Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, I missed the charts
I have been looking back through the thread and I find no charts. Please point me in the right direction. If it is on the BFF, could you tell me if it is in Chap. 1-12?

Bill Munns said:
The artwork estimated a face and head based on film images. There was no preferential decision to say the image can't be a suit. I can build a mask and suit to match the image.
But you must have made determinations based on the beast being real, Like if the PGF face was too wide for a human to have two eyes in the eye sockets, you must have either made the head thinner, or assumed it was a real beast whose' eyes fit the head.

Bill Munns said:
I would guess the fur would be about 1 1/2" long fibers extending out from the pile
Understood that this is a guess, but are you basing this on something you see in the film (if yes please describe) or are you basing this on your knowledge of Gorilla suits?
 
Drew:

"Yes, I missed the charts
I have been looking back through the thread and I find no charts. Please point me in the right direction. If it is on the BFF, could you tell me if it is in Chap. 1-12? "


BFF Notes, Part 5 "Rebuilding Patty", Page 3, post number 67
Problem here is people bring over to this forum only portions of my notes or charts and then debate this partial information, instead of debating it where the notes and charts are complete.

Originally Posted by Bill Munns
"The artwork estimated a face and head based on film images. There was no preferential decision to say the image can't be a suit. I can build a mask and suit to match the image."

"But you must have made determinations based on the beast being real, Like if the PGF face was too wide for a human to have two eyes in the eye sockets, you must have either made the head thinner, or assumed it was a real beast whose' eyes fit the head."

No, I based the determinations on what I saw in the frames, pure and simple. If I was deliberately making a mask for a human, I'd start with the human's head and build outward from there. Different process. To make a design of a mask, you first ned to establish the design constraints, and none were established, so I did not approach the artwork that way.

Originally Posted by Bill Munns
"I would guess the fur would be about 1 1/2" long fibers extending out from the pile "

"Understood that this is a guess, but are you basing this on something you see in the film (if yes please describe) or are you basing this on your knowledge of Gorilla suits? "

I'm basing this estimate on what i see in the film, and what kind of furs I recall from the time that might replicate what I see in the film.

Bill
 
There is no "misdirection" on my part. Your problem, which you must learn to correct if you hope to actually become a critical thinker, is that you read only some of the words, but not all of them, and so you form false conclusions based on your own self-inflicted misunderstanding.

Read and understand ALL the words, not just some of them.

Bill, your Patty nose is a failure. It doesn't look anything like her own nose.

Did you also miss the three full charts showing exactly how the portrait was generated, which film frames were referenced, and how the shapes of profile and head cross-section were estimated? Yes, the portrait was in reference to a specific frame of the film! But not the frame others here mistakenly compare it to.

Bill, the nose you put on her face is a glaring failure. It doesn't matter if it is the result of three charts or three hundred charts. You gave her the nose of some other creature. JREF skeptics are only pointing out the obvious. You blew it.

Repeating, the three charts showed exactly my method.

The artwork estimated a face and head based on film images. There was no preferential decision to say the image can't be a suit. I can build a mask and suit to match the image.

Your method obviously led to a false nose morphology. You show a long, low bridge leading to a flat nose with wide nares. Patty doesn't have that kind of nose. The bridge is pronounced starting from the origin of the nose. There is no flatness to any part of the nose.

I don't care what roads led to your ridiculous nose error. It only matters that you can see the nose and yet still got it horribly wrong.

Your reputation and credibility here is trashed. No, it never was in an initially functional position to be trashed. It started out as biased garbage (with an essentially worthless disclaimer "if this is a costume") on BFF and we took notice. It was quite obvious that you entered BFF speaking words that would be embraced by believers and not skeptics. If that wasn't your intention, then you blew it just like you did with the nose. Sorry.

Your tenure here has been rocky and it is only getting worse. You seem incapable of making it better in spite of trying with your rhetoric and appeals for "scientific methods", objectivity and some other weirdly meaningless noises about "rights" to think what you think and say it. Bill, we are not blind fools here and appeals towards the right to express oneself sound like a who is only just robot begging for an unapposed chance to say "bleep bleep".

You are digging a huge hole for yourself her on JREF. I'm not kidding. It's getting worse. I would give you advice on where to take your dog & pony show, but you would only again respond with an appeal to your "rights".

Guess what? I have a right to explain how your views and portrait of Patty appear to be the vision of a lost puppy. You, as a person, could be something quite different than that. I'm not supposed to attack the arguer, and instead go for the argument. In this case, it's a computer rendition of Patty's nose.

The nose is all wrong. It's a cool image, but it needs to be thrown out. It serves no purpose in the "question" of the legendary hairy ape that has defied scientific confirmation in North America for over 400 years.
 
WP:

Sounds like you're channelling Britney Spears again (bi-polar rant).

Fine, you don't like the nose.

But the original film images, in any version, are not real clear as to the exact nose shape, so lighten up.

:)

Bill
 
Gee all Bill has to do is change the nose. Its a computer graphic for gods sake. Simple to fix change the nose. Nose or no nose its not the PGF and its not an actual costume being filmed as a recreation. I think the graphic nose has too much of a pug.

As for the PGF nose perhape the bulbus image we see has more to do with the reflected light off of the fearure giving it a more prominant appearance. There are some profile fiews where the nose is less pronounced. What we could be seeing could be camera distortion. Why not there are so many other curious elements that get tossed off as such.

William are you off your meds or something?
 
Last edited:
Dfoot's Patty face looks much more like what is in the film.

IMHO, BM's Patty face looks too cute and cuddly. Too much like something the bigfoot believers would/could easily embrace.

Not that it really matters since it's a bloke in a suit.
 
WP, you might not have seen, but he's also now asking for donations to help him pay his mortgage on his house. BF doesn't always bring in the big bucks it seems. I sincerely wish him the best.

I saw it. It wasn't that long ago that he was asking his audience to buy him a new computer.

I guess the real problem is that he thought that a collection of freaky figurines and fantasy books constituted a way to declare the first-floor of your house a museum and therefore a tax deduction from gross income. The litmus test for legitimacy obviously cannot come down to the potential existence of Bigfoot or Nessie.

To have to ask for donations, he must not be making much money (or he spends it all anyways) from crypto promotion and book sales. You said BF doesn't always bring in the big bucks. I think BF might be a decent revenue stream if one runs search expeditions (Moneymaker and Biscardi), or if one produces cable TV productions about Bigfoot (Hajicek).

Coleman seems to have the qualities of a PT Barnumesque fantasy-monger, but he is aiming too low. A living room museum in Maine? Please. Hit the mass media with punchy bravado and jack the fees. Always sell a chance to see Bigfoot, Nessie, Champ, etc.

People will pay hundreds to go looking in the wilderness for something that doesn't exist. MM and Biscardi perpetually prove this. Forget asking people to get on a plane and then pay admission to your house to look at a mounted jackalope. What was Coleman thinking? Now he has to set up his museum as a free-standing, brick & mortar which would also tank. I hope he attaches a bed & breakfast which serves wood-grilled Thunderbird breasts on wild rice. How else are you going to attract the teeming masses with money to burn?
 
Coleman should rent himself out as a special guest, on the BFRO's camping trips, then they could bump the price 50 bucks/head, and increase revenue by $1500/trip, giving Loren $1000 for his endeavors, in exchange BFRO would direct all Chupacabra media question the the Crypto-Museum.
 
Sounds like you're channelling Britney Spears again (bi-polar rant).

See, I knew you were a Trojan Horse. Flatter WP with his intellectualism when he talks about BF being a myth, as long as he doesn't mention Munns. The moment he rags on Bill's work, call him a bipolar wretch.

Fine, you don't like the nose.

Don't like? It's the wrong nose. How is anyone supposed to like that? Oh wait, the BFF crowd seemed to like it. Surprise!

But the original film images, in any version, are not real clear as to the exact nose shape, so lighten up.

The film doesn't clearly show the nose? OK. Do a portrait and give it an ape-like nose with a long flat bridge. Who would object to that? After all, we might be seeing blurry images of a wild hairy ape that has not been confirmed to exist for over 400 years. Better give it a decent and acceptable nose. If you give it a nose that looks sorta fakey, people might think that Bigfoot itself is sorta fakey. When in doubt (no clear nose images) always go for solid biological anatomy. Do not make your portrait look like a costume mask!

Count Your Crows said:
William are you off your meds or something?

LOL. The crow is the troll. The troll is the crow.
 
Parch:

"Do not make your portrait look like a costume mask!"

A good costume mask should look like something real. So my portrait could be a good costume mask look. In any good mask, the nose is one of the easiest parts of the face to get creative with.

You like to find fault with essentially anything I do or say, which is something I've gotten used to. We'll never understand each other. I've accepted that too.

I'm going to continue thinking about and writing about the film and what's in it, and you are going to continue finding fault with what I do.

Such is life.

:)

Bill
 
The mask he offers as "Patty" I refuse to endorse because I want to see a profile view of it, and have asked to see one, and that view has never been shown as far as I know.

This site claims that the face was deemed too gruesome by network higher ups and they eliminated all clear shots of it from the episode. However, there are some shots of the mask/costume that you might find interesting (I believe that Dfoot has a picture of the concept art for the costume as well). Frankly, I think the only way we'd get a good side view of the mask would be to track down whoever won the mask mold at a Star Trek auction and convince them to use it to create a new mask to study.

Roe:

In this old post of mine, I noted the similarities between Patty and Patterson's drawings that were based on the Ostman and Roe reports, noting that Patterson swiped his Roe drawing from someone else's work.

Some argue that the resemblence (along with the similarities between the Roe and Patterson encounter stories) could be due to them both encountering the same type of creature and that since Patterson was a Bigfoot researcher who heard many stories, he'd have enough knowledge to draw the correct features of a Bigfoot before he saw one. However, this seems unlikely seeing as how Patty strongly resembles a picture that Patterson copied from someone else. Someone who, as far as I can tell, was not a Bigfoot researcher. The only other Bigfoot-related thing he ever did that I can find are the drawings in this article from the magazine, "Sports Afield." It seems to me that Mr. Kunstler supplied artwork for the magazine and only did cryptozoology stuff when it was assigned to him. Now, what are the odds of someone like that making a picture that matches up to what's seen on the PGF?

It should be noted that Ostman apparently saw the PGF and said that what was on the film was not the same type of being that (allegedly) abducted him (See post #29 by RayG).

Speaking of Ostman, it's noted in this thread that Ostman's story matches up exactly to a story from his native country of Sweden. Also, it seems he didn't start telling the story until after he lost his family (Post 33). I've also heard that a researcher (Peter Byrne?) tried to find the site using the topography described by Ostman, but was unable to find anything similar, even when using maps and a flyover. Sadly, I botched my link to the BFF thread where I had read this claim.

Oh, and Post #13 in this thread reveals that Dr. Swindler interviewed Ostman at one point!

But wait, Ostman's story being a hoax doesn't explain why Patty has some features like what's seen in Patterson's drawings of the female Sasquatch from Ostman's account. Unless, of course, the artist who drew those features also incorporated them into another design of his...

And, as I've noted in the past, the drawing of the creature done by Roe's daughter has facial features which resemble this bear head. But, not knowing what Roe said about that drawing (or any drawings based on his encounter story), I can't say for sure if it's an exact match to what he claims to have seen.

Breasts:

I think this picture from the Morris recreation attempt nicely illustrates the whole issue of the low placement of the breasts.

POTA remake:

The recent comments about the POTA remake reminded me of this thread, where some of the forum-goers there comment on Dfoot's "Quick look at the Patterson Bigfoot" video. One poster seemingly mistook the test footage from that remake as footage of two Patty recreation suits! They also commented on his video that notes tube's work.

Coleman:

William Parcher said:
To have to ask for donations, he must not be making much money (or he spends it all anyways) from crypto promotion and book sales.

My money's on "spends it all." I recall him noting the high cost of a coelacanth reproduction, and I'd imagine that the Bigfoot statue and prop pterodactyl cost a pretty penny as well.
 
Yes, over 400 years of "civilized" human inhabitance in North America with no confirmation of Bigfoot. Folks who, from the start, have been keen on gathering up all the animals and cataloging them. Yet one outstanding animal is said to have defied all circumstances and attempts to acquire it. The Bigfoot. Huge. Hairy. Bipedal. Bold and vocal. It will scream and throw rocks at you. With Ninja-stealth, is has always avoided the guns, germs, steel, and now electronic technology to remain unconfirmed. Never has it been taken alive or dead. Nobody has ever brought forth even a small chunk of this creature. Even its poopies are forever outside the grasp of the curious.

Only its image is attainable. You can see, or even film a Bigfoot, but its flesh and bones are forever outside of the human reach. Only a fool would seek the physical substance of Bigfoot, as he simply does not give such.

It is as if God himself chose to create a mighty creature that could not be held in the hands of any mortal man. "I will make him of myself. He will be known only to those of faith. I will make him large and hairy, and he will stink to high heaven. He will be another test of my children. He beholdeth all high things. He is a king over all the children of pride. For this one, I will add more cowbell."
 
Nobody asked me again but...

I consider Dfoot's mask (and the Star Trek creature) closer to what I perceive at PGF than Munns' interpretation. Morris' recreation also seems, to me, to be a closer match to PGF's subject, but not so close as Dfoot's presentation.

Regarding Munns' recreation, at PGF I see something with a diferent, less flattened nose, and a wider mouth with some sort of a "beard". Hair color, to me, is also wrong, since I see it as black or dark brown. I also think the head is not as pointed as in Munns' rendering. Regarding the eyes, well, I for one, can't see them at PGF, only the (usually shaded) places where they are supposed to be. I also perceive a more massive, thick lower jaw.

I think Morris recreation, despite having the wrong hair color and a more rounded head, has a more faithfull mouth than Dfoot's work; it also displays the "beard" better than Dfoot's.

Place them in whatever position you want; personally I think Dfoot's mask will look closer to Patty than Morris' recreation; Munns' rendering will be in third place, but well behind Morri's (hair color and shaggyness apart).
 
See, I knew you were a Trojan Horse. Flatter WP with his intellectualism when he talks about BF being a myth, as long as he doesn't mention Munns. The moment he rags on Bill's work, call him a bipolar wretch.



Don't like? It's the wrong nose. How is anyone supposed to like that? Oh wait, the BFF crowd seemed to like it. Surprise!



The film doesn't clearly show the nose? OK. Do a portrait and give it an ape-like nose with a long flat bridge. Who would object to that? After all, we might be seeing blurry images of a wild hairy ape that has not been confirmed to exist for over 400 years. Better give it a decent and acceptable nose. If you give it a nose that looks sorta fakey, people might think that Bigfoot itself is sorta fakey. When in doubt (no clear nose images) always go for solid biological anatomy. Do not make your portrait look like a costume mask!



LOL. The crow is the troll. The troll is the crow.

My, my William you have gone off your meds!

I'm always perplexed William how you can go along for a reasonable period of time comming off as a potentially smart and well informed person about this one particular thing called the PGF. Then all of a sudden you seem to blow a gasket and somehow tumble into the rabbits hole where an hysterical 12 year old emerges who proceeds to unravel any previous stature of substance. It reminds me of the time I applied for a position at Cold Spring Harbor Labs. I was being interviewed by a very proper and well spoken English woman and the interview was proceeding in a cordial and very professional manner. Then for some inexplicable reason this woman sudden began ranting and raving about things like coffee breaks, lunch time and so on. She was quite nearly banging her fists on the desk and I was surprised that nobody came into her office to see what she was ranting and raving about. It was like a scene out of Monte Python only it was real. I declined the position as I had reservations about any place that allowed such a lunatic to be the head of personnell. My impression of the maddness there was later confirmed by aquatinances that had spent time there.
 
Bill, I think your Patty portrait serves as a visual metaphor for your own vision and analysis of the PGF figure. Putting aside the obvious differences (nose, jaw, hair, etc.), you have drawn something that doesn't look like a costume. You drew a bipedal woodland ape. If your portrait extended from the chest downwards, I would expect more of the same. Nothing in the drawing suggests a costume, or rather, if it is a costume then it cannot be distinguished from a real creature. No seams, bulges, attachments or suspicious incongrueties. I guess that is what you see in the PGF anyway. Or rather, what you don't see.

I suspect that if you did change the nose on the portrait it would look like a more bulbous woodland ape nose without the long flat bridge. FWIW, I dont think you would ever create a portrait of Patty that would look like some costume. Maybe only the actual filmed subject would look like a costume. I think this is because drawings and CGI require personal direction and that blendings, feature junctures and other elements are going to be influenced by bias. Then there is the dynamic element. Since the thigh feature (pad, hernia, fur ruffle, or whatever) seems to pop in and out, one has to decide if they are going to show it at full expression or not.

The various curio statues of Patty seem to delete this dynamic feature and give her a smooth muscular thigh. Like a proper woodland ape without any weird distracting things sticking out. The sculptors of those statues run into another problem with the hands and fingers. These are never really resolved in the PGF. One statue settles on crude cupped appendages that seem unfinished. No real fingers there, and instead something like the "mittenish" sea otter paws that I have mentioned.

No sculptor has done the long flat nose that you have drawn. They give a much closer approximation of the projecting bulbous nose that everyone seems to see in the PGF (especially in frame 352). Do you think this is because nobody has paid such painstaking examination and graphing as you have? Is it only you that sees her true nose?
 
My, my William you have gone off your meds!

I'm always perplexed William how you can go along for a reasonable period of time comming off as a potentially smart and well informed person about this one particular thing called the PGF. Then all of a sudden you seem to blow a gasket and somehow tumble into the rabbits hole where an hysterical 12 year old emerges who proceeds to unravel any previous stature of substance.

Does my "condition" reveal itself when I call you a simple troll, or when I imply that Bill is probably not much more than a Hollywood Bigfoot Hobbyist portraying himself as a cool and calculating expert costume analyst?
 
Say Crowdaddy, are you ever going to explain why you think that Bigfoot existed in the first part of the 20th Century and then suddenly went extinct? Or, is that frame of mind reserved for a special med time?
 
Parch:

You truly are clueless as to who I am and what I'm doing.

Now you are entitled to see me and the world as you like, and that's fine. Your opinions, your point of view.

I'll correct you when I think you state something factually wrong, but as far as your point of views, nothing I've said in the past four months has made even a dent in your intriguing vision of me or my work, so I don't see the point in continuing to go around with you on this.

Have a nice day.

:)

Bill
 
Does my "condition" reveal itself when I call you a simple troll, or when I imply that Bill is probably not much more than a Hollywood Bigfoot Hobbyist portraying himself as a cool and calculating expert costume analyst?


Oh I'd say its revealing itself pretty well right now. As for me bing a "simple troll" Oh dear there is no such thing as a simple troll any more than there is a simple skeptic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom