Here's some stuff that I cut out of an overlong discussion with LAL over in the Patterson-Gimlin footage thread:
LAL said:
The analysis was done on the hair samples before LMS, with Dr. Sarmiento extracting a hair for the camera.
So, what were the results? Did they follow the procedures that led to another "Bigfoot hair" get revealed as a synthetic material?
Coyote hairs were found too. Does that make it a coyote imprint?
No, why assume coyote when elks fit the imprint so well?
And it's funny that you should mention coyotes...
Thom Powell reported an account of a juvenile approaching fruit bait in a belly-crawl. The mudhole was right next to a road and the ground around it was hard. There's an imprint of what may be toes in the cast. The print may have been squashed when the animal sat down.
But you don't know if Powell's report is true or not. Lying down to aavoid making tracks doesn't make any sense considering that it left a big imprint of its body in the ground. Also, wasn't that spot picked because they thought they could get good tracks from it? Wasn't that the whole point of the apples?
Skamania County has a long history of track events, sightings and hearings.
Yeah, and we also know that hoaxes and misidentifications (and maybe even some hallucinations) can lead to "Bigfoot reports." We know that bears and elk live in the area,
as did the BFRO. Bears can be mistaken for Bigfoot and can leave overlaid tracks resembling footprints. Both bears and elk can make noises that could be mistaken for something else. In fact, I found a video of a red stag (A European relative of North American elk) awhile back that makes a noise that would match up to Patterson's Bigfoot vocalization recreation if the elk's "voice" was deeper and if it grunted in different places.
As I once joked with a friend, perhaps the idea of Bigfoot living in the area was sparked by the ancient, Native American version of Rick Noll insisting that an elk lay was really that of a humanlike creature.
Let's not forget that "skookum" isn't just a term for Sasquatch like some might have you believe. According to
this, it can mean "Big, mighty, strong, true, genuine, solid, [and] able." Those words certainly can be applied to animals in the area, like bears and coyote. A good sized elk is nothing to sneeze at, either.
Oh, for crying out loud! mangler already explained to you why that argument was crap.
I suppose he should have used baby elk wrists, too. Whatever extremity made the imprint, it was raised straight up, several times. Neat trick for an elk; no trick at all for a primate. The peel shows hair ending below the Achilles tendon and dermatoglyphics below that.
And did someone with experience with elk/elk lays say that or is this another case of "declare it impossible and hope nobody shows otherwise" sort of argument that seems to pop up a lot on the proponents' side?
Or what about
how the "arm" doesn't seem to be in proportion to the estimated height?
They're a match for dermals showing on other casts.
And what casts would those be? I should note that
tube's experiments used the same casting material that Noll used for the Skookum Cast. I've also heard talk of mud suction causing dermal-like markings...
Where did you get that idea?
It got up during a comments discussion at Cryptomundo several months ago.
He denied Benjamin Radford and Cliff Crook, but not bona fide scientists and their families.
Hhmm...I wonder if a (corrupted) memory of this sparked my earlier statement. I tried to Google up the discussion and ended up bumbling across
this discussion where Rick Noll addresses the claim that the BFRO only let hand-picked experts look at the cast:
The only hand picking done was with getting the very best people who could help understand it, not just anybody. George Schaller because of his Gorilla work and ungulate studies, Daris Swindler because of his anatomy knowledge and skepticism, Esteban Sarimento for his current work in Africa on the Bili Ape and knowledge of just what museums might have in their basements. These are main stream scientists and naturalists, not magazine editors. We went with a magazine editor once and a major newspaper reporter another time, both at their request, and they didn't know diddly squat and their stories reflected it.
Wow, so they decided that people involved in primate studies were the best qualified. Um, why no elk experts? I've seen some comments elsewhere that imply that people who knew about elk were brought in later, but it's not clear how much experience they had (or how many of them it would take for them to ID the cast as that of an elk before the proponents conceded).
I also found
this:
The anatomy of the heel, ankle, and Achilles tendon are also distinct and consistent with models of the Sasquatch foot derived by Meldrum after examining hundreds of alleged Sasquatch footprints.
Why hello, confirmation bias! How are you doing?
The duplicates were made by BC artists for public display, not for researchers; the measurements no longer match.
So they shelled out money for and knowingly displayed inaccurate molds? Wow, that certainly doesn't paint a good picture of the people involved.
This post by Rick Noll might've sparked the "available to researchers" thing:
I made a rubber mold off a part of the original cast and then made a duplicate cast from it. It was shown in LMS and other programs. All scientists that examined the cast were given a duplicate of the heel section of the Skookum cast for later examination at their leisure.
Another post about the creation of the molds.
DY himself said a researcher should always examine originals wherever possible. Rick not only offered him a chance to examine the original, Kathy Strain offered to pay his way to Seattle. Rick offered to pick him up at the airport. DY declined because he didn't want to be filmed during his examination (and didn't want "that man", as he stated on JREF, using his name).
Well, I can't say for sure why DY felt that way, but I suspect that he was afraid of having the footage of him getting reedited into a pro-Sasquatch statement. If so, I can't say I blame him after hearing about some issues with "Legend Meets Science," like the Memorial Day footage edit job (lopped-out audio and having the narrator state the opposite of what was obvious-shades of the BBC!-when a human was shown running faster than the subject of the film).
What grief? Did you read the debate between DY and DDA on BFF? Neither Meldrum nor Swindler have retracted, to my knowledge.
Grief they're getting from skeptics. Yes, I did read that debate (and the other Skookum cast discussions). I found that DDA got more and more childishly whiny about it with each new debate.
And 1100 teeth. How did Ciochon and Munns do their reconstruction?
Yeah, I consider teeth to part of "jaw remains." Now this is just a guess, but I'd imagine that Ciochon and Munns tried to figure out what the average skin/fat/muscle thicknesses would be at certain points on the jaw, using data from human and ape skulls to guide them. After that, lots of guesswork based on any animal whose jaw/teeth most closely resembled the jaw they were working with. Here's hoping that their reconstruction turns out to be more accurate than the "reconstruction" that was originally done for the Igaunodon based on thumb spike and some teeth (and possibly some other remains).
Daris is a leading authority on primate anatomy, author of the standard text, a giant in the field and was a skeptic for thirty years prior to his four examinations of the cast. He was visibly shaken. Perhaps he should have said "It's Paranthropus!"?
"It looks like a big primate" would've sounded less odd to me. Frankly, I'd be more impressed if he was an expert in both elks and primates.
Sir Arthur Keith lived to see Piltdown exposed. He cautioned L.S.B. Leakey on account of it.
Yeah. He was wise to be a skeptic, wasn't he?