Bigfoot_ The Skookum Cast

Bigfoot is one of those woo topics I have always had a soft spot for.
I have never been to that part of the world, but if I ever get the chance I would love to see it for myself.
I'd like to ask people who know more about Bigfoot some questions:
1)Just how far fetched is the possibility of Bigfoot?
2)Could a large non human hominid really hide that effectively for so long?
3)Just how much of the country up there is true wilderness?
4)Are the Sasquatch folk tales of the native people the sort of stories people tell to kids to scare them, or are they more matter of fact general knowledge type stuff?
5) I suppose another interesting question might also be; If Bigfoot is real, what is he? Some kind of Forrest Gorrilla or a hairy Neanderthal?

Anyway I still hope he is out there and just being too smart for us dumb Saps to find him.
But if he isn't I won't be too surprised.
 
.....I'd like to ask people who know more about Bigfoot some questions:
1)Just how far fetched is the possibility of Bigfoot?

Just a bit more farfetched than the possibility that gorillas existed in Africa in the year 1840.

2)Could a large non human hominid really hide that effectively for so long?

I think so, especially since the folks who appear to have the authority to proclaim that they exist aren't looking for them.

3)Just how much of the country up there is true wilderness?

Way, way, way more than most folks can imagine.

4)Are the Sasquatch folk tales of the native people the sort of stories people tell to kids to scare them, or are they more matter of fact general knowledge type stuff?

In my opinion, both.

5) I suppose another interesting question might also be; If Bigfoot is real, what is he? Some kind of Forrest Gorrilla or a hairy Neanderthal?

I believe they are a bipedal ape.
 
1)Just how far fetched is the possibility of Bigfoot?
Very.
2)Could a large non human hominid really hide that effectively for so long?
Unlikely.
3)Just how much of the country up there is true wilderness?
Depends on what you consider as true wilderness. Note that only those that could be bigfoot's habitat would qualify for the purposes of the current discussion.
4)Are the Sasquatch folk tales of the native people the sort of stories people tell to kids to scare them, or are they more matter of fact general knowledge type stuff?
They are not stories people tell to scare people. They are myths. Note that their "true" purpose and/or meaning must be seen within their original context. Interpretations outside this framework must be made with great care.
5) I suppose another interesting question might also be; If Bigfoot is real, what is he? Some kind of Forrest Gorrilla or a hairy Neanderthal?
Its a myth, and since a myth's interpretation usually depends on the interpreter's cultural background and agenda (if present), feel free to see it the way you are more comfortable with. Be it a giant hairy homind, a gigantopithecus, an entity from another dimension, an elemental, a spiritual entity or... A myth.
 
Bigfoot is one of those woo topics I have always had a soft spot for.
Yeaaaah, me too.:)
1)Just how far fetched is the possibility of Bigfoot?
Well pull out the sticks but I'll say that the possibility isn't so far-fetched but the likelyhood on the other hand... well, so far it's been a tough sell. (Yes, Huntster. I know you're not shopping.:D )
2)Could a large non human hominid really hide that effectively for so long?
Weirder things have happened but given the range they're given by anecdotal evidence it's certainly doubtful. Is a really believable report from Kentucky any more doubtful than an equally believable report from BC. Is there any solid evidence from any report? I mean really, many would love some.(Hunster- ;) )
3)Just how much of the country up there is true wilderness?
A LOT. And more than enough. Not really the problem, though.
4)Are the Sasquatch folk tales of the native people the sort of stories people tell to kids to scare them, or are they more matter of fact general knowledge type stuff?
Well, who doesn't love scaring the crap out of their kids? Whether an actual animal versus a social construct is involved I think many forthright First Nation people would tell you it's both.
5) I suppose another interesting question might also be; If Bigfoot is real, what is he? Some kind of Forrest Gorrilla or a hairy Neanderthal?
So many suggestions and so little to support it. I'll say Paranpithecus Erectus. Or possibly Homo Gigantothropus. Or maybe just a nude, inebbriated Robin Williams.
Anyway I still hope he is out there and just being too smart for us dumb Saps to find him.
But if he isn't I won't be too surprised.
Yeah! What he said! I love posts like that. BTW Brainache, you'd be surprised that more than a few here would agree with that. Some sticks in the mud might call you stupid for thinking so or berate you for not finding sufficient excitement in what's been scientifically described but hey, maybe not, Thaiboxerken hasn't posted in any BF threads for a while so...:D
 
....Its a myth.... .

Myth:

1. a traditional or legendary story, usually concerning some being or hero or event, with or without a determinable basis of fact or a natural explanation, esp. one that is concerned with deities or demigods and explains some practice, rite, or phenomenon of nature.

2. stories or matter of this kind: realm of myth.

3. any invented story, idea, or concept: His account of the event is pure myth.

4. an imaginary or fictitious thing or person.

5. an unproved or false collective belief that is used to justify a social institution.

Which of the 5 above would you say is the most accurate definition of what you meant?
 
Read Campbell.

Much better and comprehensive than your quote, if you are really interested.
 
Thanks for those replies.
I still think Bigfoot is not impossible.
I really don't like to think of something being impossible until all the facts are in. My house is full of things that many scientists once thought were impossible.
I would say that BF is more plausible than the Loch Ness Monster, but until somebody brings him back from the bush in a cage (as sad as that would be), I can't imagine scientists ever believing in him.
 
Thanks for those replies.
I still think Bigfoot is not impossible.
I really don't like to think of something being impossible until all the facts are in. My house is full of things that many scientists once thought were impossible.
In this case, how can one put all the facts in?
The best one can do is try to narrow possibilities, in other words leave bigfeet with less places to "hide". For those wishing to "believe", the space is enough. For those who want reliable evidence, theres very litle or no space at all.

But still, its possible. But unlikely and depending on the "version" of bigfeet, implausible.

I would say that BF is more plausible than the Loch Ness Monster,
Yes, its more plausible than all lake monsters.


but until somebody brings him back from the bush in a cage (as sad as that would be), I can't imagine scientists ever believing in him.
Nope. High-quality footage or pictures with reliable provenance would be enough.
 
Correa Neto I agree with everything you wrote in that last post.
I suppose its just my childhood woo factor that keeps me interested in this particular subject.

But until every square inch of wilderness has been mapped and photographed in close up I will assert my right to at least hope.






Now, where's the thread on UFO's?;)
 
Well, my woo years lasted from my teens untill my late 20s' or even more, depending to the wooism...

Despite having concluded bigfeet, lake monsters, UFOs (as alien spacecraft), etc. are myths, I am always checking claims and news about them. Maybe one day some reliable piece of evidence will surface and I will gladly conclude I was wrong. But I am not holding my breath.
 
Read Campbell.

Much better and comprehensive than your quote, if you are really interested.

I have not read any of Campbell's work, but I have read of him. I am very impressed so far. My understanding of religion appears to mirror his.

I never figured sasquatchery would fit in with Campbellism, but I suppose (if looking at it with native religions in mind), it certainly has a role.
 
Nope. High-quality footage or pictures with reliable provenance would be enough.
I'd hope so but who are you speaking for, Correa? Regardless, here's one we haven't beat thoroughly to death. I think 'provenance' is the key word here. As in I have a crystal-clear video of a salivating sasquatch digging for clams before taking a dump then noticing the person taking the footage and going into a chest beating display before shrieking like a little girl and then making a break for the tree line complete with matching prints and it didn't come from Tom Biscardi but rather James Randi's accountant. That would be provenance, no? Meanwhile, I'll be huffy and wait for one solid piece of evidence for these creatures that doesn't fall to crap upon thorough investigation. Forgive me, I'm feeling moody about endless $#!tty sasquatch evidence claims today. :mad:
 
Well, with that film, plus the prints, plus the DNA from the saliva, the feces, and the clams, you'd have a much better package than the PGF.

With it all documented at once and proven to go together, it's pretty darn good, imo.
 
Today, DNA labs are so good, you can get good data just from skin cells.

You can probably get a DNA sample from a sasquatch footprint today.

They get DNA samples just from your clothes rubbing on your skin nowadays.

A print where sasquatch turned or rotated his foot probably has plenty of skin cells in it where the foot's skin cells were abraded off by the dirt or sand.
 
I don't follow the Bigfoot theory at all, but I was interested to ask: to Bigfoot Believers have a theory to account for the complete absence of Bigfoot remains from the paleontological or historical record? I mean, this is a large primate that has supposedly been indigenous to North American for a very long time--through massive swings in the North American climate. However restricted its range is considered to be now, it surely must have had more prosperous times in the past, when it ranged far more widely across the country. How is it that not a single Bigfoot bone, or frozen Bigfoot feces, or what have you has shown up in the entire continent?

I can believe that a Bigfoot or two could be released into the wild today and remain unfound for the rest of their lives. I don't see how a breeding population of Bigfeet has maintained itself in the continent for millions of years without leaving a single trace of its existence.

Could Bigfeet all be breatarians who leave no spoor and whose bodies evanesce rather than decompose?
 
I'm sorry, but I have not read the whole debate (slapfest) on the BFF. Was the site photgraphed, documented, and measured BEFORE they put down the apples? It just seem's silly that an animal would walk along the road, stop, lay down, and reach for the fruit. I know, "BF likes to cover his tracks", but c'mon, it really seem's ridiculous.

Yes, the site was documented, photographed, etc. The apple bits were left in the alcohol too long. Most animals approach new food with caution, keeping a low profile, especially if others may be around to steal the food. Observe primate feeding behavior sometime. The ground was hard and gravelly around the mudhole. No need for it to use the road, or try to conceal tracks, but Chimpanzees have been observed deliberately leaving tracks for the troup to follow. Even dogs seem aware of their tracks. Sasquatches are not primarily predators, though they may be opportunists and will take meat when they can get it. Chimpanzees do this too.

Read DDA and colobus' posts on the BFF "Official" thread. The rest may be safely skipped.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom