To All:
Obviously, as I hope all here can appreciate, I do not like being accused of being a fraud, and I expect anyone else here would similarly be resentful if another person accused them of being such.
But please, let's examine this simply from the standpoint of a critical thinker, setting aside the emotionalism of the issue.
Fraud is defined (in my Random House dictionary) as "deceit or trickery used to gain unfair or dishonest advantage".
1. Where is my proven deceit? Have I lied about my resume? Have I lied about materials and their properties? People have challenged me as to my "intent" but those who do feel I am deceitful in my intent have only their "inference", their opinion that my intent is other than what I state. Inferences and opinions aren't proof. So where is the proof of deceit?
2. "Gain" What have I gained? Some say fame, but I have been famous for the Giganto figure for about 15 years. I was somewhat "famous" as a makeup artist in the 80's from my work on Swamp thing and a few other films (and famous for my being fired from Return of the Living Dead, as others here love to keep bringing up). I was famous in the world of taxidermy for my two wins as "Best in World Recreation" in 1988 ans 1992, and for years after for my published articles in Breakthrough Magazine. I was famous in a way within the digital arts community from 1998 to 2002 for my Bryce 3D digital imagery (which included my work being named a milestone in computer graphics by Computer Graphis World Magazine, in their 2002 retrospective of computer graphics achievements.
So I've been "sort of famous" four times for varied accomplishments, and whatever "fame" I may seem to be gaining now because of my notes on the PG Film, I have equally gained the anomoisity and bitter resentment of skeptical people. I have more people now actively trying to discredit me than ever before in my career, hardly the kind of gain one wants or seeks.
So where's the "gain"
3. "Unfair or dishonest advantage" What "advantage" have I obtained or received? Certainly no money, not even any talk of receiving any. I still work and if someone commissions me to do some work, any issue of fraud is between me and the person I work for, if that person found my work delivered to be something other than what I promised to accomplish, but such isn not the case.
Am I taking advantage of anyone here in this forum? Am I asking of any of you that you buy something from me? There is no advantage in a forum where ideas are exchanged, and my singular relationship with you all is simply an exchange of ideas and information.
4. Fraud generally requires a victim, someone who has lost something of value to the one perpetrating the fraud. All I have heard thus far is a vague concern for "sheeple" unnamed, unidentified, and the assumption they will lose something if they feed on my words?
So I ask, who are the victims of the fraud I am accused of? What have they lost? And if they choose to believe in bigfoot, why do you feel you must tell them what they should think? Wouldn't you resent some person simply deciding to take over your life and dictate to you what you may or may not think?
Finally, if I do accomplish some research experiemnts on the issues I talk about, and then did publish or publicly release that research information, at that time it may be evaluated by one and all, and criticized by any who find it flawed, and I could be accused of fraud if I were proven to have falsified any data or misrepresented conclusions, but none of that has happened yet.
Where is the deceit? Where is the gain? Where is the advantage? Where is the fraud?
Bill