanderthal. If they were hairy enough to trigger myths of wild fur-covered men, they they would not neet any clother.

The word "paleofiction" does not rings any bells?

Check the descriptions of trolls and woodwoose. Neanderthals just don't fit with them, unless you are using the old "cavemen" renderings and assuming they were taller than sapiens, what is not true.

I'm sorry. I admit you may not have claimed that.

However, that is part of the theory of Clovis, which you appear to support, is it not?
"May not"? No. I have not made such claim, neither gave any hint of supporting or not it. And, by the way, what's the importance to any of the issues so far discussed if I support or not this theory?

Moving on would be a good idea.



Frankly, I do believe the myth discussion has been beat to death. We even have others referring to fairies.
Your discussions with other persons are not my problem.


Funny:

Dragon myths = crocodiles, alligators, similar reptiles
Sasquatch myths = anything but a bipedal ape (let's throw fairies in there, too......)
Oh yes, its very funny. Specially because a more detailed analysis will show that the most common European renderings of dragons do not match crocs or dinos, since they do not have or had bat-like wings. Chinese dragons, with their serpentiform bodies, are also quite different from these animals. And quetzalcoatl, when represented as an animal, instead of a man, besides being serpentiform, has the body covered by feathers. The more I think of it, the less likely it seems that mythical animals need real templates, unless the idea is to build a chimera.


Yes, as far as I know. I linked you to this. There is no mythical beast or prehistoric beast mentioned, referred to, or even remotely described unless you call sasquatch a mythical beast.

(BTW, it's an excellent read. Don't believe me; check out the reviews on the link provided. It's unbiased science at it's best.........)
Every single mythical beast?
Including that weird luminous skeletal thing someone (UrsulaV IIRC) mentioned somewhere else?
But I can accept that their mythical animals are based on real-life templates. I can even accept sasquatches are. I think however, their template can very well have been men.

Should I behave now like Yoink after I presented him with links?
You are free to act the way you think you should.

Not terrible.

Just flawed.
Critical analysis of evidence is flawed?
Why?
Can you offer a better opition?

Funny.

When I cite "likely, until better evidence or proof is obtained" regarding sasquatchery, that position is not accepted.

Why should your "likely" be any better than my "likely"?

Shouldn't we let the evidence dictate the facts?
Because the pro-bigfoot evidence presented so far is not reliable.

Oh, I agree. I simply cannot agree that the mode of locomotion can be determined either way with fossilized teeth or partial mandibles alone.



And if they are wrong, Gigantopithecus is a spitting image of a sasquatch.
Shouldn't you have writen "maybe Gigantopithecus is a spitting image"? Because you know, you are determinating the creature's look using a few fossilized teeth and parts of mandibles...

Not to mention that there are a number of different renderings from bigfeet...
 
Last edited:
Nevermind me but 'young mammoth' seems a strange choice of words no matter who said it. Hey, Ray. You remember that thread from a ways back on the BFF about old BF-type newspaper reports from prior to the 50's? Maybe my memory's playing tricks on me but I seem to remember at least a few pre-1900 stories in there. I looked back to front in the newspaper article section but couldn't find it. Ring a bell? Anyway, back to elephants.:boggled:
 
Nevermind me but 'young mammoth' seems a strange choice of words no matter who said it. Hey, Ray. You remember that thread from a ways back on the BFF about old BF-type newspaper reports from prior to the 50's? Maybe my memory's playing tricks on me but I seem to remember at least a few pre-1900 stories in there. I looked back to front in the newspaper article section but couldn't find it. Ring a bell? Anyway, back to elephants.:boggled:

Well, it's worth noting that woolly mammoth remains were discovered in America towards the end of the C18th. According to this site "Mammoth fever" swept America after the first complete skeleton went on display in 1801. If you look at the site you'll see an engraving of the skeleton. If you look at the feet, you might see how the "men and Indians" could be forgiven for thinking this four-toed track could be "mammoth track"--or at least how Thompson could think "this will help sell a few copies of my story--people love Mammoths."

At the very least, it shows that by the 1850s, the word "mammoth" meant "woolly mammoth" to people. It didn't mean "large animal of some kind--probably man-like and hairy."
 
BTW, I watched a really cool Japanese documentary on Neanderthals in which the narrator was set up with prosthetics and crazy make-up so he looked just like a Neanderthal and then had him clean-shaven and combed his hair and put him in a suit and he was walking in the middle of Shibuya in Tokyo and nobody looked at him twice. Though that might say more about Japanese in Tokyo than about how weird he looked. BTW, stupid question- did mammoth become an adjective meaning 'huge' before or after the discovery of wooly mammoths? I'm guessing before.
 
Hey, Ray. You remember that thread from a ways back on the BFF about old BF-type newspaper reports from prior to the 50's? Maybe my memory's playing tricks on me but I seem to remember at least a few pre-1900 stories in there. I looked back to front in the newspaper article section but couldn't find it. Ring a bell?

How about Jacko from 1884?

RayG
 
Well, Yoink beated me on this, so lets try another one...
According to Wikipedia's entry on mammoth,
The name "mammoth" comes via Russian from the Tatar language. It may have its origins in the Tatar word mamma, "earth", alluding to the long-held belief that mammoths lived underground and made burrows. The 17th century traveller Eberhard Ysbrant Ides recorded that the Evenk, Yakut and Ostyak peoples of Siberia believed that the mammoths "continually, or at least by reason of the very hard frosts, mostly live under ground, where they go backwards and forwards." Exposure to the air was enough to kill them, explaining why they were never seen alive.
Source:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mammoth#Origins_of_the_name

Thus its not originally Native American or English...

I intentionally left at the quote the part regarding the mythical being based on the remains.
 
BTW, stupid question- did mammoth become an adjective meaning 'huge' before or after the discovery of wooly mammoths? I'm guessing before.

Mammoth had been used both specifically to mean "woolly mammoth" and "elephant" before Thompson wrote. It had also been used to mean "very large non-specific animal." Huntster would have a tiny shred to hold onto if Thompson had written, say, "the men and Indians held that it was the track of some mammoth beast." This would mean just "very large."

The problem for Huntster (that he just can't address, of course) is that Thompson says "young mammoth." Once you have "young mammoth" in there then "mammoth" obviously has be being used to conjure up some specific animal: "picture a mammoth--o.k. Now picture a small one." "Small big thing" is just silly. The only specific animal that "mammoth" could mean in the mid nineteenth century is a woolly mammoth. QED.
 
(Monty Python voice on)

No, sorry, you must be mistaken, Alberta, and especially the Royal Museum in Alberta, have nothing to do with Mammoths. Absolutely nothing. N-o-t-h-i-n-g.

And now for something completely different...

(Monty Python voice off)

That's ok, I heard they had no cheese either.

:D

RayG
 
Why shoot them? Don't they just drop dead of fright at the sight of your awesome manliness? Maybe you shoot them afterwards. Kind of like necrophilia only probably not illegal.
Too much manliness, huh? You probably impregnate inanimate objects just by looking at them.
Man, I get so mixed up when I come sit at the grown-up's table.:D
 
Anyone else find it curious that someone with the moniker 'Yoink' would be talking about someone elses ummm... appendage?

Yoink wouldn't be a variation of 'Yank' would it? :boggled:

RayG
 
Anyone else find it curious that someone with the moniker 'Yoink' would be talking about someone elses ummm... appendage?

Yoink wouldn't be a variation of 'Yank' would it? :boggled:

RayG
While it's good to know I wasn't alone on that one, it's a little more satisfying that someone else said it first.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Nope. I jest not.

Yoink asked for a pre-1900 sasquatch reference. I provided it.

If Yoink asked for a squatch reference, why point out an old story that contains no reference whatsoever to squatch?

So, since the reference didn't specifically spell out "squatch", or "sasquatch", or "bigfoot" (even though those terms/words were all devoped much later), it isn't a qualified reference?

Please.................

Quote:
However, Thompson referenced the trackway. He noted it in his journal, and 40 years later wrote of it again.

But in his narrative, Thompson makes no references to squatch.

Nope. He specifically noted the length of the track, that although he thought it was a bear's track it didn't appear quite right, that there were legends that he wasn't ready to accept, and because he noted it at all (especially recalled it 40 years later) makes it noteworthy.

The Athabaskans there and then called it a mammoth. Yoink thinks it was an elephant. Fine.

There were elephants running around the Alberta Rockies in 1811.

Pretty cool, huh?

Quote:

........At no time does Thompson ever mention anything other than Bear or a Mammoth. What native North Americans refer to squatch as a Mammoth? (Mammoth remains, unlike squatch, have been found in North America).

Do you really think that in the year 1811 the natives of the area used English as we do today? Do you realize the word "mammoth" has meanings other than a hairy elephant?

Mammoth:

1. any large, elephantlike mammal of the extinct genus Mammuthus, from the Pleistocene Epoch, having hairy skin and ridged molar teeth.
–adjective 2. immensely large; huge; enormous: a mammoth organization.

Do you think that in the year 1811, David Thompson even knew what a Pleistocene mammoth was?

C'mon, guys; you can dream up better doubts than just semantics, can't you?

Quote:
The natives that were with him obviously disagreed that it was bear.

Yeah, according to Thompson, they indicated it was a Mammoth.

Right. It was an elephant. You and Yoink are convincing me.

Quote:
It was 14" long.

Whoopie. That alone makes it a squatch?

Nope.

But it would make it a damned big bear, or a damned small elephant.

Funny no mention of the bear's front paw was made.............

Quote:
He felt so strongly about it that he noted it in his journal (a man who would not be easily impressed with bear tracks), and noted that the natives with him disagreed with his bear assessment. This was noted in the woods. It was also clearly noted that there was no time (or motivation) to check out the tracks.

And there was also no mention at any time, of a sasquatch, or any creature resembling a sasquatch. The natives indicated it was a Mammoth. They did not mention squatch.

The word Thompson used was "mammoth" (in quotes). That is what he translated the Athabaskan name to.

Would you have preferred Thompson used the word "nik’inla’eena"?

Think Thompson would have spelled it right? If Thompson misspelled it, would you then have insisted that it couldn't have been a nik’inla’eena?

Quote:
It wasn't bear sign.

No evidence it was squatch either, yet it gets trundled out whenever romantics start talking about early North American squatch reports. You sure you're not a romantic Huntster?

Mrs. Huntster insists I need improvement in the field of romance.

Quote:
I don't think it was elephant sign, either.

And Thompson didn't seem to think it was squatch.

Says who?

If it's a report of something that can't be identified (especially since no sighting took place), why on earth is it used as evidence for squatch?

Ya' think maybe because the description fits better than that of, say, a giant marmot?

Quote:
Ray, are you ready to abandon David Thompson and joint "Yoink" in stating that the 1st white man to see Jasper National Park couldn't distinguish a bear track there than anywhere else, and that his Native guides couldn't either?

I abandoned Thompson's Narrative a long time ago, I just wish the romantics would do likewise.

I see. Thompson's exploratory writings were accurate in all ways for future explorers of the Canadian Rockies except his writings of the extraordinary tracks he found.

That fits the skeptical ideology. Good boy. Here's a bisquit.

Quote:
And that he was so impressed by it that he wrote about it some 40 years later?

But he never indicates it was a squatch he was impressed with.

That's right.

He was impressed with the tracks.

And you aren't because it doesn't fit your ideology.

Quote:
Surely it isn't evidence of elephants in Alberta.

Funny you mention elephants in Alberta, since the Royal Alberta Museum uses a Woolly Mammoth as its logo, and Woolly Mammoth skeleton finds have been fairly common in that province.

That's it. It's confirmed.

It was an elephant.

I like how you skeptics work.

Quote:
But I am romanced by truth.

Got some?

Yes, Mammoth remains have been discovered in Alberta, squatch remains have not. The natives indicated the tracks belonged to a Mammoth, not a squatch. Thompson never specifically mentions bigfoot, sasquatch, bush apes, boqs, Dsonaqua, Gilyuk, Stickman, Seeahtic, or any other native name for the hairy critter. The Thompson narrative is not evidence of bigfoot.

I am now in love. Romanced completely. Impressed. Convinced. The truth has been revealed.

Ray G has established that a Pleistocene wooly mammoth was discovered in the Canadian Rockies in the year 1811.

It's true.

I believe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom