Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK Mods, I'm back on my Meds. On to calm mainstream formality.

Ahem.

This little piggy went to market,
This little piggy stayed at home,
This little piggy had roast beef,
This little piggy had none.
And this little piggy went...
"Wee wee wee" all the way home.

See, I can be perfectly normal just like everyone else can.
 
Mr Munn, really although the "packaging" of WP's small analysis of your CGI from patty comes off as a little rude, the content certainly hit home. It hits home enough that you decided to switch to ad hom instead of answering/justifying your choice.
 
Last edited:
Aepervius:

"Mr Munn, really although the "packaging" of WP's small analysis of your CGI from patty comes off as a little rude, the content certainly hit home. It hits home enough that you decided to switch to ad hom instead of answering/justifying your choice. "

I'm not sure what you mean by "switching to ad hom" but I do stop answering/justifying my choices when the other person's ideas become so silly or irational that no reasonable response will make a difference.

A. It's just a nose, which is the least determanible feature of a face forensicly, because it's just soft cartilidge.

B. It has absolutely no relevence to the "real creature vs hoaxed suit" debate because it can be on either real face or suit mask equally well and thus it's shape does not weigh in to either side of the argument.

C. The frame compared by others here (352, I believe) is not the frame I referenced in making the portrait, and there are enough shape discrepencies of head/face morphology among the frames (due to the films poor resolution) that no one frame is actually an absolute in determining facial structure and nose structure.

D. You people have wasted nearly two full pages of this thread over an astonishingly trivial matter which has been clearly identified all along as simply an artistic experiment, nothing more, and has never been offered or proported to be a singular, final, or preveiling determination. To the contrary, I have always said (from the original notes supplied with the image) that other artists may likely see this differently and their ideas are as valid as mine.

E. All of you so concerned about the nose in the portrait are so myopic that not only can you not see the forest for the trees, you can't even see the first tree for one leaf. You are wallowing in minute and trivial elements and you've lost all prespective of relevence and weighted value.

To sum it up, you are collectively arguing about a truly trivial thing, a "non event" and insulting your own intelligenge by giving so much concern to something that need no concern. You have lost all perception of real issues that factor into the real vs hoax debate.

Bill
 
I think that Bills term of a wasted two pages while correct in a sense that the nose is a trivial element at the moment this thread/forum serves for some a huge purpose. Perhaps it serves the purpose of providing purpose. I suspect that the "usual suspects" have breathed a certain sigh of relief that the thread caught fire again after what seemed to be its death about 20 pages back. The thread with all of its focus on whatever needs to be perpuated. Without it purpose for some is extinguished. Everybody needs something. For some this IS the something, perhaps the only thing.
 
Last edited:
Aepervius:

"Mr Munn, really although the "packaging" of WP's small analysis of your CGI from patty comes off as a little rude, the content certainly hit home. It hits home enough that you decided to switch to ad hom instead of answering/justifying your choice. "

I'm not sure what you mean by "switching to ad hom" but I do stop answering/justifying my choices when the other person's ideas become so silly or irational that no reasonable response will make a difference.

A. It's just a nose, which is the least determanible feature of a face forensicly, because it's just soft cartilidge.

B. It has absolutely no relevence to the "real creature vs hoaxed suit" debate because it can be on either real face or suit mask equally well and thus it's shape does not weigh in to either side of the argument.

C. The frame compared by others here (352, I believe) is not the frame I referenced in making the portrait, and there are enough shape discrepencies of head/face morphology among the frames (due to the films poor resolution) that no one frame is actually an absolute in determining facial structure and nose structure.

D. You people have wasted nearly two full pages of this thread over an astonishingly trivial matter which has been clearly identified all along as simply an artistic experiment, nothing more, and has never been offered or proported to be a singular, final, or preveiling determination. To the contrary, I have always said (from the original notes supplied with the image) that other artists may likely see this differently and their ideas are as valid as mine.

E. All of you so concerned about the nose in the portrait are so myopic that not only can you not see the forest for the trees, you can't even see the first tree for one leaf. You are wallowing in minute and trivial elements and you've lost all prespective of relevence and weighted value.

To sum it up, you are collectively arguing about a truly trivial thing, a "non event" and insulting your own intelligenge by giving so much concern to something that need no concern. You have lost all perception of real issues that factor into the real vs hoax debate.

Bill

So instead of just admitting you screwed up you create 5 reasons why it's not your fault. That is an interesting and revealing reply.
 
I think that Bills term of a wasted two pages while correct in a sense that the nose is a trivial element at the moment this thread/forum serves for some a huge purpose. Perhaps it serves the purpose of providing purpose. I suspect that the "usual suspects" have breathed a certain sigh of relief that the thread caught fire again after what seemed to be its death about 20 pages back. The thread with all of its focus on whatever needs to be perpuated. Without it purpose for some is extinguished. Everybody needs something. For some this IS the something, perhaps the only thing.

Uh, Crow, maybe you should do a count of the number of posts per poster after the thread came back to life. See anything interesting?
 
GT:

"So instead of just admitting you screwed up you create 5 reasons why it's not your fault. That is an interesting and revealing reply. "

I didn't screw up anything. I created a piece of speculative art, and by the exact methodology I displayed and described originally, and succeeded in accomplishing exactly what I intended to accomplish. That's success. I succeeded in creating a work of art. I like it, I'll keep it, and I'll show it with confidence.

The nose is by far one of the most speculative features of "Patty's" face but that fact is obviously beyond your comprehension, because you clearly cannot figure out how speculative it is, or how trivial the discussion is.

What's interesting and revealing is the astonishing collective dumbness of so many in this thread who have nothing of substance to say and keep saying it, including you.

Why don't you all give it a rest, for a week or so, because I'll have my new Creature Gallery website online by next weekend, and it will have a section on my experience in the whole PG Film analysis process, and I can assure you, once it's up, there will be things of merit for you to talk about.

If on the other hand, you want to keep obcessing on something that's just one artist's idea of one nose in a speculative drawing, go on, be my guest. Show the world how petty you think. Now that will be interesting and revealing.

:)

Bill
 
Mr. Munns, trivial to you does not equal "trivial to everyone".

If we have learned anything discussing bigfoot, it's that details matter.

If you are unwilling to discuss the nose, or anything else, just say so. You had no trouble saying you were unwilling to go in other directions, and you had no trouble saying you were not on a certain side of the sasquatch fence.

No need for infantile attacks. They certainly don't help your case, nor do they reflect a professional.

If you are trying to get banned via attacks like "collective dumbness", it's better to just abandon the field voluntarily.
 
LTC:

My response is both appropriate and proportional to the intelligence (or lack thereof) and spirit of fairness (or lack thereof) of the person whose comment I am responding to.

I've talked about the nose, in reply to others who started takling about it, until it became so silly that talk ceased to be effective.

Intelligence is rising above the trivial, not wallowing in it.

Bill


By the way, here's a section from the membership agreement:

"The JREF wishes the Forum to be a friendly and lively (if challenging) Forum for a mature audience and therefore will endeavor to ensure that civility will be the norm, however this does not mean that Members will be insulated from all insults and certainly not from challenges; the nature of the forum inevitably involves strong emotions and opinions which can result in heated exchanges. Having your views challenged is not considered unfriendly nor uncivil. "

"however this does not mean that Members will be insulated from all insults"

I've endured enough myself, so a little reciprosity isn't out of line.
 
Last edited:
(A) What the hell has forensic to do with this ? Did you have a corpse to work with , or what ? Your source is not a skull. Your source is a film of a non-decomposed human/creature moving and turning its face. That you choose as an answer to talk about nose forensic CLEARLY shows that you are reaching deep to find any excuse to justify yourself.
(B) it has a BIG relevance. When one create a model, one pay attention that at least the model at face value reproduce the maim feature of what is modeled. Including nose and chin. I am sorry, but even after blurying your CGI picture under photoshop, it don't look remotely like patty, especially nose, shin and forehead. So what was your objective ?`Clearly modeling a patty was not it.
(C) (D) whatever. You call yourself an expert and oversee that a different nose , shin and forehead can change appearance greatly ? ANd then you dispute that this is a point which is irrelevant ? Who are you to decide unilaterally that the nose feature are irrelevant ?
 
Hello Bill,

I am not a Bigfoot regular, but I'm hoping you can answer a question for me anyway.

The thigh pad looks very clear to me. (In frame whavever of the PGF, the guys here can supply the frame number if you don't know the one I mean.) It contains straight lines that wouldn't be present in a real muscle. How can this be reconciled with a real animal? Thanks
 
I'm also wondering what the big deal is about the nose, since the subject as a whole bears little resemblance at all, to the subject in the film ...

work2.gif
 
Maybe we don't need a manufactured mask or even a heap of padding. Just a little fur here and there.

 
Thats a good one crow

( howdy all to those I know and to those I have yet to meet- first post on a thread here)

Having PM'd and actually talked to Bill, I have a great respect for his technical prowess, experience and effort. That said, I'm also not completely aligned with his conclusions. ( which we have discussed so its no secret)

I do however see how he derives his conclusions.

I personally see nothing on the PGF that couldnt be created (recreated) then or now nor do I see anything compelling that jumps out and says "real"
 
Thank you Crow ( feel kinda "neked" without my avatar)

Since I'm the newbie here, the onus is on me to facilitate the group in knowing the short list as to "me" regarding this subject.

1) I am a "believer" in the possible existence of BF but thats based on 2 personal encounters ( which neither provided a 100% positive recognition) so I cant say I "know" BF exists but am leaning that way.

2) I am, however, a PE with a PhD and refuse to compromise on the scientific method.( a facts and data guy who will not allow my personal beliefs to trump what factual verified evidence shows and I wont hesitate to adjust my personal beliefs in accordance to what the EVIDENCE shows)

3) My opinion of the PGF is ( as stated many times on the BFF) is 51-49 in favor of it being authentic. That margin is so weak I will never "defend" it and the more I study it- that percentage is always in flux. I am often in the position of attacking its authenticity. That doesnt bother me because my acceptance of the potential of BF being real has nothing to do with the PGF so if its ever determined to be fake, it wouldnt affect me in the least. ( BF might actually exist and the PGF still is a hoax)

4) I have stated many times ( over there) that BF "science" is a contradiction in terms and the worst enemy of those seeking to "prove" the existence of BF is themselves.

5) Like many others, I have "challenged" many of "Holy Grail" beliefs and people in the world of BFdom and have been attacked and such but have yet to be "trumped" when facts and data stand their ground.

6) I find it comfortable to be in the mix with a fellow "blog hooligan" ( LTC) and many respected posters from the BFF who I may not always agree with but hold in the highest of respect.
 
Welcome aboard Longtabber. This bigfoot thread is somewhat intimidating by its sheer size, but there are some really good points brought up throughout.

RayG

Thank you Ray

I am reading and digesting these threads ( which will take some time) and there are in fact many good points ( and posters) here.

This will be an interesting experience for me in dealing with both sides of my mind.

I "believe" in the possibility of BF based on my experience ( which neither unfortunately had a true "confirmation" so even they are open to objective scrutiny)

My education,experience and career prohibit me from exceeding the boundaries of what the FACTS show. The only "fact" on the table is that there is not a single shred of verifiable evidence ( that survives even the most rudimentary examination) that "proves" this creature exists or ever did.

When both sides of my mind collide- facts and data prevail. ( its the only thing one can count on or stand on and maintain professional integrity)

However, I do still have that BF clan living on my farm and they keep me in the loop on how they keep evading attempts to factually discover them but I have signed a confidentiality agreement with them so I cannot address those secrets.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom