Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Crowlogic said:
Can you say for certain that the costume could have been quickly and easily cranked out by hoaxer or professional? In certain of my own professional endevours clients are often stunned when given the bill or estimate of what a seemingly quick and easy operation might entail. The only people I'll trust to comment on the easiness of costume making here is Bill Munns and Dfoot. Now if you've constructed hairsuit costumes yourself and can furnish figures on the time it took to make then by all means fire away. However you're on a slippery slope if you casually remark that something must have been quick and easy to make.

That said the its a decent looking apeman. I'm still waiting for Parcher to respond back in on how the Patterson drawing works so well on Patty yet the wah mask is claimed to be the Patty face.

Read what Dfoot wrote, I understand he also considers Patty was (or could have been) built by assembling (or remanufacturing) pieces of other costumes within Patterson’s budget and timeframe. So, there you have it. Not to mention that a lot of the information required to reach such conclusion is available at the internet as well as other sources such as books and documentaries on FX tech – I highly recommend “Movie Magic”, for example. It would avoid several errors and misinformation spread from the part of some PGF defenders. You are free to consider only the opinions of those you consider as authorities. But remember, regardless of qualifications, everybody makes mistakes and errors. Meldrum and Krantz are good examples of this.

Now, it’s true I never built a gorilla costume. However, I am not by any means clueless when it comes to costume building. Back in the early 80s I helped and followed the making of carnival costumes making; lots of them – a relative of mine is one of the top professionals in this area. Now, I am NOT talking about an odd cheap costume. What I am talking about is an industry with lots of money involved and yes, it also involves the making of realistic costumes. So, I do have an idea of methods and time frame. When I see a gorilla costume, I can figure out possible methods of construction. I am not saying I have a skill level similar to Bill Munns or Dfoot. I am stating that I am not so clueless regarding the subject as you seem to have insinuated.

That's why I disagree with Munns, among other people, regarding a number of issues such as the level of physical effort that performing as Patty being too high; that's why I disagree with him as well as others regarding the number of people which would be required to help whoever wore the suit being more that one or two. That's why I disagree with arguments based on alleged inhuman proportions such as long arms, etc. That's why I disagree with whoever says it must have been an exceptional costume, beyond Patterson's technical and financial limitations. That's why I disagree regarding the flaws that some people claim are not there. That's why I disagree with so many other issues with PGF defenders.
 
Last edited:
Yep, someone tried to fix Patty's hand in that frame, Crow. Looks like they gave it a hint of fingers as well.

It's possible that the original intent was just to remove the false thumb, as it often confuses people when discussing the left hand in that frame.

However, I also see drastic mods to the hand itself and to the angle of the lower arm, plus a reshaping and an addition of just a hint of finger definition.

Someone is playing a game poorly.
 
Last edited:
If I were going for that effect I'd...

Duplicate the background layer twice. Run the first layer through a highpass filter at about 10-20 use hard light and drop the opacity a bit. Run the second layer though another highpass only crank this one way up and drop the opacity way down. Color correct, tweak and burn for effect.

Amateur's

Whoops, I forgot the nose.


m

 
Grazi de dios

Read what Dfoot wrote, I understand he also considers Patty was (or could have been) built by assembling (or remanufacturing) pieces of other costumes within Patterson’s budget and timeframe. So, there you have it.


Now, it’s true I never built a gorilla costume. However, I am not by any means clueless when it comes to costume building. Back in the early 80s I helped and followed the making of carnival costumes making; lots of them – a relative of mine is one of the top professionals in this area. Now, I am NOT talking about an odd cheap costume. What I am talking about is an industry with lots of money involved and yes, it also involves the making of realistic costumes. So, I do have an idea of methods and time frame. When I see a gorilla costume, I can figure out possible methods of construction. I am not saying I have a skill level similar to Bill Munns or Dfoot. I am stating that I am not so clueless regarding the subject as you seem to have insinuated.

That's why I disagree with Munns, among other people, regarding a number of issues such as the level of physical effort that performing as Patty being too high; that's why I disagree with him as well as others regarding the number of people which would be required to help whoever wore the suit being more that one or two. That's why I disagree with arguments based on alleged inhuman proportions such as long arms, etc. That's why I disagree with whoever says it must have been an exceptional costume, beyond Patterson's technical and financial limitations. That's why I disagree regarding the flaws that some people claim are not there. That's why I disagree with so many other issues with PGF defenders.

That's a pretty substantive claim. "helped making lots of carnivale costumes". Perhaps we could see a few pics. Those big 'sun heads' look pretty ridiculous. Did you make any mapinguari suits? That would qualify as an instant authoritarian on bigfoot costumes. Thanks again. :)
 
Astrophotographer wrote:
Additionally, when I tried your "methodology" with Bob in the suit, he suddenly did "fit". You haven't explained that.


There is nothing to explain, Astro.

My comparisons are between Patty and Bob, himself......not between Patty and "Bob-in-a-suit".
 
After looking at this image, posted by Greg...in which he suggested the back of Patty's left leg shows a 'suit defect'...

fr9aa.jpg



....I decided to put together a stabilized animated-gif of it in motion...

PattyLLEGgif33.gif




To me, it looks more like muscles contracting and bulging, under the full weight of the body, than it does padding.
 
There is nothing to explain, Astro.

My comparisons are between Patty and Bob, himself......not between Patty and "Bob-in-a-suit".


Well, using that reasoning alone, makes it a flawed analysis then. If you want to compare what may be a guy in a suit (Patty/Bunny), you should compare it the mostly likely candidate while he is in a comparable suit. Using the image of Bob outside the suit is flawed for many reasons but your answer takes the cake. Didn't you state earlier that you weren't afraid of the truth? Apparently, you are.
 
The fact still remains, Astro....Bob's fingertips do not reach down as close to his feet as Patty's do to her feet.

ALL of the comparisons between the two of them show that. :)

Like it or not.
 
Attention one and all. I suggest you go back to page 270 and read the exchange between me and WP. After WP posts side by side photos of my frame and his frame he remarks by asking if my frame has been tweeked. I respond to WP quickly and transparantly by stating that no I didn't alter the frame but state that the frame was given to me by someone who has the experties to alter/enhance it and the frame as well as analyize what is on the frame. There had been a disscussion between me and that person about the PGF and the hand arm question. If I remember the email it arrived with correctly it read... "Hi ****** Thanks for the frame I've never seen that one before.It looks like it could be a prosthetic. I think you'll be able to see it better with this."

That said it will be interesting to see how this develops on this forum. I suspect it'll explode into an all out flame war. So before that happens I hope you geniuses take note of this photo and the exchane on 370. My guess is of course that you won't but you've been notified.


 
The fact still remains, Astro....Bob's fingertips do not reach down as close to his feet as Patty's do to her feet.

ALL of the comparisons between the two of them show that. :)

Like it or not.

Again, you ignore every comment regarding your methodology. However, the final stake in the heart of this is that when you compare Patty/Bunny with Bob in a suit, they suddenly appear to be the same. This means:

1) the whole methodology is flawed (which was stated all along) since you can get different results using different pictures of Bunny/Patty and different images of Bob
2) that Bob in a suit has similar dimensions to the guy in the Patty/Bunny suit.

Comparing Bob outside of a suit to Patty/Bunny is just an effort to convince yourself that Patty/Bunny can not be Bob. This also demonstrated with your inaccurate comments that Bob's head was too big to fit into the Patty/Bunny head. If you recall, I showed with measurements that this was not true and you did not contest these measurements. You aren't convincing anybody but yourself sweaty.
 
I respond to WP quickly and transparantly by stating that no I didn't alter the frame but state that the frame was given to me by someone who has the experties to alter/enhance it and the frame as well as analyize what is on the frame. There had been a disscussion between me and that person about the PGF and the hand arm question. If I remember the email it arrived with correctly it read... "Hi ****** Thanks for the frame I've never seen that one before.It looks like it could be a prosthetic. I think you'll be able to see it better with this."

I see that it is 370. Curious about the "Naval intelligence officer" line. Having served over 20 years on Subs, I wonder if being a naval intelligence officer makes a person any more qualified to alter/enhance/analyze an image of bigfoot than MK Davis, Sweaty Yeti, Dfoot, WP, myself, etc. IMO, the answer is no. Naval intelligence officers are fine men but their area of expertise is "naval intelligence" and analyzing images of military value. Suggesting that makes them an expert in analyzing bigfoot images is not being very accurate. For that matter, we do not know what area of expertise he had as a Naval intellgence officer (or if he really was one at all). His area could have been signal intelligence, which is listening to radio traffic and interpreting intent. I am not sure how that translates into being able to analyze bigfoot images.
 
Let me get this straight...

You sent the image I posted back in March to a retired Navy guy. He makes some comments about it, and then proceeds to doctor it up in various and obvious ways. He sends the modified version back to you and you post it (yesterday) with the comment that it is the best image you have seen yet.

Is that correct?
 
After looking at this image, posted by Greg...in which he suggested the back of Patty's left leg shows a 'suit defect'...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/fr9aa.jpg[/qimg]


....I decided to put together a stabilized animated-gif of it in motion...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/PattyLLEGgif33.gif[/qimg]



To me, it looks more like muscles contracting and bulging, under the full weight of the body, than it does padding.

Time to consider again that we're not the only people who've analized the PGF. It was analized by experts from the day it was made. We today seem to find every manner of flaw, fakery and fantasy. However human eyes are still the same human eyes and human perception,reasoning and deduction is still the same too. If the PGF was as riddled with flaws as our modern "experts" claim then the seams, the buldges, the flapping skin and whatnot would have been called out long ago as the means to do so has existed before this conglomeration of people here became the final say. This is why Bill Munns, and Dfoot can make important contributions in the creation of a working demonstration model of this thing. At least one very expert observer that I know has remarked by saying that he thinks it looks pretty good and at the same time he thinks the entire event is highly unlikely.

Or to put it another way none of us are as smart and astute as we think we are!
 
You can see the first appearance of "my" Frame 350 here on page 313, post 12482. When Crow saw this image he wrote...

Crowlogic said:
William are there more Cibachrome frames available? The top one is light years better quality than most otheres out there. The thumb seems to be higher up than a human thumb. I've never seen this frame in this detail before.
 
Crow may have tweaked the image himself, and the Navy guy doesn't exist.

I may have but I didn't. My post on 312 is dated March 5 2008. Within 36 hours of my finding your photo post and my inquiry about more like it I emailed it as part of the dialogue I was engage at the time elsewhere. I had the modified image back within the week.

But since this is a Kangaroo court there's little purpose in defending the point. But at least the Magpies have something to gibber about. But this does bring up an interesting point and I propose that you all use your wits to prove the accusations you've embarked upon. What is my motivation to present a photo showing a detail being presented as not supporting the PGF being a real animal? Over on BFF there are members that have enhanced many photo offerings and usually as a means to discredit the photo/video. At least you've got a few pages worth of posts to fill you days with. Good luck!
 
Last edited:
Chronology and provenance of Frame 350. From left to right...

1) March 5, 2008. Parcher posts a one-of-a-kind image of Frame 350 cropped to 295 x 395.

2) Later on March 5. Crowlogic adds an arrow to Parcher's image, but also "sharpens" the entire image. Image size is 295 x 395.

3) July 11. Crow posts Frame 350 again, but now with background removed (false thumb) and other very dramatic enhancements to the entire image. This is attributed to a retired Navy guy. Image size is 295 x 395.

f3533bd3.jpg
423a75db.jpg
e5a2cf21.jpg
 
After looking at this image, posted by Greg...in which he suggested the back of Patty's left leg shows a 'suit defect'...

[qimg]http://i172.photobucket.com/albums/w28/SweatyYeti/Patty%20and%20Bob/fr9aa.jpg[/qimg]


....I decided to put together a stabilized animated-gif of it in motion...

PattyLLEGgif33.gif




To me, it looks more like muscles contracting and bulging, under the full weight of the body, than it does padding.

Good for you sweaty ...

Now find me some real muscles on the back of a primate's legs that look anything like that ..

Those lumps on Patty's left leg look like a couple of melons under a blanket, and nothing at all like muscles..

Just like the donuts on her arms don't look like real muscles either, unless you think the Michelin man is real ...
It wouldn't surprise me if you do ...

michelin.gif
 
Time to consider again that we're not the only people who've analized the PGF. It was analized by experts from the day it was made. We today seem to find every manner of flaw, fakery and fantasy. However human eyes are still the same human eyes and human perception,reasoning and deduction is still the same too. If the PGF was as riddled with flaws as our modern "experts" claim then the seams, the buldges, the flapping skin and whatnot would have been called out long ago as the means to do so has existed before this conglomeration of people here became the final say. This is why Bill Munns, and Dfoot can make important contributions in the creation of a working demonstration model of this thing. At least one very expert observer that I know has remarked by saying that he thinks it looks pretty good and at the same time he thinks the entire event is highly unlikely.

Or to put it another way none of us are as smart and astute as we think we are!


Crow, I'm not trying to call anyone or anything to the carpet specifically, nor am I taking a side either way ( I've stated before, I'm 51-49 in FAVOR of the PGF being a real BF but thats colored ONLY because of my 2 potential experiences and NOT based in anything the PGF shows or doesnt show, if I had to take a stance based soley on the film itself, I would have to heavily biased toward a manufactured effort rather than a real animal)- just speaking from the baseline of literal science:

>>>It was analized by experts from the day it was made.

The majority of those experts have claimed it was a fake and both sides have failed miserably in qualifying/quantifying their stances with anything resembling data- mostly subjective opinions.

>>>We today seem to find every manner of flaw, fakery and fantasy.

They have been found from day 1 and voiced but there are many ( some here) simply refuse ( or dont understand) to see what the literal analysis says.

To use as an example ( here and another places- you saw the exchanges I'm sure)- there have been "claims" aplenty from several "experts" regarding the dimensioning of Patty and the comparisons. I posted places and here the actual SCIENCE of what it takes, why it has to be, whats missing and why it cannot be obtained. To this date, NOT ONE has countermanded that because what was said was a FACT. ( yeah, they talk AROUND it, ignore it, pretend it was never said or treat it like the elephant in the room and just continue on talking in circles but never addressing it)

* Note- there are several who know that and wont post any attempt to post anything because they know it wouldnt survive even the slightest challenge and their neck would be chopped off. ( thats why they dont just "do it" and make me eat my words- they know the final answer as well as I do)

Ignoring facts and science that has been PROVEN ( and trying to skirt it with bogus arguments while selectively ignoring the FACTS) isnt "scientific" nor is it the hallmark of a LEGITIMATE "expert" in anything. Thats trying to sell wishful thinking in the face of math and physics- the hallmark of a fool.

>>>If the PGF was as riddled with flaws as our modern "experts" claim then the seams, the buldges, the flapping skin and whatnot would have been called out long ago as the means to do so has existed before this conglomeration of people here became the final say.

The "POTENTIAL" flaws have always been there. NEITHER side can claim victory on their argument( in any quantifiable way). The reason is that the ONLY available examination tool is a SUBJECTIVE analysis of the elements. It will always be 50-50. ( even if a "real" BF is captured/killed or if "the" suit is put on Ebay today- it wont help much in establishing the legitimacy of the PGF) After all, BF could still be real and the PGF still a fake. ( BF doesnt live or die in reference to the PGF)

>>>This is why Bill Munns, and Dfoot can make important contributions in the creation of a working demonstration model of this thing.

Yes but at the end of the day- its still an OPINION and thats all the weight it will ever carry.

>>>At least one very expert observer that I know has remarked by saying that he thinks it looks pretty good and at the same time he thinks the entire event is highly unlikely.

LOL, actually, thats my opinion as well
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom