Huntsman?
You're obviously "yoinking" the wrong chain there, Yoink.
You really do have a reading disorder, don't you?
I do apologize. To Huntsman.
Okay. The men and the Indians thought it was an elephant. Anything , anything but a sasquatch.............
It's Thompson's account, and Thompson's word. Why do you choose to disbelieve him? Or do you think that he was thinking "large hairy man-like thing" and just chose the word "mammoth" in a moment of confusion?
If I'm not mistaken, 14 inch tracks, 8" wide are really, really small (and quite odd shaped) for an elephant, too.
Yes. Hence "young." I'm assuming that the "men and the Indians" didn't actually have much experience with mammoth tracks either. I assume--like you--that there were no mammoth in the area. I assume that Thompson was right: these were the tracks of a very large bear.
Tell us all about mammoth and elephant tracks, bwana. Tell us if elephants and mammoths have footprints in 6" of snow that go 14" long by 8" wide.
See preceding. The "men and the Indians" (if they ever did say these things that the writer is putting down on paper forty years after they supposedly happened) saw unusually large tracks and came up with "young mammoth"--you ask them what they thought mammoth tracks should look like. Presumably like the large bear tracks that Thompson saw.
Wow. It's not just your reading that's challenged, I see.
If he left it out, we wouldn't have read about it, would we?
In fact, the amazing thing is that it is there at all. If it was an ordinary bear track, he never would have mentioned it.
"If he left it out"? He did leave it out, you moron. I'm asking why would he leave out the most interesting part of the story? Imagine you're Thompson and you find bizarre anomalous tracks. The Indians tell you "These are the tracks of a giant man-like hairy beast--you must not hunt him, he is sacred, he comes into our villages and steals our children" etc. etc. etc. All you're going to write in your journal that night is "found some large bear tracks"? All you're going to write forty years later when you're trying to get a publisher to bite on your story is "the men and the Indians thought it was a young mammoth"?
But he did, didn't he?
No. He didn't. Try to keep up. He wrote about a "young mammoth." Only to someone desperate to find proof of "Bigfoot" wherever he can is this construable as "probably a large man-like creature."
Have you?
What, and muss up my hair? Scratch my purty white skin?
Yeah. Like an elephant.
Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.....................
It just doesn't stop being hilarious to me that you can say "like an elephant. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiight" and don't see that this is exactly parallel to my saying "like bigfoot. Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight!" Except that this account actually mentions an elephant like animal but says nothing about Bigfoot. It's just comedy gold every time.
Please do it again. Please?
I don't know much about hairy elephants running around in the woods. Maybe you can fill me in.
Sure. There are none in North America today, and I'm very confident there were none in North America in Thompson's time. On the other hand, there once were (we have lots of evidence of them--unlike Bigfoot). And Thompson's evidence is, if evidence of anything other than a large bear, evidence of the spoor of "a young mammoth." So--if I had to go for "which is likelier" I'd go for the mammoth: perhaps the last of its kind (*sniff!). At least then I know for a fact I'm not postulating an animal that never existed. I know I'm describing and animal that did once live in America. And I know that I'm talking about an animal that is actually mentioned in Thompson's account. The mammoth wins on every single one of these counts.
Why are you so sure that mammoth don't live in America today? Please try to give me one reason that would not also be a reason that we should not believe in Bigfoot.
Yes, PNW natives include child stealing and even kidnap of adults in their stories of sasquatch. There are a couple of reports of such kidnaps even in the 20th Century, one by an Indian and one by a white.
There is no evidence that they eat their human captives though from these two most recent claims, but I suppose it's possible.
And? So why doesn't Bigfoot bother human communities now?
I don't chew tobacco, I prefer chainsaws, I shoot my bears, and I prefer to wear wool hats, thanks.
But I'll consider posting a photo of my hunt next week, if you'd like. If I get a chance to shoot a sasquatch, I'll take it. But I doubt there are any in that neck of the woods.
Too damned many grizzlies...................
Must be difficult for a man like you to find trousers that fit, huh? Let alone the specialized condoms....
Maintain control there, city-slicker. I don't want you to spill that latte.
I hear they're really expensive................
Oh...(giggles girlishly)...there's plenty more where that one came from.
