Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ho, People, may I suggest a time out an deep breathing ? Calming down ? Although I tend to strongly dsiagree with Mr Munn on the value of his so called negative-study too, I would not go as far as call him a downright fraud and liar, until the moment where money change hands. As far as i can tell , part of this thread went very deep in ad-hom county.
 
Ho, People, may I suggest a time out an deep breathing ? Calming down ? Although I tend to strongly dsiagree with Mr Munn on the value of his so called negative-study too, I would not go as far as call him a downright fraud and liar, until the moment where money change hands. As far as i can tell , part of this thread went very deep in ad-hom county.

Very good points! But even after the event of money changing hands Bill Munns is still not a fraud or a liar. He'd be a liar if he took the money and failed to produce the project and he'd be a fraud if he took the money, completed the project but made the subject/Patty recreation out of materials not obtainable in 1967 and used those materials to construct the subject with techniques that were not in use then. Fraud could also be claimed if he used period materials with current state of the art techniques.
 
To All:


Obviously, as I hope all here can appreciate, I do not like being accused of being a fraud, and I expect anyone else here would similarly be resentful if another person accused them of being such.

But please, let's examine this simply from the standpoint of a critical thinker, setting aside the emotionalism of the issue.

Fraud is defined (in my Random House dictionary) as "deceit or trickery used to gain unfair or dishonest advantage".


1. Where is my proven deceit? Have I lied about my resume? Have I lied about materials and their properties? People have challenged me as to my "intent" but those who do feel I am deceitful in my intent have only their "inference", their opinion that my intent is other than what I state. Inferences and opinions aren't proof. So where is the proof of deceit?

2. "Gain" What have I gained? Some say fame, but I have been famous for the Giganto figure for about 15 years. I was somewhat "famous" as a makeup artist in the 80's from my work on Swamp thing and a few other films (and famous for my being fired from Return of the Living Dead, as others here love to keep bringing up). I was famous in the world of taxidermy for my two wins as "Best in World Recreation" in 1988 ans 1992, and for years after for my published articles in Breakthrough Magazine. I was famous in a way within the digital arts community from 1998 to 2002 for my Bryce 3D digital imagery (which included my work being named a milestone in computer graphics by Computer Graphis World Magazine, in their 2002 retrospective of computer graphics achievements.

So I've been "sort of famous" four times for varied accomplishments, and whatever "fame" I may seem to be gaining now because of my notes on the PG Film, I have equally gained the anomoisity and bitter resentment of skeptical people. I have more people now actively trying to discredit me than ever before in my career, hardly the kind of gain one wants or seeks.

So where's the "gain"

3. "Unfair or dishonest advantage" What "advantage" have I obtained or received? Certainly no money, not even any talk of receiving any. I still work and if someone commissions me to do some work, any issue of fraud is between me and the person I work for, if that person found my work delivered to be something other than what I promised to accomplish, but such isn not the case.

Am I taking advantage of anyone here in this forum? Am I asking of any of you that you buy something from me? There is no advantage in a forum where ideas are exchanged, and my singular relationship with you all is simply an exchange of ideas and information.

4. Fraud generally requires a victim, someone who has lost something of value to the one perpetrating the fraud. All I have heard thus far is a vague concern for "sheeple" unnamed, unidentified, and the assumption they will lose something if they feed on my words?

So I ask, who are the victims of the fraud I am accused of? What have they lost? And if they choose to believe in bigfoot, why do you feel you must tell them what they should think? Wouldn't you resent some person simply deciding to take over your life and dictate to you what you may or may not think?


Finally, if I do accomplish some research experiemnts on the issues I talk about, and then did publish or publicly release that research information, at that time it may be evaluated by one and all, and criticized by any who find it flawed, and I could be accused of fraud if I were proven to have falsified any data or misrepresented conclusions, but none of that has happened yet.

Where is the deceit? Where is the gain? Where is the advantage? Where is the fraud?

Bill
 
So, MK Davis announced a new set of PGF theories at the recent Ohio Bigfoot conference. Patricia Patterson presented him with some photo prints from frames and he uses them to support his new ideas.

He thinks that Patterson and Gimlin were involved in killing several Bigfoots on the same sandbar that they filmed Patty. First they shoot some dead and then go get a backhoe to bury the bodies in the sand. Then some days later they return to find Patty at the burial site and the camera starts rolling. Davis claims to see blood darkening some water that has seeped through the sand from the buried bodies. He also claims to see bloodstains on her feet. During the filming, Gimlin shoots Patty and hits her at least once in the leg (the bulge). He says he can also see her react to more bullets whizzing past her. Gimlin was shooting at her with his .30-06 while Patterson was shooting her with his Kodak. Lordy!

Henry May (bf2006 on this forum) was at the conference and took pictures of the presentations. Here is a link to his blog which apparently shows some of Davis' slides. I'm assuming we are seeing some slides which Davis thinks shows the blood seeping from the buried bodies, but May doesn't provide captions or descriptions of the slides.

MK Davis frame from the PGF...
fefbfc21.jpg


This one probably is meant to show the blood seeping from the backhoed sand pile into the water. But we know that the water is the flowing creek because we've examined these frames here before. I don't think there is any evidence of bloody water nor any blood coming from the sand. We are seeing the small creek and the sand bank created by normal water flow erosion. Davis may have even implied that the water is a puddle or pool and is not the creek itself.

Frame from John Green's full frame copy of the PGF...
a78978be.jpg



Those two frames are probably not the same. Nonetheless, it is quite obvious that there is no evidence of blood or a sand pile created to hide dead Bigfoot bodies. Didn't anyone stand up in this conference to tell Davis that we are only seeing the flowing creek with a naturally eroded bank? Was there anyone in that crowd that follows this thread, or is it not cool to mention at a Bigfooter conference that JREF has some excellent PGF frames and analysis?

Davis himself has posted in this thread (as primateer). What a debacle!
 
Last edited:
More Henry May photos from the Ohio conference. I think these show prints from Daniel Perez's collection.

I think that is Patterson wearing a hood under a hat. Or, is it Gimlin with the wig? Look at the width of that cast in front of him, and get a load of that stone age cube van and ATV!

50547db8.jpg


4c042258.jpg
 
Last edited:
Nonsense.
Utter and complete nonsense.

Patterson and Gimlim would have been with the final proof at their hands during all this time, denying footers their vindication.

Have I said this is nonsense?
 
William the conference photos seem to have vanished from your posts. As for the "bloodly pool" the frame from John Green film does look like the creek. Its easy to see the ripples from the movent. Now an uproot tree very near the creek could have formed a hollow resulting in a pool that could have been fed by the creek and or ground seepage. But overall the whole Davis scenerio is crazy. I mean who would kill a few animals in the wilderness and simply not just get a sovels and bury them. Why trapse into civilizaton and get a backhoe. Talk about drawing attention to yourself.

Picture this. Patterson requests a backhoe which one assumes he's renting or borrowing. They see his from Washington and how's he going to explaing what he wants it for being so far away from home. Do we even know whether he or Gimlin could even operate a backhoe?

Then there's the little thing about a trigger happy Bob Gimlin. He was within 50 feet of his rather large and slow moving target and he couldn't bring the target down? Hell he'd wasted a few Sasquatachs the day before without any problem while they were advancing on him and Patterson no less.

But the madness gets even better that Patterson is filming Bob's poor marksmanship while Patty is seeking escape. I wonder if anybody out there is even listening to this fool.
 
Henry May (bf2006 on this forum) was at the conference and took pictures of the presentations. Here is a link to his blog which apparently shows some of Davis' slides. I'm assuming we are seeing some slides which Davis thinks shows the blood seeping from the buried bodies, but May doesn't provide captions or descriptions of the slides.
If anyone needs any extra incentive to check out that link, you get to see a picture if Bill Green.

Thanks to BF2006 for making the effort to take the pictures.:)
 
So crazy WP's links made me wind up watching BF videos on youtube and I felt like sharing:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImNDf8ImOf8&NR=1

It's a MABRC research video. I loved it. You should watch it just to enjoy the graphics. I know I did. Those guys were organized and it looks like they had some quality bigfoot fun. BTW, they saw a bigfoot in 4x4 mode. Not the truck, mind you. Enjoy.
 
Very cool pics. I wonder if that's Gimlin truck? Imagine driving that thing on wilderness logging roads at night. Imagine driving that thing anywhere at all. I've wondered about how long it actually took to drive from Yakima to Bluff creek in that thing. Now consider that they had 3 horses in the back they couldn't made very good time.
 
So I'm not sure if anyone's linked this before but I just finished listening to this interview with Bob Gimlin on youtube:

http://youtube.com/watch?v=s4yRuTdtdtk

It's terrible sound quality and I couldn't make out everything he says when he is asked about Bob Heironimus. He says he believes he knows Bob real well and he must have been conned into something. I think it's at the Willow Creek bigfoot museum. He is asked about how the horses were transported. Too bad nobody said, "So BTW, what were you doing with Heironimus' horse up there?" Yeah, there's a little non-issue for you. Interestingly the American legend says of doing conferences since 2003 and not making any money from the film that "I'm the richest man in the country from you people."
 
Last edited:
He also says that when they first saw Patty she was 18" from the creek.

It's interesting that he would be that precise now and we've never heard that from him before. It's also interesting that we see no tracks indicating she was alongside the creek in the above frame (from Green).

Gimlin has bonded with the Bigfooters and they won't ask him prying questions or follow-up his answers with more skeptically-oriented questions. It's probably an unwritten social rule that you just don't do that with Gimlin when he is making an appearance. Always treat him like he is telling the truth.
 
Fame and attention are highly reinforcing things, very much like sex or drugs. Since MK Davis' entire social game is predicated on the notion "I've discovered something novel in the holy thing", he's doing everything he can to keep the ball rolling. It's all very sad of course, to watch the public self-abasement. Kind of like when has-been celebrities are put on degrading "reality shows" on TV.

I have a suspicion that he's tolerated in the Bigfoot subculture because his root claims are that "It's not a guy in a suit", and "It's not paranormal".

But if he's now suggesting that Gimlin was slinging lead at Our Patty he may have crossed the line, as it suggests Gimlin was a bloodthirsty killer. That, my friends, is a gigantic no-no in Bigfootery...
 
But if he's now suggesting that Gimlin was slinging lead at Our Patty he may have crossed the line, as it suggests Gimlin was a bloodthirsty killer. That, my friends, is a gigantic no-no in Bigfootery...
I liked this bit:

When Davis met with Gimlin, and ran this scenario by him, the only question, (according to my conversation with M.K.) that Gimlin asked was (paraphrased) ‘what did the picture of the pool show?’ He never confirmed or denied anything Davis said, but sat with his head down, looking at the floor.
I don't know why but that just jumps out at me. I wish we could get someone to ask Gimlin if it was him, Roger, or someone else filming Jerry Merrit and Bob Heironimus with their horses.
 
So crazy WP's links made me wind up watching BF videos on youtube and I felt like sharing:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImNDf8ImOf8&NR=1

It's a MABRC research video. I loved it. You should watch it just to enjoy the graphics. I know I did. Those guys were organized and it looks like they had some quality bigfoot fun. BTW, they saw a bigfoot in 4x4 mode. Not the truck, mind you. Enjoy.

Please tell me that was a parody. Something messes with the tent 6 times at 15 minute intervals and all they do is shine a light at it to scare it away??? Redneck research at its best!
 
Please tell me that was a parody. Something messes with the tent 6 times at 15 minute intervals and all they do is shine a light at it to scare it away??? Redneck research at its best!


Nope, it is about glorifying a mystery. If somebody would have looked close they may have discovered an ordinary animal (deer, bear, badger, whatever), the wind, or something else making the noise. Nobody wants that. It seems that any shadow was being considered a bigfoot but nobody wanted to go out an investigate further. So much for bigfoot research. The excuse is "we were too scared"? LMAO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom