Bigfoot - The Patterson-Gimlin Film

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, in any case, whether the DNA is real or not, many forensic experts are convinced Bigfoot is real. I've heard that even Jane Goodall thinks Bigfoot is real.

In utter absence of biological evidence, their opinion (and make no mistake, it is only an opinion) are as valid as mine on the existence/non existence of bigfoot, unless you want to make a fallacy on appeal to authority. Even in that case, it is doubtful that the so called forensic expert and jane goodall have a better authority than any of us on this forum on a supposed big bipedial ape living today.
 
Well, in any case, whether the DNA is real or not, many forensic experts are convinced Bigfoot is real. I've heard that even Jane Goodall thinks Bigfoot is real.
CryptidFan, for future reference these are some things you should read when the desire to make the bigfoot enthusiast Jane Goodall appeal to authority:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3487872#post3487872

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3598351#post3598351

Bigfoot enthusiasts do not faithfully present all of what Goodall said on her views on Bigfoot in that NPR interview. They intentionally omit such comments as "...and maybe they do not exist." Goodall makes it readily apparent that she had a romantic attatchment to the idea of bigfoot. Also, given the demands of her life she can hardly be expected to be abreast of the facts regarding bigfoot evidence.

See these comments from the Jane Goodall Institute regarding footer editing of her wiki entry (originally found and posted by member William Parcher):

I wanted to let all people involved in this issue know that The Jane Goodall Institute has decided to remove the content relating to Bigfoot from the bio entry. We have considered the points put forward by all involved and feel very strongly that this information is being added inappropriately, and is being placed here to further other peoples agenda, not to represent Jane Goodall’s work. Jane has not done any research on Bigfoot, it simply does not fit into her appropriate legacy. Please note that Jane Travels 320 days a year giving lectures and interviews on a variety of topics – to center in on a single interview in this space is inappropriate. We suggest instead that the content posted here be moved to the more appropriate location – under Bigfoot.

We will continue to remove this section from this point forward – and it should be noted that we do represent Jane Goodall in this matter and would point to the Biographies of living persons section of wikipedia guidelines when it comes to the future of this posting string.

Thank you, The Jane Goodall Institute.
 
CrypidFan

There's nothing you're going to be able to bring to the table that's going to budge the prevailing thought pattern here. Give up move on enjoy your beliefs and even share them with others just not on this forum. Sorry that's just the way it is!
 
Last edited:
CrypidFan

There's nothing you're going to be able to bring to the table that's going to budge the prevailing thought pattern here. Give up move on enjoy your beliefs and even share them with others just not on this forum. Sorry that's just the way it is!

With respect, I think that the contrary is the case.

In my experience, this forum is overwhelmingly open to new information and insight. However, much of what is 'brought to the table' in many discussions is far from new, and is simply a repetition, restatement or reinterpretation of old information that has already been examined, discussed and assimilated.

The prevailing thoughts of many forum members will obviously not be budged by information that they are already aware of, but will be (in my opinion), if not budged, then will be formed in the full light of currently available information.

Unfortunately there are many threads, many of them very long, which is frustrating for people who come late to the party. However, there is no substitute for a good deal of searching and reading in advance of putting forward information - in many cases, the information is already known.

So, forum members are unlikely to be swayed by Jane Goodall's comments any more at the 100th time repetition than they were the first time they heard them. As is right. :)
 
She gave a brief review of Meldrum's book...

Jeff Meldrum's book Sasquatch: Legend Meets Science brings a much needed level of scientific analysis to the Sasquatch - or Bigfoot - debate. Does Sasquatch exist? There are countless people - especially indigenous people - in different parts of America who claim to have seen such a creature. And in many parts of the world I meet those who, in a matter-of-fact way, tell me of their encounters with large, bipedal, tail-less hominids. I think I have read every article and every book about these creatures, and while most scientists are not satisfied with existing evidence, I have an open mind.

Dr. Jane Goodall, DBE UN Messenger of Peace & Founder - The Jane Goodall Institute

I wonder if she has read Daegling, Long, Radford, Loxton, JREF, etc.


CryptidFan, your innocent intrigue and style will not get you far in this forum. We have already discussed almost every aspect of Bigfootery. In order for Bigfoot to be taken seriously, something must happen that has never occured in the history of North American human inhabitance. Physical biological evidence must be presented to show that this creature is not a myth. There is righteousness in strong Bigfoot skepticism and this is not indicative of a closed mind, but rather the opposite. As each year passes without scientific confirmation, its status as a myth becomes more solidified.
 
.............

Just curious, are you arguing that it's impossible for anything other than a homo sapian to do the walk?

Bill
Not at all ..

The subject in the film walks like a human..

There is no logical reason to assume or even speculate it is anything else, until you show that some other creature exists, that has been shown to walk like that ..
:)
 
Of course it walks like a human. There is no other Bipedal Mammal to compare it to.
 
I find it surprising that you've not studied the gait. The similarities of their figures and movements is readily apparent but of course that's just my opinion. You're right that he could haver learned the walk. In this case I think it's helpful to look at the extenuating circumstances. BH lives in the same small community as Gimlin. The members of the community that you see appear with BH all mention that it has long been common knowledge of the truth of the PGF. National Geographic state that in BG would not speak to them. A guy with a walk, height, and figure being a dead ringer for Patty who lives in the same community with one of the two men involved in the filming who declines to speak...

I also thought it was interesting how Bob states matter-of-factly that had he been paid his $1000, he would have kept his mouth shut.

If I made an investigation and at every point I found no case where a suit is more likely than a living bigfoot, I'd be much more mindful of such things.

It isn't simply a matter of Bob Heironimus living in the same community as P&G - he has been a personal friend of Bob Gimlin going back years before the PGF. He has lived on the same street as BG going back before the PGF. It makes sense that P&G would choose a known person rather than a stranger for the role. This makes Bob's confession all the more believable for me. Why would he give a false confession if he wasn't the guy in the suit? How could you frame your old friend (Gimlin) and tell the world that he is a hoaxer? He is still friends with Gimlin and talks about their recent conversations and the ongoing attitude of Bob. BH feels that it's time for them both to confess, but that Gimlin says he just won't do it. Gimlin doesn't tell him that there was no hoax, or that he wasn't the guy in the suit. He just says he isn't going to confess.

There isn't much that BH can do about this short of creating a loud public outcry and demand that Gimlin either confess or publicly confront him on the issue. He probably also realizes that the broad public interest in this is so miniscule that hardly anyone would care if Gimlin did finally confess. Hardly anyone thinks that Patty is a real Bigfoot. Sorta like a Salvation Army Santa being interviewed by the Nightly News and then proclaiming that he doesn't really deliver presents from a reindeer sleigh. What else is new?

Is It Real makes a common mistake by saying that numerous guys have already confessed to wearing the suit. Only Bob Heironimus has confessed. But the biggest mistake is what leads to this error. This is the mistake of taking supposedly factual information from PGF proponents on good faith. You can bet that this sort of thing will continue to happen as the Bigfooters will desperately try almost anything to legitimize their fantasy world.

There is no Bigfoot, and no amount of huffing and puffing will change that.
 
I think the biggest question here is "WHY IS THIS THREAD STILL GOING?"

It is almost 3 years old, and people are still bickering about a bit of 8 mm grainy film that might be bigfoot, might be a man in a monkey suit, or might be something else entirely.

Have we reached a conclusion? Are we going to reach a conclusion? Is this even worth typing a response to?
 
WP, those are crucial points. Looking back at my post you quoted I realize how absent-minded I was being when I made the post as the length and nature of the friendship and the degree of proximity of their homes was first and foremost in mind. Certainly nothing I would call a 'non-issue'. It was my first time to see the entire 'Is it Real?' episode and when they repeated the line about many people claiming to be in the suit it immediately brought me back to crypto-fan John Kirk on Monster Quest lamenting about the number of people who have claimed to be in the suit with the overlay of the Wallace story in the background and the comment "...one poor fellow can't even remember how to get to the film site."

Did no one in the process of the research for these shows not say "Who? Any names? How many people?"
 
Originally Posted by kitakaze
I find it surprising that you've not studied the gait. The similarities of their figures and movements is readily apparent but of course that's just my opinion. You're right that he could haver learned the walk. In this case I think it's helpful to look at the extenuating circumstances. BH lives in the same small community as Gimlin. The members of the community that you see appear with BH all mention that it has long been common knowledge of the truth of the PGF. National Geographic state that in BG would not speak to them. A guy with a walk, height, and figure being a dead ringer for Patty who lives in the same community with one of the two men involved in the filming who declines to speak...

I also thought it was interesting how Bob states matter-of-factly that had he been paid his $1000, he would have kept his mouth shut.

If I made an investigation and at every point I found no case where a suit is more likely than a living bigfoot, I'd be much more mindful of such things.


However when they put Bob H back into a Bigfoot suit neither the suit or the walk did the PGF much justice. Its also remembering that he was much thinner in 1967 and still would have needed a great deal of padding.
 
Last edited:
I think the biggest question here is "WHY IS THIS THREAD STILL GOING?"

It is almost 3 years old, and people are still bickering about a bit of 8 mm grainy film that might be bigfoot, might be a man in a monkey suit, or might be something else entirely.

There it is. The film is 16 mm, so somebody has to hang around and correct factual errors. It might be a Bigfoot, so this thread has no expiration date.
 
However when they put Bob H back into a Bigfoot suit neither the suit or the walk did the PGF much justice.

What would it take for the effort to do some justice in your opinion? What would the logistics entail? Who should undertake that effort and why? What specifically was unsatisfying about that attempt and why?

Its also remembering that he was much thinner in 1967 and still would have needed a great deal of padding.
Do you know what BH's exact proportions were in '67 and exactly what Patty's were?
 
Last edited:
WP, those are crucial points. Looking back at my post you quoted I realize how absent-minded I was being when I made the post as the length and nature of the friendship and the degree of proximity of their homes was first and foremost in mind. Certainly nothing I would call a 'non-issue'.

Nonetheless, it is still one man's story against the other. Neither one of the Bobs possess irrefutable proof of their own claim. It is interesting that Gimlin refuses to confront Heironimus in public, even though he is essentially being accused of lying about this event for forty years. According to BH, these two friends don't argue about the details. There is nothing to argue. It happened, and now one of them is confessing.

It was my first time to see the entire 'Is it Real?' episode and when they repeated the line about many people claiming to be in the suit it immediately brought me back to crypto-fan John Kirk on Monster Quest lamenting about the number of people who have claimed to be in the suit with the overlay of the Wallace story in the background and the comment "...one poor fellow can't even remember how to get to the film site."

BH says that he decided to go public with his confession (he had already done this long ago locally with relatives and friends) after he saw "World's Greatest Hoaxes" on TV. In that program, Jerry Romney was said to be the guy in the suit. He denied it on the program. He also denied ever saying he was the guy. Therefore, it can't be counted as a true public confession. Only BH has done this.

About remembering how to get to the film site: Is it any wonder that BH cannot accurately remember such details after making a single trip to Bluff Creek in 1967? Isn't it a bit crazy to expect that? That Long allowed this without intervening speaks of honesty, not support of lies. When BH tries to recall everything, you get what you get including the errors. Gimlin should be allowed such things as well. If he could not give perfect directions and logistics... do we say that he must have never been to Bluff Creek? Of course not.

I feel that both men should be given a certain amount of slack in their recollection. No matter what you think, you must understand that these are two "regular guys" talking about an event that happened over forty years ago. But the way that Roger Knights and John Green literally dissect every word uttered by Heironimus and Long... looks desperate to me. Maybe I do the same for P&G and their testimonies. But then I remember that Bigfoot has never been confirmed to exist and I feel much more confident that the desperation is predominantly held by the "other side". It takes balls to argue for Bigfoot and Patty. Maybe that is what compels them.

Did no one in the process of the research for these shows not say "Who? Any names? How many people?"

Can you imagine the producers of National Geographic trying to verify everything? Whoa! They have to read everything they can (books, articles, magazines, Internet threads, etc.) and try to deal with contradictions everywhere. Do you say that Patterson's horse fell on him, or not? Do you mention the missing stomp test? Do you spend weeks trying to establish if Roger could have had the film developed in such short time on a weekend? Where and when does the fact-seeking end?

I'm not trying to make excuses for NG, but these people decided to do a program and they have to finalize the production at some point. We could even begin to imagine what would really be different if NG had gotten this fact correct. If they said that BH is the only guy to ever confess - would it make any matter? Would PGF believers crumple under the weight of that fact? Hell no. As it stands, the various arguments against BH are not hinged upon him being one of many who have confessed. It is often stated that way, but so what? Anyone with critical thinking abilities understands that a true confession can be just one among many false confessions.

Regardless of who might be in the suit, belief in the authenticity of the PGF is really a fringe belief. Weird. Crazy. Romantic. Fantasy. Blind. Deluded. Money-seeking. Manipulative. Submissive. Lost. Content. Whatever.
 
I just refreshed my memory on the athlete from Monster Quest. It is at the end of part 1 and continuing into part 2 of the youtube recording of the original Monster Quest episode on Bigfoot. Dr. Jurgen Konczak professor and associate director of the Human Sensorimotor Control Laboratory at the University of Minnesota and paleoanthropologist Esteban Sarmiento from the American Museum of Natural History in New York conduct a experiment where they use an athlete to try see if he could get into the same seemingly awkward positions of the PGF subject.

That particular athlete could not match the eversion of the knees of Patty. Monster Quest, a show produced by bigfoot enthusiasts, represented the results as being outside human range. All it takes is a little critical thinking to realize it was outside that particular athlete's range. Did they only try one person? We already know Monster Quest is pretty slick with the facts.

I don't think they would have chosen an athlete with a disability.
In any case, they didn't find any place on the animal's body where there could be a zipper, seams, etc. I would link to several videos and webpages that give countless solid evidence supporting the idea that the film is real, but I don't have enough posts yet.
 
In any case, they didn't find any place on the animal's body where there could be a zipper, seams, etc. .

Is it possible to see seams or zippers considering the issues of film resolution? IMO, the film grain would prevent anything except a bright white seam/zipper against a dark background from being resolved. In one frame the toes of "Bunny/Patty" can barely be resolved simply because of the contrast of the white toes against a dark background. Toes are much larger than seams or zippers indicating that it is almost impossible to find conclusive proof of a seam or zipper in the film.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom