Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Originally Posted by Huntster
we know that bipedal apes existed at one time.
We do?

Well, some folks do.

Do you mean Gigantopithecus? I thought it was only speculated that Giganto was bipedal? Has new evidence come to light to confirm the bipedalism, or are you talking about something entirely different?

Correct. Gigantopithecus locomotion hasn't been determined, nor can it with the fossils that have been recovered.

However:

.......Christopher Wills had a short discussion of this evidence. It concerns a
10 million year old ape, Oreopithecus bambolii. He writes:

"Upright posture may not be unique to our own lineage. An ape that lived
ten million years ago on Sardinia, Oreopithecus bambolii, seems to have
acquired similar capabilities, perhaps independently." " Christopher Wills,
The Children of Prometheus, (Reading, Mass: Perseus Books, 1998), p. 156

He referenced an article from the Proc. Natl. Acad. of Sciences, Meike
Kšhler and Salvador Moyˆ-Solˆ "Ape-like or hominid-like? The positional
behavior of Oreopithecus bambolii reconsidered" Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
Vol. 94, pp. 11747-11750, October 1997

The abstract from the PNAS web site reads,
"Comparative morphological and functional analyses of the skeletal remains
of Oreopithecus bambolii, a hominoid from the Miocene Mediterranean island
of Tuscany-Sardinia (Italy), provides evidence that bipedal activities made
up a significant part of the positional behavior of this primate. The
mosaic pattern of its postcranial morphology is to some degree convergent
with that of Australopithecus and functionally intermediate between apes
and early hominids. Some unique traits could have been selected only under
insular conditions where the absence of predators and the limitation of
trophic resources play a crucial role in mammalian evolution. "

This raises an interesting point. Bipedality has been the sine qua non in
the definition of a hominid! This ape stood 3' 7" tall and weighed 66
pounds. Until 1992, Oreopithecus was the only late Miocene ape that had
left remains of its postcranial skeleton.(see Moya-Sola and Kohler, Nature
379(1996):156-157.) But in 1992, the postcranial remains of Dryopithecus
laietanus were found in Spain and they also showed evidence of an
'orthograde' locomotion. Moya-Sola and Kohler note:

"Several features of the trunk of Dryopithecus suggest adaptation for
orthograde postures. The lumbar vertebrae are proportionally shorter than
those of cercopithecoids and proconsulids. The transverse processes
originate on the pedicle dorsolaterally on the vertebral body, and the
caudally directed spinal process indicate reduced mobility of the lumbar
region. The more dorsally situated costal foveae of the thoracic vertebra
imply a more ventral postion of the spinal column and hence a broad thorax.
The claviccle is proportionally longer than in African apes and comparable
in relative size to the lengths of clavicles of Pongo and Hylobates. This
suggests that the scapula of Dryopithecus was situated dorsally on the
thorax as in extant hominoids, and that the clavicle would have been
oriented more vertically than in African apes, and similar to Pongo and
Hylobates, a character linked to suspensory postures." ~ Salvador Moya-Sola
and Meike Kohler, "A Dryopithecus Skeleton and the origins of Great-Ape
Locomotion," Nature, Jan. 11, 1996, p. 157-158..........

More


Yet more:

....Today’s apes are few in number and in kind. But between 22 million and 5.5 million years ago, a time known as the Miocene epoch, apes ruled the primate world. Up to 100 ape species ranged throughout the Old World, from France to China in Eurasia and from Kenya to Namibia in Africa. Out of this dazzling diversity, the comparatively limited number of apes and humans arose. Yet fossils of great apes - the large-bodied group represented today by chimpanzees, gorillas and orangutans (gibbons and siamangs make up the so-called lesser apes) - have turned up only in western and central Europe, Greece, Turkey, South Asia and China. It is thus becoming clear that, by Darwin’s logic, Eurasia is more likely than Africa to have been the birthplace of the family that encompasses great apes and humans, the hominids. (The term "hominid" has traditionally been reserved for humans and protohumans, but scientists are increasingly placing our great ape kin in the definition as well and using another word, "hominin", to refer to the human subset......

There's lots more:

WE STILL HAVE MUCH to learn. Many
fossil apes are represented only by jaws
and teeth, leaving us with little or no idea
about their posture and locomotion,
brain size or body mass. Moreover, paleontologists
have yet to recover any remains
of ancient African great apes. Indeed,
there is a substantial geographic
and temporal gap in the fossil record between
representatives of the early members
of the African hominid lineage in Europe
(Dryopithecus and Ouranopithecus)
and the earliest African fossil hominids.
Moving up the family tree (or, more
accurately, family bush), we find more
confusion in that the earliest putative
members of the human family are not obviously
human. For instance, the recently
discovered Sahelanthropus tchadensis,
a six-million- to seven-million-year-old
find from Chad, is humanlike in having
small canine teeth and perhaps a more
centrally located foramen magnum (the
hole at the base of the skull through
which the spinal cord exits), which could
indicate that the animal was bipedal. Yet
Sahelanthropus also exhibits a number of
chimplike characteristics, including a
small brain, projecting face, sloped forehead
and large neck muscles. Another
creature, Orrorin tugenensis, fossils of
which come from a Kenyan site dating to
six million years ago, exhibits a comparable
mosaic of chimp and human traits,as does 5.8-million-year-old Ardipithecus
ramidus kadabba from Ethiopia. Each of
these taxa has been described by its discoverers
as a human ancestor [see “An
Ancestor to Call Our Own,” by Kate
Wong; Scientific American, January].
But in truth, we do not yet know enough
about any of these creatures to say
whether they are protohumans, African
ape ancestors or dead-end apes....
 
Oh, I understand your side of the point quite well. And I agree it might well be the case.

You refuse to entertain or accept my side of the understanding.

Nope. I just disagree with your conclusions and beliefs. Its not a refusal.

"Myths" conform to the template, but something created that template.

Sure. But the templates might have been (were IMHO) created by humans.

I agree that needs, behaviors, fears, etc will be roughly similar. But I also believe, especially with regard to sasquatchery, that a real creature can be at the root of this "myth."

Yes, there may be one or more species of real creature(s) behind this particular myth, specially depending on the specific sasquatch/bigfoot myth you choose (I am using "sasquatch" to group Native American myths and "bigfoot" for the modern myths). But they may not necessarily be what we would actually call a bigfoot, specially on the last case. Also, there may not be any real creature behind it. What I think is the case.

I especially believe that because we know that bipedal apes existed at one time. That is not in question. It has been established.

The question is whether or not they still exist today.

If you are talking about Gigantopithecus, you should say that were "giant" apes in the past. The avaliable evidence indicates they were most likely not bipedals.

Unless you add the controversial Meganthropus, there are no fossil species that would fit the criteria for a correlation with bigfeet: size and bipedalism. Even in this case, the fur could be an extra issue, if they were related to the Homo genus.

Okay. Let's.

Is it so hard?
 
A quick nitpicking in Huntster links:

No clear undisputable link between bipedalism and dentition, as some propose to back the claim of a bipedal gigantopithecus.

And the opinion about bigfeet at the last link is far from being supportive...
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
Oh, I understand your side of the point quite well. And I agree it might well be the case.

You refuse to entertain or accept my side of the understanding.

Nope. I just disagree with your conclusions and beliefs. Its not a refusal.

Fair enough.

Nothing established for sure either way.

Originally Posted by Huntster
"Myths" conform to the template, but something created that template.

Sure. But the templates might have been (were IMHO) created by humans.

Correct.

And they might have been established as a result of creatures that are not out of the realm of possibility, we're sure existed at one time in some form, and we're just not sure if are still around.

Originally Posted by Huntster
I agree that needs, behaviors, fears, etc will be roughly similar. But I also believe, especially with regard to sasquatchery, that a real creature can be at the root of this "myth."

Yes, there may be one or more species of real creature(s) behind this particular myth, specially depending on the specific sasquatch/bigfoot myth you choose (I am using "sasquatch" to group Native American myths and "bigfoot" for the modern myths). But they may not necessarily be what we would actually call a bigfoot, specially on the last case.

True.

Also, there may not be any real creature behind it. What I think is the case.

True. And I think you're incorrect.

Originally Posted by Huntster
I especially believe that because we know that bipedal apes existed at one time. That is not in question. It has been established.

The question is whether or not they still exist today.

If you are talking about Gigantopithecus, you should say that were "giant" apes in the past. The avaliable evidence indicates they were most likely not bipedals.

I am not referring to Gigantopithecus, which were, indeed, "giant" apes.

The available evidence cannot determine whether or not they were bipeds or quadrapeds.

Unless you add the controversial Meganthropus, there are no fossil species that would fit the criteria for a correlation with bigfeet: size and bipedalism. Even in this case, the fur could be an extra issue, if they were related to the Homo genus.

See here.


Originally Posted by Huntster
Okay. Let's.

Is it so hard?

Not at all, so far.
 
A quick nitpicking in Huntster links:

No clear undisputable link between bipedalism and dentition, as some propose to back the claim of a bipedal gigantopithecus.

Correct. I don't claim that Gigantopithecus was bipedal, but that it could have been bipedal. We simply don't know.

And the opinion about bigfeet at the last link is far from being supportive...

But the fact that bipedal apes existed in the past is there.
 
[qimg]http://www.bfro.net/NEWS/BODYCAST/images/clean_cast_guide7.jpg[/qimg]

Note how we color in shapes; ignoring the actual features of the cast..

Based on the size of the heel, the critter was deemed to be over 8 feet tall..

Sadly, it seems to have a forearm reminiscent of Danny DeVito ..

I must acknowledge, that in my haste score a skeptical coup, I was fooled by perspective illusions in this picture..

I found it necessary to apologize in this post at BFF

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?s=&showtopic=15671&view=findpost&p=338365

Here is the substance of the post:



It would seem DDA has the last LOL after all .. At least based on the approximation I have come up with.

The ' forced perspective ' consideration, indeed had me jumping to an ill founded conclusion..

I apologize to DDA for insulting his obvious photographic expertise .. ( and thanks to him, I now have a very small amount )


I came up with this shot from LMS , and found some identifiable points to measure about 7.5 inches ..

skmeas.gif



Transfering those points to this image, and using the blue lines as a measuring stick.

skmeas2.gif


It looks like the indicated elbow to wrist measurement is somewhere near 15 inches.

I'm about 5-11, and my elbow to wrist is about 11 inches. Making the alleged forearm,
indeed ~ 40% longer than that of a 6 foot human..

It was quite presumptious of me to assume Dr. Meldrum had been careless in the measurements
that lead to his conclusions, or that he presented them in a careless manner..
With that in mind, I apologize..


Doing this work before I tried to score a skeptical coup would have served me well ..

Indeed it has served me well in any event...
 
Just to comment on Huntster and Correa's discussion of myth templates I don't know if it seems too much of a stretch to take into account that within the last few hundred thousand years as a species we would have maybe quite often come into contact with other similar species that would have fit quite nicely into the big, hairy monster men mould and to which we would have had a natural fear. I also don't think it's necessary for those creatures to still be around for the template to keep churning out myths. Correa's outlined on many occasions the errors of trying to read to much into myths. Whether sasquatches exist or not I find it a little bit difficult to accept the idea that they've always been rare and elusive yet would be the sole progenitor of our hairy man myth template. If I think about it a little more a pure psychological construct doesn't seem absurd at all, either.
 
One of the reasons I like to think of Bigfoot is that if he does exist his most effective survival skill is remaining hidden.
 
One of the reasons I like to think of Bigfoot is that if he does exist his most effective survival skill is remaining hidden.
Indeed.

But it begs the question of how it remained undetected while this skill was being developed...

It reminds of the owner of a Bigfoot photo, who claimed the Bigfoot was holding a stick in front of the camera to block the flash .

I posited that there should be some pictures of the Bigfoot developing this technique ...

The reply is still forthcoming..
 
Re: the myth fitting a "template", and where did the myth come from?

We know that bears will make overlapping footprints- that's the probably origination of the 'midtarsel break'. And we know the Indians told their children about the mythical sasquatch to keep them from wandering off at night. Does it take some great leap of imagination to visualise an Indian parent pointing to one of the overlapping footprints, and originating the myth of a big footed critter?
 
Originally Posted by Brainache
One of the reasons I like to think of Bigfoot is that if he does exist his most effective survival skill is remaining hidden.
Indeed.

But it begs the question of how it remained undetected while this skill was being developed.........

That's just it.........they have not remained undetected.

They have remained uncatalogued by science.
 
Re: the myth fitting a "template", and where did the myth come from?

We know that bears will make overlapping footprints- that's the probably origination of the 'midtarsel break'....

I've seen so many bear footprints and trackways I couldn't possibly remember them all. I have yet to see an overlap, or anything that I would mistake for a sasquatch footprint.

And we know the Indians told their children about the mythical sasquatch to keep them from wandering off at night. Does it take some great leap of imagination to visualise an Indian parent pointing to one of the overlapping footprints, and originating the myth of a big footed critter?

Why would you need boogermen to scare your kids with if you have bears running around?
 
I've seen so many bear footprints and trackways I couldn't possibly remember them all. I have yet to see an overlap, or anything that I would mistake for a sasquatch footprint.



Why would you need boogermen to scare your kids with if you have bears running around?

Well, there's no evidence that Native Americans invented Sasquatch (a made-up, non-Indian word, by the way) as a boogeyman for children, but your question prompts another which seems rather telling:

Why did the Europeans invent trolls when there were wolves and bears still in Europe? Why did Europeans invent myths about trolls, fairies, giants, golems, leprechauns, willis, naiads, dryads, satyrs, Wild Men, amazons, elves, banshees, mandrakes etc. etc. etc. etc.? We know that none of these (and the thousands upon thousands of other similar ones) didn't exist: why shouldn't the Native Americans invent similarly mythical hominid creatures?
 
And they might have been established as a result of creatures that are not out of the realm of possibility, we're sure existed at one time in some form, and we're just not sure if are still around.

Maybe. But we can not be sure if people would still remember such beasts (assuming they existed) say, 10K years later. One of the things that annoy me in this reasoning is that megafauna was composed by a number of magnific large beasts. Why no myths on saber-toothed tigers or mammoths, for example? These beasts probably would have had much more impact on the lives of those persons than the elusive sasquatches...

I am not referring to Gigantopithecus, which were, indeed, "giant" apes.

The available evidence cannot determine whether or not they were bipeds or quadrapeds.

Well, the guys who study it do not agree.
 
They have also remained undetected by science, which explains the lack of a catalog.

No major feat there. Pluto remained undetected by science for a long time.

In fact, even though it's been detected for nearly a century, it still seems to defy scientific cataloging................
 
.....Why did the Europeans invent trolls when there were wolves and bears still in Europe?

Who says that trolls were "invented"?:

Origin of the myth
In the genre of paleofiction, the distinguished Swedish-speaking Finnish paleontologist Björn Kurtén has entertained the theory (e.g. in Dance of the Tiger) that trolls are a distant memory of an encounter with Neanderthals by our Cro-Magnon ancestors some 40,000 years ago during their migration into northern Europe. Spanish paleoanthropologist Juan Luis Arsuaga provides evidence for these types of encounters in his book, The Neanderthal's Necklace. The theory that Neanderthals and Cro-Magnons occupied the same area of Europe at the same time in history has been theorized based on fossil evidence. Other researchers believe that they just refer to neighboring tribes. The problem with this theory is that neither Neanderthals or Cro-Magnons existed in this part of Europe during the ice-age. Most of Scandinavia was covered by a large glacier and the area was not occupied until much later.

A more plausible explanation for the troll myth, is that the trolls represent the remains of the forefather-cult which was ubiquitous in Scandinavia until the introduction of Christianity in the 10th and 11th centuries. In this cult the forefathers were worshipped in sacred groves, by altars or by gravemounds. One of the customs associated with this practice was to sit on top of a gravemound at night, possibly in order to make contact with the deceased. With the introduction of Christianity however, the religious elite sought to demonize the pagan cult, and denounced the forefathers as evil. For instance, according to Magnus Håkonsen's laws from 1276 it is illegal to attempt to wake the "mound-dwellers". It is in these laws that the word troll appears for the first time, denoting something heathen and generally unfavourable.

This fits with the trolls in Norse sagas who are often the restless dead, to be wrestled with or otherwise laid to rest.

Why did Europeans invent myths about trolls, fairies, giants, golems, leprechauns, willis, naiads, dryads, satyrs, Wild Men, amazons, elves, banshees, mandrakes etc. etc. etc. etc.? We know that none of these (and the thousands upon thousands of other similar ones) didn't exist: why shouldn't the Native Americans invent similarly mythical hominid creatures?

Actually, we don't know that. We don't have physical evidence that these creatures existed, or that they existed as the myth evolved through time after the original creature went extinct.

"Dragons" may be large lizards (like monitors) that handed down stories later made fly and breath fire. We just don't know.

I can attest that I never needed sasquatches, trolls, banshees, or any other "myths" to scare my children. The bears and my own punishments were scary enough.
 
Originally Posted by Huntster
And they might have been established as a result of creatures that are not out of the realm of possibility, we're sure existed at one time in some form, and we're just not sure if are still around.

Maybe. But we can not be sure if people would still remember such beasts (assuming they existed) say, 10K years later.

Of course they wouldn't. However, the original cave-fire talk of hairier races of hominids might evolve over 10,000 years of oral folklore into a creature that was quite different than the original Neanderthal, especially if the original Neanderthal is no longer around to compare it to..........

One of the things that annoy me in this reasoning is that megafauna was composed by a number of magnific large beasts. Why no myths on saber-toothed tigers or mammoths, for example?

Because we still have tigers and elephants.

Don't forget the "myths" of "half-man, half-beast" creatures coming out of Africa for 2,000 years that were finally put to rest in the 1850's.

These beasts probably would have had much more impact on the lives of those persons than the elusive sasquatches...

Elephants and tigers still do.

Originally Posted by Huntster
I am not referring to Gigantopithecus, which were, indeed, "giant" apes.

The available evidence cannot determine whether or not they were bipeds or quadrapeds.

Well, the guys who study it do not agree..

So it has been determined, by examining teeth and partial mandibles, that Gigantopithecus was quadraped? No examination of skull, hip, or spine is necessary?

Just how was that done?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom