Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm also wondering what the big deal is about the nose, since the subject as a whole bears little resemblance at all, to the subject in the film ...

[qimg]http://www.gatzstuff.com/images/Bigfoot/work2.gif[/qimg]

That's right. The nose is wrong, the lips are wrong, the shape of the face is wrong, etc, etc. But using BM's logic none of those things being wrong matters because they are just trivial items. :boggled:
 
Marcus:

"Hello Bill,

I am not a Bigfoot regular, but I'm hoping you can answer a question for me anyway.

The thigh pad looks very clear to me. (In frame whavever of the PGF, the guys here can supply the frame number if you don't know the one I mean.) It contains straight lines that wouldn't be present in a real muscle. How can this be reconciled with a real animal? Thanks "


The line you mention remains one of my concerns in trying to analyse the film subject, and I don't have a conclusion on that yet, but it definitely isn't a muscle. The more likely option, as I see it, is a scraped line on the fur which could equally occur on a suit and a real fur body, but I'm still looking at the film frames and trying to sort out discrepencies in the various frame versions, as far as how they depict that line.


Longtabber:

Welcome aboard, LT. Your thoughts are always great to read.

:)

Bill
 
Aepervius:

"(A) What the hell has forensic to do with this ? Did you have a corpse to work with , or what ? Your source is not a skull. Your source is a film of a non-decomposed human/creature moving and turning its face. That you choose as an answer to talk about nose forensic CLEARLY shows that you are reaching deep to find any excuse to justify yourself. "

Have you ever heard of "forensic accounting"? No corpse, no skull, just an effort to reconstruct something of the past from limited remaining evidence or source material.


"(B) it has a BIG relevance. When one create a model, one pay attention that at least the model at face value reproduce the maim feature of what is modeled. Including nose and chin. I am sorry, but even after blurying your CGI picture under photoshop, it don't look remotely like patty, especially nose, shin and forehead. So what was your objective ?`Clearly modeling a patty was not it."

It's art! not evidence! Art has no evidentuary relevence to a factual investigation of a hoax!

"(C) (D) whatever. You call yourself an expert and oversee that a different nose , shin and forehead can change appearance greatly ? ANd then you dispute that this is a point which is irrelevant ? Who are you to decide unilaterally that the nose feature are irrelevant ?"

You are so hopelesly lost in this, so think as you like.

Here's a suggestion:

How about this for a press release to send to CNN and the AP wire service:

"Breaking news: The forum members have solved a 40 year old mystery, proving conclusively that the Patterson Gimlin film is a hoax, that Roger made the suit, and that Bob H. wore it, and amazingly enough, even proved that there is no bigfoot, because these forum members with their remarkable attention to detail, found out Bill Munns' artistic exercise in making a portrait of "Patty" has a nose that doesn't look like the white blob in frame 352. Case closed! We proudly salute the incredible team of critical thinkers who noticed this glaring artistic irregularity, and thus resolved the mystery of the Patterson Film."

Then you, GT, Diogenes, WP, LTC and the whole gang can sign your names to it and bask in the glory of this amazing accomplishment.

:)


Bill
 
Last edited:
Marcus:


The line you mention remains one of my concerns in trying to analyse the film subject, and I don't have a conclusion on that yet, but it definitely isn't a muscle. The more likely option, as I see it, is a scraped line on the fur which could equally occur on a suit and a real fur body, but I'm still looking at the film frames and trying to sort out discrepencies in the various frame versions, as far as how they depict that line.


Bill

Thanks Bill, at least you addressed the issue. The Bigfoot devotees simply deny that the line exists. I doubt that a scraped line would persist in a real animal, but then I don't work with animals, perhaps a zooligist would have a relevant opinion.
 
Marcus, there are actually two places on the thigh that show unusual features.

One is "the line" across the whole upper thigh. This could look like the revealed outline of the end of a pad which pushes upwards during the stride. It is above the hand and its action occurs from the movement of the leg, not the hand.

The other is a spot on the forward part of the thigh that does coincide with the position of the hand during the swing. As the hand swings across this spot, the fur appears to bristle as if the hand did "ruffle it up".

If you were to inquire about this from a primatologist (or anyone), you would need to point out and ask about both features.

IMO, the upper line is a crease revealing the top of the thigh padding, and the lower ruffling is from the hand brushing across the furcloth.
 
Last edited:
Marcus:

"Thanks Bill, at least you addressed the issue. The Bigfoot devotees simply deny that the line exists. I doubt that a scraped line would persist in a real animal, but then I don't work with animals, perhaps a zooligist would have a relevant opinion. "

Actually there are several lines. In the post following yours, by William Parcher (or WP, as sometimes referred to), he pointed out another.

In total there are, 1. a line around the waist, 2. a diagonal upward (sometimes referred to as the "butt pad" line), 3. a jagged circular line across the top of the hip (but it sometimes has a "W" shaped shadow), 4. then the straight line mid thigh (which many people call the "hip wader line, I believe) and then 5. the sudden bluge on the thigh onften called the herniated bulge,

Frankly, all are curious and deserve more consideration. Part of the confusion lies in the fact some explanations could only occur on something real, some would only occur on something fake (a suit) and some explanations could occur equally on either real creature or fake suit. Sorting it all out is obviously still an ongoing debate.


Bill
 
4. then the straight line mid thigh (which many people call the "hip wader line, I believe)


Bill

Bill,

Heres the problem I have. A "thigh" is circular and somewhat "oblique" yet this line is "uniform"

I have a difficult time accepting this is from a thumb ( which would hit the highest part but not follow a circular line as a thigh) and even then, the line is uniform in the frames

Also, if "patty" was a normal mammal, for this line to be prevalent- she would have to scrape it often and almost wear it to the skin for it to be a "feature"
( I have no BF experience but I raise dogs,goats,cows and such) and I see no such lines with such uniformity on other mammals
 
LT:

"Bill,

Heres the problem I have. A "thigh" is circular and somewhat "oblique" yet this line is "uniform"

I have a difficult time accepting this is from a thumb ( which would hit the highest part but not follow a circular line as a thigh) and even then, the line is uniform in the frames

Also, if "patty" was a normal mammal, for this line to be prevalent- she would have to scrape it often and almost wear it to the skin for it to be a "feature"
( I have no BF experience but I raise dogs,goats,cows and such) and I see no such lines with such uniformity on other mammals "


If Patty is a real creature: The line might simply be ruffled fur brushed in a line that day, or a worn permanent feature. I'd guess the ruffled fur just that day, not a permanent feature requiring repeated rubbing because one rubing event can ruffle fur (depending on the fur length, density, hair shaft thickness and hair length, all which imapact on how noticably fur can be ruffled on a specific animal). I think what you were questioning was a permanent rubbing and not a purely temporary ruffling of fur.

If Patty's a suit, then fur cloth ruffles relatively easily (far easier than real furs do) and irregularities of a structure under the furcloth may also induce ridges or folds in the fur surface.

I personally don't have an answer or conclusion on this yet. Still thinking it through.

Bill
 
IMO, the "line" (crease) is not the same as the hand brushing the fur. Both occur, but they are in two different locations.

The crease subducts, and shows itself, independently of the hand swinging across the thigh. It appears to be something going on under the thigh skin that is not related to the hand. This internal "tucking" involves a whole line across the thigh and appears to be related to the leg movement.

The hand brushing the fur is seen on the backswing (in this gif) at the instant the hand meets the forward part of the thigh. There is an instantaneous bristling of the fur and there might even be a "shock wave" that jiggles the area around the hand impact. It might be more like the hand smacks the thigh rather than simply brushes it on the backswing.

Watch closely for both features...

a2d75dc0.jpg
post-10-1101609371.gif
 
If Patty is a real creature: The line might simply be ruffled fur brushed in a line that day, or a worn permanent feature. I'd guess the ruffled fur just that day, not a permanent feature requiring repeated rubbing because one rubing event can ruffle fur (depending on the fur length, density, hair shaft thickness and hair length, all which imapact on how noticably fur can be ruffled on a specific animal). I think what you were questioning was a permanent rubbing and not a purely temporary ruffling of fur.

If Patty's a suit, then fur cloth ruffles relatively easily (far easier than real furs do) and irregularities of a structure under the furcloth may also induce ridges or folds in the fur surface.

I personally don't have an answer or conclusion on this yet. Still thinking it through.
Bill,

In my engineering mind, I see 2 possible conclusions

1) Patty is a BF

2) Patty is a suit

(I dont see a 3rd option)

As WP has shown, the "line" is well below where the hand strikes ( and theres a reaction where the hand passes)


That line stays both uniform and constant throughout the movement- it looks like she is wearing a garter. It never changes during locomotion.

I'm having difficulty accepting that this is natural because its so uniform and even. ( and it stays that way thru the full range of motion)

I see the "jiggle" below it yet nothing in it or above it. Muscles just dont work that way.

Also, it appears that this "line" extends to the top of the leg as well ( has no defined start and end as one would think a rub would) Thats as if it "rounds" the top.

Can you help me see what I'm not seeing here?
 
LT:

The animated clip posted above has visual flaws. Looking at the top of the head, it changes shape through the sequence, which neither a real head or a mask can do (the top back of the skull warps noticably), suggesting the animation itself has elements of distortion that challenge the integrity of other visual parts.

That's the kind of thing I'm seeing more and more in various still and video versions of the film, which makes me more cautious about the analysis of the stuff in the hip and thigh.

Bill
 
Judging from the little gif WP posted it appears to me the there is a horozontal line that appears as the arm swings backwards across the thigh causing a darkening of the fur. Then as the arm swings forward again across the thigh it seems to swipe the thigh and there is a dark line while the entire entire area below it becomes lighter in color as if the fur has been moved to a different lay due to the stroke. Some but only some of what we see is most likely due to the hand against the thigh.
 
That's the kind of thing I'm seeing more and more in various still and video versions of the film, which makes me more cautious about the analysis of the stuff in the hip and thigh.

As has been said before, the film lacks the quality and resolution to make definite claims about what the subject of the film actually is.

Hopefully you are just as cautious about the rest of Patty.
 
If Patty is a real creature: The line might simply be ruffled fur brushed in a line that day, or a worn permanent feature. I'd guess the ruffled fur just that day, not a permanent feature requiring repeated rubbing because one rubing event can ruffle fur (depending on the fur length, density, hair shaft thickness and hair length, all which imapact on how noticably fur can be ruffled on a specific animal). I think what you were questioning was a permanent rubbing and not a purely temporary ruffling of fur.

If Patty's a suit, then fur cloth ruffles relatively easily (far easier than real furs do) and irregularities of a structure under the furcloth may also induce ridges or folds in the fur surface.

I personally don't have an answer or conclusion on this yet. Still thinking it through.
Bill,

In my engineering mind, I see 2 possible conclusions

1) Patty is a BF

2) Patty is a suit

(I dont see a 3rd option)

As WP has shown, the "line" is well below where the hand strikes ( and theres a reaction where the hand passes)


That line stays both uniform and constant throughout the movement- it looks like she is wearing a garter. It never changes during locomotion.

I'm having difficulty accepting that this is natural because its so uniform and even. ( and it stays that way thru the full range of motion)

I see the "jiggle" below it yet nothing in it or above it. Muscles just dont work that way.

Also, it appears that this "line" extends to the top of the leg as well ( has no defined start and end as one would think a rub would) Thats as if it "rounds" the top.

Can you help me see what I'm not seeing here?

Oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, we have a new member so I get to post Sweaty's wrist band photo again!!!!!

Longtabber, if you think the thigh pad line is obvious check out Patty's wrist in the little photo in WP's post, then look at the attached of an adjacent frame. Don't know about you but I've never seen an animal with such a uniform line between its hand (glove) and its arm (sleeve).

BTW, where is Sweaty. I miss the big oaf. Sort of. Well not really.
He didn't leave at the same time Creek vanished did he?
 

Attachments

  • handmove1.gif
    handmove1.gif
    45.5 KB · Views: 96
Last edited:
This same gif also allows you to see the problems with the breasts. They are attached low on the torso and do not show any normal movement. I suspect that they are rigid features and are not fluid-filled for realistic action.

As the arm swings back, you can see the furcloth at the pectoral location being pulled back. This is all going on above the breast. The breast does not seem to move at all in spite of the arm swing, torso rotation or the footsteps. Any of those things should be causing genuine large breasts to swing and bounce. But rigid attachments would not do this, and this is what we are seeing. The left foot comes down for a step... boom... and yet the breast doesn't even budge. Hollywood costume designers would probably consider this feature to be a failure, or at least could have been done more convincingly with more effort. Whoever did this costume must have decided that very low and rigid breasts were "good enough".

Under critical examination, the breasts are fairly crude costume devices. They only "fool" a very small percentage of people who get a chance to examine them. Of course a number of people seem so biased in regarding Patty as authentic that even serious problems like this do not change their feelings.

post-10-1101609371.gif
 
Oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, we have a new member so I get to post Sweaty's wrist band photo again!!!!!

Longtabber, if you think the thigh pad line is obvious check out Patty's wrist in the little photo in WP's post, then look at the attached of an adjacent frame. Don't know about you but I've never seen an animal with such a uniform line between its hand (glove) and its arm (sleeve).

BTW, where is Sweaty. I miss the big oaf. Sort of. Well not really.
He didn't leave at the same time Creek vanished did he?

I see what could be a wrist band but there's also another band towards the elbow. What's with that one?
 
Everytime I watch that GIF, i see a new take on the seam on the thigh

Now I'm looking at it, and seeing a 1-2" gap between the diaper, and the thigh, and I'm seeing a strip of fur glued or sewn to the diaper, so the fur hangs down and covers the seam.

Bill is that a common fix for Apesuit seams? Cheap fix of course, but a fix nonetheless, and something that might even be less conspicuous considering the filming conditions and camera/film type
 
Last edited:
Oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, we have a new member so I get to post Sweaty's wrist band photo again!!!!!

Longtabber, if you think the thigh pad line is obvious check out Patty's wrist in the little photo in WP's post, then look at the attached of an adjacent frame. Don't know about you but I've never seen an animal with such a uniform line between its hand (glove) and its arm (sleeve).

BTW, where is Sweaty. I miss the big oaf. Sort of. Well not really.
He didn't leave at the same time Creek vanished did he?

I've seen that one before too but ( to me anyway) that level of enhancement could produce an artifact so I stop at "suspicious" and dont have enough data to go to "conclusive"

The thigh line is clear,reasonably focused and pronounced. ( thats hard for me to "excuse around")

Its been my experience that there are very few truly "straight" lines in nature and I see the hand significantly lower than the line making a thumb strike unlikely and even if it were- that would take a lot of rubbing to make such a pronounced line.

As has been stated hundreds of times before- the film quality,focus and speed make a truly quantative and definitive analysis of possible seams 6 inches short of impossible
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom