Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Who says that trolls were "invented"?:

Actually, we don't know that. We don't have physical evidence that these creatures existed, or that they existed as the myth evolved through time after the original creature went extinct.

"Dragons" may be large lizards (like monitors) that handed down stories later made fly and breath fire. We just don't know.

I can attest that I never needed sasquatches, trolls, banshees, or any other "myths" to scare my children. The bears and my own punishments were scary enough.


Ah ha, I see. Well...so long as we agree that Bigfoot is just as likely to exist (or have existed) as trolls, pixies, elves, fairies, leprechauns and satyrs, I guess we've got nothing to argue about.

(Backs away slowly.)
 
Ah ha, I see. Well...so long as we agree that Bigfoot is just as likely to exist (or have existed) as trolls, pixies, elves, fairies, leprechauns and satyrs, I guess we've got nothing to argue about......

Hear of anybody lately claiming to see a troll, pixy, elf, fairy, leprechaun, or satyr?

Thousands of folks, even, over the past century?

See any footprints left by an elf, troll, pixy, fairy, leprechaun, or satyr?

Any films?

(Stands firm, waiting for lame answer...............)
 
Hear of anybody lately claiming to see a troll, pixy, elf, fairy, leprechaun, or satyr?

Thousands of folks, even, over the past century?

See any footprints left by an elf, troll, pixy, fairy, leprechaun, or satyr?

Any films?

(Stands firm, waiting for lame answer...............)

Oh, there have been crazes of fairy sightings. There have even been fairy photographs--the Bigfoot footage of their day--that many hundreds of otherwise normal and rational people accepted as solid "evidence" for the existence of fairies. See here for example.

But that silliness died away, eventually (although there are, apparently, still a few defenders of the faith out there).

Of course, nowadays nobody would be silly enough to believe in some mythical creature just because of some unsupported "eyewitness" accounts and some highly suspicious photographic "evidence."
 
Actually, it's interesting that the first recorded Bigfoot "sightings" occur around the same time as the Cottingly fairy photographs. It looks like "Bigfoot evidence" and "fairy evidence" are running roughly neck-and-neck.

And there's probably a good reason why we don't find any fairy tracks or scat: so they're one up on Bigfoot there. Maybe you should move to England, Huntster, and start hunting fairies? Although you may not want to say to the immigration guys as you arrive that the purpose of your visit is to "track down some fairies." It might give them the wrong idea.
 
Oh, there have been crazes of fairy sightings. There have even been fairy photographs--the Bigfoot footage of their day--that many hundreds of otherwise normal and rational people accepted as solid "evidence" for the existence of fairies. See here for example.

Yeah. The Cottingley Fairy photos is the classic, recurring response to that question.

Any other examples?

But that silliness died away, eventually (although there are, apparently, still a few defenders of the faith out there).

Really? Like who?

Of course, nowadays nobody would be silly enough to believe in some mythical creature just because of some unsupported "eyewitness" accounts and some highly suspicious photographic "evidence."

Of course not!

Hahahahahahahahahahahaha!
 
Actually, it's interesting that the first recorded Bigfoot "sightings" occur around the same time as the Cottingly fairy photographs....

Actually, it's interesting that reference to sasquatches occurred by Europeans in the New World over a century before the Cottingley Fairy photos.

It looks like "Bigfoot evidence" and "fairy evidence" are running roughly neck-and-neck.

Not even close. For example:

The cousins remained evasive about the authenticity of the pictures for most of their lives, at times claiming they were forgeries, and at other times leaving it to the individual to decide.

Never, not even once, have Roger Patterson or Bob Gimlin even hinted that their film footage was a hoax.

And there's probably a good reason why we don't find any fairy tracks or scat: so they're one up on Bigfoot there.

And what might that good reason be?

Maybe you should move to England, Huntster, and start hunting fairies?

No, thanks. I like it quite well right here in Alaska. Hell, I don't even want to go back to Amerika.

And I don't believe in fairies.

Although you may not want to say to the immigration guys as you arrive that the purpose of your visit is to "track down some fairies." It might give them the wrong idea.

It might.

And they might also say, "Good luck. Shoot straight. We need to get rid of a few of them around here."
 
Those measurements strike me as pretty imprecise. I see no evidence there that the arm length can be determined with any accuracy.

Meldum is careless from the get go. He doesn't know that it's even an arm in the first place.
 
Yeah. The Cottingley Fairy photos is the classic, recurring response to that question.

Any other examples?

Why do there have to be other examples? Doesn't one make the point?

Really? Like who?

Like this guy, for one. Go to the "unanswered questions" link. You may find its reasoning eerily familiar.

Of course not!

Hahahahahahahahahahahaha!

Yes, I agree that this is very funny. And just a little bit sad.
 
Actually, it's interesting that reference to sasquatches occurred by Europeans in the New World over a century before the Cottingley Fairy photos.

Got an indisputable example (i.e., a reference in a book actually published before 1900)?

Never, not even once, have Roger Patterson or Bob Gimlin even hinted that their film footage was a hoax.

One of the girls died insisting that the photographs were real. Does that make it true now?

And what might that good reason be?

Because fairies live on sunbeams and pixie scat is indistinguishable from kitten sighs. I thought everyone knew that.

And I don't believe in fairies.

Why not? There's photos, and lots of witnesses. That seems to be enough for you with Bigfoot.
 

Wow. Hard to argue with evidence like that. I mean, it must have been something, right Hunster? I mean, that's dozens of witnesses, right there. And we certainly don't have any conclusive evidence that it wasn't a leprechaun. So...I guess we add leprechauns to the list of "possible undiscovered bipedal primates."

I think it's fairly evident that the leprechaun (australopithecus pattanmurfius leprechaunus) is a close relative of Bigfoot; they both show the same "camera attraction/avoidance" technique: drawn, apparently, to people with cameras, but immediately hiding as soon as one is trained directly at them.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Yeah. The Cottingley Fairy photos is the classic, recurring response to that question.

Any other examples?

Why do there have to be other examples? Doesn't one make the point?

Not if you're comparing fairies to sasquatches. There are literally hundreds of hoaxed sasquatch photos out there, not to mention the one film that hasn't been established as a hoax.

Quote:
Really? Like who?

Like this guy, for one.

I read through the link. I didn't find where "this guy" states that he believed the photo subjects were real fairies.

Perhaps you can help me there?

Go to the "unanswered questions" link. You may find its reasoning eerily familiar.

Actually, no, I don't. What should I find familiar?
 
Not if you're comparing fairies to sasquatches. There are literally hundreds of hoaxed sasquatch photos out there, not to mention the one film that hasn't been established as a hoax.

So...you're saying that the fact that there are a lot of hoaxes somehow adds credibility to the Bigfoot story? If there were more hoax fairy photos we'd be more likely to believe in fairies?

By the way, I'm sure it was oversight, but you forgot to give me that (published) pre-1900 account of Bigfoot.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Actually, it's interesting that reference to sasquatches occurred by Europeans in the New World over a century before the Cottingley Fairy photos.

Got an indisputable example (i.e., a reference in a book actually published before 1900)?

Got a few. How about the year 1840?:

"Bear with me if I trouble you with a little of their superstitions. They believe in a race of giants, which inhabit a certain mountain off to the west of us. This mountain is covered with perpetual snow. They (the creatures) inhabit the snow peaks. They hunt and do all their work at night. They are men stealers.
They come to the people's lodges at night when the people are asleep and take them and put them under their skins and to their place of abode without even waking. Their track is a foot and a half long. They steal salmon from Indian nets and eat then raw as the bears do. If the people are awake, they always know when they are coming very near by their strong smell that is most intolerable. It is not uncommon for them to come in the night and give three whistles and then the stones will begin to hit their houses."

Earlier? How about 1811?

Quote:
Never, not even once, have Roger Patterson or Bob Gimlin even hinted that their film footage was a hoax.

One of the girls died insisting that the photographs were real. Does that make it true now?

Nope.

Quote:
And what might that good reason be?

Because fairies live on sunbeams and pixie scat is indistinguishable from kitten sighs. I thought everyone knew that.

Nope. I never paid much attention to them, because I don't believe they exist.

Apparently, you're the authority on fairies and pixies.

Quote:
And I don't believe in fairies.

Why not? There's photos, and lots of witnesses. That seems to be enough for you with Bigfoot.

There are only one set of photos you can produce, those involved in the photographs have admitted that they were hoaxed, you've only produced them as witnesses, and no, that isn't enough for me with Bigfoot.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Not if you're comparing fairies to sasquatches. There are literally hundreds of hoaxed sasquatch photos out there, not to mention the one film that hasn't been established as a hoax.

So...you're saying that the fact that there are a lot of hoaxes somehow adds credibility to the Bigfoot story?...

No, I'm saying that your comparison of the Bigfoot phenomenon to fairies with a single set of hoaxed fairy photos is a lame attempt to debunk sasquatchery.

If there were more hoax fairy photos we'd be more likely to believe in fairies?

We?

It wouldn't impress me, but you're free to believe whatever you please.

By the way, I'm sure it was oversight, but you forgot to give me that (published) pre-1900 account of Bigfoot..

Not an oversight. Just a little busy to be playing with you.

It has been delivered.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Actually, no, I don't. What should I find familiar?
The inability to realize that failure to disprove X in no way whatsoever lends weight to a belief in X.

How very profound!

Does that now mean that the inability to prove "X" (even though there is evidence that "X" exists) mean that "X" cannot possibly exist?
 
Got a few. How about the year 1840?:

Not published pre-1900. A link to a reputable site giving the text of this journal would be nice. What he describes (a beastie with distinctly predatory characteristics) in no way matches any of the modern claims about Bigfoot. Why adduce "giants who live on a mountain" as evidence of Bigfoot if the rest of the inconvenient testimony can be simply laid aside?


Earlier? How about 1811?
.

Again: link to a reputable text? (I ask about reputable texts, by the way, not just to be pissy but because I tried googling some passages from the excerpts given in these links and found other Bigfoot enthusiast sites, but nothing else. Some attributed the quotations to "journals" some to "narratives" some to "letters" and they didn't give exactly the same wording.

This one, by the way, even if authentic, is even less helpful as testimony. Even in the form quoted the guy says he thinks it could be a very large bear with worn down claws.

If the question had been "did anyone ever find spoor they couldn't properly identify before 1900" I'd have been very confident that the answer would have been yes.

Apparently, you're the authority on fairies and pixies.

Please, "cryptopixologist."

There are only one set of photos you can produce, those involved in the photographs have admitted that they were hoaxed, you've only produced them as witnesses, and no, that isn't enough for me with Bigfoot.

You yourself say there's only one "film" of Bigfoot, and the only thing going for it is that no one has admitted to it being a hoax. If the girls had died before one of them confessed, would we now be required to believe in fairies?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom