Originally Posted by Huntster
Thank you. (For Huntsman; I'm sure he'll agree).
Me?
No apology is necessary.
Just the admission of screwing up is enough.
After all, we can see that you cannot read............
No, it's evidence that I can't write.
Fine.
Either way, you can't.
And I already knew that.
Quote:
I don't disbelieve him. I believe every word.
Every word except two: "young mammoth." Obviously he really meant to write "large hairy man-like animal" but his pen slipped.
I believe now. You and Ray are impressive and qualified enough to convince me that it was an elephant.
Boy, you guys sure are something...........
Quote:
I disbelieve you.
No. Your argument--whether you believe it or not--is not with me. It's with Thompson. Thompson says that he thought it was a bear, and that the "men and Indians" thought it was a "young mammoth." You don't like the idea of it being a bear, so you disagree with Thompson. You don't like the idea of it being a "young mammoth" so you disagree with the "men and Indians." As to why you think it's a Bigfoot--well, I guess that's between you and your strange obsession.
I now believe you.
It was a fricken elephant.
Quote:
He didn't choose the word, Sherlock.
The Indians did.
Huntster, do you imagine that FORTY YEARS AFTER THE INCIDENT he got out his tape recorder and played back what the Indians had said? If you think he actually remembered the word they used, and if you think that they would have used the word "mammoth," then you're just so far out of touch with reality that you've forgotten its address.
Gee. I thought that was my argument.
Wasn't it you that was so insistent that the word "mammoth" made it an elephant?
Now I'm getting confused.
The word "young mammoth" is Thompson's. It is the word he has chosen, in this account of something that happened FORTY YEARS AGO to describe, as best he recalls, what it was that "the men and the Indians" thought the beast might be. Personally, I think his entire account is flim-flam, but if you want to give it any evidentiary weight whatsoever, then its weight is entirely that the "men and the Indians" though the beast was something like a mammoth.
Right. Thompson, the great original explorer of the Canadian interior, was correct in all accounts except this.
Because you say so.
Quote:
Do you still contend that they were talking about "elephants"?
I think the passage says what it says, yes.
Recorded for posterity:
According to the Great and Powerful Yoink, it was a fricken elephant.
Quote:
Now that you're here, brimmed with experience with "mammoth" tracks, we will all be educated.
Again, you seem to be having some problems with reading comprehension. I don't think these were mammoth tracks. I think they were large bear tracks. You know, like David Thompson does.
No, I don't know. Because Thompson also clearly writes:
the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear
Who's having reading comprehension problems?
Quote:
Have you ever seen grizz tracks?
No. Remember? I'm the lily-livered city slicker. You're the one who wrassles bears naked and knocks out grizzlies with the power of your schlong.
No, I don't.
I shoot them.
The fact that I haven't a clue what grizzly tracks look like doesn't magically make "young mammoth" turn into "man-like hairy beast," Hunster--however much you wish it did.
But the fact that you don't have a clue means that you don't have a clue.
He was writing this down FORTY YEARS AFTER IT HAPPENED. It contradicts the account HE WROTE AT THE TIME. You seem to think he was giving testimony under oath and consulting a video he'd made of the events at the same time. Tell me what you were doing forty years ago today, Huntster.
Going to school, working, and spending as much time in the woods as I could.
Tell me the exact words you used, and the exact words your interlocuters used. What? It's difficult? Well, how about last week. Can you repeat word for word what someone said to you last week? No? Hmmmmm.
Actually, I can't. It wasn't noteworthy.
However, I found a trackway in the woods in 1972 (34 years ago), and I remember it like yesterday.
They weren't bear tracks, and they weren't elephant tracks.
I even remember the exact word I uttered when I first saw it, but I can't type that here. It's forbidden.
Quote:
This individual isn't a nameless soul on the Internet. It was David Thompson.
Yes. That is why I keep calling him by that name. What is your point?
His word is better than yours.
Especially since you admit you can't write.
Quote:
Again, YES. It was an elephant.
No. Try reading this again veeeeerrryyy sloooowwwwlllyyyy:
1/ I believe, with David Thompson, that these were bear tracks.
Yet:
the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear
Quote:
It was an elephant. It had footprints in 6" of snow that were 14" long and 8" wide.
No, it was a bear. The "men and Indians" thought it was a "young mammoth."
Yet:
the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear
So, if "the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear", and it can't be a sasquatch (even though the description of the prints fits perfectly), and the men and Indians called it a "young mammoth", then it must be an elephant.
Quote:
You win.
Yes. Yes I do.
Let me find you a bisquit, skeptic.............
Quote:
I'm not. It's just that you're the only one who has tried to convince me that hairy elephants live here.
Sigh. Do I have to spell this out yet again? I believe--just as David Thompson does--that the tracks were bear tracks.
Yet, (must I spell it out for you again?):
yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear
Quote:
I tend to shoot moose, caribou, deer, and bear.
Why shoot them? Don't they just drop dead of fright at the sight of your awesome manliness?
Nope. Gotta shoot 'em.
Quote:
For the same reason that Captain Lewis thought the "great white bear" didn't bother human settlements.
That is irrelevant on so many different levels I can't think how to respond to it. Maybe if you'd said "for the same reason that Capt. Kirk decided tribbles were a nuisance" I might have found some way to relate it to the question asked.
No doubt, TV Man.

Nice idea about the nerds in the bush though.