Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

How very profound!

Does that now mean that the inability to prove "X" (even though there is evidence that "X" exists) mean that "X" cannot possibly exist?

No. I cannot prove that fairies cannot possibly exist. However, despite centuries of testimony to their existence, I'm comfortable in denying it. The fact that you think the question "can you prove that it doesn't exist?" is important tells me that you are suffering from precisely the error I described in my earlier post.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Got a few. How about the year 1840?:

Not published pre-1900. A link to a reputable site giving the text of this journal would be nice.

I see. We're going to play that game, huh?

The Walker Library is extensive.

Okay. It will take some time.

Then beware. This road travels both ways.

What he describes (a beastie with distinctly predatory characteristics) in no way matches any of the modern claims about Bigfoot.

Now comes the traffic in the other direction. You made that claim.

Substantiate it.

Quote:
Earlier? How about 1811?

Again: link to a reputable text? (I ask about reputable texts, by the way, not just to be pissy but because I tried googling some passages from the excerpts given in these links and found other Bigfoot enthusiast sites, but nothing else.

Did you spell correctly?

I had no problem.

Some attributed the quotations to "journals" some to "narratives" some to "letters" and they didn't give exactly the same wording.

As the BFRO site clearly stated, Thompson wrote of the incident more than once.

This one, by the way, even if authentic, is even less helpful as testimony. Even in the form quoted the guy says he thinks it could be a very large bear with worn down claws.

And he also wrote that his Native guides disagreed, and that he clearly indicated "Monster Bear".

Quote:
There are only one set of photos you can produce, those involved in the photographs have admitted that they were hoaxed, you've only produced them as witnesses, and no, that isn't enough for me with Bigfoot.

You yourself say there's only one "film" of Bigfoot, and the only thing going for it is that no one has admitted to it being a hoax.

No, I didn't. I stated that it is the one that hasn't been shown to be a hoax. There are many other hoaxed films.

If the girls had died before one of them confessed, would we now be required to believe in fairies?

I'm certainly not, but (like I wrote) you're free to believe whatever you wish.
 
Of course they wouldn't. However, the original cave-fire talk of hairier races of hominids might evolve over 10,000 years of oral folklore into a creature that was quite different than the original Neanderthal, especially if the original Neanderthal is no longer around to compare it to..........[?QUOTE]

Is there any evidence neandethals were hairer and/or taller than we are?

Because we still have tigers and elephants.
In North America?

And using the reasoning you presented above, don't you think saber-toothed tigers (that by the way were related to jaguars, an not tigers) could trigger the same cultural phenomena? They were much more impressive than cougars, imagine the mythical beasts that would be created using them as a template.

Giant terrestrial sloths also have no current equivalent. Not enough impressive?

Don't forget the "myths" of "half-man, half-beast" creatures coming out of Africa for 2,000 years that were finally put to rest in the 1850's.
All African "manimal" myths are based on gorillas?

[
So it has been determined, by examining teeth and partial mandibles, that Gigantopithecus was quadraped? No examination of skull, hip, or spine is necessary?

Just how was that done?
Simple.
The most similar and closely related animal is the orang-utang. Then...

Oh, note you are disagreeing with a famous bigfoot researcher. Here's something we agree with, LOL.
 
Of course they wouldn't. However, the original cave-fire talk of hairier races of hominids might evolve over 10,000 years of oral folklore into a creature that was quite different than the original Neanderthal, especially if the original Neanderthal is no longer around to compare it to..........

Is there any evidence neandethals were hairer and/or taller than we are?

Nope. However:

Neanderthals had many adaptations to a cold climate, such as large braincases, short but robust builds, and large noses — traits selected by nature in cold climates, as observed in modern sub-arctic populations. Their brain sizes have been estimated as larger than modern humans. On average, Neanderthal males stood about 1.65m tall (just under 5' 5") and were heavily built, and muscular due to their physical activity and robust bone structure. Females were about 1.53 to 1.57m tall (about 5'-5'2").

Originally Posted by Huntster
Because we still have tigers and elephants.

In North America?

Nope.

And humans were arriving in the North America when the last saber toothed cats and hairy proboscidea were dying out.

But..............you knew that, didn't you?

And using the reasoning you presented above, don't you think saber-toothed tigers (that by the way were related to jaguars, an not tigers) could trigger the same cultural phenomena? They were much more impressive than cougars, imagine the mythical beasts that would be created using them as a template.

Sure enough, huh?

But, at least with the Natives of Alaska today, their totems and spiritual ties to animals only refer to animals that are alive today.

Their totems and religion include, specifically, sasquatches.

Reference. Discussion.

Funny how that works out, huh?

Giant terrestrial sloths also have no current equivalent. Not enough impressive?

No current mention of giant sloths among native peoples that I know of. They are also "reasoned" to become extinct in the Americas around 10,000 years ago; right around the time man "is thought" to have arrived.

Now, do you want "proof" of those dates?

Ask your fellow scientists. That's where all these dates come from.

Don't forget the "myths" of "half-man, half-beast" creatures coming out of Africa for 2,000 years that were finally put to rest in the 1850's.
All African "manimal" myths are based on gorillas?

Nope. But before 1850, though, all "manimal" "myths" were rejected by your beloved "scientists." Only after an adventurer brought out the first carcass of a gorilla did science get dragged to the table (and here in the U.S., they still resisted for years).


Originally Posted by Huntster
So it has been determined, by examining teeth and partial mandibles, that Gigantopithecus was quadraped? No examination of skull, hip, or spine is necessary?

Just how was that done?

Simple.
The most similar and closely related animal is the orang-utang. Then...

So, the determination wasn't made based on the actual evidence, but on what "the most similar and closely related animal" is like, even though that "most similar and closely related animal" is 1/3 the size of the questioned beast?

Oh, note you are disagreeing with a famous bigfoot researcher. Here's something we agree with, LOL.

I'm not "disagreeing with a famous bigfoot researcher." I'm stating facts.

You?
 
Last edited:

Are you suggesting they had more hairs than we do as an adaptation to the cold?

There are some (circunstantial) evidence that hey used clothes, what would not be an indication of neanderthals having more hairs than we do. It is nowdays known their looks were not that different from ours - wearing modern clothes one could pass by you right now and you would not note any major difference. Also, as your quote shows, they were not tall, thus they can hardly be the source of any legend of giant hairy man-like beings wandering in the woods.

Nope.

And humans were arriving in the North America when the last saber toothed cats and hairy proboscidea were dying out.

But..............you knew that, didn't you?

Incorrect. Humans cohexisted with the megafauna for some millenia in North America. The Clovis people (the ancestors of Native Americans) actively hunted mammoths. Some suppose they contributed to the extinction of the species. The overlap between man and megafauna in the Americas may have been something between 3Ky or 5Ky.

Sure enough, huh?

But, at least with the Natives of Alaska today, their totems and spiritual ties to animals only refer to animals that are alive today.

Their totems and religion include, specifically, sasquatches.

Reference. Discussion.

Funny how that works out, huh?

Huntster, we are focusing the discussion on the point if the preservation of memory of extinct beasts as myths is or not likely. If their tradition is based just on currently existing animals, then it can be seen as a hint it is not.

Now, are you interested in moving on and discuss the possibility of the current Native American myths of "sasquatch" being based on a real animal that exists nowdays?

That would be a different topic, with different pro and con arguments.

No current mention of giant sloths among native peoples that I know of. They are also "reasoned" to become extinct in the Americas around 10,000 years ago; right around the time man "is thought" to have arrived.

Now, do you want "proof" of those dates?

Ask your fellow scientists. That's where all these dates come from.

I am quite well aware of the methodology, since I am a geologist. You could say that in a certain way I am one of them.

As I wrote before, the overlap between the Clovis people and megafauna may have been something between 3K and 5K years. Not to mention that there are evidence of an earlier population, but the chances of cultural continuity between both people are very low.

Nope. But before 1850, though, all "manimal" "myths" were rejected by your beloved "scientists." Only after an adventurer brought out the first carcass of a gorilla did science get dragged to the table (and here in the U.S., they still resisted for years).

Might I ask you to tone down the hostility?

So, the determination wasn't made based on the actual evidence, but on what "the most similar and closely related animal" is like, even though that "most similar and closely related animal" is 1/3 the size of the questioned beast?

You have any better option than say it could have been bipedal because a mythical beast is supposed to be bipedal?

I'm not "disagreeing with a famous bigfoot researcher." I'm stating facts.

You?

The facts you stated are in disagreement with Krantz's interpretation that Gigantopithecus's teeth indicate bipedalism.

What am I doing?

I am trying to maintain a polite discussion with someone who has a diferent point of view. I am exposing my reasoning and the evidence I use to back it.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Huntster
Nope. However:

Are you suggesting they had more hairs than we do as an adaptation to the cold?

I'm stating that more hair/fur is a biological reality for cold climate terrestrial mammals.

Is it not?

There are some (circunstantial) evidence that hey used clothes, what would not be an indication of neanderthals having more hairs than we do.

Utilizing clothing/tools is also the hallmark of humanity, as opposed to mastadons/elephants.

Obviously, if you subscribe to Darwin's theories, as man evolved into a reasoning/thinking creature, his reliance on fur diminished as he clothed himself. Neanderthal wasn't "created" naked, then clothed himself with fur, did he?

It is nowdays known their looks were not that different from ours - wearing modern clothes one could pass by you right now and you would not note any major difference.

Unless he was extremely hairy, which can't be known from the fossil record. His skeletal evidence demonstrates that some modern people are built like they were, but humans are built in many, many ways, aren't they?

Also, as your quote shows, they were not tall, thus they can hardly be the source of any legend of giant hairy man-like beings wandering in the woods.

Asian "sasquatch" reports don't refer to creatures as tall as the Pacific Northwest. Almas aren't reported to be any taller than men.

Originally Posted by Huntster
Nope.

And humans were arriving in the North America when the last saber toothed cats and hairy proboscidea were dying out.

But..............you knew that, didn't you?

Incorrect. Humans cohexisted with the megafauna for some millenia in North America. The Clovis people (the ancestors of Native Americans) actively hunted mammoths. Some suppose they contributed to the extinction of the species. The overlap between man and megafauna in the Americas may have been something between 3Ky or 5Ky.

That is current theory. The overlap is now considered approximately 3,000 years.

Please provide a citation for the evidence of that claim.

Originally Posted by Huntster
Sure enough, huh?

But, at least with the Natives of Alaska today, their totems and spiritual ties to animals only refer to animals that are alive today.

Their totems and religion include, specifically, sasquatches.

Reference. Discussion.

Funny how that works out, huh?

Huntster, we are focusing the discussion on the point if the preservation of memory of extinct beasts as myths is or not likely. If their tradition is based just on currently existing animals, then it can be seen as a hint it is not.

I'm focused on the possibility that these creatures exist or existed recently. You are focused on the likelihood that they do not.

We're presently dancing around the definition and origins of myths. I'm pointing out that traditional Native American myths, especially in the region most noted for sasquatch sightings and evidence, don't include such myths as dragons, trolls, or others brought to the Americas, but that sasquatches are an integral part of their culture, and that PNW totems include no creatures that do not presently exist (nor do they include such creatures as saber toothed cats or mastadons which existed as recently as 10,000 years ago, are still found intact in glaciers, and which you claim they even hunted to extinction).

Now, are you interested in moving on and discuss the possibility of the current Native American myths of "sasquatch" being based on a real animal that exists nowdays?

That is exactly what I wish to discuss.

That would be a different topic, with different pro and con arguments.

That is part and parcel of the possibility that sasquatches exist or recently existed in the North American PNW.

Originally Posted by Huntster
No current mention of giant sloths among native peoples that I know of. They are also "reasoned" to become extinct in the Americas around 10,000 years ago; right around the time man "is thought" to have arrived.

Now, do you want "proof" of those dates?

Ask your fellow scientists. That's where all these dates come from.

I am quite well aware of the methodology, since I am a geologist. You could say that in a certain way I am one of them.

As I wrote before, the overlap between the Clovis people and megafauna may have been something between 3K and 5K years. Not to mention that there are evidence of an earlier population, but the chances of cultural continuity between both people are very low.

Thus the lack of myths regarding species that went extinct prior to 10,000 years ago.

So why do Haida have totems with sasquatch faces on them?

Originally Posted by Huntster
Nope. But before 1850, though, all "manimal" "myths" were rejected by your beloved "scientists." Only after an adventurer brought out the first carcass of a gorilla did science get dragged to the table (and here in the U.S., they still resisted for years).

Might I ask you to tone down the hostility?

So now we're back to "hostility"?

Please point out my specific hostile words.

Originally Posted by Huntster
So, the determination wasn't made based on the actual evidence, but on what "the most similar and closely related animal" is like, even though that "most similar and closely related animal" is 1/3 the size of the questioned beast?

You have any better option than say it could have been bipedal because a mythical beast is supposed to be bipedal?

Yes. I'd say that the mode of locomotion for the Gigantopithecus is not known because there is no way to determine that from the only known fossils, which are teeth and partial mandibles.


Originally Posted by Huntster
I'm not "disagreeing with a famous bigfoot researcher." I'm stating facts.

You?

The facts you stated are in disagreement with Krantz's interpretation that Gigantopithecus's teeth indicate bipedalism.

So?
 
I'm stating that more hair/fur is a biological reality for cold climate terrestrial mammals.

Is it not?
...snip...
Do you think neanderthals had much more body hairs than we?

Do you think neanderthals may have been a template for myths such as sasquatch or not?

I say no, given their similarity with modern humans.

If you disagree, then please tell why.

Asian "sasquatch" reports don't refer to creatures as tall as the Pacific Northwest. Almas aren't reported to be any taller than men.

Neanderthals were restricted to Europe and parts of the wstern Asia. Better look for another template for these mythical beings if they are not within this geographic range.

That is current theory. The overlap is now considered approximately 3,000 years.

Please provide a citation for the evidence of that claim.

See below.

I'm focused on the possibility that these creatures exist or existed recently. You are focused on the likelihood that they do not.

We're presently dancing around the definition and origins of myths. I'm pointing out that traditional Native American myths, especially in the region most noted for sasquatch sightings and evidence, don't include such myths as dragons, trolls, or others brought to the Americas, but that sasquatches are an integral part of their culture, and that PNW totems include no creatures that do not presently exist (nor do they include such creatures as saber toothed cats or mastadons which existed as recently as 10,000 years ago, are still found intact in glaciers, and which you claim they even hunted to extinction).

Well, Huntster, lets be precise here. I have not claimed the Clovis people hunted mammoths or mastodons to extinction. I wrote:
Some suppose they contributed to the extinction of the species. The overlap between man and megafauna in the Americas may have been something between 3Ky or 5Ky.
Care to correct your statement?

Easy info on the Clovis:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clovis_culture

Easy info on the overhunt theory:
http://www.exn.ca/mammoth/extinction-overkill.cfm

http://www.dbc.uci.edu/~sustain/bio65/lec04/b65lec04.htm
Researchers with another POV:
http://www.smu.edu/anthro/faculty/dMeltzer/pdf files/JWP_2002_Clovis_hunting.pdf

More pro and con people:
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q...on simulation Mithen&hl=pt-BR&lr=&oi=scholart

Understood?

So why do Haida have totems with sasquatch faces on them?
Why shouldn't they have? The myth is part of their culture.
However, to interpretate their myth according to another background is questionable. And this is the point, isn't it? There are other options than a real creature.

So now we're back to "hostility"?

Please point out my specific hostile words.

Well, the
your beloved "scientists."
, for example, seems to be the old hostility starting to surface again. I hope I am wrong, however.

Can we try to avoid this?

Yes. I'd say that the mode of locomotion for the Gigantopithecus is not known because there is no way to determine that from the only known fossils, which are teeth and partial mandibles.

You are free to say so. But you can't ignore the fact that based onthe avaliable evidence, they most likely were not.


Their interpretations are not flawless.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Huntster
I'm stating that more hair/fur is a biological reality for cold climate terrestrial mammals.

Is it not?
...snip...

Do you think neanderthals had much more body hairs than we?

Yes, I think they did.

Do you think neanderthals may have been a template for myths such as sasquatch or not?

Yes, I think neanderthals may have been the template for myths of trolls, almas, and possibly other Eurasian myths, and certainly may have been the template for the catchall myths of brutish, crude, bipedal, sub-human "boogiemen".

I don't think they are the template for North American sasquatches.

I say no, given their similarity with modern humans.

If you disagree, then please tell why.

I neither agree nor disagree. I don't know.

I say it's possible.

Originally Posted by Huntster
Asian "sasquatch" reports don't refer to creatures as tall as the Pacific Northwest. Almas aren't reported to be any taller than men.

Neanderthals were restricted to Europe and parts of the wstern Asia. Better look for another template for these mythical beings if they are not within this geographic range.

Okay. If you wish such discipline, than drop the almas reference.

Europe has plenty of myths of sub-human, bipedal boogermen.

Originally Posted by Huntster
I'm focused on the possibility that these creatures exist or existed recently. You are focused on the likelihood that they do not.

We're presently dancing around the definition and origins of myths. I'm pointing out that traditional Native American myths, especially in the region most noted for sasquatch sightings and evidence, don't include such myths as dragons, trolls, or others brought to the Americas, but that sasquatches are an integral part of their culture, and that PNW totems include no creatures that do not presently exist (nor do they include such creatures as saber toothed cats or mastadons which existed as recently as 10,000 years ago, are still found intact in glaciers, and which you claim they even hunted to extinction).


Well, Huntster, lets be precise here. I have not claimed the Clovis people hunted mammoths or mastodons to extinction. I wrote:

Quote:
Some suppose they contributed to the extinction of the species. The overlap between man and megafauna in the Americas may have been something between 3Ky or 5Ky.

Care to correct your statement?

Correct which statement?


I will address Clovis and the overhunting theories later, if the myth generation/template derail continues.............

Originally Posted by Huntster
So why do Haida have totems with sasquatch faces on them?

Why shouldn't they have? The myth is part of their culture.
However, to interpretate their myth according to another background is questionable. And this is the point, isn't it? There are other options than a real creature.

That's the point; the myth theory isn't whole.

Why do Haida have totems with sasquatches and do not have any totems, reference, traditional background, or any mention whatsoever with dragons? Dragons are a cultural icon in Europe, all through Asia, and even Central America. Why didn't the dragon myth include the North American Pacific Northwest, but the sasquatch myth did (and so very prominently)?

After all, humanity moved through the PNW before reaching Central America, did it not?

Originally Posted by Huntster
So now we're back to "hostility"?

Please point out my specific hostile words.

Well, the
Quote:
your beloved "scientists."

, for example, seems to be the old hostility starting to surface again. I hope I am wrong, however.

Can we try to avoid this?

Is a challenge toward the inaction and entrenchment of science and scientists with regard to this phenomenon with such words hostile?

Originally Posted by Huntster
Yes. I'd say that the mode of locomotion for the Gigantopithecus is not known because there is no way to determine that from the only known fossils, which are teeth and partial mandibles.

You are free to say so. But you can't ignore the fact that based on the avaliable evidence, they most likely were not.

That is incorrect. Based on the available evidence, there is no way to determine the mode of Gigantopithecus' locomotion.

If you disagree, please provide some evidence. As a scientist, that shouldn't be difficult for you.

Originally Posted by Huntster
So?

Their interpretations are not flawless.

Bravo for that observation!

I'd like to point out that our interpretations are not flawless, either.

So, Krantz opined that Gigantopithecus was bipedal. You appear to opine that Gigantopithecus was a quadraped.

I opine that the mode of locomotion cannot be determined by the available evidence.

There is no other option, unless someone wishes to opine that Gigantopithecus traveled on either one leg or three.

Who is correct?
 
I see. We're going to play that game, huh?

Yes, the game I am playing is the "I want to know that the evidence is sound" game. It's a fun game. You should try learning the rules.

Now comes the traffic in the other direction. You made that claim.

Substantiate it.

Just to remind you, you're referring here to my claim that the behaviour described in the Walker diary (or letter, or narrative--depending on which site you consult) is inconsistent with claims made about Bigfoot. In the passage you referred me to here is what these putative "Bigfoots" are described as doing:

"They come to the people's lodges at night when the people are asleep and take them and put them under their skins and to their place of abode without even waking."

You have consistently accounted for the absence of concrete evidence of Bigfoot by hypothesizing that Bigfoot as extremely shy and wary. Here, though, you offer me evidence of a predatory beast who actually barges in to human habitations and makes off with its victims. Can you really imagine that such an animal would have remained unknown all this time?

Did you spell correctly?

Try googling the phrase "track is a foot and a half long" from the Walker extract you gave me. You'll find that you get two sites, each quoting the same characteristic, but each locating the phrase within different sentence structures of supposedly different works by Walker. This is why I asked for a more scholarly version of the text.


No, that simply tells me that this person did exist. It doesn't give me the text of the passage in a scholarly, non "Bigfoot enthusiast" context. The Wikipedia entry does, though, mention that Bigfoot enthusiasts are keen on Thompson's account of some unidentified tracks that he found. You may yourself have noticed, though, that the Wikipedia entry agrees with me that his description is useless for Bigfoot purposes. Unless you hypothesize that Bigfoot occasionally grows claws on his four toes, and then sheds them, Thompson clearly wasn't describing Bigfoot tracks.

So Thompson is "evidence" for you simply because he found some tracks of a surprisingly large bear? Or do you feel that it is justifiable to assume away every part of his account that doesn't fit with Bigfoot but keep the "unidentifiable track" part because it props up the fantasy?

And he also wrote that his Native guides disagreed, and that he clearly indicated "Monster Bear".

And Bigfoot is a monster bear? I think you'll find that a lot of people would be willing to agree with that proposition: hunter's in bad light see a very large bear on its hind legs and spin this into a Bigfoot sighting. Yep, that sounds very believable.

No, I didn't. I stated that it is the one that hasn't been shown to be a hoax. There are many other hoaxed films.

I'm still not seeing how the fact that there are many hoaxed films supports your case. Surely the fact that there are many hoaxed accounts of Bigfoot sheds doubt over every account? We know that people have an incentive to lie: the very fact that so many have been caught lying proves that.

I'm certainly not, but (like I wrote) you're free to believe whatever you wish.

Yes, we're all free to believe what we wish. However, we're also all free to choose to believe things that we actually have some evidence for.
 
Just a thought but while we're on the hairy monster men myth origin topic it seems to me that were the template based on an external rather than psychological construct it is not totally necessary for a single species to be involved. With our collective flare for the dramatic we have often taken rather unrelated creatures and inferred a level of humanity on them. Huntster has already made a good point of how gorillas were considered wild men. I'm pretty sure orangutans and bears have fallen in that category. How 'bout the rug-chested, mono-browed guys on the other side of the valley? I guess the point being that we're pretty imaginative and it doesn't take much to make monster men and we seem to enjoy having them. On the other hand what we call bigfeet or sasquatch (not a native word) may have been a contributor and I do think Huntster has a point in bring up the fact that native peoples of the PNW (Haida, etc.) portrayed in their totems only animals that they were familiar with. I guess that begs the question of where thunderbirds fit in.:confused:
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
I see. We're going to play that game, huh?

Yes, the game I am playing is the "I want to know that the evidence is sound" game. It's a fun game. You should try learning the rules.

Oh, I know "the rules" quite well. This doesn't qualify. You stated that there was no reference to sasquatchery before 1900. I supplied a link that establishes your error, which was clearly made because you don't know enough about the subject to debate intelligently. Then you attempt to degrade the link with the lame argument of "soundness".

Trying to make me waste time with painstaking research/reference is a game I will not play with you. There has been reference to sasquatch before the year 1900. I provided evidence. Period.

Take your lumps and move on.

Quote:
Now comes the traffic in the other direction. You made that claim.

Substantiate it.

Just to remind you, you're referring here to my claim that the behaviour described in the Walker diary (or letter, or narrative--depending on which site you consult) is inconsistent with claims made about Bigfoot. In the passage you referred me to here is what these putative "Bigfoots" are described as doing:

"They come to the people's lodges at night when the people are asleep and take them and put them under their skins and to their place of abode without even waking."

You have consistently accounted for the absence of concrete evidence of Bigfoot by hypothesizing that Bigfoot as extremely shy and wary. Here, though, you offer me evidence of a predatory beast who actually barges in to human habitations and makes off with its victims. Can you really imagine that such an animal would have remained unknown all this time?

You "substantiate" your claim with this?: "Can you really imagine that such an animal would have remained unknown all this time."

I reply with: yes. Such a creature can remain unknown all this time to people like yourself.

Quote:
Did you spell correctly?

Try googling the phrase "track is a foot and a half long" from the Walker extract you gave me. You'll find that you get two sites, each quoting the same characteristic, but each locating the phrase within different sentence structures of supposedly different works by Walker. This is why I asked for a more scholarly version of the text.

Try googling the words "ELKANAH WALKER" or "DAVID THOMPSON". You'll find sites (on the very first reference page) which lead to sasquatch references, as well as to original works for both men.

Quote:
I had no problem.

No, that simply tells me that this person did exist. It doesn't give me the text of the passage in a scholarly, non "Bigfoot enthusiast" context. The Wikipedia entry does, though, mention that Bigfoot enthusiasts are keen on Thompson's account of some unidentified tracks that he found. You may yourself have noticed, though, that the Wikipedia entry agrees with me that his description is useless for Bigfoot purposes.

No, I don't. The Wikipedia article states:

In his published journals, Thompson recorded seeing large footprints near what is now Jasper, Alberta, in 1811. It has been suggested that these prints were similar to what has since been called the sasquatch. However, Thompson noted that these tracks showed "a small Nail at the end of each [toe]", and stated that these tracks "very much resembles a large Bear's Track". [3]

It did not use any words that indicated "useless for Bigfoot purposes."

Further, did you notice that little "[3]" at the end of that statement? That's called a "footnote." When one scrolls to the bottom of the page, one finds what is called a "reference." In this particular case, the reference is:

Thompson, David. Columbia Journals. Edited by Barbara Belyea. McGill-Queen's University Press, 1994, p. 135

If you don't like the Wikipedia statements, follow the reference. Don't ask me for it.

Unless you hypothesize that Bigfoot occasionally grows claws on his four toes, and then sheds them, Thompson clearly wasn't describing Bigfoot tracks.

I don't hypothosize such, nor do I reject it. Thompson, as the first white man traversing that path, clearly saw lots of brown bear tracks. That he commented on these more than once, described them as "monster", and stated that his native guides disagreed that it was bear spoor, indicates that he was very impressed with the sign, and that there is question in his mind whether or not it was truly bear sign.

So Thompson is "evidence" for you simply because he found some tracks of a surprisingly large bear?

Yes, it is. It is testimony, and I hold it in much greater regard than anything you might say or write.

Do you posit that the testimony of the first white man to enter that country is not evidence?

Or do you feel that it is justifiable to assume away every part of his account that doesn't fit with Bigfoot but keep the "unidentifiable track" part because it props up the fantasy?

It is as described, is it not? It was a very large track that Thompson thought might be a "monster bear", but his native guides told him was not, and that it belonged to a "mammoth."

Or do feel an obligation to degrade that, in order to keep "the fantasy" from becoming possible?

Quote:
And he also wrote that his Native guides disagreed, and that he clearly indicated "Monster Bear".

And Bigfoot is a monster bear?

I don't know, nor do I know what made that track, however Thompson's native guides told him it was not.

I think you'll find that a lot of people would be willing to agree with that proposition: hunter's in bad light see a very large bear on its hind legs and spin this into a Bigfoot sighting. Yep, that sounds very believable.

Are you now dealing in "believable", or are you willing to stick to the evidence?

Quote:
No, I didn't. I stated that it is the one that hasn't been shown to be a hoax. There are many other hoaxed films.

I'm still not seeing how the fact that there are many hoaxed films supports your case.

You tried to dilute sasquatchery with a single reference and photo of fairies. I asked for more, and you digressed further with the "do I need more" game. I showed that there are certainly more hoaxed sasquatch photos, as well as one moving picture which is accepted by many as valid and which hasn't been shown to be a hoax.

Your fairy strawman has reached this end. Shall we continue to play with it, or can we burn it now?

Surely the fact that there are many hoaxed accounts of Bigfoot sheds doubt over every account?

Only if you're into doubt and not evidence, or wish to believe in fairies.

We know that people have an incentive to lie: the very fact that so many have been caught lying proves that.

You and I are people, too.

So how about leaving the fairy photos in the fairy thread and focus on sasquatch in the sasquatch thread?

Quote:
I'm certainly not, but (like I wrote) you're free to believe whatever you wish.

Yes, we're all free to believe what we wish. However, we're also all free to choose to believe things that we actually have some evidence for.

Very good. That's what I choose to believe in; things that offer enough evidence.

If proof is available, I no longer need to believe. I know.

We have evidence of sasquatch. We don't have proof.
 
Just a thought but while we're on the hairy monster men myth origin topic it seems to me that were the template based on an external rather than psychological construct it is not totally necessary for a single species to be involved. With our collective flare for the dramatic we have often taken rather unrelated creatures and inferred a level of humanity on them. Huntster has already made a good point of how gorillas were considered wild men. I'm pretty sure orangutans and bears have fallen in that category. How 'bout the rug-chested, mono-browed guys on the other side of the valley? I guess the point being that we're pretty imaginative and it doesn't take much to make monster men and we seem to enjoy having them. On the other hand what we call bigfeet or sasquatch (not a native word) may have been a contributor and I do think Huntster has a point in bring up the fact that native peoples of the PNW (Haida, etc.) portrayed in their totems only animals that they were familiar with. I guess that begs the question of where thunderbirds fit in.:confused:

Well, we can do anything we want in our minds;).

The way I see it, "manimals" are a common theme around the world. From the shaman that clais to morph in to a jaguar after ingesting some holy weed or potion to the elusive hairy humanoid beasts supposed to live in North America, passing through European werewolves, there are similaritires and comon elements. The primordial motivations could well be a link, desirable or not, with nature. On the benevolent aspect you would have these creatures as a metaphor of a desire for a bigger proximity between humans and animals, nature if you preffer. The gentle shy bigfoot would fit in this endmember. The fear of loosing humanity (civilization, culture), what separates us from animals, would be expressed as werewolves and similar beasts. How would be an "arquetypical" template for these creatures? How would one imagine the looks of a human loosing its humanity and living in the woods? The answer is a recurrent theme, that can be first read at the Gilgamesh epic, but can also be inferred from petroglyphs that are even older. Hairy men-like beings.

So, I don't think a real "undiscovered animal" template is truly needed for this sort of myths, at lest in their original form. Current bigfoot myths borrows from science the template (or parts of it).
 
Oh, I know "the rules" quite well. This doesn't qualify. You stated that there was no reference to sasquatchery before 1900. I supplied a link that establishes your error, which was clearly made because you don't know enough about the subject to debate intelligently. Then you attempt to degrade the link with the lame argument of "soundness".

Huntster, in the very first post in which I asked for pre-1900 evidence I specifically stated that it should come from work "published before 1900." You give me unsubstantiated quotations from works that were not published before 1900 and which do not describe animals that either behave like or leaves tracks that conform with the animal you believe to be the modern Bigfoot. Nor is either account an account of a "sighting." Walker is merely relating an interesting Indian myth. If Indian children were regularly being carried off by these beasties, don't you think he'd have seen evidence of it? If you see this as having "established my error" then you're clearly playing a very different "game" from the one that I am playing.

Trying to make me waste time with painstaking research/reference is a game I will not play with you. There has been reference to sasquatch before the year 1900. I provided evidence. Period.

No, I can see that painstaking research is not your style. That much is clear.

Take your lumps and move on.

Oh, I intend to move on--it's pretty clear that these two irrelevant passages were your best shot.

You "substantiate" your claim with this?: "Can you really imagine that such an animal would have remained unknown all this time."

Yes--my claim was that the creature described behaves quite unlike the creature you hypothesize currently exists. What is your explanation for the fact that a bold predator who regularly invades human habitations to carry off and eat people would remain undetected in a country with so much prey bustling around? I notice that you don't actually attempt to answer that question except in the following lame way"

I reply with: yes. Such a creature can remain unknown all this time to people like yourself.

So, your answer to how an animal that regular preys on people could remain undetected is that it in fact continues to prey on people but only "people like myself" are unaware of this fact? Or is it that because "people like myself" are unaware of this fact that for some reason Bigfoot has changed his behaviour? If I become aware of his existence will he recommence preying on people? Don't worry--I know that you won't actually try to construct a plausible defense of your position. Consider the "sigh--you're just being silly" answer understood.

Ouch! Those lumps are so painful! :rolleyes:

Try googling the words "ELKANAH WALKER" or "DAVID THOMPSON". You'll find sites (on the very first reference page) which lead to sasquatch references, as well as to original works for both men.

I did. I find lots and lots of Bigfoot enthusiast sites. I did see that Elkanah Walker's diary was published (in the 20th century), but I have found no online edition of that publication. I might bother to go look it up next time I'm in the library. But even if the passage is exactly as described on the Bigfoot sites, it's still useless for your case, for precisely the reasons I've already outlined. It describes an animal who seeks out human encampments to prey upon them.

No, I don't. The Wikipedia article states:

And what it says is not a debunking of the Bigfoot claim because...?

It did not use any words that indicated "useless for Bigfoot purposes."

Then I submit you didn't read it very carefully.

Further, did you notice that little "[3]" at the end of that statement? That's called a "footnote." When one scrolls to the bottom of the page, one finds what is called a "reference." In this particular case, the reference is:

Thank you. All my life I'd wondered what a reference was. Again, this refers to a book (published post-1900) which supposedly contains this account. But, again, it is not an online text. And, again, even if it turns out that the wording is exactly as your Bigfoot websites have it, Thompson's big bear print is utterly useless for you as evidence.

Let us look at it a little more closely, shall we:

Here's what Thompson wrote in his journal entry on January 7th, 1811:


I saw the track of a large Animal - has 4 large Toes abt 3 or 4 In long & a small nail at the end of each. The Bal of his foot sank abt 3 In deeper than his Toes - the hinder part of his foot did not mark well. The whole is about 14 In long by 8 In wide & very much resembles a large Bear's Track. It was in the Rivulet in about 6 In snow.


Gosh. How mysterious.

​

Forty years later--please note that FORTY YEARS LATER he writes his "Narrative" and gussies the story up a little:

​

January 7th. continuing our journey in the afternoon we came on the track of a large animal, the snow about six inches deep on the ice; I measured it; four large toes each of four inches in length, to each a short claw; the ball of the foot sunk three inches lower than the toes. the hinder part of the foot did not mark well, the length fourteen inches, by eight inches in breadth, walking from north to south, and having passed about six hours. We were in no humour to follow him; the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear, otherwise that of a very large old Bear, his claws worn away, the Indians would not allow.

Now...give me your reasons for preferring the account made FORTY YEARS after the sighting to the utterly offhand account offered at the time. Oh, yeah, that's right: in your version of the "game" everything that tends towards your favored result is "good evidence" but everything that doesn't is "bad."

Also, I note that you're keen on it being the "Indians" who insist on it being a supernatural being. Ah yes, the "Indians" know all about sasquatch...they know sasquatch track when they see it! But this word "mammouth" is a bit of a problem for you, isn't it? He says "young mammouth." He can't be using the word to mean simply "something very big" or the word "young" would just be silly ("it was the track of a small very large thing"). So he can only mean it in the sense of "elephant-like animal." But, hang on, now your Indians with their deep knowledge of animal spoor and their intimate knowledge of ol' Bigfoot are, in your view, mistaking his tracks for those of a small elephant. Quadruped, not biped.

So the Indians are utterly unquestionable when it comes to it not being bear (which Thompson continues to believe). But they're obviously a bunch of idiots when it comes to it being a large quadruped. Oh, that's right, though--I forgot that the rules of your game mean tht only evidence that tends to prove your position counts.

​

I don't hypothosize such, nor do I reject it. Thompson, as the first white man traversing that path, clearly saw lots of brown bear tracks. That he commented on these more than once, described them as "monster", and stated that his native guides disagreed that it was bear spoor, indicates that he was very impressed with the sign, and that there is question in his mind whether or not it was truly bear sign.

See above. And not that he never describes the tracks themselves as "monster." He says that the "men and Indians" held the tracks were those of a "young mammouth."

Yes, it is. It is testimony, and I hold it in much greater regard than anything you might say or write.

But what it is testimony of? That is surely the important question. You only get it to be "Bigfoot" testimony by cherry-picking the bits you like.

Do you posit that the testimony of the first white man to enter that country is not evidence?

Of course it is evidence. It is evidence that he saw tracks that looked, to him, like tracks of a big bear. Forty years later he seems to recall that his companions would have it be the tracks of a "young mammouth." Where in all of this you see evidence of "Bigfoot" I leave for you to fail to point out.

It is as described, is it not? It was a very large track that Thompson thought might be a "monster bear", but his native guides told him was not, and that it belonged to a "mammoth."

I'm not surprised you leave out both the "forty years later" and the "young mammoth" parts.

Or do feel an obligation to degrade that, in order to keep "the fantasy" from becoming possible?

This "evidence" comes "pre-degraded"--no effort on my part needed.

I don't know, nor do I know what made that track, however Thompson's native guides told him it was not.

Forty years after the event he remembers "the men and Indians" plumping for "young mammoth." He also remembers the Indians saying "not bear." As we have a contemporary account that gives no indication of this supposed controversy, and as we have no record at all from the Indians as to what they thought, and as there would have been good reason for someone to want to spice up a "narrative" if they had plans to publish it with tall tales of mammoths (not bigfeet) still roaming the wilderness, then....obviously Bigfoot is REAL!!!!!

Are you now dealing in "believable", or are you willing to stick to the evidence?

If the evidence isn't believable, it's not much use, is it?

You tried to dilute sasquatchery with a single reference and photo of fairies. I asked for more, and you digressed further with the "do I need more" game. I showed that there are certainly more hoaxed sasquatch photos, as well as one moving picture which is accepted by many as valid and which hasn't been shown to be a hoax.

Yes, I'm still not sure why you think that more hoaxes makes Bigfoot more believable.

Your fairy strawman has reached this end. Shall we continue to play with it, or can we burn it now?

When did it reach an end? How is it a "strawman"?
 
Yes, I think they did.

Yes, I think neanderthals may have been the template for myths of trolls, almas, and possibly other Eurasian myths, and certainly may have been the template for the catchall myths of brutish, crude, bipedal, sub-human "boogiemen".
What are your reasons to think they were, since we nowdays know they were not that different from us? Unless one sticks to the very outdated reconstructions of neanderthals (the "cavemen", "missing links" from the 50s and 60s), there's no way to find similarities between them and trolls, woodwoose, etc.

I don't think they are the template for North American sasquatches.

In this, we agree.

Okay. If you wish such discipline, than drop the almas reference.

Europe has plenty of myths of sub-human, bipedal boogermen.
We must try to be as exact as possible.
I bet there are plenty of myths everywhere on humanoid creatures. This is not an evidence of real creatures.

Correct which statement?
This one:
and which you claim they even hunted to extinction

I will address Clovis and the overhunting theories later, if the myth generation/template derail continues.............

It was brought in to light to demonstrate these people interacted with animals from the megafauna that would be much more impresive than bigfeet. You then asked for links proving what you erroneously said was my claim regardint the overhunting. I provided them, despite the fact I have not made such claim. Aniway, if the purposes were fulfilled, then we can move on.

And if you think this thread has been derailed by the myth discussion, then, in case you are interested in continuing the discussion, then feel free to start a new one.

Why do Haida have totems with sasquatches and do not have any totems, reference, traditional background, or any mention whatsoever with dragons? Dragons are a cultural icon in Europe, all through Asia, and even Central America. Why didn't the dragon myth include the North American Pacific Northwest, but the sasquatch myth did (and so very prominently)?
You could make a supposition that it would be because there are no crocodiles, alligators or similar reptiles there or that they never found the fossil remains of a dinosaur. And still it would provide no backing to the idea that a real animal is behind the myth we are discuting (bigfoot).

Are therevreal animals behind every mythical beasts from Native American lore? Or its just people trying to interpretate a myth outside its original context?

Is a challenge toward the inaction and entrenchment of science and scientists with regard to this phenomenon with such words hostile?
Sounded quite like hostility to me.

That is incorrect. Based on the available evidence, there is no way to determine the mode of Gigantopithecus' locomotion.

If you disagree, please provide some evidence. As a scientist, that shouldn't be difficult for you.

Check the links I more than once provided.

Bravo for that observation!

I'd like to point out that our interpretations are not flawless, either.

At no point I said or left implicit that my conclusions, interpretation, etc. are flawess. Neither have most people here who oppose your views. We will gladly change our minds as soon as reliable evidence shows up. Is it such a terrible behavior?

So, Krantz opined that Gigantopithecus was bipedal. You appear to opine that Gigantopithecus was a quadraped.

I opine that the mode of locomotion cannot be determined by the available evidence.

There is no other option, unless someone wishes to opine that Gigantopithecus traveled on either one leg or three.

Who is correct?

"Who is most likely to be correct?" should be the question, untill better evidence shows up.

And please note that its not mine the "opinion" that they were knuckle-walkers. I merely think the interpretations of the guys who discovered and studied it are more plausible than Krantz's, for the reasons I have already discussed somewhere else with LAL, if my memory does not fails me.

If they are right, then the animal in question can be ruled out as being bigfoot's template of bigfoot itself.
 
Last edited:
....If you see this as having "established my error" then you're clearly playing a very different "game" from the one that I am playing.

I'm not playing.

Quote:
Trying to make me waste time with painstaking research/reference is a game I will not play with you. There has been reference to sasquatch before the year 1900. I provided evidence. Period.

No, I can see that painstaking research is not your style. That much is clear.

Your evidence?

Quote:
Take your lumps and move on.

Oh, I intend to move on--

More games?

Quote:
You "substantiate" your claim with this?: "Can you really imagine that such an animal would have remained unknown all this time."

Yes

Thank you for your impressive science and painstaking research.

The next time you ask me for evidence, I'll reply with a question, too.

My claim was that the creature described behaves quite unlike the creature you hypothesize currently exists.

And I asked for something to substantiate that claim.

What is your explanation for the fact that a bold predator who regularly invades human habitations to carry off and eat people would remain undetected in a country with so much prey bustling around?

I would respond thus:

1) I don't believe they are a "bold predator"
2) No great apes are "bold predators"
3) All great apes are very shy, reclusive creatures
4) I don't believe sasquatches eat people
5) No great apes eat people
6) You are asking a stupid question, and I believe you're doing it on purpose

Quote:
I reply with: yes. Such a creature can remain unknown all this time to people like yourself.

So, your answer to how an animal that regular preys on people could remain undetected is that it in fact continues to prey on people but only "people like myself" are unaware of this fact?

Try reading this again, slooooooowly:

Such a creature can remain unknown all this time to people like yourself.

You have twice written that sasquatches "regular prey on people".

Please provide evidence of that.

Or is it that because "people like myself" are unaware of this fact that for some reason Bigfoot has changed his behaviour?

People like yourself refuse to learn about these creatures, you are skeptical regarding their existence, you've made up your mind that they do not exist, you ignore the evidence to the contrary, and you wouldn't know how to find your way out of the woods if you had a compass, and would probably wet your pants if you had to spend the night in the woods alone.

You know; with all the man-eating sasquatch boogermen salivating out there..........

Hell, the broad side of the barn could hide from you.

If I become aware of his existence will he recommence preying on people?

I doubt it.

Don't worry--I know that you won't actually try to construct a plausible defense of your position.

Defense? What do I need a defense for?

I don't see anything to defend against.

Certainly not your blather..........

Quote:
Try googling the words "ELKANAH WALKER" or "DAVID THOMPSON". You'll find sites (on the very first reference page) which lead to sasquatch references, as well as to original works for both men.

I did. I find lots and lots of Bigfoot enthusiast sites. I did see that Elkanah Walker's diary was published (in the 20th century), but I have found no online edition of that publication. I might bother to go look it up next time I'm in the library. But even if the passage is exactly as described on the Bigfoot sites, it's still useless for your case, for precisely the reasons I've already outlined. It describes an animal who seeks out human encampments to prey upon them.

Oh, that's where you get the boogerman stuff!

I guess you're not very familiar with the other famous explorers of North America. How about Lewis and Clark. Here were educated men, sent by the President of the United States to explore and document, including biology and botony. They're ancestral roots were from Europe, which has always been the range of brown bears. The Spanish had colonized California well before the Corp of Discovery left Washington, and were well aware of the California grizzly.

Yet when Lewis and Clark settled with the Mandan Indians in the Dakotas for their first winter, and the Mandans told them of the "great white bears" they would encounter to the west, Lewis wrote:

April 13 [Lewis]

We saw also many tracks of the white bear of enormous size, along the river shore and about the carcases of the Buffaloe, on which I presume they feed. we have not as yet seen one of these anamals, tho' their tracks are so abundant and recent. the men as well as ourselves are anxious to meet with some of these bear. the Indians give a very formidable account of the strengh and ferocity of this anamal, which they never dare to attack but in parties of six eight or ten persons; and are even then frequently defeated with the loss of one or more of their party. the savages attack this anamal with their bows and arrows and the indifferent guns with which the traders furnish them, with these they shoot with such uncertainty and at so short a distance, that they frequently mis their aim & fall a sacrefice to the bear. two Minetaries were killed during the last winter in an attack on a white bear. this anamall is said more frequently to attack a man on meeting with him, than to flee from him. When the Indians are about to go in quest of the white bear, previous to their departure, they paint themselves and perform all those supersticious rights commonly observed when they are about to make war uppon a neighbouring nation.

April 14 [Clark]

We Saw two white bear running from the report of Capt. Lewis Shot, those animals assended those Steep hills with Supprising ease & verlocity. they were too far to discover their prosise Colour & Size.

April 17 [Lewis]

Tho' we continue to see many tracks of the bear we have seen but very few of them, and those are at a great distance generally runing from us; I thefore presume that they are extreemly wary and shy; the Indian account of them dose not corrispond with our experience so far.

April 18 [Clark]

Two men went up the river to Set their beaver traps they met with a Bear and being without their arms thought prodent to return &c.

April 29 [Lewis]

Set out this morning at the usual hour....about 8 A.M. we fell in with two brown or [white] bear; both of which we wounded; one of them made his escape, the other after my firing on him pursued me seventy or eighty yards, but fortunately had been so badly wounded that he was unable to pursue so closely as to prevent my charging my gun; we again repeated our [fire] and killed him....it's colour is yellowish brown....this anamal appeared to me to differ from the black bear; it is a much more furious and formidable anamal, and will frequently pursue the hunter when wounded. it is asstonishing to see the wounds they will bear before they can be put to death.

They continue to learn:

Capt. Clark & Drewyer killed the largest brown bear this evening which we have yet seen. it was a most tremendious looking anamal, and extreemly hard to kill notwithstanding he had five balls through his lungs and five others in various parts he swam more than half the distance across the river to a sandbar & it was at least twenty minutes before he died; he did not attempt to attact, but fled and made the most tremendous roaring from the moment he was shot.

Maybe the Indians weren't so dumb, after all:

I find that the curiossity of our party is pretty well satisfied with rispect to this anamal, the formidable appearance of the male bear killed on the 5th added to the difficulty with which they die when even shot through the vital parts, has staggered the resolution of several of them, others however seem keen for action with the bear; I expect these gentlemen will give us some amusement shotly as they soon begin now to coppolate.

Hmmmmmm:

About 5 P.M. my attention was struck by one of the Party running at a distance toward us and making signs and hollowing as if in distress, I ordered the perogues to put too, and waited until he arrived; I found that it was Bratton the man with the soar hand whom I had permitted to walk on shore, he arrived so much out of breath that it was several minutes before he could tell what had happened. ...had shot a brown bear which immediately turned on him and pursued him a considerable distance but he had wounded it so badly that it could not overtake him; I immediately turned out with seven of the party in quest of this monster, we at length found his trale and persued him about a mile by the blood through very thick brush of rosbushes and the large leafed willow; we finally found him concealed in some very thick brush and shot him through the skull with two balls. we proceeded dress him as soon as possible,...we now found that Bratton had shot him through the center of the lungs, notwithstanding which he had pursued him near half a mile and had returned more than double that distance and with his tallons had prepared himself a bed in the earth of about 2 feet deep and five long and was perfectly alive when we found him which could not have been less than 2 hours after he received the wound. these bear being so hard to die reather intimedates us all; I must confess that I do not like the gentlemen and had reather fight two Indians than one bear......

You know, those Indians knew what they were talking about, didn't they?:

Six good hunters of the party fired at a Brown or Yellow Bear Several times before they killed him, & indeed he had like to have defeated the whole party, he pursued them Seperately as they fired on him, and was near Cattching Several of them one he pursued into the river, this bear was large & fat would way about 500 wt. he pursued two of them seperately so close that they were obliged to throw aside their guns and poucnes and throw themselves into the river altho' the bank was nearly twenty feet perpendicular; so enraged was this animal that he plunged into the river only a few feet behind the second man he had compelled to take refuge in the water, when one of those who still remained on shore shot him through the head and finally killed him

Those damned bears..........:

The White bear have become so troublesome to us that I do not think it prudent to send one man alone on an errand of any kind, particularly where he has to pass through the brush. we have seen two of them on the large Island opposite to us today but are so much engaged that we could not spare the time to hunt them, but will make a frolick of it when the party return and drive them from these islands. they come close arround our camp every night but have never yet ventured to attack us and our dog gives us timely notice of their visits, he keeps constantly padroling all night. I have made the men sleep with their arms by them as usual for fear of accedents.

Yeah, you just go ahead and ignore those foolish Indians. You in your impressive city know everything, anyway, don't you?
Those scientists tell you............

Quote:
No, I don't. The Wikipedia article states:

And what it says is not a debunking of the Bigfoot claim because...?

..........Because that is not what it says.

Quote:
It did not use any words that indicated "useless for Bigfoot purposes."

Then I submit you didn't read it very carefully.

Not only did I read it carefully, I quoted it for you.

I won't do it again. It would be useless. You clearly have a reading problem.

Quote:
Further, did you notice that little "[3]" at the end of that statement? That's called a "footnote." When one scrolls to the bottom of the page, one finds what is called a "reference." In this particular case, the reference is:

Thank you. All my life I'd wondered what a reference was.

Yes, I can see that.

You're quite welcome.

Again, this refers to a book (published post-1900) which supposedly contains this account. But, again, it is not an online text. And, again, even if it turns out that the wording is exactly as your Bigfoot websites have it, Thompson's big bear print is utterly useless for you as evidence.

No, it is not.

Let us look at it a little more closely, shall we:

Yes. Let's.

Here's what Thompson wrote in his journal entry on January 7th, 1811:

Quote:
I saw the track of a large Animal - has 4 large Toes abt 3 or 4 In long & a small nail at the end of each. The Bal of his foot sank abt 3 In deeper than his Toes - the hinder part of his foot did not mark well. The whole is about 14 In long by 8 In wide & very much resembles a large Bear's Track. It was in the Rivulet in about 6 In snow.

Gosh. How mysterious.

Just another bear track, right?

Then why bother writing it in the journal?

Forty years later--please note that FORTY YEARS LATER he writes his "Narrative" and gussies the story up a little:

Quote:
January 7th. continuing our journey in the afternoon we came on the track of a large animal, the snow about six inches deep on the ice; I measured it; four large toes each of four inches in length, to each a short claw; the ball of the foot sunk three inches lower than the toes. the hinder part of the foot did not mark well, the length fourteen inches, by eight inches in breadth, walking from north to south, and having passed about six hours. We were in no humour to follow him; the Men and Indians would have it to be a young mammouth and I held it to be the track of a large old grizzly bear; yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear, otherwise that of a very large old Bear, his claws worn away, the Indians would not allow.

Yes. Later. When out of the field. Where there are writing instruments and parchment. In a dry building.

Things you wouldn't know how to do without.............

Now...give me your reasons for preferring the account made FORTY YEARS after the sighting to the utterly offhand account offered at the time. Oh, yeah, that's right: in your version of the "game" everything that tends towards your favored result is "good evidence" but everything that doesn't is "bad."

How about your "favored result"?

What part of the report don't you like?

I, frankly, love the whole thing. Every word..............

Also, I note that you're keen on it being the "Indians" who insist on it being a supernatural being.

"Supernatural being"?

Where did you read that?

You really have a serious reading problem, don't you?

Ah yes, the "Indians" know all about sasquatch...they know sasquatch track when they see it!

They damned sure know more than you.

But this word "mammouth" is a bit of a problem for you, isn't it?

Not at all.

He says "young mammouth." He can't be using the word to mean simply "something very big" or the word "young" would just be silly ("it was the track of a small very large thing"). So he can only mean it in the sense of "elephant-like animal." But, hang on, now your Indians with their deep knowledge of animal spoor and their intimate knowledge of ol' Bigfoot are, in your view, mistaking his tracks for those of a small elephant. Quadruped, not biped.

Huh? Now you want it to be an elephant?

Anything, anything but a sasquatch?

My, my, you're getting desperate now, aren't you?

So the Indians are utterly unquestionable when it comes to it not being bear (which Thompson continues to believe). But they're obviously a bunch of idiots when it comes to it being a large quadruped. Oh, that's right, though--I forgot that the rules of your game mean tht only evidence that tends to prove your position counts.

No, no. To hell with the Indians who were there, and lived their whole lives there. They obviously don't know what they're talking about, because you say so.

Of course..............it was an elephant. Just like you say.............

Quote:
I don't hypothosize such, nor do I reject it. Thompson, as the first white man traversing that path, clearly saw lots of brown bear tracks. That he commented on these more than once, described them as "monster", and stated that his native guides disagreed that it was bear spoor, indicates that he was very impressed with the sign, and that there is question in his mind whether or not it was truly bear sign.

See above. And not that he never describes the tracks themselves as "monster." He says that the "men and Indians" held the tracks were those of a "young mammouth."




Quote:
Do you posit that the testimony of the first white man to enter that country is not evidence?

Of course it is evidence. It is evidence that he saw tracks that looked, to him, like tracks of a big bear. Forty years later he seems to recall that his companions would have it be the tracks of a "young mammouth." Where in all of this you see evidence of "Bigfoot" I leave for you to fail to point out.

His words:

yet the shortness of the nails, the ball of the foot, and its great size was not that of a Bear, otherwise that of a very large old Bear, his claws worn away, the Indians would not allow

More of his words:

In another part of the "Narrative", Thompson brings it up this experience again:

"I now recur to what I have already noticed in the early part of last winter, when proceeding up the Athabasca River to cross the mountains, in company with....Men and four hunters, on one of the channels of the River we came to the track of a large animal, which measured fourteen inches in length by eight inches in breadth by a tape line. As snow was about six inches in depth the track was well defined, and we could see it for a full hundred yards from us, this animal was proceeding from north to south. We did not attempt to follow it, we had not time for it, and the Hunters, eager as they are to follow and shoot every animal, made no attempt to follow this beast, for what could the balls of our fowling guns do against such an animal? Report from old times had made the head branches of this River, and the Mountains in the vicinity the abode of one, or more, very large animals, to which I never appeared to give credence; for these reports appeared to arise from that fondness for the marvellous so common to mankind: but the sight of the track of that large a beast staggered me, and I often thought of it, yet never could bring myself to believe such an animal existed, but thought it might be the track of some Monster Bear."

That skeptic thought about that for a long time, didn't he?

Unfortunately, skeptics like yourself don't bother thinking about such things, do you?

Quote:
It is as described, is it not? It was a very large track that Thompson thought might be a "monster bear", but his native guides told him was not, and that it belonged to a "mammoth."

I'm not surprised you leave out both the "forty years later" and the "young mammoth" parts.

And I'm not surprised you're trying to use them as debate points.

Elephants, indeed!

Quote:
Or do feel an obligation to degrade that, in order to keep "the fantasy" from becoming possible?

This "evidence" comes "pre-degraded"--no effort on my part needed.

Then why are you wasting your valuable time debating with me?

Besides...........I think I hear 'yo momma calling for 'ya...............

Quote:
I don't know, nor do I know what made that track, however Thompson's native guides told him it was not.

Forty years after the event he remembers "the men and Indians" plumping for "young mammoth." He also remembers the Indians saying "not bear." As we have a contemporary account that gives no indication of this supposed controversy, and as we have no record at all from the Indians as to what they thought, and as there would have been good reason for someone to want to spice up a "narrative" if they had plans to publish it with tall tales of mammoths (not bigfeet) still roaming the wilderness, then....obviously Bigfoot is REAL!!!!!

And since I have every reason to take more stock in the greatest Canadian outdoorsman and adventurer than you, yes.........His words hold more water than yours.

In fact, yours don't hold any whatsoever......

Quote:
Are you now dealing in "believable", or are you willing to stick to the evidence?

If the evidence isn't believable, it's not much use, is it?

Depends on the evidence, and on who is doing the believing, and who is not.

Quote:
You tried to dilute sasquatchery with a single reference and photo of fairies. I asked for more, and you digressed further with the "do I need more" game. I showed that there are certainly more hoaxed sasquatch photos, as well as one moving picture which is accepted by many as valid and which hasn't been shown to be a hoax.

Yes, I'm still not sure why you think that more hoaxes makes Bigfoot more believable.

I don't. I'm still playing "the fairy game" with you.

Ready to move on?

Quote:
Your fairy strawman has reached this end. Shall we continue to play with it, or can we burn it now?

When did it reach an end?

Oh, it hasn't? You still want to insist fairies exist?

How is it a "strawman"?

What do fairies have to do with sasquatchery, and why did you bring it up?
 
Huntsman, that's the most hilarious post I've ever seen. I see that you've just been stringing everyone along all this time. You obviously don't actually believe any of this stuff!

Oh and the "you wouldn't last a day in the woods, young whippersnapper" stuff is just hi-larious. Gen-u-ine frontier gibberish. It really adds color.

I'm not going to bother going through all your points in detail. You spend a very long time proving that Lewis and Clark encountered bears. Color me amazed. Bears! Bears, indeed. Hoo, boy. Well now I just KNOW that Bigfoot existed.

Your stunning reply to the fact that Thompson tells us that he thought he'd found the tracks of a big bear and that the "men and Indians" claimed it was the tracks of a "young mammoth" is that of course he didn't mean mammoth. How absurd, you say. A mammoth? Ho ho ho ho ho.

Huntster, get a dictionary. Look up the word "mammoth." It can be used to mean "monster," sure. But mostly it means "elephant-like creature." Now, Thompson calls it "a young mammoth." If he meant "monster" what is that word "young" doing in there? "Young" is an estimate (when looking at tracks) of size. You know "these prints are small for a deer--perhaps it is a young deer." If he means just "monstrous animal" how would he have a clue that it was a "young monstrous animal" from the tracks alone?

Ah, you say, the Indians knew. They told him it was a Sasquatch, and a young one at that. But then why does he leave that incredibly exciting part of the story out? And are you telling me that Bigfoot is so ENORMOUS that a young one is the size of a "monster grizzly"????

No, he says "young mammoth" because he knows what his readers think a mammoth looks like and wants them to picture some kind of creature roughly like a young mammoth.

I do love the fact, by the way, that you think it positively laughable that he could imagine that there were mammoths in the woods, but you seriously believe that this passage is "evidence" that there were Bigfoot there. Why would he be in any more of a position to discount the existence of mammoths than Bigfoot, Huntster? Oh, I forgot, you don't answer questions that destroy your little fantasy.

Oh, and finally: you keep asking "where did I get man-eating sasquatches from." Obviously you find it difficult to keep track of an argument. You gave me a link to the Walker journal. In that journal Walker gave his testimony of the Indian's belief in giant hairy beings who regularly invade the village and steal children to eat. So: care to tell me now why I'm supposed to accept that this is proof positive of the existence of these beasts, but that the behaviour attributed to them is just fanciful campfire BS-ing.

Why isn't their existence the BS-ing?

Please feel free to spit into a spittoon, split a tree with your mighty thrown hatchet, wrassle a bear, and fashion a coonskin hat with your bare teeth before responding. I promise to be very impressed and to spill my latte in lily-livered, city-boy panic.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Huntster
Yes, I think they did.

Yes, I think neanderthals may have been the template for myths of trolls, almas, and possibly other Eurasian myths, and certainly may have been the template for the catchall myths of brutish, crude, bipedal, sub-human "boogiemen".

What are your reasons to think they were, since we nowdays know they were not that different from us?

1) There is no way to ascertain from the fossil record whether or not they were more hirsute than we are,

2) Cold weather terrestrial mammals are more furry, bulky, and heavier than mammals in warmer climes

3) The fossil record can determine bulk, and indeed, Neanderthals are known as being more robust and bulky, and

4) They were recognized as a cold weather inhabitant

Unless one sticks to the very outdated reconstructions of neanderthals (the "cavemen", "missing links" from the 50s and 60s), there's no way to find similarities between them and trolls, woodwoose, etc.

Source:

Origin of the myth
In the genre of paleofiction, the distinguished Swedish-speaking Finnish paleontologist Björn Kurtén has entertained the theory (e.g. in Dance of the Tiger) that trolls are a distant memory of an encounter with Neanderthals by our Cro-Magnon ancestors some 40,000 years ago during their migration into northern Europe. Spanish paleoanthropologist Juan Luis Arsuaga provides evidence for these types of encounters in his book, The Neanderthal's Necklace. The theory that Neanderthals and Cro-Magnons occupied the same area of Europe at the same time in history has been theorized based on fossil evidence.....

Originally Posted by Huntster
Correct which statement?

This one:

Originally Posted by Huntster
and which you claim they even hunted to extinction

I'm sorry. I admit you may not have claimed that.

However, that is part of the theory of Clovis, which you appear to support, is it not?

Originally Posted by Huntster
I will address Clovis and the overhunting theories later, if the myth generation/template derail continues.............

It was brought in to light to demonstrate these people interacted with animals from the megafauna that would be much more impresive than bigfeet. You then asked for links proving what you erroneously said was my claim regardint the overhunting. I provided them, despite the fact I have not made such claim. Aniway, if the purposes were fulfilled, then we can move on.

Moving on would be a good idea.

And if you think this thread has been derailed by the myth discussion, then, in case you are interested in continuing the discussion, then feel free to start a new one.

Frankly, I do believe the myth discussion has been beat to death. We even have others referring to fairies.

Originally Posted by Huntster
Why do Haida have totems with sasquatches and do not have any totems, reference, traditional background, or any mention whatsoever with dragons? Dragons are a cultural icon in Europe, all through Asia, and even Central America. Why didn't the dragon myth include the North American Pacific Northwest, but the sasquatch myth did (and so very prominently)?

You could make a supposition that it would be because there are no crocodiles, alligators or similar reptiles there or that they never found the fossil remains of a dinosaur. And still it would provide no backing to the idea that a real animal is behind the myth we are discuting (bigfoot).

Funny:

Dragon myths = crocodiles, alligators, similar reptiles
Sasquatch myths = anything but a bipedal ape (let's throw fairies in there, too......)

Are therevreal animals behind every mythical beasts from Native American lore?

Yes, as far as I know. I linked you to this. There is no mythical beast or prehistoric beast mentioned, referred to, or even remotely described unless you call sasquatch a mythical beast.

(BTW, it's an excellent read. Don't believe me; check out the reviews on the link provided. It's unbiased science at it's best.........)

Or its just people trying to interpretate a myth outside its original context?

From a review of the cited book:

"Far from being a romantic attempt to pass on the spiritual lore of Native Americans for a quick fix by others, this is a very serious ethnographic study of some Alaskan Indians in the Northern Forest area. . . . He has painstakingly regarded their views of earth, sky, water, mammals and every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth. He does admire their love of nature and spirit. Those who see the world through his eyes using their
eyes will likely come away with new respect for the boreal forest and those
who live with it and in it, not against it."--The Christian Century

Originally Posted by Huntster
That is incorrect. Based on the available evidence, there is no way to determine the mode of Gigantopithecus' locomotion.

If you disagree, please provide some evidence. As a scientist, that shouldn't be difficult for you.

Check the links I more than once provided.

Should I behave now like Yoink after I presented him with links?

Originally Posted by Huntster
Bravo for that observation!

I'd like to point out that our interpretations are not flawless, either.

At no point I said or left implicit that my conclusions, interpretation, etc. are flawess. Neither have most people here who oppose your views. We will gladly change our minds as soon as reliable evidence shows up. Is it such a terrible behavior?

Not terrible.

Just flawed.

Originally Posted by Huntster
So, Krantz opined that Gigantopithecus was bipedal. You appear to opine that Gigantopithecus was a quadraped.

I opine that the mode of locomotion cannot be determined by the available evidence.

There is no other option, unless someone wishes to opine that Gigantopithecus traveled on either one leg or three.

Who is correct?


"Who is most likely to be correct?" should be the question, untill better evidence shows up.

Funny.

When I cite "likely, until better evidence or proof is obtained" regarding sasquatchery, that position is not accepted.

Why should your "likely" be any better than my "likely"?

Shouldn't we let the evidence dictate the facts?

And please note that its not mine the "opinion" that they were knuckle-walkers. I merely think the interpretations of the guys who discovered and studied it are more plausible than Krantz's, for the reasons I have already discussed somewhere else with LAL, if my memory does not fails me.

Oh, I agree. I simply cannot agree that the mode of locomotion can be determined either way with fossilized teeth or partial mandibles alone.

If they are right, then the animal in question can be ruled out as being bigfoot's template of bigfoot itself.

And if they are wrong, Gigantopithecus is a spitting image of a sasquatch.
 
Huntsman, that's the most hilarious post I've ever seen. I see that you've just been stringing everyone along all this time. You obviously don't actually believe any of this stuff!

Huntsman?

You're obviously "yoinking" the wrong chain there, Yoink.

You really do have a reading disorder, don't you?

Oh and the "you wouldn't last a day in the woods, young whippersnapper" stuff is just hi-larious. Gen-u-ine frontier gibberish. It really adds color.

Yeah, it is good, isn't it?
I'm going hunting tomorrow evening. Wanna go, pilgrim?............

I'm not going to bother going through all your points in detail. You spend a very long time proving that Lewis and Clark encountered bears. Color me amazed. Bears! Bears, indeed. Hoo, boy. Well now I just KNOW that Bigfoot existed.

There's your reading problem again.

Yes. Lewis and Clark encountered bears. Bears they didn't know existed. Bears that are native to Europe. Lewis and Clark. Educated men. Thought they were smart. Like you.

The Indians told them about the bears. They didn't believe 'em.

They sure got to believing.................the hard way.

Folks like yourself like the hard way, don't you?

Huntster, get a dictionary. Look up the word "mammoth." It can be used to mean "monster," sure. But mostly it means "elephant-like creature." Now, Thompson calls it "a young mammoth."

There you go with your reading problem again.

Thompson thought it was a "monster bear." The men and the Indians called it a mammoth.

You say that means elephant.

Okay. The men and the Indians thought it was an elephant. Anything , anything but a sasquatch.............

If he meant "monster" what is that word "young" doing in there? "Young" is an estimate (when looking at tracks) of size. You know "these prints are small for a deer--perhaps it is a young deer." If he means just "monstrous animal" how would he have a clue that it was a "young monstrous animal" from the tracks alone?

I'm starting to be impressed with you. Yes, "young" indicates small. The 14" track is fairly small for a sasquatch.

If I'm not mistaken, 14 inch tracks, 8" wide are really, really small (and quite odd shaped) for an elephant, too.

Tell us all about mammoth and elephant tracks, bwana. Tell us if elephants and mammoths have footprints in 6" of snow that go 14" long by 8" wide.

Ah, you say, the Indians knew. They told him it was a Sasquatch, and a young one at that. But then why does he leave that incredibly exciting part of the story out?

Wow. It's not just your reading that's challenged, I see.

If he left it out, we wouldn't have read about it, would we?

In fact, the amazing thing is that it is there at all. If it was an ordinary bear track, he never would have mentioned it.

But he did, didn't he?

And are you telling me that Bigfoot is so ENORMOUS that a young one is the size of a "monster grizzly"????

That's what they say. I don't know, because I've never seen one, but tracks have been reported up to 22" in length. The Bossburg prints were 17" long. The prints I saw in the California Sierras were approximately 15" long.

I've hunted Kodiak Island. I've seen brown bears that weighed in excess of 1,000 lbs. I've never seen a brown bear rear footprint that went over 12" in length.

Have you?

No, he says "young mammoth" because he knows what his readers think a mammoth looks like and wants them to picture some kind of creature roughly like a young mammoth.

Yeah. Like an elephant.

Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiight.....................

I do love the fact, by the way, that you think it positively laughable that he could imagine that there were mammoths in the woods, but you seriously believe that this passage is "evidence" that there were Bigfoot there.

Yes. Yes, I do.

Why would he be in any more of a position to discount the existence of mammoths than Bigfoot, Huntster?

I don't know much about hairy elephants running around in the woods. Maybe you can fill me in.

Oh, and finally: you keep asking "where did I get man-eating sasquatches from." Obviously you find it difficult to keep track of an argument. You gave me a link to the Walker journal. In that journal Walker gave his testimony of the Indian's belief in giant hairy beings who regularly invade the village and steal children to eat. So: care to tell me now why I'm supposed to accept that this is proof positive of the existence of these beasts, but that the behaviour attributed to them is just fanciful campfire BS-ing.

Sorry about that. I realized that's where you got it later, and that's why I posted the info on Lewis and Clark and the Indians.

Yes, PNW natives include child stealing and even kidnap of adults in their stories of sasquatch. There are a couple of reports of such kidnaps even in the 20th Century, one by an Indian and one by a white.

There is no evidence that they eat their human captives though from these two most recent claims, but I suppose it's possible.

Please feel free to spit into a spittoon, split a tree with your mighty thrown hatchet, wrassle a bear, and fashion a coonskin hat with your bare teeth before responding.

I don't chew tobacco, I prefer chainsaws, I shoot my bears, and I prefer to wear wool hats, thanks.

But I'll consider posting a photo of my hunt next week, if you'd like. If I get a chance to shoot a sasquatch, I'll take it. But I doubt there are any in that neck of the woods.

Too damned many grizzlies...................

I promise to be very impressed and to spill my latte in lily-livered, city-boy panic.

Maintain control there, city-slicker. I don't want you to spill that latte.

I hear they're really expensive................
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom