Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

I don't follow the Bigfoot theory at all, but I was interested to ask: to Bigfoot Believers have a theory to account for the complete absence of Bigfoot remains from the paleontological or historical record?

Only about 1% of all species that have lived have left traces in the fossil record. Wet, acid soils even disolve teeth. Sasquatches may be a late Pliestocene arrival, not something that was here for millions of years. Their possible ancestors were widespread and long-lived as a species, yet left only three jawbones (deposited in caves by water or porcupines) and 1100 teeth.

Gorillas and okapis have no fossil record (yet) either. And, despite decades of digs, only three chimpanzee teeth have turned up so far. It took the Leakeys thirty years to find hominid fossils and even fossil hominids are scarce.

Fossilization requires rapid burial (to protect remains from scavengers), the right kind of soil conditions, then exposure and someone to find them.
 
Only about 1% of all species that have lived have left traces in the fossil record. Wet, acid soils even disolve teeth. Sasquatches may be a late Pliestocene arrival, not something that was here for millions of years. Their possible ancestors were widespread and long-lived as a species, yet left only three jawbones (deposited in caves by water or porcupines) and 1100 teeth.

Gorillas and okapis have no fossil record (yet) either. And, despite decades of digs, only three chimpanzee teeth have turned up so far. It took the Leakeys thirty years to find hominid fossils and even fossil hominids are scarce.

Fossilization requires rapid burial (to protect remains from scavengers), the right kind of soil conditions, then exposure and someone to find them.

But I specifically referred, for the reasons you adduce, to more than the (always scanty) fossil record. This is an animal that believers claim continues to live down to the present day. So why didn't any explorer stumble on a Bigfoot skeleton? Why didn't someone purchase a "Bigfoot fur" bag or headdress or ceremonial item from some Indian? Why has no one found Bigfoot feces etc. etc. etc.?
 
clean_cast_guide7.jpg


Note how we color in shapes; ignoring the actual features of the cast..

Based on the size of the heel, the critter was deemed to be over 8 feet tall..

Sadly, it seems to have a forearm reminiscent of Danny DeVito ..
 
Last edited:
What is the actual measurement from 'elbow' to 'hand'? I don't think I've seen that information posted anywhere.

RayG


I haven't seen it either .. I just noticed, looking at this picture, it looks shorter
than Meldrum's elbow-to-hand length ..


http://www.bfro.net/news/bodycast/green_statement.asp

Dr. Meldrum, who is a professor of anatomy, was able to determine the position of the joints for some of the limbs, establishing that the bones were 40 to 50 percent longer than those of a 6-foot human.
 
I don't follow the Bigfoot theory at all, but I was interested to ask: to Bigfoot Believers have a theory to account for the complete absence of Bigfoot remains from the paleontological or historical record?...

I believe it's because they're a recent immigrant, just like man.

....I mean, this is a large primate that has supposedly been indigenous to North American for a very long time--through massive swings in the North American climate. However restricted its range is considered to be now, it surely must have had more prosperous times in the past, when it ranged far more widely across the country. How is it that not a single Bigfoot bone, or frozen Bigfoot feces, or what have you has shown up in the entire continent?...

I believe their densities have always been low, just like they are now.
 
Bigfoot is one of those woo topics I have always had a soft spot for.
I have never been to that part of the world, but if I ever get the chance I would love to see it for myself.
I'd like to ask people who know more about Bigfoot some questions:
1)Just how far fetched is the possibility of Bigfoot?
2)Could a large non human hominid really hide that effectively for so long?
3)Just how much of the country up there is true wilderness?
4)Are the Sasquatch folk tales of the native people the sort of stories people tell to kids to scare them, or are they more matter of fact general knowledge type stuff?
5) I suppose another interesting question might also be; If Bigfoot is real, what is he? Some kind of Forrest Gorrilla or a hairy Neanderthal?

Anyway I still hope he is out there and just being too smart for us dumb Saps to find him.
But if he isn't I won't be too surprised.

Smart doesn't really enter in. Scarce does and dense forests do. I've been learning on some recent excursions just how dense and extensive the forests are even here in the SE. The PNW is unbelievable.

Wilderness doesn't seem to be a requirement. I used to live in Washington State and the area that seemed to have the most sightings was mature second growth. There were quite a few crossings on HWY 14 in the west end of the Columbia Gorge.

They could well be a descendant of Gigantopithecus blacki, and would likely be most closely related to orangutans.

The coastal tribes seem to have them in their traditions, but I'm not so sure eastern tribes describe them. I'm in process of learning more about "boogers".

It took sixty years after their "discovery" for a Panda to be brought in despite expeditions out to bring them in for zoos. There's a real lack of well-funded scientific expeditions out to hunt Sasquatches. One would be a start.

I don't think they're far-fetched at all. They're far-ranging, eat what bears eat and would probably have been collected years ago if they were quadrupedal. There seems to be a reluctance on our part to acknowlege a species of bipedal hominid primate alive and well in our times. I think we liked being alone.
 
Myth:

Which of the 5 above would you say is the most accurate definition of what you meant?

And how do multiple witness sightings a of Sasquatches crossing roads fit in any of those catagories?

"Why did the Sasquatch cross the road?" "To get to the other side."

Most sightings last about twenty seconds and are really mundane.

In some Native belief systems, a sighting is supposed to herald some sort of change, but I've heard much more detailed stories of talking hawks and eagles.
 
By 'the rest', I assume you mean DY's scientific thoughts and opinions?

Why should 'the rest' be safely skipped?

RayG

I included us, Ray. We didn't really add much of substance.

DY's been posting here, so I assume they know what he thinks. If not, he started his own thread on BFF and anyone is free to read it. He wasn't really on the OSC thread much and didn't give us the great debate I was expecting when he finally confronted DDA.

His arguments largely rested on an interpretation of hair flow that was 50% absent in the copies he saw and the copies themselves were painted. He also attributed a scraping to an elk knee/wrist. That really changes the position of his putative elk. I'm still waiting for the drawings.

It's a great thread though, and if anyone wants to read the whole thing they're certainly welcome to do so.

Start here:

http://www.bigfootforums.com/index.php?showtopic=15671

There were quite a few complaints even from BFFers, though. They must have been talking about Wildman. ;)
 
Last edited:
But I specifically referred, for the reasons you adduce, to more than the (always scanty) fossil record. This is an animal that believers claim continues to live down to the present day. So why didn't any explorer stumble on a Bigfoot skeleton? Why didn't someone purchase a "Bigfoot fur" bag or headdress or ceremonial item from some Indian? Why has no one found Bigfoot feces etc. etc. etc.?

Scat has been found and analysed. No one trips over skeletons of anything in places like the PNW. THe scavenger system goes from bears down to bacteria. I once had a vulture check me out. I'm not sure they always wait until the animal is dead.

Many Native peoples had taboos about what animals could be killed. A Cascades Indian couldn't kill beaver, e.g., if he dreamed beaver was his medicine. White hunters have turned down shots at them because they look so human. A few have shot but failed to bring them down. Personally, I would not want to try to kill an 8' animal with a spear or a bow and arrow. Mammoth hunting in a group would have been a lot easier.
 
I'd hope so but who are you speaking for, Correa? Regardless, here's one we haven't beat thoroughly to death. I think 'provenance' is the key word here. As in I have a crystal-clear video of a salivating sasquatch digging for clams before taking a dump then noticing the person taking the footage and going into a chest beating display before shrieking like a little girl and then making a break for the tree line complete with matching prints and it didn't come from Tom Biscardi but rather James Randi's accountant. That would be provenance, no? Meanwhile, I'll be huffy and wait for one solid piece of evidence for these creatures that doesn't fall to crap upon thorough investigation. Forgive me, I'm feeling moody about endless $#!tty sasquatch evidence claims today. :mad:

Who am I speaking for? I am not a representative of anyone or any institution. Its a personal opinion, a conclusion based in the behavior of the people I know that work in the academic field. You are right when it comes to provenance. If the footage has provenance, it will surely raise lots of eyebrows and soon researchers will go to the field. Possibly officially looking for wolves, bears, deer, whatever, but actually searching evidence to validate the footage. I would also expect some more evident searches, backed by NG, for example.

But as long as "Biscardi-Marx" quality evidence are shown as THE evidence, I expect very few people to take it seriously. We've been telling footers for a looong time to drop all the shytty claims and and disputable evidence if they want to be taken seriously. Yes, this includes some pieces that are dear for some (PGF, cripplefoot, Skookum cast, Minesota Iceman). Quality prevails over quantity.
 
I have not read any of Campbell's work, but I have read of him. I am very impressed so far. My understanding of religion appears to mirror his.

I never figured sasquatchery would fit in with Campbellism, but I suppose (if looking at it with native religions in mind), it certainly has a role.

Campbell's work basically shows the similarities among myths. The was not the first to think this, but surely he was probably the person who managed to express the idea more clearly.

Check the roles and characteristics of heroes, for example. Same could be said for villains and monsters (here bigfeet would most likely fit). He showed clearly that myths tend to follow templates. You seem to have not understood that this was the line I was proposing when at some other thread I compared bigfeet with other mythical hairy bipedal characters from other parts of the world. Werewolves, for example. Other people got the idea quite quickly. Myths have similarities, templates. Its not unlikely neither unexpected to find myths about hairy bipedals at many places of the world. By no means they are evidence of real creatures.l

Now, this put, the nature and the cause of the templates for myths are open to discussions. Many people (yeah, you guessed right, I amone of them) consider its not an "external" or "independent" cause, such as Jungian archetypes or a "spiritual world". Its can be merely a cause due to the fact that we are all humans, with very similar bodies and brains. We share psichology, needs, behavior, fears and when subject to roughly similar pressures, the outcomes will be similar.

Huntster, I am finding extremely pleasant to be having -at least untill now- a polite discussion with you. Let's please try to keep this level when we start to disagree.
 
He also attributed a scraping to an elk knee/wrist.

Correction: I should have said "slippage". There were striations typical of the bottom of a hoof. DY interpreted this as the impression of a joint in his resting elk scenario.
 
....But as long as "Biscardi-Marx" quality evidence are shown as THE evidence, I expect very few people to take it seriously. ......

As long as it's Biscardi and Marx out there looking (and not NG or state fish and game agencies), you're gonna get "Biscardi-Marx quality evidence."
 
....He showed clearly that myths tend to follow templates. You seem to have not understood that this was the line I was proposing when at some other thread I compared bigfeet with other mythical hairy bipedal characters from other parts of the world. Werewolves, for example. Other people got the idea quite quickly. Myths have similarities, templates. Its not unlikely neither unexpected to find myths about hairy bipedals at many places of the world. ...

Oh, I understand your side of the point quite well. And I agree it might well be the case.

You refuse to entertain or accept my side of the understanding.

"Myths" conform to the template, but something created that template.

Now, this put, the nature and the cause of the templates for myths are open to discussions.

Many people (yeah, you guessed right, I amone of them) consider its not an "external" or "independent" cause, such as Jungian archetypes or a "spiritual world". Its can be merely a cause due to the fact that we are all humans, with very similar bodies and brains. We share psichology, needs, behavior, fears and when subject to roughly similar pressures, the outcomes will be similar.

I agree that needs, behaviors, fears, etc will be roughly similar. But I also believe, especially with regard to sasquatchery, that a real creature can be at the root of this "myth."

I especially believe that because we know that bipedal apes existed at one time. That is not in question. It has been established.

The question is whether or not they still exist today.

Huntster, I am finding extremely pleasant to be having -at least untill now- a polite discussion with you. Let's please try to keep this level when we start to disagree.

Okay. Let's.
 
Scat has been found and analysed. No one trips over skeletons of anything in places like the PNW. THe scavenger system goes from bears down to bacteria. I once had a vulture check me out. I'm not sure they always wait until the animal is dead.

If scat has been found, wouldn't it be possible to do DNA analysis on it that would be definitive? (I assume DNA of an unknown primate species would be readily identifiable as such.)

Many Native peoples had taboos about what animals could be killed. A Cascades Indian couldn't kill beaver, e.g., if he dreamed beaver was his medicine. White hunters have turned down shots at them because they look so human. A few have shot but failed to bring them down. Personally, I would not want to try to kill an 8' animal with a spear or a bow and arrow. Mammoth hunting in a group would have been a lot easier.

Yes, different Indian tribes often tended to mark tribal identity by their particular food taboos. But the very example you give (beaver) shows the problem with that as an argument for why no Indian "bigfoot" relics have ever shown up. It's not as if finding Indian items made of beaver fur is tough work. Why isn't there a "bigfoot bone ornament" or a "bigfoot fur headdress" or what have you, sitting in a draw in the Smithsonian?

As for white hunters "turning down shots"--well, all I can say is that it seems amazing that this guy is both incredibly scarce, leaves no prints or feces for anyone to collect, and yet keeps sticking his head out from behind a tree and thumbing his nose at people whose cameras just broke, or who just ran out of film, or when it was just getting a little too dark to take a photo etc. etc. etc. He's both the shyest, scarcest, tidiest animal in the world (even cleaning up after himself when he takes a dump) AND he's a merry prankster who likes to hunt out down-on-their-luck Bigfoot believers and give them just a little bit of inconclusive song and dance.

If I were a Bigfoot believer I'd go in guns blazing--this bastard is laughing at you!
 
You can drop an elephant or a rhino or a cape buffalo with a gun, but not sasquatch? Seems odd.

Feces are not very good for DNA sampling.

Without known samples, you don't really have any sasquatch scat.

Scientifically speaking, no one has ever found any sasquatch scat, hair, or tracks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom