Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Coleman is not above editing, censoring and general posturing to make himself look better. He has complete control of his own blog and can eliminate postings that might point out his errors... then correct what he wrote so it appears that he did not bumble anything. He may have wrote what you said then later pulled that part out.

The SWDJ clip is titled "The Second Reel". But it isn't. If anything, it contains the plaster pour scene and panning of footprints which is alleged to be found on the "second reel". It also contains some footage which obviously cannot be from a second reel (loaded into the camera after the Patty filming).

I'm curious about the actual origin of the SWDJ clip. It seems to be very similar to the Mysterious Monsters program narrated by Peter Graves. It is as if there were two versions of this show. But the SWDJ version has a reddish hue and slightly different narrative. The whinnying horse audio effect seems to be almost identical.
 
The ball's in your court, fellow forum members. Can we have an intelligent discussion of the film and the issues related to it? I'm willing to try if you are.

LOL. This thread (and others) is the court and the ball is Bigfoot. This creature has never been confirmed to exist and looks just like a myth that is perpetually promoted as reality by way of hoaxing and general credulity (believing what others claim).

One could put aside requests for "intelligent discussion" and instead make an appeal to "common sense", rationality and reason. That is what this forum (the court you refer to) is based upon.

It defies common sense that Bigfoot could remain unconfirmed after so many centuries of open opportunity to do so. It is not rational or reasonable to think that such a creature could exist for so long in our local midst and yet not present genuine evidence of its existence. This is way beyond the point of making excuses for non-confirmation and is fully into special pleading. The case for Bigfoot has exceeded the statute of limitations. Bigfoot is not analogous to other famous and now-confirmed "hidden" mammals such as the mountain gorilla, okapi, saoli, giant panda, etc. Nonetheless, cryptozoologists want people to think otherwise.

So often we read and hear the term "open mind" when dealing with Bigfoot. We hear that to think and act appropriately (scientific and smart) concerning the proposition of Bigfoot - we should keep an open mind. The problem with that is that huge numbers of people could be accused of having "closed minds" who actually do not. Saying "Bigfoot is a myth" is not necessarily any indication of a closed mind. It could well be a proclamation coming from someone who has a good grasp on what constitutes a real animal living in a real world. Animals do not exist in vacuums, and yet if Bigfoot exists, then it seems to be doing so in a vacuum. A vacuum or black hole that never spits out any biological material (dead or alive). Bill, this is just not rational or reasonable. Bigfoot is not even a tiny microorganism... it's supposed to be a huge honking ape!

Putting aside hoaxery and pretending to believe - IMO, a genuine conviction held by anyone, that Bigfoot exists, indicates an open mind with tunnel vision.
 
WP:

Thank you for this very well reasoned statement (the above post).

Your arguments are very well structured and presented.

I commend you for focusing on the ideas, more so that the persons discussing the ideas. Hopefully we will continue to see this kind of content here.

Bill
 
Bill, I appreciate that you took value from my post. But I also smell a trojan horse in that your flattery is most likely based on me not specifically attacking you and your beliefs... as if the person lacking common sense and rationality which I am talking about must be someone other than you.

What this means is that the "Question of Bigfoot" has gone so far beyond rationality and reason, that it is now fully into the realm of personality and cultural psychology. OK, so Bigfoot perfectly matches a mythological creature... now what? Now we can take a look at the individuals and groups who support the reality of its existence and critically examine them. Why do they seem to buck against rationality and reason? What is going on behind the Wizard of Oz curtain? Suddenly, it's no longer about an elusive wild hairy bipedal primate and is instead about the human mind and its ability to imagine and argue for almost anything. Fake some huge footprints and put a guy in a furry costume and you have yourself a freaking cult of belief. Roger Patterson only picked up the torch from others who carried it before him.

Ivan Marx then grabbed the torch and make his own ridiculous limping fake Bigfoot which totally fooled John Green. Leaping lizards and holy crap... where is rationality and reason when it comes to these top notch Bigfoot experts? Decades later, Meldrum watches the Snow Walker and thinks he is seeing a real Yeti. That belief stops only when the hoax is revealed. When is this goofy carnival of gullibility ever going to end? Skepticism cannot stop people from indulging their fantasies.

You and I both know you could make a fleshed-out life model of Piltdown Man (like you did for Gigantopithecus). But Piltdown Man was a hoax. It doesn't matter. You know you could create a whole creature model out of what little was presented as this "new fossil find" known as Piltdown Man. You did it for Giganto which is not regarded as a hoax.

Pretend that Piltdown was not a hoax and go make a hairy head model of it (or do a computer graphic). I saw your CGI Patty head. She sure as hell could be a hoax.

You've got great artistic skills. C'mon Bill, do Piltdown Man. :)
 
Last edited:
Bill, here is your portrait of Patty that you posted on BFF. Great work. It is sorta like what she might look like if Patterson filmed her from only 10 feet away. Of course we both know that no 1967 Bigfoot costume could ever look like that. Maybe that was your point. Patty doesn't look at all like a costume and instead she looks like this.

How would you do a similar portrait based on some hypothetical mask built in 1967? Can't do it? Because you can't imagine or see Patty's head being a fabricated piece when you watch the PGF? Would you be forcing yourself to make the head shape, eye sockets, nose, ears and mouth, etc. into something that you simply do not see in the PGF?

I thought her nose looked more bulbous than in your portrait.

Is this exactly what Bill Munns sees in the PGF?...

519c22b6.jpg
 
WP:

The "Patty" portrait was simply an exercise in 3D modeling to see if I could build a head that tended to have highlight/shadow reflective values close to what I saw in various frames of the film. And it was a rough first try, not a final result. I like to rough something out and refine it over time.

The actual portrait was mostly photoshop art over this basic 3D model test.

I'm not sure if you would understand this (and no offence intended, because it is simply a reflection of how my mind thinks things through, with no expectation how other intelligent people think things through), but when I visualize something like the "Patty" portrait, it challenges me to think of the whole issue from a fresh perspective. I ask myself question about what I see in the film which I otherwise wouldn't. I see details I might not otherwise give attention to. So an artistic exercise like my "Patty" portrait is as much a thinking exercise for me as it is an artistic expression.

It's a highly personalized process of thinking and research, combined with artistic experiment which I've been doing now for about 30 years (on scientific paleontology subjects mainly), and all I can say is the process serves me well, in terms of helping me feel I have a clearer understanding of issues or controversies.

That said, the whole "Patty" thing, indeed the whole BF thing, has been a curious adventure for me and I'm certainly not at the end of the road yet, in terms of understanding it all.

So all I really can say is what you see is my way of working through a subject of controversy or debate. Just in this case, I'm working it through publicly, as others watch and question, instead of usually alone in my workshop.

Bill

post script:

actually I don't do "Trojan Horses". I actually am a "what you see is what you get" kind of guy, but you don't know me that well. I do acknowledge you are suspicious of me and my motives. But I still base my notes and replies on what i simply and directly feel, as much as I can.
 
Last edited:
Bill Munns said:
I like to rough something out and refine it over time.

Will you make Patty look more like the figure shown in the Dahinden Cibachrome over time?

Look closely at Patty. Notice the size and spacial relationships of the eye socket, cheek bone and nose. Those are all tight and almost linear. Her nose looks bulbous, yet compact, and the whole of the nose barely extends below the cheek bone. It's also as if her entire nose is the same size as her eye socket. Her mouth and chin appears massive as if there is possibly no tapering to the face as you go down. Her head appears to be wider from the nose down than it is from the nose upwards.

You got the skull bulk very close from the brow upwards, but from that point downwards you tapered the whole thing into a non-representative rendition. Bill, her lower mandible is truly massive and her nose is a small bulb located way up by her eyeball.

Repeated: Your portrait shows a discreetly lengthened nose and lower face with a pointy chin.

IMO, Patty's face is hulking block, but you show something else. Why does your face and head structure look significantly different?

7cf0f40f.jpg
d6d73fd0.jpg
 
WP:

I had started a second portrait using a frame pretty similar to the one you showed, more of the look back and face more straight on toward camera, but it's still not done (or even close to done). I've been tied up working on cataloguing all my photos for the new creature gallery I'm setting up.

The face in the frame you've shown is obviously different than my "portrait" as you have pointed out. My portrait was derived more from an "averaging" of numerous frame outlines (which themself were estimated).

As I said, it was an exercise in evaluating the face and thinking about how much facial detail can be extracted from the film.

One of my concerns is precisely the varying levels of detail seen in various versions of the frames, and wondering what details may be reliably extracted from the film and varying frames. I don't have any answers yet on this, just questions in my mind.

That's why I hope to do some research on filming various head shapes at the same 16mm film and resolution as the PG film, side by side with a zoomed in hi-def video, so I have some reference to try and get a clearer idea of how the 16mm film (and a head in so small a part of the frame) might be distorted by the process, the film grain, etc. (using the hi-def video as the known reference).

So all I can say to you now is the portrait of mine is a work in progress, a study model to help me think it through. But I agree the other frame you referenced does need to be factored into any analysis of head shape.

Bill
 
Bill, the image I used of Patty is a crop of the Frame 352 (famous turn-to-look) Dahinden Cibachrome. See the whole thing below. Your version of the nose and where it is located is wildly different from Patty's nose. The sun glare off her nose defines the whole thing. It's compact and bulbous like some old boxer who has been pounded to smithereens. Then the lower mandible is outrageously massive. It's completely different than you depicted. If your portrait is a result of "averaging", then the average is completely wrong!

If you care about credibility and realism, then you need to go back to the drawing board and start with something that begins to replicate this. Otherwise, you might be accused of running a fantasy scam using some software. Your Patty nose doesn't look anything like the one she wears. Forget "averaging" or giving her a nose like you may "think" she should have. Instead give her the nose that is shown in the Dahinden Cibachrome. Is there any better image of her nose? Hell no. The whole thing is defined by the sunlight in this image.

9415fc42.jpg
 
I caught for the first time the new remake of Planet Of The Apes on network TV. I don't know who did the costumes but wyhile they were better than the Chambers Apes they were nowhere near convincingly real. Just something to think about.
 
WP:

"Then the lower mandible is outrageously massive. It's completely different than you depicted. If your portrait is a result of "averaging", then the average is completely wrong!"

What I have learned over the years both making models and photographing them is the potential of the camera and it's lack of depth perception to represent a 3D shape (in a 2D image) apparently different from it's actual 3D physical shape. There are a lot of apparent shape discrepencies in head and face shape I've noticed over the past 6 months of looking at the various stills of the film. The frame you offered as example is one I am thinking about still.

But we are in agreement. My "portrait" (artwork) does not look similar to the frame you think is the best rendition of the face.

Bill
 
Here's some more for you Bill. The nose is bulbous. The lower jaw is like an end-loader bucket. Chin? What kind of chin do you see?

f3b88396.jpg


af957bcd.jpg



Oh, and here's one for comedy. This comes from Owen Caddy after he monkeyed with the film. LOL. How on earth could he think that that really shows the head and face of Patty? Maybe it's because his opinion doesn't come from earth.

0f4f70a8.jpg


Look at that huge eye socket, no nose, droopy lip thing. Is that more acceptable than a Bluff Creek Bigfoot massacre theory? Hell no. Both are the result of fantastic imaginations gone wild combined with a belief that Bigfoot exists. It's totally ridiculous. Davis and Caddy should be spanked. These are adults who show no kind of rationality or reason. Belief in Bigfoot does that to some people. Insane. Crazy. Funny as hell to anyone with a working brain.
 
The blurry bottom photo with the blue outlining looks like a cocker spaniel.
 
WP:

I did check and i have 5 slightly varied versions of frame 352 (and two different ones of 350) which vary in image size, contrast, color balance, etc.

Will be curious to compare them more closely when I have time.

Bill
 
Certainly looks a lot more like subject in the film than Mr. Munns' interpretation ...

This is a lot closer also ..

post-1483-1199774230.gif


I wonder what keeps Mr. Munns from giving credit, where credit is due ..

I'm really trying to understand Bill Munn's motivation for presenting an image so far removed from what we see in the film..

He is clearly an artist in his own right; so the artistic obfuscation makes no sense if he is really looking at this objectively ..


There is a clue there somewhere ...

First, we see all the BFF fandom affirmation of Mr. Munns' conclusions that the the subject in the film is not a man in a suit..

Then Mr. Munns presents an artistic interpretation of the subject in the film, that doesn't even come close ( unless you count two eyes, one mouth, etc ... ), which some of the fans go all ga ga over ...

Gee, whiz .. Photoshop does wonders, when it come to tattered scraps of furry whatever, coming apart at the seams and bulging in all the wrong places ...
 
Last edited:
pgfstudy.gif



from: http://kids.niehs.nih.gov/wrong.htm

What's Wrong With These Pictures?
One of These Things
(Is Not Like The Others)
One of these things is not like the others,
One of these things just doesn't belong,
Can you tell which thing is not like the others
By the time I finish my song?
Did you guess which thing was not like the others?
Did you guess which thing just doesn't belong?
If you guessed this one is not like the others,
Then you're absolutely...right!

from Sesame Street, by Joe Raposo and Jon Stone
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom